First Lensman by EE “Doc” Smith

18682342381_72fbaf4306_bFIRST LENSMAN


The enemy spacefleet arrowed toward the armored mountain–nerve center
of the Galactic Patrol. The Patrol battle cruisers swerved to meet
them, and a miles-long cone of pure energy ravened out at the invaders,
destroying whatever it touched.

But the moment before the force beam struck, thousands of tiny objects
dropped from the enemy fleet and, faster than light, flashed straight
at their target–each one an atom bomb powerful enough to destroy
Patrol Headquarters by itself!

The Galactic Patrol–and civilization itself–had seconds to live.
Unless a miracle happened….


Second in the Great Series


The visitor, making his way unobserved through the crowded main
laboratory of The Hill, stepped up to within six feet of the back
of a big Norwegian seated at an electrono-optical bench. Drawing an
automatic pistol, he shot the apparently unsuspecting scientist seven
times, as fast as he could pull the trigger; twice through the brain,
five times, closely spaced, through the spine.

“Ah, Gharlane of Eddore, I have been expecting you to look me up. Sit
down.” Blonde, blue-eyed Dr. Nels Bergenholm, completely undisturbed by
the passage of the stream of bullets through his head and body, turned
and waved one huge hand at a stool beside his own.

“But those were not ordinary projectiles!” the visitor protested.
Neither person–or rather, entity–was in the least surprised that no
one else had paid any attention to what had happened, but it was clear
that the one was taken aback by the failure of his murderous attack.
“They should have volatilized that form of flesh–should at least have
blown you back to Arisia, where you belong.”

“Ordinary or extraordinary, what matter? As you, in the guise of
Gray Roger, told Conway Costigan a short time since, ‘I permitted
that, as a demonstration of futility.’ Know, Gharlane, once and for
all, that you will no longer be allowed to act directly against any
adherent of Civilization, wherever situate. We of Arisia will not
interfere in person with your proposed conquest of the two galaxies
as you have planned it, since the stresses and conflicts involved are
necessary–and, I may add, sufficient–to produce the Civilization
which must and shall come into being. Therefore, neither will you, or
any other Eddorian, so interfere. You will go back to Eddore and you
will stay there.”

“Think you so?” Gharlane sneered. “You, who have been so afraid of us
for over two thousand million Tellurian years that you dared not let us
even learn of you? So afraid of us that you dared not take any action
to avert the destruction of any one of your budding Civilizations upon
any one of the worlds of either galaxy? So afraid that you dare not,
even now, meet me mind to mind, but insist upon the use of this slow
and unsatisfactory oral communication between us?”

“Either your thinking is loose, confused, and turbid, which I do not
believe to be the case, or you are trying to lull me into believing
that you are stupid.” Bergenholm’s voice was calm, unmoved. “I do not
think that you will go back to Eddore; I know it. You, too, as soon
as you have become informed upon certain matters, will know it. You
protest against the use of spoken language because it is, as you know,
the easiest, simplest, and surest way of preventing you from securing
any iota of the knowledge for which you are so desperately searching.
As to a meeting of our two minds, they met fully just before you,
operating as Gray Roger, remembered that which your entire race forgot
long ago. As a consequence of that meeting I so learned every line
and vibration of your life pattern as to be able to greet you by your
symbol, Gharlane of Eddore, whereas you know nothing of me save that I
am an Arisian, a fact which has been obvious from the first.”

In an attempt to create a diversion, Gharlane released the zone of
compulsion which he had been holding; but the Arisian took it over so
smoothly that no human being within range was conscious of any change.

“It is true that for many cycles of time we concealed our existence
from you,” Bergenholm went on without a break. “Since the reason for
that concealment will still further confuse you, I will tell you what
it was. Had you Eddorians learned of us sooner you might have been able
to forge a weapon of power sufficient to prevent the accomplishment of
an end which is now certain.

“It is true that your operations as Lo Sung of Uighar were not
constrained. As Mithridates of Pontus–as Sulla, Marius, and Nero of
Rome–as Hannibal of Carthage–as those self-effacing wights Alcixerxes
of Greece and Menocoptes of Egypt–as Genghis Khan and Attila and
the Kaiser and Mussolini and Hitler and the Tyrant of Asia–you were
allowed to do as you pleased. Similar activities upon Rigel Four,
Velantia, Palain Seven, and elsewhere were also allowed to proceed
without effective opposition. With the appearance of Virgil Samms,
however, the time arrived to put an end to your customary pernicious,
obstructive, and destructive activities. I therefore interposed a
barrier between you and those who would otherwise be completely
defenseless against you.”

“But why now? Why not thousands of cycles ago? And why Virgil Samms?”

“To answer those questions would be to give you valuable data. You
may–too late–be able to answer them yourself. But to continue: you
accuse me, and all Arisia, of cowardice; an evidently muddy and inept
thought. Reflect, please, upon the completeness of your failure in the
affair of Roger’s planetoid; upon the fact that you have accomplished
nothing whatever since that time; upon the situation in which you now
find yourself.

“Even though the trend of thought of your race is basically
materialistic and mechanistic, and you belittle ours as being
‘philosophic’ and ‘impractical’, you found–much to your surprise–that
your most destructive physical agencies are not able to affect even
this form of flesh which I am now energizing, to say nothing of
affecting the reality which is I.

“If this episode is the result of the customary thinking of the
second-in-command of Eddore’s Innermost Circle … but no, my
visualization cannot be that badly at fault. Overconfidence–the
tyrant’s innate proclivity to underestimate an opponent–these things
have put you into a false position; but I greatly fear that they will
not operate to do so in any really important future affair.”

“Rest assured that they will not!” Gharlane snarled. “It may not
be–exactly–cowardice. It is, however, something closely akin. If you
could have acted effectively against us at any time in the past, you
would have done so. If you could act effectively against us now, you
would be acting, not talking. That is elementary–self-evidently true.
So true that you have not tried to deny it–nor would you expect me to
believe you if you did.” Cold black eyes stared level into icy eyes of
Norwegian blue.

“Deny it? No. I am glad, however, that you used the word ‘effectively’
instead of ‘openly’; for we have been acting effectively against you
ever since these newly-formed planets cooled sufficiently to permit of
the development of intelligent life.”

“What? You have? How?”

“That, too, you may learn–too late. I have now said all I intend
to say. I will give you no more information. Since you already know
that there are more adult Arisians than there are Eddorians, so that
at least one of us can devote his full attention to blocking the
direct effort of any one of you, it is clear to you that it makes no
difference to me whether you elect to go or to stay. I can and I will
remain here as long as you do; I can and I will accompany you whenever
you venture out of the volume of space protected by Eddorian screen,
wherever you go. The election is yours.”

Gharlane disappeared. So did the Arisian–instantaneously. Dr. Nels
Bergenholm, however, remained. Turning, he resumed his work where he
had left off, knowing exactly what he had been doing and exactly what
he was going to do to finish it. He released the zone of compulsion,
which he had been holding upon every human being within sight or
hearing, so dexterously that no one suspected, then or ever, that
anything out of the ordinary had happened. He knew these things and
did these things in spite of the fact that the form of flesh which his
fellows of the Triplanetary Service knew as Nels Bergenholm was then
being energized, not by the stupendously powerful mind of Drounli the
Molder, but by an Arisian child too young to be of any use in that
which was about to occur.

Arisia was ready. Every Arisian mind capable of adult, or of even
near-adult thinking was poised to act when the moment of action should
come. They were not, however, tense. While not in any sense routine,
that which they were about to do had been foreseen for many cycles of
time. They knew exactly what they were going to do, and exactly how to
do it. They waited.

“My visualization is not entirely clear concerning the succession of
events stemming from the fact that the fusion of which Drounli is
a part did not destroy Gharlane of Eddore while he was energizing
Gray Roger,” a young Watchman, Eukonidor by symbol, thought into the
assembled mind. “May I take a moment of this idle time in which to
spread my visualization, for enlargement and instruction?”

“You may, youth.” The Elders of Arisia–the mightiest intellects of
that tremendously powerful race–fused their several minds into one
mind and gave approval. “That will be time well spent. Think on.”

“Separated from the other Eddorians by inter-galactic distance as
he then was, Gharlane could have been isolated and could have been
destroyed,” the youth pointed out, as he somewhat diffidently spread
his visualization in the public mind. “Since it is axiomatic that his
destruction would have weakened Eddore somewhat and to that extent
would have helped us, it is evident that some greater advantage will
accrue from allowing him to live. Some points are clear enough: that
Gharlane and his fellows will believe that the Arisian fusion could
not kill him, since it did not; that the Eddorians, contemptuous of our
powers and thinking us vastly their inferiors, will not be driven to
develop such things as atomic-energy-powered mechanical screens against
third-level thought until such a time as it will be too late for even
those devices to save their race from extinction; that they will, in
all probability, never even suspect that the Galactic Patrol which is
so soon to come into being will in fact be the prime operator in that
extinction. It is not clear, however, in view of the above facts, why
it has now become necessary for us to slay one Eddorian upon Eddore.
Nor can I formulate or visualize with any clarity the techniques
to be employed in the final wiping out of the race; I lack certain
fundamental data concerning events which occurred and conditions which
obtained many, many cycles before my birth. I am unable to believe that
my perception and memory could have been so imperfect–can it be that
none of that basic data is, or ever has been available?”

“That, youth, is the fact. While your visualization of the future is of
course not as detailed nor as accurate as it will be after more cycles
of labor, your background of knowledge is as complete as that of any
other of our number.”

“I see.” Eukonidor gave the mental equivalent of a nod of complete
understanding. “It is necessary, and the death of a lesser Eddorian–a
Watchman–will be sufficient. Nor will it be either surprising or
alarming to Eddore’s Innermost Circle that the integrated total mind of
Arisia should be able to kill such a relatively feeble entity. I see.”

Then silence; and waiting. Minutes? Or days? Or weeks? Who can tell?
What does time mean to any Arisian?

Then Drounli arrived; arrived in the instant of his leaving The
Hill–what matters even inter-galactic distance to the speed of
thought? He fused his mind with those of the three other Molders
of Civilization. The massed and united mind of Arisia, poised and
ready, awaiting only his coming, launched itself through space. That
tremendous, that theretofore unknown concentration of mental force
arrived at Eddore’s outer screen in practically the same instant as
did the entity that was Gharlane. The Eddorian, however, went through
without opposition; the Arisians did not.

Some two thousand million years ago, when the Coalescence occurred–the
event which was to make each of the two interpassing galaxies teem with
planets–the Arisians were already an ancient race; so ancient that
they were even then independent of the chance formation of planets. The
Eddorians, it is believed, were older still. The Arisians were native
to this, our normal space-time continuum; the Eddorians were not.

Eddore was–and is–huge, dense, and hot. Its atmosphere is not air,
as we of small, green Terra, know air, but is a noxious mixture of
gaseous substances known to mankind only in chemical laboratories.
Its hydrosphere, while it does contain some water, is a poisonous,
stinking, foully corrosive, slimy and sludgy liquid.

And the Eddorians were as different from any people we know as Eddore
is different from the planets indigenous to our space and time. They
were, to our senses, utterly monstrous; almost incomprehensible. They
were amorphous, amoeboid, sexless. Not androgynous or parthenogenetic,
but absolutely sexless; with a sexlessness unknown in any Earthly form
of life higher than the yeasts. Thus they were, to all intents and
purposes and except for death by violence, immortal; for each one,
after having lived for hundreds of thousands of Tellurian years and
having reached its capacity to live and to learn, simply divided into
two new individuals, each of which, in addition to possessing in full
its parent’s mind and memories and knowledges, had also a brand-new
zest and a greatly increased capacity.

And, since life was, there had been competition. Competition for power.
Knowledge was worth while only insofar as it contributed to power.
Warfare began, and aged, and continued; the appallingly efficient
warfare possible only to such entities as those. Their minds, already
immensely powerful, grew stronger and stronger under the stresses of
inter-necine struggle.

But peace was not even thought of. Strife continued, at higher and even
higher levels of violence, until two facts became apparent. First, that
every Eddorian who could be killed by physical violence had already
died; that the survivors had developed such tremendous powers of mind,
such complete mastery of things physical as well as mental, that they
could not be slain by physical force. Second, that during the ages
through which they had been devoting their every effort to mutual
extermination, their sun had begun markedly to cool; that their planet
would very soon become so cold that it would be impossible for them
ever again to live their normal physical lives.

Thus there came about an armistice. The Eddorians worked together–not
without friction–in the development of mechanisms by the use of which
they moved their planet across light-years of space to a younger,
hotter sun. Then, Eddore once more at its hot and reeking norm, battle
was resumed. Mental battle, this time, that went on for more than a
hundred thousand Eddorian years; during the last ten thousand of which
not a single Eddorian died.

Realizing the futility of such unproductive endeavor, the relatively
few survivors made a peace of sorts. Since each had an utterly
insatiable lust for power, and since it had become clear that they
could neither conquer nor kill each other, they would combine forces
and conquer enough planets–enough galaxies–so that each Eddorian
could have as much power and authority as he could possibly handle.

What matter that there were not that many planets in their native
space? There were other spaces, an infinite number of them; some of
which, it was mathematically certain, would contain millions upon
millions of planets instead of only two or three. By mind and by
machine they surveyed the neighboring continua; they developed the
hyper-spatial tube and the inertialess drive; they drove their planet,
space-ship-wise, through space after space after space.

And thus, shortly after the Coalescence began, Eddore came into our
space-time; and here, because of the multitudes of planets already
existing and the untold millions more about to come into existence,
it stayed. Here was what they had wanted since their beginnings; here
were planets enough, here were fields enough for the exercise of power,
to sate even the insatiable. There was no longer any need for them to
fight each other; they could now cooperate whole-heartedly–as long as
each was getting more–and more and MORE!

Enphilisor, a young Arisian, his mind roaming eagerly abroad as was its
wont, made first contact with the Eddorians in this space. Inoffensive,
naive, innocent, he was surprised beyond measure at their reception of
his friendly greeting; but in the instant before closing his mind to
their vicious attacks, he learned the foregoing facts concerning them.

The fused mind of the Elders of Arisia, however, was not surprised. The
Arisians, while not as mechanistic as their opponents, and innately
peaceful as well, were far ahead of them in the pure science of the
mind. The Elders had long known of the Eddorians and of their lustful
wanderings through plenum after plenum. Their Visualizations of the
Cosmic All had long since forecast, with dreadful certainty, the
invasion which had now occurred. They had long known what they would
have to do. They did it. So insidiously as to set up no opposition they
entered the Eddorians’ minds and sealed off all knowledge of Arisia.
They withdrew, tracelessly.

They did not have much data, it is true; but no more could be obtained
at that time. If any one of those touchy suspicious minds had been
given any cause for alarm, any focal point of doubt, they would have
had time in which to develop mechanisms able to force the Arisians out
of this space before a weapon to destroy the Eddorians–the as yet
incompletely designed Galactic Patrol–could be forged. The Arisians
could, even then, have slain by mental force alone all the Eddorians
except the All-Highest and his Innermost Circle, safe within their then
impenetrable shield; but as long as they could not make a clean sweep
they could not attack–then.

Be it observed that the Arisians were not fighting for themselves. As
individuals or as a race they had nothing to fear. Even less than the
Eddorians could they be killed by any possible application of physical
force. Past masters of mental science, they knew that no possible
concentration of Eddorian mental force could kill any one of them. And
if they were to be forced out of normal space, what matter? To such
mentalities as theirs, any given space would serve as well as any other.

No, they were fighting for an ideal; for the peaceful, harmonious,
liberty-loving Civilization which they had envisaged as developing
throughout, and eventually entirely covering the myriads of planets
of, two tremendous Island Universes. Also, they felt a heavy weight
of responsibility. Since all these races, existing and yet to appear,
had sprung from and would spring from the Arisian life-spores which
permeated this particular space, they all were and would be, at bottom,
Arisian. It was starkly unthinkable that Arisia would leave them to
the eternal dominance of such a rapacious, such a tyrannical, such a
hellishly insatiable breed of monsters.

Therefore the Arisians fought; efficiently if insidiously. They did
not–they could not–interfere openly with Eddore’s ruthless conquest
of world after world; with Eddore’s ruthless smashing of Civilization
after Civilization. They did, however, see to it, by selective matings
and the establishment of blood-lines upon numberless planets, that the
trend of the level of intelligence was definitely and steadily upward.

Four Molders of Civilization–Drounli, Kriedigan, Nedanillor, and
Brolenteen, who, in fusion, formed the “Mentor of Arisia” who was to
become known to every wearer of Civilization’s Lens–were individually
responsible for the Arisian program of development upon the four
planets of Tellus, Rigel IV, Velantia, and Palain VII. Drounli
established upon Tellus two principal lines of blood. In unbroken male
line of descent the Kinnisons went back to long before the dawn of
even mythical Tellurian history. Kinnexa of Atlantis, daughter of one
Kinnison and sister of another, is the first of the blood to be named
in these annals; but the line was then already old. So was the other
line; characterized throughout its tremendous length, male and female,
by peculiarly spectacular red-bronze-auburn hair and equally striking
gold-flecked, tawny eyes.

Nor did these strains mix. Drounli had made it psychologically
impossible for them to mix until the penultimate stage of development
should have been reached.

While that stage was still in the future Virgil Samms appeared, and
all Arisia knew that the time had come to engage the Eddorians openly,
mind to mind. Gharlane-Roger was curbed, savagely and sharply. Every
Eddorian, wherever he was working, found his every line of endeavor
solidly blocked.

Gharlane, as has been intimated, constructed a supposedly irresistible
weapon and attacked his Arisian blocker, with results already told. At
that failure Gharlane knew that there was something terribly amiss;
that it had been amiss for over two thousand million Tellurian years.
Really alarmed for the first time in his long life, he flashed back to
Eddore; to warn his fellows and to take counsel with them as to what
should be done. And the massed and integrated force of all Arisia was
only an instant behind him.

Arisia struck Eddore’s outermost screen, and in the instant of impact
that screen went down. And then, instantaneously and all unperceived
by the planet’s defenders, the Arisian forces split. The Elders,
including all the Molders, seized the Eddorian who had been handling
that screen–threw around him an impenetrable net of force–yanked him
out into inter-galactic space.

Then, driving in resistlessly, they turned the luckless wight inside
out. And before the victim died under their poignant probings, the
Elders of Arisia learned everything that the Eddorian and all of his
ancestors had ever known. They then withdrew to Arisia, leaving their
younger, weaker, partially-developed fellows to do whatever they could
against mighty Eddore.

Whether the attack of these lesser forces would be stopped at the
second, the third, the fourth, or the innermost screen; whether they
would reach the planet itself and perhaps do some actual damage before
being driven off; was immaterial. Eddore must be allowed and would
be allowed to repel that invasion with ease. For cycles to come the
Eddorians must and would believe that they had nothing really to fear
from Arisia.

The real battle, however, had been won. The Arisian visualizations
could now be extended to portray every essential element of the
climactic conflict which was eventually to come. It was no cheerful
conclusion at which the Arisians arrived, since their visualizations
all agreed in showing that the only possible method of wiping out the
Eddorians would also of necessity end their own usefulness as Guardians
of Civilization.

Such an outcome having been shown necessary, however, the Arisians
accepted it, and worked toward it, unhesitatingly.


As has been said, The Hill, which had been built to be the Tellurian
headquarters of the Triplanetary Service and which was now the
headquarters of the half-organized Solarian Patrol, was–and is–a
truncated, alloy-sheathed, honey-combed mountain. But, since human
beings do not like to live eternally underground, no matter how
beautifully lighted or how carefully and comfortably air-conditioned
the dungeon may be, the Reservation spread far beyond the foot of
that gray, forbidding, mirror-smooth cone of metal. Well outside that
farflung Reservation there was a small city; there were hundreds
of highly productive farms; and, particularly upon this bright May
afternoon, there was a Recreation Park, containing, among other things,
dozens of tennis courts.

One of these courts was three-quarters enclosed by stands, from which
a couple of hundred people were watching a match which seemed to be of
some little local importance. Two men sat in a box which had seats for
twenty, and watched admiringly the pair who seemed in a fair way to win
in straight sets the mixed-doubles championship of the Hill.

