My Response to ‘Laurie Halse Anderson’s ‘Speak’ almost too much for Temecula’

The LA Times Jacket Copy blog has posted the fol­low­ing story:

Lau­rie Halse Anderson’s 1999 young adult novel, “Speak,” which was a final­ist for the L.A. Times Book Award and the National Book Award, was selected as School Library Journal’s Best Book of the Year and received numer­ous other hon­ors, was the focus of con­tro­versy in Temec­ula this week. The school board’s trustees were decid­ing whether or not to add “Speak” to the list of books that may be taught in high school Eng­lish classes, and were con­cerned that it deals with the topic of rape and its after­math. more at http://bit.ly/2bjyqT

Which leads me to won­der: Why is it that stu­dents can be opted out of read­ings so eas­ily? At what point did we decide that teens were too frag­ile to face dif­fi­cult sub­jects in the Eng­lish class­room but strong enough to learn about them in math, sci­ence, his­tory, etc.? Is it because we fear gen­uine sto­ries more than we fear text­books? Or is it because we under­stand intu­itively how pow­er­ful the writ­ten word is and know that the most impor­tant thing that a teacher can do is con­nect a stu­dent with story? If so, why aren’t teens read­ing more books and tak­ing fewer tests?

Comments are disabled for this post