“Fine-looking couple, Rod, if I do say so myself, as well as being
smooth performers.” Solarian Councillor Virgil Samms spoke to his
companion as the opponents changed courts. “I still think, though, the
young hussy ought to wear some clothes–those white nylon shorts make
her look nakeder even than usual. I told her so, too, the jade, but she
keeps on wearing less and less.”

“Of course,” Commissioner Roderick K. Kinnison laughed quietly. “What
did you expect? She got her hair and eyes from you, why not your
hard-headedness, too? One thing, though, that’s all to the good–she’s
got what it takes to strip ship that way, and most of ’em haven’t. But
what I can’t understand is why they don’t….” He paused.

“I don’t either. Lord knows we’ve thrown them at each other hard
enough, and Jack Kinnison and Jill Samms would certainly make a pair to
draw to. But if they won’t … but maybe they will yet. They’re still
youngsters, and they’re friendly enough.”

If Samms père could have been out on the court, however, instead of in
the box, he would have been surprised; for young Kinnison, although
smiling enough as to face, was addressing his gorgeous partner in terms
which carried little indeed of friendliness.

“Listen, you bird-brained, knot-headed, grand-standing half-wit!” he
stormed, voice low but bitterly intense. “I ought to beat your alleged
brains out! I’ve told you a thousand times to watch your own territory
and stay out of mine! If you had been where you belonged, or even
taken my signal, Frank couldn’t have made that thirty-all point; and
if Lois hadn’t netted she’d’ve caught you flat-footed, a kilometer
out of position, and made it deuce. What do you think you’re doing,
anyway–playing tennis or seeing how many innocent bystanders you can
bring down out of control?”

“What do you think?” the girl sneered, sweetly. Her tawny eyes, only
a couple of inches below his own, almost emitted sparks. “And just
look at who’s trying to tell who how to do what! For your information,
Master Pilot John K. Kinnison, I’ll tell you that just because you
can’t quit being ‘Killer’ Kinnison even long enough to let two good
friends of ours get a point now and then, or maybe even a game, is no
reason why I’ve got to turn into ‘Killer’ Samms. And I’ll also tell

“You’ll tell me nothing, Jill–I’m telling you! Start giving away
points in anything and you’ll find out some day that you’ve given away
too many. I’m not having any of that kind of game–and as long as
you’re playing with me you aren’t either–or else. If you louse up this
match just once more, the next ball I serve will hit the tightest part
of those fancy white shorts of yours–right where the hip pocket would
be if they had any–and it’ll raise a welt that will make you eat off
of the mantel for three days. So watch your step!”

“You insufferable lug! I’d like to smash this racket over your head!
I’ll do it, too, and walk off the court, if you don’t….”

The whistle blew. Virgilia Samms, all smiles, toed the base-line and
became the personification and embodiment of smoothly flowing motion.
The ball whizzed over the net, barely clearing it–a sizzling service
ace. The game went on.

And a few minutes later, in the shower room, where Jack Kinnison was
caroling lustily while plying a towel, a huge young man strode up and
slapped him ringingly between the shoulder blades.

“Congratulations, Jack, and so forth. But there’s a thing I want to ask
you. Confidential, sort of…?”

“Shoot! Haven’t we been eating out of the same dish for lo, these many
moons? Why the diffidence all of a sudden, Mase? It isn’t in character.”

“Well … it’s … I’m a lip-reader, you know.”

“Sure. We all are. What of it?”

“It’s only that … well, I saw what you and Miss Samms said to each
other out there, and if that was lovers’ small talk I’m a Venerian

Lovers! Who the hell ever said we were lovers?… Oh, you’ve been
inhaling some of dad’s balloon-juice. Lovers! Me and that red-headed
stinker–that jelly-brained sapadilly? Hardly!

“Hold it, Jack!” The big officer’s voice was slightly edged.
“You’re off course–a hell of a long flit off. That girl has got
everything. She’s the class of the Reservation–why, she’s a regular

“Huh?” Amazed, young Kinnison stopped drying himself and stared. “You
mean to say you’ve been giving her a miss just because….” He had
started to say “because you’re the best friend I’ve got in the System,”
but he did not.

“Well, it would have smelled slightly cheesy, I thought.” The other
man did not put into words, either, what both of them so deeply knew
to be the truth. “But if you haven’t got … if it’s O.K. with you, of

“Stand by for five seconds–I’ll take you around.”

Jack threw on his uniform, and in a few minutes the two young officers,
immaculate in the space-black-and-silver of the Patrol, made their way
toward the women’s dressing rooms.

“… but she’s all right, at that … in most ways … I guess.”
Kinnison was half-apologizing for what he had said. “Outside of being
chicken-hearted and pig-headed, she’s a good egg. She really
qualifies … most of the time. But I wouldn’t have her, bonus
attached, any more than she would have me. It’s strictly mutual. You
won’t fall for her, either, Mase; you’ll want to pull one of her legs
off and beat the rest of her to death with it inside of a week–but
there’s nothing like finding things out for yourself.”

In a short time Miss Samms appeared; dressed somewhat less revealingly
than before in the blouse and kilts which were the mode of the moment.

“Hi, Jill! This is Mase–I’ve told you about him. My boat-mate. Master
Electronicist Mason Northrop.”

“Yes, I’ve heard about you, ‘Troncist–a lot.” She shook hands warmly.

“He hasn’t been putting tracers on you, Jill, on accounta he figured
he’d be poaching. Can you feature that? I straightened him out, though,
in short order. Told him why, too, so he ought to be insulated against
any voltage you can generate.”

“Oh, you did? How sweet of you! But how … oh, those?” She gestured at
the powerful prism binoculars, a part of the uniform of every officer
of space.

“Uh-huh.” Northrop wriggled, but held firm.

“If I’d only been as big and husky as you are,” surveying admiringly
some six feet two of altitude and two hundred-odd pounds of hard
meat, gristle, and bone, “I’d have grabbed him by one ankle, whirled
him around my head, and flung him into the fifteenth row of seats.
What’s the matter with him, Mase, is that he was born centuries and
centuries too late. He should have been an overseer when they built
the pyramids–flogging slaves because they wouldn’t step just so. Or
better yet, one of those people it told about in those funny old books
they dug up last year–liege lords, or something like that, remember?
With the power of life and death–‘high, middle, and low justice’,
whatever that was–over their vassals and their families, serfs, and
serving-wenches. Especially serving-wenches! He likes little, cuddly
baby-talkers, who pretend to be utterly spineless and completely
brainless–eh, Jack?”

“Ouch! Touché, Jill–but maybe I had it coming to me, at that. Let’s
call it off, shall we? I’ll be seeing you two, hither or yon.” Kinnison
turned and hurried away.

“Want to know why he’s doing such a quick flit?” Jill grinned up at her
companion; a bright, quick grin. “Not that he was giving up. The blonde
over there–the one in rocket red. Very few blondes can wear such a
violent shade. Dimples Maynard.”

“And is she … er…?”

“Cuddly and baby-talkish? Uh-uh. She’s a grand person. I was just
popping off; so was he. You know that neither of us really meant half
of what we said … or … at least….” Her voice died away.

“I don’t know whether I do or not,” Northrop replied, awkwardly but
honestly. “That was savage stuff if there ever was any. I can’t see for
the life of me why you two–two of the world’s finest people–should
have to tear into each other that way. Do you?”

“I don’t know that I ever thought of it like that.” Jill caught her
lower lip between her teeth. “He’s splendid, really, and I like him a
lot–usually. We get along perfectly most of the time. We don’t fight
at all except when we’re too close together … and then we fight about
anything and everything … say, suppose that that could be it? Like
charges, repelling each other inversely as the square of the distance?
That’s about the way it seems to be.”

“Could be, and I’m glad.” The man’s face cleared. “And I’m a charge of
the opposite sign. Let’s go!”

And in Virgil Samms’ deeply-buried office, Civilization’s two strongest
men were deep in conversation.

“… troubles enough to keep four men of our size awake nights.”
Samms’ voice was light, but his eyes were moody and somber. “You can
probably whip yours, though, in time. They’re mostly in one solar
system; a short flit covers the rest. Languages and customs are known.
But how–how–can legal processes work efficiently–work at all,
for that matter–when a man can commit a murder or a pirate can loot
a space-ship and be a hundred parsecs away before the crime is even
discovered? How can a Tellurian John Law find a criminal on a strange
world that knows nothing whatever of our Patrol, with a completely
alien language–maybe no language at all–where it takes months even
to find out who and where–if any–the native police officers are? But
there must be a way, Rod–there’s got to be a way!” Samms slammed his
open hand resoundingly against his desk’s bare top. “And by God I’ll
find it–the Patrol will come out on top!”

“‘Crusader’ Samms, now and forever!” There was no trace of mockery in
Kinnison’s voice or expression, but only friendship and admiration.
“And I’ll bet you do. Your Interstellar Patrol, or whatever….”

“Galactic Patrol. I know what the name of it is going to be, if nothing

“… is just as good as in the bag, right now. You’ve done a job so
far, Virge. This whole system, Nevia, the colonies on Aldebaran II and
other planets, even Valeria, as tight as a drum. Funny about Valeria,
isn’t it….”

There was a moment of silence, then Kinnison went on:

“But wherever diamonds are, there go Dutchmen. And Dutch women
go wherever their men do. And, in spite of medical advice, Dutch
babies arrive. Although a lot of the adults died–three G’s is no
joke–practically all of the babies keep on living. Developing
bones and muscles to fit–walking at a year and a half old–living
normally–they say that the third generation will be perfectly at home

“Which shows that the human animal is more adaptable than some ranking
medicos had believed, is all. Don’t try to side-track me, Rod. You
know as well as I do what we’re up against; the new headaches that
inter-stellar commerce is bringing with it. New vices–drugs–thionite,
for instance; we haven’t been able to get an inkling of an idea as to
where that stuff is coming from. And I don’t have to tell you what
piracy has done to insurance rates.”

“I’ll say not–look at the price of Aldebaranian cigars, the only kind
fit to smoke! You’ve given up, then, on the idea that Arisia is the
pirates’ GHQ?”

“Definitely. It isn’t. The pirates are even more afraid of it than
tramp spacemen are. It’s out of bounds–absolutely forbidden territory,
apparently–to everybody, my best operatives included. All we know
about it is the name–Arisia–that our planetographers gave it. It is
the first completely incomprehensible thing I have ever experienced. I
am going out there myself as soon as I can take the time–not that I
expect to crack a thing that my best men couldn’t touch, but there have
been so many different and conflicting reports–no two stories agree on
anything except in that no one could get anywhere near the planet–that
I feel the need of some first-hand information. Want to come along?”

“Try to keep me from it!”

“But at that, we shouldn’t be too surprised,” Samms went on,
thoughtfully. “Just beginning to scratch the surface as we are,
we should expect to encounter peculiar, baffling–even completely
inexplicable things. Facts, situations, events, and beings for which
our one-system experience could not possibly have prepared us. In fact,
we already have. If, ten years ago, anyone had told you that such a
race as the Rigellians existed, what would you have thought? One ship
went there, you know–once. One hour in any Rigellian city–one minute
in a Rigellian automobile–drives a Tellurian insane.”

“I see your point.” Kinnison nodded. “Probably I would have ordered
a mental examination. And the Palainians are even worse. People–if
you can call them that–who live on Pluto and like it! Entities so
alien that nobody, as far as I know, understands them. But you don’t
have to go even that far from home to locate a job of unscrewing the
inscrutable. Who, what, and why–and for how long–was Gray Roger? And,
not far behind him, is this young Bergenholm of yours. And by the way,
you never did give me the lowdown on how come it was the ‘Bergenholm’,
and not the ‘Rodebush-Cleveland’, that made trans-galactic commerce
possible and caused nine-tenths of our headaches. As I get the story,
Bergenholm wasn’t–isn’t–even an engineer.”

“Didn’t I? Thought I did. He wasn’t, and isn’t. Well, the original
Rodebush-Cleveland free drive was a killer, you know….”

How I know!” Kinnison exclaimed, feelingly.

“They beat their brains out and ate their hearts out for months,
without getting it any better. Then, one day, this kid Bergenholm
ambles into their shop–big, awkward, stumbling over his own feet. He
gazes innocently at the thing for a couple of minutes, then says:

“‘Why don’t you use uranium instead of iron and rewind it so it will
put out a wave-form like this, with humps here, and here; instead of
there, and there?’ and he draws a couple of free-hand, but really
beautiful curves.

“‘Why should we?’ they squawk at him.

“‘Because it will work that way,’ he says, and ambles out as
unconcernedly as he came in. Can’t–or won’t–say another word.

“Well in sheer desperation, they tried it–and it WORKED! And nobody
has ever had a minute’s trouble with a Bergenholm since. That’s why
Rodebush and Cleveland both insisted on the name.”

“I see; and it points up what I just said. But if he’s such a mental
giant, why isn’t he getting results with his own problem, the meteor?
Or is he?”

“No … or at least he wasn’t as of last night. But there’s a note on
my pad that he wants to see me sometime today–suppose we have him come
in now?”

“Fine! I’d like to talk to him, if it’s O.K. with you and with him.”

The young scientist was called in, and was introduced to the

“Go ahead, Doctor Bergenholm,” Samms suggested then. “You may talk to
both of us, just as freely as though you and I were alone.”

“I have, as you already know, been called psychic,” Bergenholm began,
abruptly. “It is said that I dream dreams, see visions, hear voices,
and so on. That I operate on hunches. That I am a genius. Now I very
definitely am not a genius–unless my understanding of the meaning of
that word is different from that of the rest of mankind.”

Bergenholm paused. Samms and Kinnison looked at each other. The latter
broke the short silence.

“The Councillor and I have just been discussing the fact that there
are a great many things we do not know; that with the extension of our
activities into new fields, the occurrence of the impossible has become
almost a commonplace. We are able, I believe, to listen with open minds
to anything you have to say.”

“Very well. But first, please know that I am a scientist. As such, I
am trained to observe; to think calmly, clearly, and analytically;
to test every hypothesis. I do not believe at all in the so-called
supernatural. This universe did not come into being, it does not
continue to be, except by the operation of natural and immutable laws.
And I mean immutable, gentlemen. Everything that has ever happened,
that is happening now, or that ever is to happen, was, is, and will
be statistically connected with its predecessor event and with its
successor event. If I did not believe that implicitly, I would lose
all faith in the scientific method. For if one single ‘supernatural’
event or thing had ever occurred or existed it would have constituted
an entirely unpredictable event and would have initiated a series–a
succession–of such events; a state of things which no scientist will
or can believe possible in an orderly universe.

“At the same time, I recognize the fact that I myself have done
things–caused events to occur, if you prefer–that I cannot explain to
you or to any other human being in any symbology known to our science;
and it is about an even more inexplicable–call it ‘hunch’ if you
like–that I asked to have a talk with you today.”

“But you are arguing in circles,” Samms protested. “Or are you trying
to set up a paradox?”

“Neither. I am merely clearing the way for a somewhat startling thing I
am to say later on. You know, of course, that any situation with which
a mind is unable to cope; a really serious dilemma which it cannot
resolve; will destroy that mind–frustration, escape from reality, and
so on. You also will realize that I must have become cognizant of my
own peculiarities long before anyone else did or could?”

“Ah. I see. Yes, of course.” Samms, intensely interested, leaned
forward. “Yet your present personality is adequately, splendidly
integrated. How could you possibly have overcome–reconciled–a
situation so full of conflict?”

“You are, I think, familiar with my parentage?” Samms, keen as he was,
did not consider it noteworthy that the big Norwegian answered his
question only by asking one of his own.

“Yes … oh, I’m beginning to see … but Commissioner Kinnison has not
had access to your dossier. Go ahead.”

“My father is Dr. Hjalmar Bergenholm. My mother, before her marriage,
was Dr. Olga Bjornson. Both were, and are, nuclear physicists–very
good ones. Pioneers, they have been called. They worked, and are still
working, in the newest, outermost fringes of the field.”

“Oh!” Kinnison exclaimed. “A mutant? Born with second sight–or
whatever it is?”

“Not second sight, as history describes the phenomenon, no. The
records do not show that any such faculty was ever demonstrated to the
satisfaction of any competent scientific investigator. What I have is
something else. Whether or not it will breed true is an interesting
topic of speculation, but one having nothing to do with the problem now
in hand. To return to the subject, I resolved my dilemma long since.
There is, I am absolutely certain, a science of the mind which is as
definite, as positive, as immutable of law, as is the science of the
physical. While I will make no attempt to prove it to you, I know
that such a science exists, and that I was born with the ability to
perceive at least some elements of it.

“Now to the matter of the meteor of the Patrol. That emblem was and is
purely physical. The pirates have just as able scientists as we have.
What physical science can devise and synthesize, physical science can
analyze and duplicate. There is a point, however, beyond which physical
science cannot go. It can neither analyze nor imitate the tangible
products of that which I have so loosely called the science of the mind.

“I know, Councillor Samms, what the Triplanetary Service needs;
something vastly more than its meteor. I also know that the need will
become greater and greater as the sphere of action of the Patrol
expands. Without a really efficient symbol, the Solarian Patrol will
be hampered even more than the Triplanetary Service; and its logical
extension into the Space Patrol, or whatever that larger organization
may be called, will be definitely impossible. We need something which
will identify any representative of Civilization, positively and
unmistakably, wherever he may be. It must be impossible of duplication,
or even of imitation, to which end it must kill any unauthorized entity
who attempts imposture. It must operate as a telepath between its owner
and any other living intelligence, of however high or low degree, so
that mental communication, so much clearer and faster than physical,
will be possible without the laborious learning of language; or between
us and such peoples as those of Rigel Four or of Palain Seven, both
of whom we know to be of high intelligence and who must already be
conversant with telepathy.”

“Are you or have you been, reading my mind?” Samms asked quietly.

“No,” Bergenholm replied flatly. “It is not and has not been necessary.
Any man who can think, who has really considered the question, and
who has the good of Civilization at heart, must have come to the same

“Probably so, at that. But no more side issues. You have a solution of
some kind worked out, or you would not be here. What is it?”

“It is that you, Solarian Councillor Samms, should go to Arisia as soon
as possible.”

“Arisia!” Samms exclaimed, and:

“Arisia! Of all the hells in space, why Arisia? And how can we make the
approach? Don’t you know that nobody can get anywhere near that damn

Bergenholm shrugged his shoulders and spread both arms wide in a
pantomime of complete helplessness.

“How do you know–another of your hunches?” Kinnison went on. “Or did
somebody tell you something? Where did you get it?”

“It is not a hunch,” the Norwegian replied, positively. “No one told me
anything. But I know–as definitely as I know that the combustion of
hydrogen in oxygen will yield water–that the Arisians are very well
versed in that which I have called the science of the mind; that if
Virgil Samms goes to Arisia he will obtain the symbol he needs; that he
will never obtain it otherwise. As to how I know these things … I
can’t … I just … I know it, I tell you!”

Without another word, without asking permission to leave, Bergenholm
whirled around and hurried out. Samms and Kinnison stared at each other.

“Well?” Kinnison asked, quizzically.

“I’m going. Now. Whether I can be spared or not, and whether you think
I’m out of control or not. I believe him, every word–and besides,
there’s the Bergenholm. How about you? Coming?”

“Yes. Can’t say that I’m sold one hundred percent; but, as you say, the
Bergenholm is a hard fact to shrug off. And at minimum rating, it’s got
to be tried. What are you taking? Not a fleet, probably–the Boise?
Or the Chicago?” It was the Commissioner of Public Safety speaking
now, the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces. “The Chicago, I’d
say–the fastest and strongest thing in space.”

“Recommendation approved. Blast-off; twelve hundred hours tomorrow!”


The superdreadnought Chicago, as she approached the imaginary but
nevertheless sharply defined boundary, which no other ship had been
allowed to pass, went inert and crept forward, mile by mile. Every
man, from Commissioner and Councillor down, was taut and tense. So
widely variant, so utterly fantastic, were the stories going around
about this Arisia that no one knew what to expect. They expected the
unexpected–and got it.

“Ah, Tellurians, you are precisely on time.” A strong, assured,
deeply resonant pseudo-voice made itself heard in the depths of
each mind aboard the tremendous ship of war. “Pilots and navigating
officers, you will shift course to one seventy eight dash seven twelve
fifty three. Hold that course, inert, at one Tellurian gravity of
acceleration. Virgil Samms will now be interviewed. He will return to
the consciousnesses of the rest of you in exactly six of your hours.”

Practically dazed by the shock of their first experience with
telepathy, not one of the Chicago’s crew perceived anything unusual
in the phraseology of that utterly precise, diamond-clear thought.
Samms and Kinnison, however, precisionists themselves, did. But, warned
although they were and keyed up although they were to detect any sign
of hypnotism or of mental suggestion, neither of them had the faintest
suspicion, then or ever, that Virgil Samms did not as a matter of fact
leave the Chicago at all.

Samms knew that he boarded a lifeboat and drove it toward the
shimmering haze beyond which Arisia was. Commissioner Kinnison knew,
as surely as did every other man aboard, that Samms did those things,
because he and the other officers and most of the crew watched Samms do
them. They watched the lifeboat dwindle in size with distance; watched
it disappear within the peculiarly iridescent veil of force which their
most penetrant ultra-beam spy-rays could not pierce.

They waited.

And, since every man concerned knew, beyond any shadow of doubt and
to the end of his life, that everything that seemed to happen actually
did happen, it will be so described.

Virgil Samms, then, drove his small vessel through Arisia’s innermost
screen and saw a planet so much like Earth that it might have been her
sister world. There were the white ice-caps, the immense blue oceans,
the verdant continents partially obscured by fleecy banks of cloud.

Would there, or would there not, be cities? While he had not known
at all exactly what to expect, he did not believe that there would
be any large cities upon Arisia. To qualify for the role of deus ex
, the Arisian with whom Samms was about to deal would have to
be a super-man indeed–a being completely beyond man’s knowledge or
experience in power of mind. Would such a race of beings have need of
such things as cities? They would not. There would be no cities.

Nor were there. The lifeboat flashed downward–slowed–landed smoothly
in a regulation dock upon the outskirts of what appeared to be a small
village surrounded by farms and woods.

“This way, please.” An inaudible voice directed him toward a
two-wheeled vehicle which was almost, but not quite, like a Dillingham

This car, however, took off by itself as soon as Samms closed the door.
It sped smoothly along a paved highway devoid of all other traffic,
past farms and past cottages, to stop of itself in front of the low,
massive structure which was the center of the village and, apparently,
its reason for being.

“This way, please,” and Samms went through an automatically-opened
door; along a short, bare hall; into a fairly large central room
containing a vat and one deeply-holstered chair.

“Sit down, please.” Samms did so, gratefully. He did not know whether
he could have stood up much longer or not.

He had expected to encounter a tremendous mentality; but this was a
thing far, far beyond his wildest imaginings. This was a brain–just
that–nothing else. Almost globular; at least ten feet in diameter;
immersed in and in perfect equilibrium with a pleasantly aromatic
liquid–a BRAIN!

“Relax,” the Arisian ordered, soothingly, and Samms found that he
could relax. “Through the one you know as Bergenholm I heard of your
need and have permitted you to come here this once for instruction.”

“But this … none of this … it isn’t … it can’t be real!” Samms
blurted. “I am–I must be–imagining it … and yet I know that I
can’t be hypnotized–I’ve been psychoed against it!”

“What is reality?” the Arisian asked, quietly. “Your profoundest
thinkers have never been able to answer that question. Nor, although I
am much older and a much more capable thinker than any member of your
race, would I attempt to give you its true answer. Nor, since your
experience has been so limited, is it to be expected that you could
believe without reservation any assurances I might give you in thoughts
or in words. You must, then, convince yourself–definitely, by means
of your own five senses–that I and everything about you are real, as
you understand reality. You saw the village and this building; you see
the flesh that houses the entity which is I. You feel your own flesh;
as you tap the woodwork with your knuckles you feel the impact and
hear the vibrations as sound. As you entered this room you must have
perceived the odor of the nutrient solution in which and by virtue of
which I live. There remains only the sense of taste. Are you by any
chance either hungry or thirsty?”


“Drink of the tankard in the niche yonder. In order to avoid any
appearance of suggestion I will tell you nothing of its content except
the one fact that it matches perfectly the chemistry of your tissues.”

Gingerly enough, Samms brought the pitcher to his lips–then, seizing
it in both hands, he gulped down a tremendous draught. It was GOOD! It
smelled like all appetizing kitchen aromas blended into one; it tasted
like all of the most delicious meals he had ever eaten; it quenched his
thirst as no beverage had ever done. But he could not empty even that
comparatively small container–whatever the stuff was, it had a satiety
value immensely higher even than old, rare, roast beef! With a sigh of
repletion Samms replaced the tankard and turned again to his peculiar

“I am convinced. That was real. No possible mental influence could so
completely and unmistakably satisfy the purely physical demands of
a body as hungry and as thirsty as mine was. Thanks, immensely, for
allowing me to come here, Mr….?”

“You may call me Mentor. I have no name, as you understand the term.
Now, then, please think fully–you need not speak–of your problems and
of your difficulties; of what you have done and of what you have it in
mind to do.”

Samms thought, flashingly and cogently. A few minutes sufficed to cover
Triplanetary’s history and the beginning of the Solarian Patrol; then,
for almost three hours, he went into the ramifications of the Galactic
Patrol of his imaginings. Finally he wrenched himself back to reality.
He jumped up, paced the floor, and spoke.

“But there’s a vital flaw, one inherent and absolutely ruinous fact
that makes the whole thing impossible!” he burst out, rebelliously. “No
one man, or group of men, no matter who they are, can be trusted with
that much power. The Council and I have already been called everything
imaginable; and what we have done so far is literally nothing at
all in comparison with what the Galactic Patrol could and must do.
Why, I myself would be the first to protest against the granting of
such power to anybody. Every dictator in history, from Philip of
Macedon to the Tyrant of Asia, claimed to be–and probably was, in his
beginnings–motivated solely by benevolence. How am I to think that the
proposed Galactic Council, or even I myself, will be strong enough to
conquer a thing that has corrupted utterly every man who has ever won
it? Who is to watch the watchmen?”

“The thought does you credit, youth,” Mentor replied, unmoved. “That is
one reason why you are here. You, of your own force, can not know that
you are in fact incorruptible. I, however, know. Moreover, there is an
agency by virtue of which that which you now believe to be impossible
will become commonplace. Extend your arm.”

Samms did so, and there snapped around his wrist a platinum-iridium
bracelet carrying, wrist-watch-wise, a lenticular something at which
the Tellurian stared in stupefied amazement. It seemed to be composed
of thousands–millions–of tiny gems, each of which emitted pulsatingly
all the colors of the spectrum; it was throwing out–broadcasting–a
turbulent flood of writhing, polychromatic light!

“The successor to the golden meteor of the Triplanetary Service,”
Mentor said, calmly. “The Lens of Arisia. You may take my word for it,
until your own experience shall have convinced you of the fact, that
no one will ever wear Arisia’s Lens who is in any sense unworthy. Here
also is one for your friend, Commissioner Kinnison; it is not necessary
for him to come physically to Arisia. It is, you will observe, in an
insulated container, and does not glow. Touch its surface, but lightly
and very fleetingly, for the contact will be painful.”

Samms’ finger-tip barely touched one dull, gray, lifeless jewel: his
whole arm jerked away uncontrollably as there swept through his whole
being the intimation of an agony more poignant by far than any he had
ever known.

“Why–it’s alive!” he gasped.

“No, it is not really alive, as you understand the term …” Mentor
paused, as though seeking a way to describe to the Tellurian a thing
which was to him starkly incomprehensible. “It is, however, endowed
with what you might call a sort of pseudo-life; by virtue of which it
gives off its characteristic radiation while, and only while, it is
in physical circuit with the living entity–the ego, let us say–with
whom it is in exact resonance. Glowing, the Lens is perfectly harmless;
it is complete–saturated–satiated–fulfilled. In the dark condition
it is, as you have learned, dangerous in the extreme. It is then
incomplete–unfulfilled–frustrated–you might say seeking or yearning
or demanding. In that condition its pseudo-life interferes so strongly
with any life to which it is not attuned that that life, in a space of
seconds, is forced out of this plane or cycle of existence.”

“Then I–I alone–of all the entities in existence, can wear this
particular Lens?” Samms licked his lips and stared at it, glowing so
satisfyingly and contentedly upon his wrist. “But when I die, will it
be a perpetual menace?”

“By no means. A Lens cannot be brought into being except to match some
one living personality; a short time after you pass into the next cycle
your Lens will disintegrate.”

“Wonderful!” Samms breathed, in awe. “But there’s one thing … these
things are … priceless, and there will be millions of them to
make … and you don’t….”

“What will we get out of it, you mean?” The Arisian seemed to smile.

“Exactly.” Samms blushed, but held his ground. “Nobody does anything
for nothing. Altruism is beautiful in theory, but it has never been
known to work in practice. I will pay a tremendous price–any price
within reason or possibility–for the Lens; but I will have to know
what that price is to be.”

“It will be heavier than you think, or can at present realize; although
not in the sense you fear.” Mentor’s thought was solemnity itself.
“Whoever wears the Lens of Arisia will carry a load that no weaker mind
could bear. The load of authority; of responsibility; of knowledge
that would wreck completely any mind of lesser strength. Altruism? No.
Nor is it a case of good against evil, as you so firmly believe. Your
mental picture of glaring white and of unrelieved black is not a true
picture. Neither absolute evil nor absolute good do or can exist.”

“But that would make it still worse!” Samms protested. “In that case,
I can’t see any reason at all for your exerting yourselves–putting
yourselves out–for us.”

“There is, however, reason enough; although I am not sure that I can
make it as clear to you as I would wish. There are in fact three
reasons; any one of which would justify us in exerting–would compel
us to exert–the trivial effort involved in the furnishing of Lenses
to your Galactic Patrol. First, there is nothing either intrinsically
right or intrinsically wrong about liberty or slavery, democracy or
autocracy, freedom of action or complete regimentation. It seems to us,
however, that the greatest measure of happiness and of well-being for
the greatest number of entities, and therefore the optimum advancement
toward whatever sublime Goal it is toward which this cycle of existence
is trending in the vast and unknowable Scheme of Things, is to be
obtained by securing for each and every individual the greatest amount
of mental and physical freedom compatible with the public welfare. We
of Arisia are only a small part of this cycle; and, as goes the whole,
so goes in greater or lesser degree each of the parts. Is it impossible
for you, a fellow citizen of this cycle-universe, to believe that
such fulfillment alone would be ample compensation for a much greater

“I never thought of it in that light….” It was hard for Samms to
grasp the concept; he never did understand it thoroughly. “I begin to
see, I think … at least, I believe you.”

“Second, we have a more specific obligation in that the life of many,
many worlds has sprung from Arisian seed. Thus, in loco parentis, we
would be derelict indeed if we refused to act. And third, you yourself
spend highly valuable time and much effort in playing chess. Why do you
do it? What do you get out of it?”

“Why, I … uh … mental exercise, I suppose … I like it!”

“Just so. And I am sure that one of your very early philosophers came
to the conclusion that a fully competent mind, from a study of one
fact or artifact belonging to any given universe, could construct
or visualize that universe, from the instant of its creation to its
ultimate end?”

“Yes. At least, I have heard the proposition stated, but I have never
believed it possible.”

“It is not possible simply because no fully competent mind ever has
existed or ever will exist. A mind can become fully competent only by
the acquisition of infinite knowledge, which would require infinite
time as well as infinite capacity. Our equivalent of your chess,
however, is what we call the ‘Visualization of the Cosmic All’. In my
visualization a descendant of yours named Clarrissa MacDougall will, in
a store called Brenleer’s upon the planet … but no, let us consider
a thing nearer at hand and concerning you personally, so that its
accuracy will be subject to check. Where you will be and exactly what
you will be doing, at some definite time in the future. Five years, let
us say?”

“Go ahead. If you can do that you’re good.”

“Five Tellurian calendar years then, from the instant of your passing
through the screen of ‘The Hill’ on this present journey, you will
be … allow me, please, a moment of thought … you will be in a
barber shop not yet built; the address of which is to be fifteen
hundred fifteen Twelfth Avenue, Spokane, Washington, North America,
Tellus. The barber’s name will be Antonio Carbonero and he will be
left-handed. He will be engaged in cutting your hair. Or rather, the
actual cutting will have been done and he will be shaving, with a razor
trade-marked ‘Jensen-King-Byrd’, the short hairs in front of your
left ear. A comparatively small, quadrupedal, grayish-striped entity,
of the race called ‘cat’–a young cat, this one will be, and called
Thomas, although actually of the female sex–will jump into your lap,
addressing you pleasantly in a language with which you yourself are
only partially familiar. You call it mewing and purring, I believe?”

“Yes,” the flabbergasted Samms managed to say. “Cats do
purr–especially kittens.”

“Ah–very good. Never having met a cat personally, I am gratified at
your corroboration of my visualization. This female youth erroneously
called Thomas, somewhat careless in computing the elements of her
trajectory, will jostle slightly the barber’s elbow with her tail; thus
causing him to make a slight incision, approximately three millimeters
long, parallel to and just above your left cheek-bone. At the precise
moment in question, the barber will be applying a styptic pencil to
this insignificant wound. This forecast is, I trust, sufficiently
detailed so that you will have no difficulty in checking its accuracy
or its lack thereof?”

“Detailed! Accuracy!” Samms could scarcely think. “But listen–not
that I want to cross you up deliberately, but I’ll tell you now that a
man doesn’t like to get sliced by a barber, even such a little nick as
that. I’ll remember that address–and the cat–and I’ll never go into
the place!”

“Every event does affect the succession of events,” Mentor
acknowledged, equably enough. “Except for this interview, you would
have been in New Orleans at that time, instead of in Spokane. I have
considered every pertinent factor. You will be a busy man. Hence, while
you will think of this matter frequently and seriously during the near
future, you will have forgotten it in less than five years. You will
remember it only at the touch of the astringent, whereupon you will
give voice to certain self-derogatory and profane remarks.”

“I ought to,” Samms grinned; a not-too-pleasant grin. He had been
appalled by the quality of mind able to do what Mentor had just done;
he was now more than appalled by the Arisian’s calm certainty that what
he had foretold in such detail would in every detail come to pass.
“If, after all this Spokane–let a tiger-striped kitten jump into my
lap–let a left-handed Tony Carbonero nick me–uh-uh, Mentor, UH-UH!
If I do, I’ll deserve to be called everything I can think of!”

“These that I have mentioned, the gross occurrences, are problems
only for inexperienced thinkers.” Mentor paid no attention to Samms’
determination never to enter that shop. “The real difficulties lie
in the fine detail, such as the length, mass, and exact place and
position of landing, upon apron or floor, of each of your hairs as
it is severed. Many factors are involved. Other clients passing
by–opening and shutting doors–air currents–sunshine–wind–pressure,
temperature, humidity. The exact fashion in which the barber will flick
his shears, which in turn depends upon many other factors–what he will
have been doing previously, what he will have eaten and drunk, whether
or not his home life will have been happy … you little realize,
youth, what a priceless opportunity this will be for me to check the
accuracy of my visualization. I shall spend many periods upon the
problem. I cannot attain perfect accuracy, of course. Ninety nine point
nine nines percent, let us say … or perhaps ten nines … is all that
I can reasonably expect….”

“But, Mentor!” Samms protested. “I can’t help you on a thing like that!
How can I know or report the exact mass, length, and orientation of
single hairs?”

“You cannot; but, since you will be wearing your Lens, I myself can
and will compare minutely my visualization with the actuality. For
know, youth, that wherever any Lens is, there can any Arisian be if he
so desires. And now, knowing that fact, and from your own knowledge
of the satisfactions to be obtained from chess and other such mental
activities, and from the glimpses you have had into my own mind, do you
retain any doubts that we Arisians will be fully compensated for the
trifling effort involved in furnishing whatever number of Lenses may be

“I have no more doubts. But this Lens … I’m getting more afraid of
it every minute. I see that it is a perfect identification; I can
understand that it can be a perfect telepath. But is it something else,
as well? If it has other powers … what are they?”

“I cannot tell you; or, rather, I will not. It is best for your own
development that I do not, except in the most general terms. It has
additional qualities, it is true; but, since no two entities ever have
the same abilities, no two Lenses will ever be of identical qualities.
Strictly speaking, a Lens has no real power of its own; it merely
concentrates, intensifies, and renders available whatever powers are
already possessed by its wearer. You must develop your own powers and
your own abilities; we of Arisia, in furnishing the Lens, will have
done everything that we should do.”

“Of course, sir; and much more than we have any right to expect. You
have given me a Lens for Roderick Kinnison; how about the others? Who
is to select them?”

“You are, for a time.” Silencing the man’s protests, Mentor went on:
“You will find that your judgment will be good. You will send to us
only one entity who will not be given a Lens, and it is necessary
that that one entity should be sent here. You will begin a system of
selection and training which will become more and more rigorous as
time goes on. This will be necessary; not for the selection itself,
which the Lensmen themselves could do among babies in their cradles,
but because of the benefits thus conferred upon the many who will not
graduate, as well as upon the few who will. In the meantime you will
select the candidates; and you will be shocked and dismayed when you
discover how few you will be able to send.

“You will go down in history as First Lensman Samms; the Crusader,
the man whose wide vision and tremendous grasp made it possible for
the Galactic Patrol to become what it is to be. You will have highly
capable help, of course. The Kinnisons, with their irresistible driving
force, their indomitable will to do, their transcendent urge; Costigan,
back of whose stout Irish heart lie Erin’s best of brains and brawn;
your cousins George and Ray Olmstead; your daughter Virgilia….”

“Virgilia! Where does she fit into this picture? What do you know
about her–and how?”

“A mind would be incompetent indeed who could not visualize, from even
the most fleeting contact with you, a fact which has been in existence
for some twenty three of your years. Her doctorate in psychology;
her intensive studies under Martian and Venerian masters–even under
one reformed Adept of North Polar Jupiter–of the involuntary,
uncontrollable, almost unknown and hence highly revealing muscles
of the face, the hands, and other parts of the human body. You will
remember that poker game for a long time.”

“I certainly will.” Samms grinned, a bit shamefacedly. “She gave us
clear warning of what she was going to do, and then cleaned us out to
the last millo.”

“Naturally. She has, all unconsciously, been training herself for
the work she is destined to do. But to resume; you will feel yourself
incompetent, unworthy–that, too, is a part of a Lensman’s Load. When
you first scan the mind of Roderick Kinnison you will feel that he, not
you, should be the prime mover in the Galactic Patrol. But know now
that no mind, not even the most capable in the universe, can either
visualize truly or truly evaluate itself. Commissioner Kinnison, upon
scanning your mind as he will scan it, will know the truth and will be
well content. But time presses; in one minute you leave.”

“Thanks a lot … thanks.” Samms got to his feet and paused,
hesitantly. “I suppose that it will be all right … that is, I can
call on you again, if…?”

“No,” the Arisian declared, coldly. “My visualization does not indicate
that it will ever again be either necessary or desirable for you to
visit or to communicate with me or with any other Arisian.”

Communication ceased as though a solid curtain had been drawn between
the two. Samms strode out and stepped into the waiting vehicle, which
whisked him back to his lifeboat. He blasted off; arriving in the
control room of the Chicago precisely at the end of the sixth hour
after leaving it.

“Well, Rod, I’m back …” he began, and stopped; utterly unable to
speak. For at the mention of the name Samms’ Lens had put him fully
en rapport with his friend’s whole mind; and what he perceived struck
him–literally and precisely–dumb.

He had always liked and admired Rod Kinnison. He had always known
that he was tremendously able and capable. He had known that he was
big; clean; a square shooter; the world’s best. Hard; a driver who
had little more mercy on his underlings in selected undertakings than
he had on himself. But now, as he saw spread out for his inspection
Kinnison’s ego in its entirety; as he compared in fleeting glances that
terrific mind with those of the other officers–good men, too, all of
them–assembled in the room; he knew that he had never even begun to
realize what a giant Roderick Kinnison really was.

“What’s the matter, Virge?” Kinnison exclaimed, and hurried up, both
hands outstretched. “You look like you’re seeing ghosts! What did they
do to you?”

“Nothing–much. But ‘ghosts’ doesn’t half describe what I’m seeing
right now. Come into my office, will you, Rod?”

Ignoring the curious stares of the junior officers, the Commissioner
and the Councillor went into the latter’s quarters, and in those
quarters the two Lensmen remained in close consultation during
practically all of the return trip to Earth. In fact, they were still
conferring deeply, via Lens, when the Chicago landed and they took a
ground-car into The Hill.

“But who are you going to send first, Virge?” Kinnison demanded. “You
must have decided on at least some of them, by this time.”

“I know of only five, or possibly six, who are ready,” Samms replied,
glumly. “I would have sworn that I knew of a hundred, but they don’t
measure up. Jack, Mason Northrop, and Conway Costigan, for the first
load. Lyman Cleveland, Fred Rodebush, and perhaps Bergenholm–I haven’t
been able to figure him out, but I’ll know when I get him under my
Lens–next. That’s all.”

“Not quite. How about your identical-twin cousins, Ray and George
Olmstead, who have been doing such a terrific job of counter-spying?”

“Perhaps … Quite possibly.”

“And if I’m good enough, Clayton and Schweikert certainly are, to name
only two of the commodores. And Knobos and DalNalten. And above all,
how about Jill?”

“Jill? Why, I don’t … she measures up, of course, but … but at
that, there was nothing said against it, either … I wonder….”

“Why not have the boys in–Jill, too–and thrash it out?”

The young people were called in; the story was told; the problem
stated. The boys’ reaction was instantaneous and unanimous. Jack
Kinnison took the lead.

“Of course Jill’s going, if anybody does!” he burst out vehemently.
“Count her out, with all the stuff she’s got? Hardly!”

“Why, Jack! This, from you?” Jill seemed highly surprised. “I have it
on excellent authority that I’m a stinker; a half-witted one, at that.
A jelly-brain, with come-hither eyes.”

“You are, and a lot of other things besides.” Jack Kinnison did not
back up a millimeter, even before their fathers. “But even at your
sapadilliest your half wits are better than most other people’s whole
ones; and I never said or thought that your brain couldn’t function,
whenever it wanted to, back of those sad eyes. Whatever it takes to be
a Lensman, sir,” he turned to Samms, “she’s got just as much of as the
rest of us. Maybe more.”

“I take it, then, that there is no objection to her going?” Samms asked.

There was no objection.

“What ship shall we take, and when?”

“The Chicago. Now.” Kinnison directed. “She’s hot and ready. We
didn’t strike any trouble going or coming, so she didn’t need much
servicing. Flit!”

They flitted, and the great battleship made the second cruise as
uneventfully as she had made the first. The Chicago’s officers and
crew knew that the young people left the vessel separately; that they
returned separately, each in his or her lifeboat. They met, however,
not in the control room, but in Jack Kinnison’s private quarters; the
three young Lensmen and the girl. The three were embarrassed; ill at
ease. The Lenses were–definitely–not working. No one of them would
put his Lens on Jill, since she did not have one…. The girl broke the
short silence.

“Wasn’t she the most perfectly beautiful thing you ever saw?” she
breathed. “In spite of being over seven feet tall? She looked to be
about twenty–except her eyes–but she must have been a hundred, to
know so much–but what are you boys staring so about?”

She!” Three voices blurted as one.

“Yes. She. Why? I know we weren’t together, but I got the impression,
some way or other, that there was only the one. What did you see?”

All three men started to talk at once, a clamor of noise; then all
stopped at once.

“You first, Spud. Whom did you talk to, and what did he, she, or it
say?” Although Conway Costigan was a few years older than the other
three, they all called him by nickname as a matter of course.

“National Police Headquarters–Chief of the Detective Bureau,”
Costigan reported, crisply. “Between forty three and forty five; six
feet and half an inch; one seventy five. Hard, fine, keen, a Big Time
Operator if there ever was one. Looked a lot like your father, Jill;
the same dark auburn hair, just beginning to gray, and the same deep
orange-yellow markings in his eyes. He gave me the works; then took
this Lens out of his safe, snapped it onto my wrist, and gave me two
orders–get out and stay out.”

Jack and Mase stared at Costigan, at Jill, and at each other. Then they
whistled in unison.

“I see this is not going to be a unanimous report, except possibly in
one minor detail,” Jill remarked. “Mase, you’re next.”

“I landed on the campus of the University of Arisia,” Northrop stated,
flatly. “Immense place–hundreds of thousands of students. They look
me to the Physics Department–to the private laboratory of the
Department Head himself. He had a panel with about a million meters
and gauges on it; he scanned and measured every individual component
element of my brain. Then he made a pattern, on a milling router
just about as complicated as his panel. From there on, of course, it
was simple–just like a dentist making a set of china choppers or a
metallurgist embedding a test-section. He snapped a couple of sentences
of directions at me, and then said ‘Scram!’ That’s all.”

“Sure that was all?” Costigan asked. “Didn’t he add ‘and stay

“He didn’t say it, exactly, but the implication was clear enough.”

“The one point of similarity,” Jill commented. “Now you, Jack. You have
been looking as though we were all candidates for canvas jackets that
lace tightly up the back.”

“Uh-uh. As though maybe I am. I didn’t see anything at all. Didn’t
even land on the planet. Just floated around in an orbit inside that
screen. The thing I talked with was a pattern of pure force. This Lens
simply appeared on my wrist, bracelet and all, out of thin air. He told
me plenty, though, in a very short time–his last word being for me not
to come back or call back.”

“Hm … m … m.” This of Jack’s was a particularly indigestible bit,
even for Jill Samms.

“In plain words,” Costigan volunteered, “we all saw exactly what we
expected to see.”

“Uh-uh,” Jill denied. “I certainly did not expect to see a
woman … no; what each of us saw, I think, was what would do us the
most good–give each of us the highest possible lift. I am wondering
whether or not there was anything at all really there.”

“That might be it, at that.” Jack scowled in concentration. “But there
must have been something there–these Lenses are real. But what makes
me mad is that they wouldn’t give you a Lens. You’re just as good a man
as any one of us–if I didn’t know it wouldn’t do a damn bit of good
I’d go back there right now and….”

“Don’t pop off so, Jack!” Jill’s eyes, however, were starry. “I know
you mean it, and I could almost love you, at times–but I don’t need a
Lens. As a matter of fact, I’ll be much better off without one.”

“Jet back, Jill!” Jack Kinnison stared deeply into the girl’s eyes–but
still did not use his Lens. “Somebody must have done a terrific job of
selling, to make you believe that … or are you sold, actually?”

“Actually. Honestly. That Arisian was a thousand times more of a
woman than I ever will be, and she didn’t wear a Lens–never had
worn one. Women’s minds and Lenses don’t fit. There’s a sex-based
incompatibility. Lenses are as masculine as whiskers–and at that, only
a very few men can ever wear them, either. Very special men, like you
three and Dad and Pops Kinnison. Men with tremendous force, drive, and
scope. Pure killers, all of you; each in his own way, of course. No
more to be stopped than a glacier, and twice as hard and ten times as
cold. A woman simply can’t have that kind of a mind! There is going
to be a woman Lensman some day–just one–but not for years and years;
and I wouldn’t be in her shoes for anything. In this job of mine,

“Well, go on. What is this job you’re so sure you are going to do?”

“Why, I don’t know!” Jill exclaimed, startled eyes wide. “I thought I
knew all about it, but I don’t! Do you, about yours?”

They did not, not one of them; and they were all as surprised at that
fact as the girl had been.

“Well, to get back to this Lady Lensman who is going to appear some
day, I gather that she is going to be some kind of a freak. She’ll have
to be, practically, because of the sex-based fundamental nature of the
Lens. Mentor didn’t say so, in so many words, but she made it perfectly
clear that….”

“Mentor!” the three men exclaimed.

Each of them had dealt with Mentor!

“I am beginning to see,” Jill said, thoughtfully. “Mentor. Not a real
name at all. To quote the Unabridged verbatim–I had occasion to look
the word up the other day and I am appalled now at the certainty that
there was a connection–quote; Mentor, a wise and faithful counselor;
unquote. Have any of you boys anything to say? I haven’t; and I am
beginning to be scared blue.”

Silence fell; and the more they thought, those three young Lensmen
and the girl who was one of the two human women ever to encounter
knowingly an Arisian mind, the deeper that silence became.


“So you didn’t find anything on Nevia.” Roderick Kinnison got up,
deposited the inch-long butt of his cigar in an ashtray, lit another,
and prowled about the room; hands jammed deep into breeches pockets.
“I’m surprised. Nerado struck me as being a B.T.O…. I thought sure
he’d qualify.”

“So did I.” Samms’ tone was glum. “He’s Big Time, and an Operator;
but not big enough, by far. I’m–we’re both–finding out that Lensman
material is damned scarce stuff. There’s none on Nevia, and no
indication whatever that there ever will be any.”

“Tough … and you’re right, of course, in your stand that we’ll have
to have Lensmen from as many different solar systems as possible on
the Galactic Council or the thing won’t work at all. So damned much
jealousy–which is one reason why we’re here in New York instead
of out at The Hill, where we belong–we’ve found that out already,
even in such a small and comparatively homogeneous group as our own
system–the Solarian Council will not only have to be made up mostly
of Lensmen, but each and every inhabited planet of Sol will have to
be represented–even Pluto, I suppose, in time. And by the way, your
Mr. Saunders wasn’t any too pleased when you took Knobos of Mars and
DalNalten of Venus away from him and made Lensmen out of them–and put
them miles over his head.”

“Oh, I wouldn’t say that … exactly. I convinced him … but at that,
since Saunders is not Lensman grade himself, it was a trifle difficult
for him to understand the situation completely.”

“You say it easy–‘difficult’ is not the word I would use. But back
to the Lensman hunt.” Kinnison scowled blackly. “I agree, as I said
before, that we need non-human Lensmen, the more the better, but I
don’t think much of your chance of finding any. What makes you
think … Oh, I see … but I don’t know whether you’re justified or
not in assuming a high positive correlation between a certain kind of
mental ability and technological advancement.”

“No such assumption is necessary. Start anywhere you please, Rod, and
take it from there; including Nevia.”

“I’ll start with known facts, then. Interstellar flight is new to
us. We haven’t spread far, or surveyed much territory. But in the
eight solar systems with which we are most familiar there are seven
planets–I’m not counting Valeria–which are very much like Earth in
point of mass, size, climate, atmosphere, and gravity. Five of the
seven did not have any intelligent life and were colonized easily and
quickly. The Tellurian worlds of Procyon and Vega became friendly
neighbors–thank God we learned something on Nevia–because they were
already inhabited by highly advanced races: Procia by people as human
as we are, Vegia by people who would be so if it weren’t for their
tails. Many other worlds of these systems are inhabited by more or less
intelligent non-human races. Just how intelligent they are we don’t
know, but the Lensmen will soon find out.

“My point is that no race we have found so far has had either atomic
energy or any form of space-drive. In any contact with races having
space-drives we have not been the discoverers, but the discovered.
Our colonies are all within twenty six light-years of Earth except
Aldebaran II, which is fifty seven, but which drew a lot of people,
in spite of the distance, because it was so nearly identical with
Earth. On the other hand, the Nevians, from a distance of over a
hundred light-years, found us … implying an older race and a higher
development … but you just told me that they would never produce a

“That point stopped me, too, at first. Follow through; I want to see if
you arrive at the same conclusion I did.”

“Well … I … I …” Kinnison thought intensely, then went on: “Of
course, the Nevians were not colonizing; nor, strictly speaking,
exploring. They were merely hunting for iron–a highly organized,
intensively specialized operation to find a raw material they needed

“Precisely,” Samms agreed.

“The Rigellians, however, were surveying, and Rigel is about four
hundred and forty light-years from here. We didn’t have a thing they
needed or wanted. They nodded at us in passing and kept on going. I’m
still on your track?”

“Dead center. And just where does that put the Palainians?”

“I see … you may have something there, at that. Palain is so
far away that nobody knows even where it is–probably thousands
of light-years. Yet they have not only explored this system; they
colonized Pluto long before our white race colonized America. But damn
it, Virge, I don’t like it–any part of it. Rigel Four you may be able
to take, with your Lens … even one of their damned automobiles, if
you stay solidly en rapport with the driver. But Palain, Virge! Pluto
is bad enough, but the home planet! You can’t. Nobody can. It simply
can’t be done!”

“I know it won’t be easy,” Samms admitted, bleakly, “but if it’s got
to be done, I’ll do it. And I have a little information that I haven’t
had time to tell you yet. We discussed once before, you remember, what
a job it was to get into any kind of communication with the Palainians
on Pluto. You said then that nobody could understand them, and you were
right–then. However, I re-ran those brain-wave tapes, wearing my Lens,
and could understand them–the thoughts, that is–as well as though
they had been recorded in precisionist-grade English.”

What?” Kinnison exclaimed, then fell silent. Samms remained silent.
What they were thinking of Arisia’s Lens cannot be expressed in words.

“Well, go on,” Kinnison finally said. “Give me the rest of it–the
stinger that you’ve been holding back.”

“The messages–as messages–were clear and plain. The backgrounds,
however, the connotations and implications, were not. Some of their
codes and standards seem to be radically different from ours–so
utterly and fantastically different that I simply cannot reconcile
either their conduct or their ethics with their obviously high
intelligence and their advanced state of development. However,
they have at least some minds of tremendous power, and none of
the peculiarities I deduced were of such a nature as to preclude
Lensmanship. Therefore I am going to Pluto; and from there–I hope–to
Palain Seven. If there’s a Lensman there, I’ll get him.”

“You will, at that,” Kinnison paid quiet tribute to what he, better
than anyone else, knew that his friend had.

“But enough of me–how are you doing?”

“As well as can be expected at this stage of the game. The thing is
developing along three main lines. First, the pirates. Since that kind
of thing is more or less my own line I’m handling it myself, unless and
until you find someone better qualified. I’ve got Jack and Costigan
working on it now.

“Second; drugs, vice, and so on. I hope you find somebody to take this
line over, because, frankly, I’m in over my depth and want to get out.
Knobos and DalNalten are trying to find out if there’s anything to
the idea that there may be a planetary, or even inter-planetary, ring
involved. Since Sid Fletcher isn’t a Lensman I couldn’t disconnect him
openly from his job, but he knows a lot about the dope-vice situation
and is working practically full time with the other two.

“Third; pure–or rather, decidedly impure–politics. The more I studied
that subject, the clearer it became that politics would be the worst
and biggest battle of the three. There are too many angles I don’t
know a damned thing about, such as what to do about the succession of
foaming, screaming fits your friend Senator Morgan will be throwing
the minute he finds out what our Galactic Patrol is going to do. So I
ducked the whole political line.

“Now you know as well as I do–better, probably–that Morgan is only
the Pernicious Activities Committee of the North American Senate.
Multiply him by the thousands of others, all over space, who will be on
our necks before the Patrol can get its space-legs, and you will see
that all that stuff will have to be handled by a Lensman who, as well
as being a mighty smooth operator, will have to know all the answers
and will have to have plenty of guts. I’ve got the guts, but none of
the other prime requisites. Jill hasn’t, although she’s got everything
else. Fairchild, your Relations ace, isn’t a Lensman and can never
become one. So you can see quite plainly who has got to handle politics

“You may be right … but this Lensman business comes first….” Samms
pondered, then brightened. “Perhaps–probably–I can find somebody on
this trip–a Palainian, say–who is better qualified than any of us.”

Kinnison snorted. “If you can, I’ll buy you a week in any Venerian
relaxerie you want to name.”

“Better start saving up your credits, then, because from what I already
know of the Palainian mentality such a development is distinctly more
than a possibility.” Samms paused, his eyes narrowing. “I don’t know
whether it would make Morgan and his kind more rabid or less so to have
a non-Solarian entity possess authority in our affairs political–but
at least it would be something new and different. But in spite of what
you said about ‘ducking’ politics, what have you got Northrop, Jill and
Fairchild doing?”

“Well, we had a couple of discussions. I couldn’t give either Jill or
Dick orders, of course….”

“Wouldn’t, you mean,” Samms corrected.

“Couldn’t,” Kinnison insisted. “Jill, besides being your daughter and
Lensman grade, had no official connection with either the Triplanetary
Service or the Solarian Patrol. And the Service, including Fairchild,
is still Triplanetary; and it will have to stay Triplanetary until
you have found enough Lensmen so that you can spring your twin
surprises–Galactic Council and Galactic Patrol. However, Northrop and
Fairchild are keeping their eyes and ears open and their mouths shut,
and Jill is finding out whatever she can about drugs and so on, as
well as the various political angles. They’ll report to you–facts,
deductions, guesses, and recommendations–whenever you say the word.”

“Nice work, Rod. Thanks. I think I’ll call Jill now, before I
go–wonder where she is? … but I wonder … with the Lens perhaps
telephones are superfluous? I’ll try it.”

“JILL!” he thought intensely into his Lens, forming as he did so a
mental image of his gorgeous daughter as he knew her. But he found,
greatly to his surprise, that neither elaboration nor emphasis was

“Ouch!” came the almost instantaneous answer, long before his thought
was complete. “Don’t think so hard, Dad, it hurts–I almost missed a
step.” Virgilia was actually there with him; inside his own mind; in
closer touch with him than she had ever before been. “Back so soon?
Shall we report now, or aren’t you ready to go to work yet?”

“Skipping for the moment your aspersions on my present activities–not
quite.” Samms moderated the intensity of his thought to a
conversational level. “Just wanted to check with you. Come in, Rod.” In
flashing thoughts he brought her up to date. “Jill, do you agree with
what Rod here has just told me?”

“Yes. Fully. So do the boys.”

“That settles it, then–unless, of course, I can find a more capable

“Of course–but we will believe that when we see it.”

“Where are you and what are you doing?”

“Washington, D.C. European Embassy. Dancing with Herkimer Third,
Senator Morgan’s Number One secretary. I was going to make passes at
him–in a perfectly lady-like way, of course–but it wasn’t necessary.
He thinks he can break down my resistance.”

“Careful, Jill! That kind of stuff….”

“Is very old stuff indeed, Daddy dear. Simple. And Herkimer Third isn’t
really a menace; he just thinks he is. Take a look–you can, can’t
you, with your Lens?”

“Perhaps … Oh, yes. I see him as well as you do.” Fully en rapport
with the girl as he was, so that his mind received simultaneously with
hers any stimulus which she was willing to share, it seemed as though a
keen, handsome, deeply tanned face bent down from a distance of inches
toward his own. “But I don’t like it a bit–and him even less.”

“That’s because you aren’t a girl,” Jill giggled mentally. “This is
fun; and it won’t hurt him a bit, except maybe for a slightly bruised
vanity, when I don’t fall down flat at his feet. And I’m learning a lot
that he hasn’t any suspicion he’s giving away.”

“Knowing you, I believe that. But don’t … that is … well, be very
careful not to get your fingers burned. The job isn’t worth it–yet.”

“Don’t worry, Dad.” She laughed unaffectedly. “When it comes to
playboys like this one, I’ve got millions and skillions and whillions
of ohms of resistance. But here comes Senator Morgan himself, with a
fat and repulsive Venerian–he’s calling my boy-friend away from me,
with what he thinks is an imperceptible high-sign, into a huddle–and
my olfactory nerves perceive a rich and fruity aroma, as of
skunk–so … I hate to seem to be giving a Solarian Councillor the
heave-ho, but if I want to read what goes on–and I certainly do–I’ll
have to concentrate. As soon as you get back give us a call and we’ll
report. Take it easy, Dad!”

“You’re the one to be told that, not me. Good hunting, Jill!”

Samms, still seated calmly at his desk, reached out and pressed a
button marked “GARAGE”. His office was on the seventieth floor;
the garage occupied level after level of sub-basement. The screen
brightened; a keen young face appeared.

“Good evening, Jim. Will you please send my car up to the Wright Skyway

“At once, sir. It will be there in seventy five seconds.”

Samms cut off; and, after a brief exchange of thought with Kinnison,
went out into the hall and along it to the “DOWN” shaft. There,
going free, he stepped through a doorless, unguarded archway into
over a thousand feet of air. Although it was long after conventional
office hours the shaft was still fairly busy, but that made no
difference–inertialess collisions cannot even be felt. He bulleted
downward to the sixth floor, where he brought himself to an
instantaneous halt.

Leaving the shaft, he joined the now thinning crowd hurrying toward
the exit. A girl with meticulously plucked eyebrows and an astounding
hair-do, catching sight of his Lens, took her hands out of her breeches
pockets–skirts went out, as office dress, when up-and-down open-shaft
velocities of a hundred or so miles per hour replaced elevators–nudged
her companion, and whispered excitedly:

“Look there! Quick! I never saw one close up before, did you? That’s
him–himself! First Lensman Samms!”

At the Portal, the Lensman as a matter of habit held out his car-check,
but such formalities were no longer necessary, or even possible.
Everybody knew, or wanted to be thought of as knowing, Virgil Samms.

“Stall four sixty five, First Lensman, sir,” the uniformed gateman told
him, without even glancing at the extended disk.

“Thank you, Tom.”

“This way, please, sir, First Lensman,” and a youth, teeth gleaming
white in a startlingly black face, strode proudly to the indicated
stall and opened the vehicle’s door.

“Thank you, Danny,” Samms said, as appreciatively as though he did not
know exactly where his ground-car was.

He got in. The door jammed itself gently shut. The runabout–a
Dillingham eleven-forty–shot smoothly forward upon its two fat, soft
tires. Half-way to the exit archway he was doing forty; he hit the
steeply-banked curve leading into the lofty “street” at ninety. Nor was
there shock or strain. Motorcycle-wise, but automatically, the “Dilly”
leaned against its gyroscopes at precisely the correct angle; the huge
low-pressure tires clung to the resilient synthetic of the pavement
as though integral with it. Nor was there any question of conflicting
traffic, for this thoroughfare, six full levels above Varick Street
proper, was not, strictly speaking, a street at all. It had only one
point of access, the one which Samms had used; and only one exit–it
was simply and only a feeder into Wright Skyway, a limited-access

Samms saw, without noting particularly, the maze of traffic-ways of
which this feeder was only one tiny part; a maze which extended from
ground-level up to a point well above even the towering buildings of
New York’s metropolitan district.

The way rose sharply; Samms’ right foot went down a little farther;
the Dillingham began to pick up speed. Moving loud-speakers sang to
him and yelled and blared at him, but he did not hear them. Brilliant
signs, flashing and flaring all the colors of the spectrum–sheer
triumphs of the electrician’s art–blazed in or flamed into arresting
words and eye-catching pictures, but he did not see them. Advertising–
designed by experts to sell everything from aardvarks to Martian zyzmol
(“bottled ecstacy”)–but the First Lensman was a seasoned big-city
dweller. His mind had long since become a perfect filter, admitting to
his consciousness only things which he wanted to perceive: only so can
big-city life be made endurable.

Approaching the Skyway, he cut in his touring roadlights, slowed down
a trifle, and insinuated his low-flyer into the stream of traffic.
Those lights threw fifteen hundred watts apiece, but there was no
glare–polarized lenses and wind-shields saw to that.

He wormed his way over to the left-hand, high-speed lane and opened
up. At the edge of the skyscraper district, where Wright Skyway angles
sharply downward to ground level, Samms’ attention was caught and
held by something off to his right–a blue-white, whistling something
that hurtled upward into the air. As it ascended it slowed down; its
monotone shriek became lower and lower in pitch; its light went down
through the spectrum toward the red. Finally it exploded, with an
earth-shaking crash; but the lightning-like flash of the detonation,
instead of vanishing almost instantaneously, settled itself upon a
low-hanging artificial cloud and became a picture and four words–two
bearded faces and “SMITH BROS. COUGH DROPS”!

“Well, I’ll be damned!” Samms spoke aloud, chagrined at having been
compelled to listen to and to look at an advertisement. “I thought I
had seen everything, but that is really new!”

Twenty minutes–fifty miles–later, Samms left the Skyway at a point
near what had once been South Norwalk, Connecticut; an area transformed
now into the level square miles of New York Spaceport.

New York Spaceport; then, and until the establishment of Prime
Base, the biggest and busiest field in existence upon any planet of
Civilization. For New York City, long the financial and commercial
capital of the Earth, had maintained the same dominant position in the
affairs of the Solar System and was holding a substantial lead over her
rivals, Chicago, London, and Stalingrad, in the race for inter-stellar

And Virgil Samms himself, because of the ever-increasing menace of
piracy, had been largely responsible for the policy of basing the
war-vessels of the Triplanetary Patrol upon each space-field in direct
ratio to the size and importance of that field. Hence he was no
stranger in New York Spaceport; in fact, master psychologist that he
was, he had made it a point to know by first name practically everyone
connected with it.

No sooner had he turned his Dillingham over to a smiling attendant,
however, than he was accosted by a man whom he had never seen before.

“Mr. Samms?” the stranger asked.

“Yes.” Samms did not energize his Lens; he had not yet developed either
the inclination or the technique to probe instantaneously every entity
who approached him, upon any pretext whatever, in order to find out
what that entity really wanted.

“I’m Isaacson …” the man paused, as though he had supplied a world of

“Yes?” Samms was receptive, but not impressed.

“Interstellar Spaceways, you know. We’ve been trying to see you for
two weeks, but we couldn’t get past your secretaries, so I decided to
buttonhole you here, myself. But we’re just as much alone here as we
would be in either one of our offices–yes, more so. What I want to
talk to you about is having our exclusive franchise extended to cover
the outer planets and the colonies.”

“Just a minute, Mr. Isaacson. Surely you know that I no longer have
even a portfolio in the Council; that practically all of my attention
is, and for some time to come will be, directed elsewhere?”

“Exactly–officially.” Isaacson’s tone spoke volumes. “But you’re
still the Boss; they’ll do anything you tell them to. We couldn’t try
to do business with you before, of course, but in your present position
there is nothing whatever to prevent you from getting into the biggest
thing that will ever be. We are the biggest corporation in existence
now, as you know, and we are still growing–fast. We don’t do business
in a small way, or with small men; so here’s a check for a million
credits, or I will deposit it to your account….”

“I’m not interested.”

“As a binder,” the other went on, as smoothly as though his sentence
had not been interrupted, “with twenty-five million more to follow on
the day that our franchise goes through.”

“I’m still not interested.”

“No … o … o …?” Isaacson studied the Lensman narrowly: and Samms,
Lens now wide awake, studied the entrepreneur. “Well … I … while
I admit that we want you pretty badly, you are smart enough to know
that we’ll get what we want anyway, with or without you. With you,
though, it will be easier and quicker, so I am authorized to offer you,
besides the twenty six million credits …” he savored the words as he
uttered them: “twenty two and one-half percent of Spaceways. On today’s
market that is worth fifty million credits; ten years from now it will
be worth fifty billion. That’s my high bid; that’s as high as we can
possibly go.”

“I’m glad to hear that–I’m still not interested,” and Samms strode
away, calling his friend Kinnison as he did so.

“Rod? Virgil.” He told the story.

“Whew!” Kinnison whistled expressively. “They’re not pikers, anyway,
are they? What a sweet set-up–and you could wrap it up and hand it
to them like a pound of coffee….”

“Or you could, Rod.”

“Could be….” The big Lensman ruminated. “But what a hookup!
Perfectly legitimate, and with plenty of precedents–and arguments, of
a sort–in its favor. The outer planets. Then Alpha Centauri and Sirius
and Procyon and so on. Monopoly–all the traffic will bear….”

“Slavery, you mean!” Samms stormed. “It would hold Civilization back
for a thousand years!”

“Sure, but what do they care?”

“That’s it … and he said–and actually believed–that they would get
it without my help…. I can’t help wondering about that.”

“Simple enough, Virge, when you think about it. He doesn’t know yet
what a Lensman is. Nobody does, you know, except Lensmen. It will take
some time for that knowledge to get around….”

“And still longer for it to be believed.”

“Right. But as to the chance of Interstellar Spaceways ever getting the
monopoly they’re working for, I didn’t think I would have to remind you
that it was not entirely by accident that over half of the members of
the Solarian Council are Lensmen, and that any Galactic Councillor will
automatically have to be a Lensman. So go right ahead with what you
started, my boy, and don’t give Isaacson and Company another thought.
We’ll bend an optic or two in that direction while you are gone.”

“I was overlooking a few things, at that, I guess.” Samms sighed in
relief as he entered the main office of the Patrol.

The line at the receptionist’s desk was fairly short, but even
so, Samms was not allowed to wait. That highly decorative, but
far-from-dumb blonde, breaking off in mid-sentence her business of
the moment, turned on her charm as though it had been a battery of
floodlights, pressed a stud on her desk, and spoke to the man before
her and to the Lensman:

“Excuse me a moment, please. First Lensman Samms, sir…?”

“Yes, Miss Regan?” her communicator–“squawk-box”, in every day
parlance–broke in.

“First Lensman Samms is here, sir,” the girl announced, and broke the

“Good evening, Sylvia. Lieutenant-Commander Wagner, please, or whoever
else is handling clearances,” Samms answered what he thought was to
have been her question.

“Oh, no, sir; you are cleared. Commodore Clayton has been waiting for
you … here he is, now.”

“Hi, Virgil!” Commodore Clayton, a big, solid man with a scarred face
and a shock of iron-gray hair, whose collar bore the two silver stars
which proclaimed him to be the commander-in-chief of a continental
contingent of the Patrol, shook hands vigorously. “I’ll zip you out.
Miss Regan, call a bug, please.”

“Oh, that isn’t necessary, Alex!” Samms protested. “I’ll pick one up

“Not in any Patrol base in North America, my friend; nor, unless I am
very badly mistaken, anywhere else. From now on, Lensmen have absolute
priority, and the quicker everybody realizes exactly what that means,
the better.”

The “bug”–a vehicle something like a jeep, except more so–was waiting
at the door. The two men jumped aboard.

“The Chicago–and blast!” Clayton ordered, crisply.

The driver obeyed–literally. Gravel flew from beneath skidding tires
as the highly maneuverable little ground-car took off. A screaming
turn into the deservedly famous Avenue of Oaks. Along the Avenue.
Through the Gate, the guards saluting smartly as the bug raced past
them. Past the barracks. Past the airport hangars and strips. Out
into the space-field, the scarred and blackened area devoted solely
to the widely-spaced docks of the tremendous vessels which plied the
vacuous reaches of inter-planetary and inter-stellar space. Spacedocks
were, and are, huge and sprawling structures; built of concrete and
steel and asbestos and ultra-stubborn refractory and insulation
and vacuum-breaks; fully air-conditioned and having refrigeration
equipment of thousands of tons per hour of ice; designed not only
to expedite servicing, unloading, and loading, but also to protect
materials and personnel from the raving, searing blasts of take-off and
of landing.

A space-dock is a squat and monstrous cylinder, into whose hollow top
the lowermost one-third of a space-ship’s bulk fits as snugly as does a
baseball into the “pocket” of a veteran fielder’s long-seasoned glove.
And the tremendous distances between those docks minimize the apparent
size, both of the structures themselves and of the vessels surmounting
them. Thus, from a distance, the Chicago looked little enough, and
harmless enough; but as the bug flashed under the overhanging bulk and
the driver braked savagely to a stop at one of the dock’s entrances,
Samms could scarcely keep from flinching. That featureless, gray,
smoothly curving wall of alloy steel loomed so incredibly high above
them–extended so terrifyingly far outward beyond its visible means of
support! It must be on the very verge of crashing!

Samms stared deliberately at the mass of metal towering above him, then
smiled–not without effort–at his companion.

“You’d think, Alex, that a man would get over being afraid that a ship
was going to fall on him, but I haven’t–yet.”

“No, and you probably never will. I never have, and I’m one of the old
hands. Some claim not to mind it–but not in front of a lie detector.
That’s why they had to make the passenger docks bigger than the
liners–too many passengers fainted and had to be carried aboard on
stretchers–or cancelled passage entirely. However, scaring hell out of
them on the ground had one big advantage; they felt so safe inside that
they didn’t get the colly-wobbles so bad when they went free.”

“Well, I’ve got over that, anyway. Good-bye, Alex; and thanks.”

Samms entered the dock, shot smoothly upward, followed an escorting
officer to the captain’s own cabin, and settled himself into a
cushioned chair facing an ultra-wave view-plate. A face appeared upon
his communicator screen and spoke.

“Winfield to First Lensman Samms–you will be ready to blast off at
twenty one hundred?”

“Samms to Captain Winfield,” the Lensman replied. “I will be ready.”

Sirens yelled briefly; a noise which Samms knew was purely a formality.
Clearance had been issued; Station PIXNY was filling the air with
warnings. Personnel and material close enough to the Chicago’s dock
to be affected by the blast were under cover and safe.

The blast went on; the plate showed, instead of a view of the
space-field, a blaze of blue-white light. The war-ship was inertialess,
it is true; but so terrific were the forces released that incandescent
gases, furiously driven, washed the dock and everything for hundreds of
yards around it.

The plate cleared. Through the lower, denser layers of atmosphere the
Chicago bored in seconds; then, as the air grew thinner and thinner,
she rushed upward faster and faster. The terrain below became
concave … then convex. Being completely without inertia, the ship’s
velocity was at every instant that at which the friction of the medium
through which she blasted her way equaled precisely the force of her
driving thrust.

Wherefore, out in open space, the Earth a fast-shrinking tiny ball and
Sol himself growing smaller, paler, and weaker at a startling rate, the
Chicago’s speed attained an almost constant value; a value starkly
impossible for the human mind to grasp.


For hours Virgil Samms sat motionless, staring almost unseeing into his
plate. It was not that the view was not worth seeing–the wonder of
space, the ever-changing, constantly-shifting panorama of incredibly
brilliant although dimensionless points of light, against that wondrous
background of mist-besprinkled black velvet, is a thing that never
fails to awe even the most seasoned observer–but he had a tremendous
load on his mind. He had to solve an apparently insoluble problem.
How … how … HOW could he do what he had to do?

Finally, knowing that the time of landing was approaching, he got up,
unfolded his fans, and swam lightly through the air of the cabin to a
hand-line, along which he drew himself into the control room. He could
have made the trip in that room, of course, if he had so chosen; but,
knowing that officers of space do not really like to have strangers in
that sanctum, he did not intrude until it was necessary.

Captain Winfield was already strapped down at his master conning plate.
Pilots, navigators, and computers worked busily at their respective

“I was just going to call you, First Lensman.” Winfield waved a
hand in the general direction of a chair near his own. “Take the
Lieutenant-Captain’s station, please.” Then, after a few minutes: “Go
inert, Mr. White.”

“Attention, all personnel,” Lieutenant-Captain White spoke
conversationally into a microphone. “Prepare for inert maneuvering,
Class Three. Off.”

A bank of tiny red lights upon a panel turned green practically as
one. White cut the Bergenholm, whereupon Virgil Samms’ mass changed
instantly from a weight of zero to one of five hundred and twenty
five pounds–ships of war then had no space to waste upon such
non-essentials as artificial gravity. Although he was braced for the
change and cushioned against it, the Lensman’s breath whooshed! out
sharply; but, being intensely interested in what was going on, he
swallowed convulsively a couple of times, gasped a few deep breaths,
and fought his way back up to normalcy.

The Chief Pilot was now at work, with all the virtuoso’s skill of his
rank and grade; one of the hall-marks of which is to make difficult
tasks look easy. He played trills and runs and arpeggios–at times
veritable glissades–upon keyboards and pedals, directing with
micrometric precision the tremendous forces of the superdreadnaught to
the task of matching the intrinsic velocity of New York Spaceport at
the time of his departure to the I. V. of the surface of the planet so
far below.

Samms stared into his plate; first at the incredibly tiny apparent size
of that incredibly hot sun, and then at the barren-looking world toward
which they were dropping at such terrific speed.

“It doesn’t seem possible …” he remarked, half to Winfield, half
to himself, “that a sun could be that big and that hot. Rigel Four
is almost two hundred times as far away from it as Earth is from
Sol–something like eighteen billion miles–it doesn’t look much, if
any, bigger than Venus does from Luna–yet this world is hotter than
the Sahara Desert.”

“Well, blue giants are both big and hot,” the captain replied,
matter-of-factly, “and their radiation, being mostly invisible, is
deadly stuff. And Rigel is about the biggest in this region. There are
others a lot worse, though. Doradus S, for instance, would make Rigel,
here, look like a tallow candle. I’m going out there, some of these
days, just to take a look at it. But that’s enough of astronomical
chit-chat–we’re down to twenty miles of altitude and we’ve got your
city just about stopped.”

The Chicago slowed gently to a halt; perched motionless upon softly
hissing jets. Samms directed his visibeam downward and sent along it
an exploring, questing thought. Since he had never met a Rigellian in
person, he could not form the mental image or pattern necessary to
become en rapport with any one individual of the race. He did know,
however, the type of mind which must be possessed by the entity with
whom he wished to talk, and he combed the Rigellian city until he found
one. The rapport was so incomplete and imperfect as to amount almost to
no contact at all, but he could, perhaps, make himself understood.

“If you will excuse this possibly unpleasant and certainly unwarranted
intrusion,” he thought, carefully and slowly, “I would like very
much to discuss with you a matter which should become of paramount
importance to all the intelligent peoples of all the planets in space.”

“I welcome you, Tellurian.” Mind fused with mind at every one of
uncountable millions of points and paths. This Rigellian professor
of sociology, standing at his desk, was physically a monster …
the oil-drum of a body, the four blocky legs, the multi-branchiate
tentacular arms, that immobile dome of a head, the complete lack
of eyes and of ears … nevertheless Samms’ mind fused with the
monstrosity’s as smoothly, as effortlessly, and almost as completely as
it had with his own daughter’s!

And what a mind! The transcendent poise; the staggeringly tremendous
range and scope–the untroubled and unshakeable calm; the sublime
quietude; the vast and placid certainty; the ultimate stability,
unknown and forever unknowable to any human or near-human race!

“Dismiss all thought of intrusion, First Lensman Samms … I have heard
of you human beings, of course, but have never considered seriously the
possibility of meeting one of you mind to mind. Indeed, it was reported
that none of our minds could make any except the barest and most
unsatisfactory contact with any of yours they chanced to encounter. It
is, I now perceive, the Lens which makes this full accord possible, and
it is basically about the Lens that you are here?”

“It is,” and Samms went on to cover in flashing thoughts his
conception of what the Galactic Patrol should be and should become.
That was easy enough; but when he tried to describe in detail the
qualifications necessary for Lensmanship, he began to bog down. “Force,
drive, scope, of course … range … power … but above all, an
absolute integrity … an ultimate incorruptibility….” He could
recognize such a mind after meeting it and studying it, but as to
finding it … It might not be in any place of power or authority. His
own, and Rod Kinnison’s, happened to be; but Costigan’s was not … and
both Knobos and DalNalten had made inconspicuousness a fine art….

“I see,” the native stated, when it became clear that Samms could say
no more. “It is evident, of course, that I cannot qualify; nor do I
know anyone personally who can. However….”

“What?” Samms demanded. “I was sure, from the feel of your mind, that
you … but with a mind of such depth and breadth, such tremendous
scope and power, you must be incorruptible!”

“I am,” came the dry rejoinder. “We all are. No Rigellian is, or ever
will be or can be, what you think of as ‘corrupt’ or ‘corruptible’.
Indeed, it is only by the narrowest, most intense concentration upon
every line of your thought that I can translate your meaning into a
concept possible for any of us even to understand.”

“Then what … Oh, I see. I was starting at the wrong end. Naturally
enough, I suppose, I looked first for the qualities rarest in my own

“Of course. Our minds have ample scope and range; and, perhaps,
sufficient power. But those qualities which you refer to as ‘force’
and ‘drive’ are fully as rare among us as absolute mental integrity is
among you. What you know as ‘crime’ is unknown. We have no police, no
government, no laws, no organized armed forces of any kind. We take,
practically always, the line of least resistance. We live and let live,
as your thought runs. We work together for the common good.”

“Well … I don’t know what I expected to find here, but certainly not
this….” If Samms had never before been completely thunderstruck,
completely at a loss, he was then. “You don’t think, then, that there
is any chance?”

“I have been thinking, and there may be a chance … a slight one,
but still a chance,” the Rigellian said, slowly. “For instance, that
youth, so full of curiosity, who first visited your planet. Thousands
of us have wondered, to ourselves and to each other, about the
peculiar qualities of mind which compelled him and others to waste
so much time, effort, and wealth upon a project so completely useless
as exploration. Why, he had even to develop energies and engines
theretofore unknown, and which can never be of any real use!”

Samms was shaken by the calm finality with which the Rigellian
dismissed all possibility of the usefulness of inter-stellar
exploration, but stuck doggedly to his purpose.

“However slight the chance, I must find and talk to this man. I suppose
he is now out in deep space somewhere. Have you any idea where?”

“He is now in his home city, accumulating funds and manufacturing fuel
with which to continue his pointless activities. That city is named …
that is, in your English you might call it … Suntown? Sunberg? No, it
must be more specific … Rigelsville? Rigel City?”

“Rigelston, I would translate it?” Samms hazarded.

“Exactly–Rigelston.” The professor marked its location upon a globular
mental map far more accurate and far more detailed than the globe which
Captain Winfield and his lieutenant were then studying.

“Thanks. Now, can you and will you get in touch with this explorer and
ask him to call a meeting of his full crew and any others who might be
interested in the project I have outlined?”

“I can. I will. He and his kind are not quite sane, of course, as
you know; but I do not believe that even they are so insane as to be
willing to subject themselves to the environment of your vessel.”

“They will not be asked to come here. The meeting will be held in
Rigelston. If necessary, I shall insist that it be held there.”

“You would? I perceive that you would. It is strange … yes,
fantastic … you are quarrelsome, pugnacious, anti-social, vicious,
small-bodied and small-brained; timid, nervous, and highly and
senselessly excitable; unbalanced and unsane; as sheerly monstrous
mentally as you are physically….” These outrageous thoughts were sent
as casually and as impersonally as though the sender were discussing
the weather. He paused, then went on: “And yet, to further such a
completely visionary project, you are eager to subject yourself to
conditions whose counterparts I could not force myself, under any
circumstances whatever, to meet. It may be … it must be true that
there is an extension of the principle of working together for the
common good which my mind, for lack of pertinent data, has not been
able to grasp. I am now en rapport with Dronvire the explorer.”

“Ask him, please, not to identify himself to me. I do not want to go
into that meeting with any preconceived ideas.”

“A balanced thought,” the Rigellian approved. “Someone will be at the
airport to point out to you the already desolated area in which the
space-ship of the explorers makes its so-frightful landings; Dronvire
will ask someone to meet you at the airport and bring you to the place
of meeting.”

The telepathic line snapped and Samms turned a white and sweating face
to the Chicago’s captain.

“God, what a strain! Don’t ever try telepathy unless you positively
have to–especially not with such an outlandishly different race as
these Rigellians are!”

“Don’t worry; I won’t.” Winfield’s words were not at all sympathetic,
but his tone was. “You looked as though somebody was beating your
brains out with a spiked club. Where next, First Lensman?”

Samms marked the location of Rigelston upon the vessel’s chart, then
donned ear-plugs and a special, radiation-proof suit of armor, equipped
with refrigerators and with extra-thick blocks of lead glass to protect
the eyes.

The airport, an extremely busy one well outside the city proper, was
located easily enough, as was the spot upon which the Tellurian ship
was to land. Lightly, slowly, she settled downward, her jets raving
out against a gravity fully twice that of her native Earth. Those
blasts, however, added little or nothing to the destruction already
accomplished by the craft then lying there–a torpedo-shaped cruiser
having perhaps one-twentieth of the Chicago’s mass and bulk.

The superdreadnaught landed, sinking into the hard, dry ground to a
depth of some ten or fifteen feet before she stopped. Samms, en rapport
with the entity who was to be his escort, made a flashing survey of the
mind so intimately in contact with his own. No use. This one was not
and never could become Lensman material. He climbed heavily down the
ladder. This double-normal gravity made the going a bit difficult, but
he could stand that a lot better than some of the other things he was
going to have to take. The Rigellian equivalent of an automobile was
there, waiting for him, its door invitingly open.

Samms had known–in general–what to expect. The two-wheeled chassis
was more or less similar to that of his own Dillingham. The body
was a narrow torpedo of steel, bluntly pointed at both ends, and
without windows. Two features, however, were both unexpected and
unpleasant–the hard, tough steel of which that body was forged
was an inch and a half thick, instead of one-sixteenth; and even
that extraordinarily armored body was dented and scarred and marred,
especially about the fore and rear quarters, as deeply and as badly and
as casually as are the fenders of an Earthly jalopy!

The Lensman climbed, not easily or joyously, into that grimly
forbidding black interior. Black? It was so black that the
port-hole-like doorway seemed to admit no light at all. It was blacker
than a witch’s cat in a coal cellar at midnight! Samms flinched; then,
stiffening, thought at the driver.

“My contact with you seems to have slipped. I’m afraid that I will
have to cling to you rather more tightly than may be either polite or
comfortable. Deprived of sight, and without your sense of perception, I
am practically helpless.”

“Come in, Lensman, by all means. I offered to maintain full
engagement, but it seemed to me that you declined it; quite possibly
the misunderstanding was due to our unfamiliarity with each others’
customary mode of thought. Relax, please, and come in … there!

“Infinitely better. Thanks.”

And it was. The darkness vanished; through the unexplainable perceptive
sense of the Rigellian he could “see” everything–he had a practically
perfect three-dimensional view of the entire circumambient sphere. He
could see both the inside and the outside of the ground car he was in
and of the immense space-ship in which he had come to Rigel IV. He
could see the bearings and the wrist-pins of the internal-combustion
engine of the car, the interior structure of the welds that held the
steel plates together, the busy airport outside, and even deep into
the ground. He could see and study in detail the deepest-buried, most
heavily shielded parts of the atomic engines of the Chicago.

But he was wasting time. He could also plainly see a deeply-cushioned
chair, designed to fit a human body, welded to a stanchion and equipped
with half a dozen padded restraining straps. He sat down quickly;
strapped himself in.



The door banged shut with a clangor which burst through space-suit and
ear-plugs with all the violence of a nearby thunderclap. And that was
merely the beginning. The engine started–an internal-combustion engine
of well over a thousand horsepower, designed for maximum efficiency
by engineers in whose lexicon there were no counterparts of any
English words relating to noise, or even to sound. The car took off;
with an acceleration which drove the Tellurian backward, deep into the
cushions. The scream of tortured tires and the crescendo bellowing
of the engine combined to form an uproar which, amplified by and
reverberating within the resonant shell of metal, threatened to addle
the very brain inside the Lensman’s skull.

“You suffer!” the driver exclaimed, in high concern. “They cautioned
me to start and stop gently, to drive slowly and carefully, to bump
softly. They told me you are frail and fragile, a fact which I
perceived for myself and which has caused me to drive with the utmost
possible care and restraint. Is the fault mine? Have I been too rough?”

“Not at all. It isn’t that. It’s the ungodly noise.” Then, realizing
that the Rigellian could have no conception of his meaning, he
continued quickly:

“The vibrations in the atmosphere, from sixteen cycles per second up
to about nine or ten thousand.” He explained what a second was. “My
nervous system is very sensitive to those vibrations. But I expected
them and shielded myself against them as adequately as I could. Nothing
can be done about them. Go ahead.”

“Atmospheric vibrations? Atmospheric vibrations? Atmospheric
vibrations?” The driver marveled, and concentrated upon this entirely
new concept while he–

  1. Swung around a steel-sheathed concrete pillar at a speed of at least
    sixty miles per hour, grazing it so closely that he removed one layer
    of protective coating from the metal.
  2. Braked so savagely to miss a wildly careening truck that the
    restraining straps almost cut Samms’ body, space-suit and all, into
  3. Darted into a hole in the traffic so narrow that only tiny fractions
    of inches separated his hurtling Juggernaut from an enormous steel
    column on one side and another speeding vehicle on the other.
  4. Executed a double-right-angle reverse curve, thus missing by hair’s
    breadths two vehicles traveling in the opposite direction and one in
    his own.

  5. As a grand climax to this spectacular exhibition of insane driving,
    he plunged at full speed into a traffic artery which seemed so full
    already that it could not hold even one more car. But it could–just
    barely could. However, instead of near misses or grazing hits, this
    time there were bumps, dents–little ones, nothing at all, really,
    only an inch or so deep–and an utterly hellish concatenation and
    concentration of noise.

“I fail completely to understand what effect such vibrations could
have,” the Rigellian announced finally, sublimely unconscious that
anything at all out of the ordinary had occurred. For him, nothing had.
“But surely they cannot be of any use?”

“On this world, I am afraid not. No,” Samms admitted, wearily. “Here,
too, apparently, as everywhere, the big cities are choking themselves
to death with their own traffic.”

“Yes. We build and build, but never have roads enough.”

“What are those mounds along the streets?” For some time Samms had been
conscious of those long, low, apparently opaque structures; attracted
to them because they were the only non-transparent objects within range
of the Rigellian’s mind. “Or is it something I should not mention?”

“What? Oh, those? By no means.”

One of the nearby mounds lost its opacity. It was filled with swirling,
gyrating bands and streamers of energy so vivid and so solid as to
resemble fabric; with wildly hurtling objects of indescribable shapes
and contours; with brilliantly flashing symbols which Samms found,
greatly to his surprise, made sense–not through the Rigellian’s mind,
but through his own Lens:


“Advertising!” Samms’ thought was a snort.

“Advertising. You do not perceive yours, either, as you drive?” This
was the first bond to be established between two of the most highly
advanced races of the First Galaxy!

The frightful drive continued; the noise grew worse and worse. Imagine,
if you can, a city of fifteen millions of people, throughout whose
entire length, breadth, height, and depth no attempt whatever had
ever been made to abate any noise, however violent or piercing! If
your imagination has been sufficiently vivid and if you have worked
understandingly enough, the product may approximate what First Lensman
Samms was forced to listen to that day.

Through ever-thickening traffic, climbing to higher and ever higher
roadways between towering windowless walls of steel, the massive
Rigellian automobile barged and banged its way. Finally it stopped, a
thousand feet or so above the ground, beside a building which was still
under construction. The heavy door clanged open. They got out.

And then–it chanced to be daylight at the time–Samms saw a tangle
of fighting, screaming colors whose like no entity possessing the
sense of sight had ever before imagined. Reds, yellows, blues, greens,
purples, and every variation and inter-mixture possible; laid on or
splashed on or occurring naturally at perfect random, smote his eyes as
violently as the all-pervading noise had been assailing his ears.

He realized then that through his guide’s sense of perception he had
been “seeing” only in shades of gray, that to these people “visible”
light differed only in wave-length from any other band of the complete
electromagnetic spectrum of vibration.

Strained and tense, the Lensman followed his escort along a narrow
catwalk, through a wall upon which riveters and welders were busily at
work, into a room practically without walls and ceiled only by story
after story of huge I-beams. Yet this was the meeting-place; almost a
hundred Rigellians were assembled there!

And as Samms walked toward the group a craneman dropped a couple of
tons of steel plate, from a height of eight or ten feet, upon the floor
directly behind him.

“I just about jumped right out of my armor,” is the way Samms himself
described his reactions; and that description is perhaps as good as any.

At any rate, he went briefly out of control, and the Rigellian sent him
a steadying, inquiring, wondering thought. He could no more understand
the Tellurian’s sensitivity than Samms could understand the fact that
to these people, even the concept of physical intrusion was absolutely
incomprehensible. These builders were not workmen, in the Tellurian
sense. They were Rigellians, each working his few hours per week for
the common good. They would be no more in contact with the meeting than
would their fellows on the other side of the planet.

Samms closed his eyes to the riot of clashing colors, deafened himself
by main strength to the appalling clangor of sound, forced himself to
concentrate every fiber of his mind upon his errand.

“Please synchronize with my mind, as many of you as possible,” he
thought at the group as a whole, and went en rapport with mind after
mind after mind. And mind after mind after mind lacked something. Some
were stronger than others, had more initiative and drive and urge, but
none would quite do. Until–

“Thank God!” In the wave of exultant relief, of fulfillment, Samms
no longer saw the colors or heard the din. “You, sir, are of Lensman
grade. I perceive that you are Dronvire.”

“Yes, Virgil Samms, I am Dronvire; and at long last I know what it
is that I have been seeking all my life. But how of these, my other
friends? Are not some of them…?”

“I do not know, nor is it necessary that I find out. You will
select …” Samms paused, amazed. The other Rigellians were still in
the room, but mentally, he and Dronvire were completely alone.

“They anticipated your thought, and, knowing that it was to be more or
less personal, they left us until one of us invites them to return.”

“I like that, and appreciate it. You will go to Arisia. You will
receive your Lens. You will return here. You will select and send to
Arisia as many or as few of your fellows as you choose. These things
I require you, by the Lens of Arisia, to do. Afterward–please note
that this is in no sense obligatory–I would like very much to have you
visit Earth and accept appointment to the Galactic Council. Will you?”

“I will.” Dronvire needed no time to consider his decision.

The meeting was dismissed. The same entity who had been Samms’
chauffeur on the in-bound trip drove him back to the Chicago,
driving as “slowly” and as “carefully” as before. Nor, this time,
did the punishment take such toll, even though Samms knew that each
terrific lunge and lurch was adding one more bruise to the already
much-too-large collection discoloring almost every square foot of his
tough hide. He had succeeded, and the thrill of success had its usual
analgesic effect.

The Chicago’s captain met him in the air-lock and helped him remove
his suit.

“Are you sure you’re all right, Samms?” Winfield was no longer the
formal captain, but a friend. “Even though you didn’t call, we were
beginning to wonder … you look as though you’d been to a Valerian
clambake, and I sure as hell don’t like the way you’re favoring those
ribs and that left leg. I’ll tell the boys you got back in A-prime
shape, but I’ll have the doctors look you over, just to make sure.”

Winfield made the announcement, and through his Lens Samms could
plainly feel the wave of relief and pleasure that spread throughout the
great ship with the news. It surprised him immensely. Who was he,
that all these boys should care so much whether he lived or died?

“I’m perfectly all right,” Samms protested. “There’s nothing at all the
matter with me that twenty hours of sleep won’t fix as good as new.”

“Maybe; but you’ll go to the sick-bay first, just the same,” Winfield
insisted. “And I suppose you want me to blast back to Tellus?”

“Right. And fast. The Ambassadors’ Ball is next Tuesday evening, you
know, and that’s one function I can’t stay away from, even with a Class
A Double Prime excuse.”


The Ambassadors’ Ball, one of the most ultra-ultra functions of the
year, was well under way. It was not that everyone who was anyone was
there; but everyone who was there was, in one way or another, very
emphatically someone. Thus, there were affairs at which there were more
young and beautiful women, and more young and handsome men; but none
exhibiting newer or more expensive gowns, more ribbons and decorations,
more or costlier or more refined jewelry, or a larger acreage of
powdered and perfumed epidermis.

And even so, the younger set was well enough represented. Since
pioneering appeals more to youth than to age, the men representing the
colonies were young; and their wives, together with the daughters and
the second (or third or fourth, or occasionally the fifth) wives of the
human personages practically balanced the account.

Nor was the throng entirely human. The time had not yet come, of
course, when warm-blooded, oxygen-breathing monstrosities from hundreds
of other solar systems would vie in numbers with the humanity present.
There were, however, a few Martians on the floor, wearing their light
“robes du convention” and dancing with meticulously mathematical
precision. A few Venerians, who did not dance, sat in state or waddled
importantly about. Many worlds of the Solarian System, and not a few
other systems, were represented.

One couple stood out, even against that opulent and magnificent
background. Eyes followed them wherever they went.

The girl was tall, trim, supple; built like a symphony. Her Callistan
vexto-silk gown, of the newest and most violent shade of “radio-active”
green, was phosphorescently luminous; fluorescent; gleaming and
glowing. Its hem swept the floor, but above the waist it vanished
mysteriously except for wisps which clung to strategic areas here and
there with no support, apparently, except the personal magnetism of the
wearer. She, almost alone of all the women there, wore no flowers. Her
only jewelry was a rosette of huge, perfectly-matched emeralds, perched
precariously upon her bare left shoulder. Her hair, unlike the other
women’s flawless coiffures, was a flamboyant, artistically-disarranged,
red-bronze-auburn mop. Her soft and dewy eyes–Virgilia Samms could
control her eyes as perfectly as she could her highly educated
hands–were at the moment gold-flecked, tawny wells of girlish
innocence and trust.

“But I can’t give you this next dance, too, Herkimer–Honestly I
can’t!” she pleaded, snuggling just a trifle closer into the embrace of
the young man who was just as much man, physically, as she was woman.
“I’d just love to, really, but I just simply can’t, and you know
why, too.”

“You’ve got some duty-dances, of course …”

Some? I’ve got a list as long as from here to there! Senator
Morgan first, of course, then Mr. Isaacson, then I sat one out with
Mr. Ossmen–I can’t stand Venerians, they’re so slimy and fat and
repulsive!–and that leathery horned toad from Mars and that Jovian
hippopotamus …”

She went down the list, and as she named or characterized each entity
another finger of her left hand pressed down upon the back of her
partner’s right, to emphasize the count of her social obligations. But
those talented fingers were doing more–far, far more–than that.

Herkimer Third, although no little of a Don Juan, was a highly
polished, smoothly finished, thoroughly seasoned diplomat. As such, his
eyes and his other features–particularly his eyes–had been schooled
for years to reveal no trace of whatever might be going on inside his
brain. If he had entertained any suspicion of the beautiful girl in
his arms, if anyone had suggested that she was trying her best to pump
him, he would have smiled the sort of smile which only the top-drawer
diplomat can achieve. He was not suspicious of Virgilia Samms. However,
simply because she was Virgil Samms’ daughter, he took an extra bit of
pain to betray no undue interest in any one of the names she recited.
And besides, she was not looking at his eyes, nor even at his face. Her
glance, demurely downcast, was all too rarely raised above the level of
his chin.

There were some things, however, that Herkimer Herkimer Third did not
know. That Virgilia Samms was the most accomplished muscle-reader of
her times. That she was so close to him, not because of his manly
charm, but because only in that position could she do her prodigious
best. That she could work with her eyes alone, but in emergencies,
when fullest possible results were imperative, she had to use her
exquisitely sensitive fingers and her exquisitely tactile skin. That
she had studied intensively, and had tabulated the reactions of, each
of the entities on her list. That she was now, with his help, fitting
those reactions into a pattern. And finally, that that pattern was
beginning to assume the grim shape of MURDER!

And Virgilia Samms, working now for something far more urgent and
vastly more important than a figmental Galactic Patrol, hoped
desperately that this Herkimer was not a muscle-reader too; for she
knew that she was revealing her secrets even more completely than was
he. In fact, if things got much worse, he could not help but feel the
pounding of her heart … but she could explain that easily enough, by
a few appropriate wiggles … No, he wasn’t a reader, definitely not.
He wasn’t watching the right places; he was looking where that gown had
been designed to make him look, and nowhere else … and no tell-tale
muscles lay beneath any part of either of his hands.

As her eyes and her fingers and her lovely torso sent more and more
information to her keen brain, Jill grew more and more anxious. She
was sure that murder was intended, but who was to be the victim? Her
father? Probably. Pops Kinnison? Possibly. Somebody else? Barely
possibly. And when? And where? And how? She didn’t know! And she
would have to be sure … Mentioning names hadn’t been enough, but a
personal appearance … Why didn’t dad show up–or did she wish he
wouldn’t come at all…?

Virgil Samms entered the ball-room.

“And dad told me, Herkimer,” she cooed sweetly, gazing up into his eyes
for the first time in over a minute, “that I must dance with every one
of them. So you see … Oh, there he is now, over there! I’ve been
wondering where he’s been keeping himself.” She nodded toward the
entrance and prattled on artlessly. “He’s almost never late, you
know, and I’ve …”

He looked, and as his eyes met those of the First Lensman, Jill learned
three of the facts she needed so badly to know. Her father. Here. Soon.
She never knew how she managed to keep herself under control; but, some
way and just barely, she did.

Although nothing showed, she was seething inwardly: wrought up as
she had never before been. What could she do? She knew, but she did
not have a scrap or an iota of visible or tangible evidence; and if
she made one single slip, however slight, the consequences could be
immediate and disastrous.

After this dance might be too late. She could make an excuse to leave
the floor, but that would look very bad, later … and none of them
would Lens her, she knew, while she was with Herkimer–damn such
chivalry!… She could take the chance of waving at her father, since
she hadn’t seen him for so long … no, the smallest risk would be with
Mase. He looked at her every chance he got, and she’d make him use
his Lens …

Northrop looked at her; and over Herkimer’s shoulder, for one fleeting
instant, she allowed her face to reveal the terrified appeal she so
keenly felt.

“Want me, Jill?” His Lensed thought touched only the outer fringes of
her mind. Full rapport is more intimate than a kiss: no one except her
father had ever really put a Lens on Virgilia Samms. Nevertheless:

Want you! I never wanted anybody so much in my life! Come in,

Diffidently enough, he came; but at the first inkling of the girl’s
news all thought of diffidence or of privacy vanished.

“Jack! Spud! Mr. Kinnison! Mr. Samms!” he Lensed sharp, imperative,
almost frantic thoughts. “Listen in!”

“Steady, Mase, I’ll take over,” came Roderick Kinnison’s deeper,
quieter mental voice. “First, the matter of guns. Anybody except me
wearing a pistol? You are, Spud?”

“Yes, sir.”

“You would be. But you and Mase, Jack?”

“We’ve got our Lewistons!”

“You would have. Blasters, my sometimes-not-quite-so-bright son, are
fine weapons indeed for certain kinds of work. In emergencies, it is
of course permissible to kill a few dozen innocent bystanders. In such
a crowd as this, though, it is much better technique to kill only the
one you are aiming at. So skip out to my car, you two, right now, and
change–and make it fast.” Everyone knew that Roderick Kinnison’s car
was at all times an arsenal on wheels. “Wish you were in uniform, too,
Virge, but it can’t be helped now. Work your way–slowly–around to
the northwest corner. Spud, do the same.”

“It’s impossible–starkly unthinkable!” and “I’m not sure of
anything, really …” Samms and his daughter began simultaneously to

“Virgil, you talk like a man with a paper nose. Keep still until after
you’ve used your brain. And I’m sure enough of what you know, Jill, to
take plenty of steps. You can relax now–take it easy. We’re covering
Virgil and I called up support in force. You can relax a little,
I see. Good! I’m not trying to hide from anybody that the next few
minutes may be critical. Are you pretty sure, Jill, that Herkimer is a
key man?”

“Pretty sure, Pops.” How much better she felt, now that the Lensmen
were on guard! “In this one case, at least.”

“Good! Then let him talk you into giving him every dance, right
straight through until something breaks. Watch him. He must know the
signal and who is going to operate, and if you can give us a fraction
of a second of warning it will help no end. Can do?”

“I’ll say I can–and I would love to, the big, slimy, stinking
skinker!” As transliterated into words, the girl’s thought may seem a
trifle confused, but Kinnison knew exactly what she meant.

“One more thing, Jill; a detail. The boys are coming back in and are
working their partners over this way. See if Herkimer notices that they
have changed their holsters.”

“No, he didn’t notice,” Jill reported, after a moment. “But I don’t
notice any difference, either, and I’m looking for it.”

“Nevertheless, it’s there, and the difference between a Mark Seventeen
and a Mark Five is something more than that between Tweedledum and
Tweedledee,” Kinnison returned, dryly. “However, it may not be as
obvious to non-military personnel as it is to us. That’s far enough,
boys, don’t get too close. Now, Virge, keep solidly en rapport with
Jill on one side and with us on the other, so that she won’t have to
give herself and the show away by yelling and pointing, and …”

“But this is preposterous!” Samms stormed.

“Preposterous, hell,” Roderick Kinnison’s thought was still coldly
level; only the fact that he was beginning to use non-ballroom language
revealed any sign of the strain he was under. “Stop being so goddam
heroic and start using your brain. You turned down fifty billion
credits. Why do you suppose they offered that much, when they can get
anybody killed for a hundred? And what would they do about it?”

“But they couldn’t get away with it, Rod, at an Ambassadors’ Ball. They
couldn’t, possibly.”

“Formerly, no. That was my first thought, too. But it was you who
pointed out to me, not so long ago, that the techniques of crime have
changed of late. In the new light, the swankier the brawl the greater
the confusion and the better the chance of getting away clean. Comb
that out of your whiskers, you red-headed mule!”

“Well … there might be something in it, after all …” Samms’ thought
showed apprehension at last.

“You know damn well there is. But you boys–Jack and Mase
especially–loosen up. You can’t do good shooting while you’re strung
up like a couple of cocoons. Do something–talk to your partners or
think at Jill …”

“That won’t be hard, sir.” Mason Northrop grinned feebly. “And that
reminds me of something, Jill. Mentor certainly bracketed the target
when he–or she, or it, maybe–said that you would never need a Lens.”

“Huh?” Jill demanded, inelegantly. “I don’t see the connection, if any.”

“No? Everybody else does, I’ll bet. How about it?” The other Lensmen,
even Samms, agreed enthusiastically. “Well, do you think that any of
those characters, particularly Herkimer Herkimer Third, would let a
harness bull in harness–even such a beautiful one as you–get close
enough to him to do such a Davey the Dip act on his mind?”

“Oh … I never thought of that, but it’s right, and I’m glad … but
Pops, you said something about ‘support in force.’ Have you any idea
how long it will be? I hope I can hold out, with you all supporting
me, but …”

“You can, Jill. Two or three minutes more, at most.”

“Support? In force? What do you mean?” Samms snapped.

“Just that. The whole damned army,” Kinnison replied. “I sent Two-Star
Commodore Alexander Clayton a thought that lifted him right out of his
chair. Everything he’s got, at full emergency blast. Armor–mark eighty
fours–six by six extra heavies–a ninety sixty for an ambulance–full
escort, upstairs and down–way-friskers–‘copters–cruisers and big
stuff–in short, the works. I would have run with you before this, if I
dared; but the minute the relief party shows up, we do a flit.”

“If you dared?” Jill asked, shaken by the thought.

“Exactly, my dear. I don’t dare. If they start anything we’ll do our
damnedest, but I’m praying they won’t.”

But Kinnison’s prayers–if he made any–were ignored. Jill heard a
sharp, but very usual and insignificant sound; someone had dropped a
pencil. She felt an inconspicuous muscle twitch slightly. She saw the
almost imperceptible tensing of a neck-muscle which would have turned
Herkimer’s head in a certain direction if it had been allowed to act.
Her eyes flashed along that line, searched busily for milli-seconds. A
man was reaching unobtrusively, as though for a handkerchief. But men
at Ambassadors’ Balls do not carry blue handkerchiefs; nor does any
fabric, however dyed, resemble at all closely the blued steel of an
automatic pistol.

Jill would have screamed, then, and pointed; but she had time to do
neither. Through her rapport with her father the Lensmen saw everything
that she saw, in the instant of her seeing it. Hence five shots blasted
out, practically as one, before the girl could scream, or point, or
even move. She did scream, then; but since dozens of other women were
screaming, too, it made no difference–then.

Conway Costigan, trigger-nerved spacehound that he was and with years
of gun-fighting and of hand-to-hand brawling in his log, shot first;
even before the gunman did. It was Costigan’s blinding speed that saved
Virgil Samms’ life that day; for the would-be assassin was dying, with
a heavy slug crashing through his brain, before he finished pulling the
trigger. The dying hand twitched upward. The bullet intended for Samms’
heart went high; through the fleshy part of the shoulder.

Roderick Kinnison, because of his age, and his son and Northrop,
because of their inexperience, were a few milli-seconds slow. They,
however, were aiming for the body, not for the head; and any of those
three resulting wounds would have been satisfactorily fatal. The man
went down, and stayed down.

Samms staggered, but did not go down until the elder Kinnison, as
gently as was consistent with the maximum of speed, threw him down.

“Stand back! Get back! Give him air!” Men began to shout, the while
pressing closer themselves.

“You men, stand back. Some of you go get a stretcher. You women, come
here.” Kinnison’s heavy, parade-ground voice smashed down all lesser
noises. “Is there a doctor here?”

There was; and, after being “frisked” for weapons, he went busily to

“Joy–Betty–Jill–Clio,” Kinnison called his own wife and their
daughter, Virgilia Samms, and Mrs. Costigan. “You four first. Now
you–and you–and you–and you….” he went on, pointing out large,
heavy women wearing extremely extreme gowns, “Stand here, right over
him. Cover him up, so that nobody else can get a shot at him. You other
women, stand behind and between these–closer yet–fill those spaces
up solid–there! Jack, stand there. Mase, there. Costigan, the other
end; I’ll take this one. Now, everybody, listen. I know damn well that
none of you women are wearing guns above the waist, and you’ve all got
long skirts–thank God for ballgowns! Now, fellows, if any one of these
women makes a move to lift her skirt, blow her brains out, right then,
without waiting to ask questions.”

“Sir, I protest! This is outrageous!” one of the dowagers exclaimed.

“Madam, I agree with you fully. It is.” Kinnison smiled as genuinely
as he could under the circumstances. “It is, however, necessary. I
will apologize to all you ladies, and to you, doctor–in writing if you
like–after we have Virgil Samms aboard the Chicago; but until then I
would not trust my own grandmother.”

The doctor looked up. “The Chicago? This wound does not appear to be
a very serious one, but this man is going to a hospital at once. Ah,
the stretcher. So … please … easy … there, that is excellent.
Call an ambulance, please, immediately.”

“I did. Long ago. But no hospital, doctor. All those windows–open
to the public–or the whole place bombed–by no means. I’m taking no
chances whatever.”

“Except with your own life!” Jill put in sharply, looking up from her
place at her father’s side. Assured that the First Lensman was in no
danger of dying, she had begun to take interest in other things. “You
are important, too, you know, and you’re standing right out there in
the open. Get another stretcher, lie down on it, and we’ll guard you,
too … and don’t be too stiff-necked to take your own advice!” she
flared, as he hesitated.

“I’m not, if it were necessary, but it isn’t. If they had killed him,
yes. I’d probably be next in line. But since he got only a scratch,
there’d be no point at all in killing even a good Number Two.”

“A scratch!” Jill fairly seethed. “Do you call that horrible wound a

“Huh? Why, certainly–that’s all it is–thanks to you,” he returned,
in honest and complete surprise. “No bones shattered–no main arteries
cut–missed the lung–he’ll be as good as new in a couple of weeks.”

“And now,” he went on aloud, “if you ladies will please pick up this
stretcher we will move en masse, and slowly, toward the door.”

The women, no longer indignant but apparently enjoying the sensation of
being the center of interest, complied with the request.

“Now, boys,” Kinnison Lensed a thought. “Did any of you–Costigan?–see
any signs of a concerted rush, such as there would have been to get the
killer away if we hadn’t interfered?”

“No, sir,” came Costigan’s brisk reply. “None within sight of me.”

“Jack and Mase–I don’t suppose you looked?”

They hadn’t–had not thought of it in time.

“You’ll learn. It takes a few things like this to make it automatic.
But I couldn’t see any, either, so I’m fairly certain there wasn’t any.
Smart operators–quick on the uptake.”

“I’d better get at this, sir, don’t you think, and let Operation
Boskone go for a while?” Costigan asked.

“I don’t think so.” Kinnison frowned in thought. “This operation was
planned, son, by people with brains. Any clues you could find now
would undoubtedly be plants. No, we’ll let the regulars look; well
stick to our own …”

Sirens wailed and screamed outside. Kinnison sent out an exploring


“Yes. Where do you want this ninety-sixty with the doctors and nurses?
It’s too wide for the gates.”

“Go through the wall. Across the lawn. Right up to the door, and never
mind the frippery they’ve got all over the place–have your adjutant
tell them to bill us for damage. Samms is shot in the shoulder. Not too
serious, but I’m taking him to the Hill, where I know he’ll be safe.
What have you got on top of the umbrella, the Boise or the Chicago?
I haven’t had time to look up yet.”


“Good man.”

Jack Kinnison started at the monstrous tank, which was smashing
statues, fountains, and ornamental trees flat into the earth as it
moved ponderously across the grounds, and licked his lips. He looked
at the companies of soldiers “frisking” the route, the grounds, and
the crowd–higher up, at the hovering helicopters–still higher,
at the eight light cruisers so evidently and so viciously ready to
blast–higher still, at the long streamers of fire which, he now knew,
marked the locations of the two most powerful engines of destruction
ever built by man–and his face turned slowly white.

“Good Lord, Dad!” he swallowed twice. “I had no idea … but they
might, at that.”

“Not ‘might’, son. They damn well would, if they could get here soon
enough with heavy enough stuff.” The elder Kinnison’s jaw-muscles
did not loosen, his darting eyes did not relax their vigilance for
a fraction of a second as he Lensed the thought. “You boys can’t be
expected to know it all, but right now you’re learning fast. Get
this–paste it in your iron hats. Virgil Samms’ life is the most
important thing in this whole damned universe!
If they had got him
then it would not, strictly speaking, have been my fault, but if they
get him now, it will be.”

The land cruiser crunched to a stop against the very entrance, and a
white-clad man leaped out.

“Let me look at him, please…”

“Not yet!” Kinnison denied, sharply. “Not until he’s got four inches
of solid steel between him and whoever wants to finish the job they
started. Get your men around him, and get him aboard–fast!”

Samms, protected at every point at every instant, was lifted into the
maw of the ninety-sixty; and as the massive door clanged shut Kinnison
heaved a tremendous sigh of relief. The cavalcade moved away.

“Coming with us, Rod?” Commodore Clayton shouted.

“Yes, but got a couple minutes’ work here yet. Have a staff car wait
for me, and I’ll join you.” He turned to the three young Lensmen and
the girl. “This fouls up our plans a little, but not too much–I
hope. No change in Mateese or Boskone; you and Costigan, Jill, can go
ahead as planned. Northrop, you’ll have to brief Jill on Zwilnik and
find out what she knows. Virgil was going to do it tonight, after the
brawl here, but you know as much about it now as any of us. Check with
Knobos, DalNalten, and Fletcher–while Virgil is laid up you and Jack
may have to work on both Zabriska and Zwilnik–he’ll Lens you. Get the
dope, then do as you think best. Get going!” He strode away toward the
waiting staff-car.

“Boskone? Zwilnik?” Jill demanded. “What gives? What are they, Jack?”

“We don’t know yet–maybe we’re going to name a couple of planets…”

“Piffle!” she scoffed. “Can you talk sense, Mase? What’s Boskone?”

“A simple, distinctive, pronounceable coined word; suggested, I
believe, by Dr. Bergenholm …” he began.

“You know what I mean, you …” she broke in, but was silenced by a
sharply Lensed thought from Jack. His touch was very light, barely
sufficient to make conversation possible; but even so, she flinched.

“Use your brain, Jill; you aren’t thinking a lick–not that you can be
blamed for it. Stop talking; there may be lip-readers or high-powered
listeners around. This feels funny, doesn’t it?” He twitched mentally
and went on: “You already know what Operation Mateese is, since it’s
your own dish–politics. Operation Zwilnik is drugs, vice, and so on.
Operation Boskone is pirates; Spud is running that. Operation Zabriska
is Mase and me checking some peculiar disturbances in the sub-ether.
Come in, Mase, and do your stuff–I’ll see you later, aboard. Clear
ether, Jill!”

Young Kinnison vanished from the fringes of her mind and Northrop
appeared. And what a difference! His mind touched hers as gingerly as
Jack’s had done; as skittishly, as instantaneously ready to bolt away
from anything in the least degree private. However, Jack’s mind had
rubbed hers the wrong way, right from the start–and Mase’s didn’t!

“Now, about this Operation Zwilnik,” Jill began.

“Something else first. I couldn’t help noticing, back there, that you
and Jack … well, not out of phase, exactly, or really out of sync,
but sort of … well, as though …”

“‘Hunting’?” she suggested.

“Not exactly … ‘forcing’ might be better–like holding a tight beam
together when it wants to fall apart. So you noticed it yourself?”

“Of course, but I thought Jack and I were the only ones who did. Like
scratching a blackboard with your finger-nails–you can do it, but
you’re awfully glad to stop … and I like Jack, too, darn it–at a

“And you and I fit like precisely tuned circuits. Jack really meant it,
then, when he said that you … that is, he … I didn’t quite believe
it until now, but if … you know, of course, what you’ve already done
to me.”

Jill’s block went on, full strength. She arched her eyebrows and spoke
aloud–“why, I haven’t the faintest idea!”

“Of course not. That’s why you’re using voice. I’ve found out, too,
that I can’t lie with my mind. I feel like a heel and a louse, with
so much job ahead, but you’ve simply got to tell me something.
Then–whatever you say–I’ll hit the job with everything I’ve got. Do I
get heaved out between planets without a space-suit, or not?”

“I don’t think so.” Jill blushed vividly, but her voice was steady.
“You would rate a space-suit, and enough oxygen to reach another
plan–another goal. And now we’d better get to work, don’t you think?”

“Yes. Thanks, Jill, a million. I know as well as you do that I was
talking out of turn, and how much–but I had to know.” He breathed
deep. “And that’s all I ask–for now. Cut your screens.”

She lowered her mental barriers, finding it surprisingly easy to do so
in this case; let them down almost as far as she was in the habit of
doing with her father. He explained in flashing thoughts everything he
knew of the four Operations, concluding:

“I’m not assigned to Zabriska permanently; I’ll probably work with you
on Mateese after your father gets back into circulation. I’m to act
more as a liaison man–neither Knobos nor DalNalten knows you well
enough to Lens you. Right?”

“Yes, I’ve met Mr. Knobos only once, and have never even seen Dr.

“Ready to visit them, via Lens?”

“Yes. Go ahead.”

The two Lensmen came in. They came into his mind, not hers.
Nevertheless their thoughts, superimposed upon Northrop’s, came to the
girl as clearly as though all four were speaking to each other face to

“What a weird sensation!” Jill exclaimed. “Why, I never imagined
anything like it!”

“We are sorry to trouble you, Miss Samms….” Jill was surprised anew.
The silent voice deep within her mind was of characteristically Martian
timber, but instead of the harshly guttural consonants and the hissing
sibilants of any Martian’s best efforts at English, pronunciation and
enunciation were flawless.

“Oh, I didn’t mean that. It’s no trouble at all, really, I just haven’t
got used to this telepathy yet.”

“None of us has, to any noticeable degree. But the reason for this call
is to ask you if you have anything new, however slight, to add to our
very small knowledge of Zwilnik?”

“Very little, I’m afraid; and that little is mostly guesses,
deductions, and jumpings at conclusions. Father told you about the way
I work, I suppose?”

“Yes. Exact data is not to be expected. Hints, suggestions, possible
leads, will be of inestimable value.”

“Well, I met a very short, very fat Venerian, named Ossmen, at a party
at the European Embassy. Do either of you know him?”

“I know of him,” DalNalten replied. “A highly reputable merchant, with
such large interests on Tellus that he has to spend most of his time
here. He is not in any one of our books … although there is nothing
at all surprising in that fact. Go on, please, Miss Samms.”

“He didn’t come to the party with Senator Morgan; but he came to some
kind of an agreement with him that night, and I am pretty sure that it
was about thionite. That’s the only new item I have.”

Thionite!” The three Lensmen were equally surprised.

“Yes. Thionite. Definitely.”

“How sure are you of this, Miss Samms?” Knobos asked, in deadly

“I am not sure that this particular agreement was about thionite,
no; but the probability is roughly nine-tenths. I am sure, however,
that both Senator Morgan and Ossmen know a lot about thionite that they
want to hide. Both gave very high positive reactions–well beyond the
six-sigma point of virtual certainty.”

There was a pause, broken by the Martian, but not by a thought directed
at any one of the three.

“Sid!” he called, and even Jill could feel the Lensed thought speed.

“Yes, Knobos? Fletcher.”

“That haul-in you made, out in the asteroids. Heroin, hadive, and
ladolian, wasn’t it? No thionite involved anywhere?”

“No thionite. However, you must remember that part of the gang got
away, so all I can say positively is that we didn’t see, or hear about,
any thionite. There was some gossip, of course: but you know there
always is.”

“Of course. Thanks, Sid.” Jill could feel the brilliant Martian’s
mental gears whirl and click. Then he went into such a flashing
exchange of thought with the Venerian that the girl lost track in

“One more question, Miss Samms?” DalNalten asked. “Have you detected
any indications that there may be some connection between either Ossmen
or Morgan and any officer or executive of Interstellar Spaceways?”

Spaceways! Isaacson?” Jill caught her breath. “Why … nobody even
thought of such a thing–at least, nobody ever mentioned it to me–I
never thought of making any such tests.”

“The possibility occurred to me only a moment ago, at your mention of
thionite. The connection, if any exists, will be exceedingly difficult
to trace. But since most, if not all, of the parties involved will
probably be included in your Operation Mateese, and since a finding,
either positive or negative, would be tremendously significant, we feel
emboldened to ask you to keep this point in mind.”

“Why, of course I will. I’ll be very glad to.”

“We thank you for your courtesy and your help. One or both of us will
get in touch with you from time to time, now that we know the pattern
of your personality. May immortal Grolossen speed the healing of your
father’s wound.”


Late that night–or, rather, very early the following morning–Senator
Morgan and his Number One secretary were closeted in the former’s
doubly spy-ray-proofed office. Morgan’s round, heavy, florid face had
perhaps lost a little of its usual color; the fingers of his left hand
drummed soundlessly upon the glass top of his desk. His shrewd gray
eyes, however, were as keen and as calculating as ever.

“This thing smells, Herkimer … it reeks … but I can’t figure
any of the angles. That operation was planned. Sure fire, it
couldn’t miss. Right up to the last split second it worked perfectly.
Then–blooie! A flat bust. The Patrol landed and everything was under
control. There must have been a leak somewhere–but where in hell
could it have been?”

“There couldn’t have been a leak, Chief; it doesn’t make sense.”
The secretary uncrossed his long legs, recrossed them in the other
direction, threw away a half-smoked cigarette, lit another. “If there’d
been any kind of a leak they would have done a lot more than just
kill the low man on the ladder. You know as well as I do that Rocky
Kinnison is the hardest-boiled character this side of hell. If he had
known anything, he would have killed everybody in sight, including you
and me. Besides, if there had been a leak, he would not have let Samms
get within ten thousand miles of the place–that’s one sure thing.
Another is he wouldn’t have waited until after it was all over to get
his army there. No, Chief, there couldn’t have been a leak. Whatever
Samms or Kinnison found out–probably Samms, he’s a hell of a lot
smarter than Kinnison is, you know–he learned right there and then. He
must have seen Brainerd start to pull his gun.”

“I thought of that. I’d buy it, except for one fact. Apparently you
didn’t time the interval between the shots and the arrival of the

“Sorry, Chief.” Herkimer’s face was a study in chagrin. “I made a bad
slip there.”

“I’ll say you did. One minute and fifty eight seconds.”


Morgan remained silent.

“The patrol is fast, of course … and always ready … and they would
yank the stuff in on tractor beams, not under their own power … but
even so … five minutes, is my guess, Chief. Four and a half, absolute

“Check. And where do you go from there?”

“I see your point. I don’t. That blows everything wide open. One set of
facts says there was a leak, which occurred between two and a half and
three minutes before the signal was given. I ask you, Chief, does that
make sense?”

“No. That’s what is bothering me. As you say, the facts seem to be
contradictory. Somebody must have learned something before anything
happened; but if they did, why didn’t they do more? And Murgatroyd.
If they didn’t know about him, why the ships–especially the big
battlewagons? If they did think he might be out there somewhere, why
didn’t they go and find out?”

“Now I’ll ask one. Why didn’t our Mr. Murgatroyd do something? Or
wasn’t the pirate fleet supposed to be in on this? Probably not,

“My guess would be the same as yours. Can’t see any reason for having
a fleet cover a one-man operation, especially as well-planned a one as
this was. But that’s none of our business. These Lensmen are. I was
watching them every second. Neither Samms nor Kinnison did anything
whatever during that two minutes.”

“Young Kinnison and Northrop each left the hall about that time.”

“I know it. So they did. Either one of them could have called the
Patrol–but what has that to do with the price of beef C. I. F.

Herkimer refrained tactfully from answering the savage question. Morgan
drummed and thought for minutes, then went on slowly:

“There are two, and only two, possibilities; neither of which seem even
remotely possible. It was–must have been–either the Lens or the

“The girl? Act your age, Senator. I knew where she was, and what she
was doing, every second.”

“That was evident.” Morgan stopped drumming and smiled cynically. “I’m
getting a hell of a kick out of seeing you taking it, for a change,
instead of dishing it out.”

“Yes?” Herkimer’s handsome face hardened. “That game isn’t over, my

“That’s what you think,” the Senator jibed. “Can’t believe that any
woman can be Herkimer-proof, eh? You’ve been working on her for six
weeks now, instead of the usual six hours, and you haven’t got anywhere

“I will, Senator.” Herkimer’s nostrils flared viciously. “I’ll get her,
one way or another, if it’s the last thing I ever do.”

“I’ll give you eight to five you don’t; and a six-month time limit.”

“I’ll take five thousand of that. But what makes you think that she’s
anything to be afraid of? She’s a trained psychologist, yes; but so am
I; and I’m older and more experienced than she is. That leaves that
yoga stuff–her learning how to sit cross-legged, how to contemplate
her navel, and how to try to get in tune with the infinite. How do you
figure that puts her in my class?”

“I told you, I don’t. Nothing makes sense. But she is Virgil Samms’

“What of it? You didn’t gag on George Olmstead–you picked him yourself
for one of the toughest jobs we’ve got. By blood he’s just about as
close to Virgil Samms as Virgilia is. They might as well have been
hatched out of the same egg.”

“Physically, yes. Mentally and psychologically, no. Olmstead is a
realist, a materialist. He wants his reward in this world, not the
next, and is out to get it. Furthermore, the job will probably kill
him, and even if it doesn’t, he will never be in a position of trust
or where he can learn much of anything. On the other hand, Virgil Samms
is–but I don’t need to tell you what he is like. But you don’t seem
to realize that she’s just like him–she isn’t playing around with you
because of your overpowering charm….”

“Listen, Chief. She didn’t know anything and she didn’t do anything. I
was dancing with her all the time, as close as that,” he clasped his
hands tightly together, “so I know what I’m talking about. And if you
think she could ever learn anything from me, skip it. You know that
nobody on Earth, or anywhere else, can read my face; and besides, she
was playing coy right then–wasn’t even looking at me. So count her

“We’ll have to, I guess.” Morgan resumed his quiet drumming. “If there
were any possibility that she pumped you I’d send you to the mines, but
there’s no sign … that leaves the Lens. It has seemed, right along,
more logical than the girl–but a lot more fantastic. Been able to find
out anything more about it?”

“No. Just what they’ve been advertising. Combination radio-phone,
automatic language-converter, telepath, and so on. Badge of the top
skimmings of the top-bracket cops. But I began to think, out there on
the floor, that they aren’t advertising everything they know.”

“So did I. You tell me.”

“Take the time zero minus three minutes. Besides the five Lensmen–and
Jill Samms–the place was full of top brass; scrambled eggs all over
the floor. Commodores and lieutenant-Commodores from all continental
governments of the Earth, the other planets, and the colonies, all
wearing full-dress side-arms. Nobody knew anything then; we agree on
that. But within the next few seconds, somebody found out something
and called for help. One of the Lensmen could possibly have done that
without showing signs. BUT–at zero time all four Lensmen had their
guns out–and not Lewistons, please note–and were shooting; whereas
none of the other armed officers knew that anything was going on until
after it was all over. That puts the finger on the Lens.”

“That’s the way I figured it. But the difficulties remain unchanged.
How? Mind-reading?”

“Space-drift!” Herkimer snorted. “My mind can’t be read.”

“Nor mine.”

“And besides, if they could read minds, they wouldn’t have waited
until the last possible split second to do it, unless … say, wait a
minute!… Did Brainerd act or look nervous, toward the last? I wasn’t
to look at him, you know.”

“Not nervous, exactly; but he did get a little tense.”

“There you are, then. Hired murderers aren’t smart. A Lensman saw
him tighten up and got suspicious. Turned in the alarm on general
principles. Warned the others to keep on their toes. But even so, it
doesn’t look like mind-reading–they’d have killed him sooner. They
were watchful, and mighty quick on the draw.”

“That could be it. That’s about as thin and as specious an explanation
as I ever saw cooked up, but it does cover the facts … and the two
of us will be able to make it stick … but take notice, pretty boy,
that certain parties are not going to like this at all. In fact, they
are going to be very highly put out.”

“That’s a nice hunk of understatement, boss. But notice one beautiful
thing about this story?” Herkimer grinned maliciously. “It lets us pass
the buck to Big Jim Towne. We can be–and will be–sore as hell because
he picks such weak-sister characters to do his killings!”

In the heavily armored improvised ambulance, Virgil Samms sat up and
directed a thought at his friend Kinnison, finding his mind a turmoil
of confusion.

“What’s the matter, Rod?”

“Plenty!” the big Lensman snapped back. “They were–maybe still
are–too damn far ahead of us. Something has been going on that we
haven’t even suspected. I stood by, as innocent as a three-year-old
girl baby, and let you walk right into that one–and I emphatically
do not enjoy getting caught with my pants down that way. It makes me
jumpy. This may be all, but it may not be–not by eleven thousand
light-years–and I’m trying to dope out what is going to happen next.”

“And what have you deduced?”

“Nothing. I’m stuck. So I’m tossing it into your lap. Besides, that’s
what you are getting paid for, thinking. So go ahead and think. What
would you be doing, if you were on the other side?”

“I see. You think, then, that it might not be good technique to take
the time to go back to the spaceport?”

“You get the idea. But–can you stand transfer?”

“Certainly. They got my shoulder dressed and taped, and my arm in a
sling. Shock practically all gone. Some pain, but not much. I can walk
without falling down.”

“Fair enough. Clayton!” He Lensed a vigorous thought. “Have any of the
observers spotted anything, high up or far off?”

“No, sir.”

“Good. Kinnison to Commodore Clayton, orders. Have a ‘copter come down
and pick up Samms and myself on tractors. Instruct the Boise and
the cruisers to maintain utmost vigilance. Instruct the Chicago to
pick us up. Detach the Chicago and the Boise from your task force.
Assign them to me. Off.”

“Clayton to Commissioner Kinnison. Orders received and are being
carried out. Off.”

The transfers were made without incident. The two super-dreadnaughts
leaped into the high stratosphere and tore westward. Half-way to the
Hill, Kinnison called Dr. Frederick Rodebush.

“Fred? Kinnison. Have Cleve and Bergenholm link up with us. Now–how
are the Geigers on the outside of the Hill behaving?”

“Normal, all of them,” the physicist-Lensman reported after a moment.

Kinnison detailed the happenings of the recent past. “So tell the boys
to unlimber all the stuff the Hill has got.”

“My God!” Cleveland exclaimed. “Why, that’s putting us back to the days
of the Interplanetary Wars!”

“With one notable exception,” Kinnison pointed out. “The attack, if
any, will be strictly modern. I hope we’ll be able to handle it. One
good thing, the old mountain’s got a lot of sheer mass. How much
radioactivity will it stand?”

“Allotropic iron, U-235, or plutonium?” Rodebush seized his slide-rule.

“What difference does it make?”

“From a practical standpoint … perhaps none. But with a task force
defending, not many bombs could get through, so I’d say …”

“I wasn’t thinking so much of bombs.”

“What, then?”

“Isotopes. A good, thick blanket of dust. Slow-speed, fine stuff that
neither our ships nor the Hill’s screens could handle. We’ve got to
decide, first, whether Virgil will be safer there in the Hill or out in
space in the Chicago; and second, for how long.”

“I see … I’d say here, under the Hill. Months, perhaps years,
before anything could work down this far. And we can always get out.
No matter how hot the surface gets, we’ve got enough screen, heavy
water, cadmium, lead, mercury, and everything else necessary to get him
out through the locks.”

“That’s what I was hoping you’d say. And now, about the defense …
I wonder … I don’t want everybody to think I’ve gone completely
hysterical, but I’ll be damned if I want to get caught again with….”
His thought faded out.

“May I offer a suggestion, sir?” Bergenholm’s thought broke the
prolonged silence.

“I’d be very glad to have it–your suggestions so far haven’t been idle
vaporings. Another hunch?”

“No, sir, a logical procedure. It has been some months since the last
emergency call-out drill was held. If you issue such another call now,
and nothing happens, it can be simply another surprise drill; with
credit, promotion, and monetary awards for the best performances;
further practice and instruction for the less proficient units.”

“Splendid, Dr. Bergenholm!” Samms’ brilliant and agile mind snatched
up the thought and carried it along. “And what a chance, Rod, for
something vastly larger and more important than a Continental, or even
a Tellurian, drill–make it the first maneuver of the Galactic Patrol!”

“I’d like to, Virge, but we can’t. My boys are ready, but you aren’t.
No top appointments and no authority.”

“That can be arranged in a very few minutes. We have been waiting for
the psychological moment. This, especially if trouble should develop,
is the time. You yourself expect an attack, do you not?”

“Yes. I would not start anything unless and until I was ready to finish
it, and I see no reason for assuming that whoever it was that tried to
kill you is not at least as good a planner as I am.”

“And the rest of you…? Dr. Bergenholm?”

“My reasoning, while it does not exactly parallel that of Commissioner
Kinnison, leads to the same conclusion; that an attack in great force
is to be expected.”

“Not exactly parallel?” Kinnison demanded. “In what respects?”

“You do not seem to have considered the possibility, Commissioner, that
the proposed assassination of First Lensman Samms could very well have
been only the first step in a comprehensive operation.”

“I didn’t … and it could have been. So go ahead, Virge, with….”

The thought was never finished, for Samms had already gone ahead.
Simultaneously, it seemed, the minds of eight other Lensmen joined
the group of Tellurians. Samms, intensely serious, spoke aloud to his

“The Galactic Council is now assembled. Do you, Roderick K. Kinnison,
promise to uphold, in as much as you conscientiously can and with all
that in you lies, the authority of this Council throughout all space?”

“I promise.”

“By virtue of the authority vested in me its president by the Galactic
Council, I appoint you Port Admiral of the Galactic Patrol. My fellow
councillors are now inducting the armed forces of their various solar
systems into the Galactic Patrol … It will not take long … There,
you may make your appointments and issue orders for the mobilization.”

The two super-dreadnaughts were now approaching the Hill. The Boise
stayed “up on top”; the Chicago went down. Kinnison, however, paid
very little attention to the landing or to Samms’ disembarkation, and
none whatever to the Chicago’s reascent into the high heavens. He
knew that everything was under control; and, now alone in his cabin, he
was busy.

“All personnel of all armed forces just inducted into the Galactic
Patrol, attention!” He spoke into an ultra-wave microphone, the
familiar parade-ground rasp very evident in his deep and resonant
voice. “Kinnison of Tellus, Port Admiral, speaking. Each of you has
taken oath to the Galactic Patrol?”

They had.

“At ease. The organization chart already in your hands is made
effective as of now. Enter in your logs the date and time. Promotions:
Commodore Clayton of North America, Tellus….”

In his office at New York Spaceport Clayton came to attention and
saluted crisply; his eyes shining, his deeply-scarred face alight.

“… to be Admiral of the First Galactic Region. Commodore Schweikert
of Europe, Tellus …”

In Berlin a narrow-waisted, almost foppish-seeming man, with roached
blond hair and blue eyes, bowed stiffly from the waist and saluted

“… to be Lieutenant-Admiral of the First Galactic Region.”

And so on, down the list. A marshal and a lieutenant-marshal of the
Solarian System; a general and a lieutenant-general of the planet Sol
Three. Promotions, agreed upon long since, to fill the high offices
thus vacated. Then the list of commodores upon other planets–Guindlos
of Redland, Mars; Sesseffsen of Talleron, Venus; Raymond of the Jovian
Sub-System; Newman of Alphacent; Walters of Sirius; van-Meeter of
Valeria; Adams of Procyon; Roberts of Altair; Barrtell of Fomalhout;
Armand of Vega; and Coigne of Aldebaran–each of whom was actually the
commander-in-chief of the armed forces of a world. Each of these was
made general of his planet.

“Except for lieutenant-commodores and up, who will tune their minds to
me–dismissed!” Kinnison stopped talking and went onto his Lens.

“That was for the record. I don’t need to tell you, fellows, how glad
I am to be able to do this. You’re tops, all of you–I don’t know of
anybody I’d rather have at my back when the ether gets rough …”

“Right back at you, chief!” “Same to you Rod!” “Rocky Rod, Port
Admiral!” “Now we’re blasting!” came a melange of thoughts. Those
splendid men, with whom he had shared so much of danger and of stress,
were all as jubilant as schoolboys.

“But the thing that makes this possible may also make it necessary
for us to go to work; to earn your extra stars and my wheel.”
Kinnison smothered the welter of thoughts and outlined the situation,
concluding: “So you see it may turn out to be only a drill–but
on the other hand, since the outfit is big enough to have built a
war-fleet alone, if it wanted one, and since it may have had a lot of
first-class help that none of us knows anything about, we may be in
for the damndest battle that any of us ever saw. So come prepared for
anything. I am now going back onto voice, for the record.

“Kinnison to the commanding officers of all fleets, sub-fleets, and
task-forces of the Galactic Patrol. Information. Subject, tactical
problem; defense of the Hill against a postulated Black Fleet of
unknown size, strength, and composition; of unknown nationality or
origin; coming from an unknown direction in space at an unknown time.

“Kinnison to Admiral Clayton. Orders. Take over. I am relinquishing
command of the Boise and the Chicago.”

“Clayton to Port Admiral Kinnison. Orders received. Taking over. I
am at the Chicago’s main starboard lock. I have instructed Ensign
Masterson, the commanding officer of this gig, to wait; that he is to
take you down to the Hill.”

“WHAT? Of all the damned….” This was a thought, and unrecorded.

“Sorry, Rod–I’m sorry as hell, and I’d like no end to have you along.”
This, too, was a thought. “But that’s the way it is. Ordinary Admirals
ride the ether with their fleets. Port Admirals stay aground. I report
to you, and you run things–in broad–by remote control.”

“I see.” Kinnison then Lensed a fuming thought at Samms. “Alex
couldn’t do this to me–and wouldn’t–and knows damn well that I’d
burn him to a crisp if he had the guts to try it. So it’s your
doing–what in hell’s the big idea?”

“Who’s being heroic now, Rod?” Samms asked, quietly. “Use your brain.
And then come down here, where you belong.”

And Kinnison, after a long moment of rebellious thought and with as
much grace as he could muster, came down. Down not only to the Patrol’s
familiar offices, but down into the deepest crypts beneath them. He was
glum enough, and bitter, at first: but he found much to do. Grand Fleet
Headquarters–his headquarters–was being organized, and the best
efforts of the best minds and of the best technologists of three worlds
were being devoted to the task of strengthening the already extremely
strong defenses of THE HILL. And in a very short time the plates of
GFHQ showed that Admiral Clayton and Lieutenant-Admiral Schweikert were
doing a very nice job.

All of the really heavy stuff was of Earth, the Mother Planet, and
was already in place; as were the less numerous and much lighter
contingents of Mars, of Venus, and of Jove. And the fleets of the
outlying solar systems–cutters, scouts, and a few light cruisers–were
neither maintaining fleet formation nor laying course for Sol. Instead,
each individual vessel was blasting at maximum for the position in
space in which it would form one unit of a formation englobing at a
distance of light-years the entire Solarian System, and each of those
hurtling hundreds of ships was literally combing all circumambient
space with its furiously-driven detector beams.

“Nice.” Kinnison turned to Samms, now beside him at the master plate.
“Couldn’t have done any better myself.”

“After you get it made, what are you going to do with it in case
nothing happens?” Samms was still somewhat skeptical. “How long can you
make a drill last?”

“Until all the ensigns have long gray whiskers if I have to, but don’t
worry–if we have time to get the preliminary globe made I’ll be the
surprisedest man in the system.”

And Kinnison was not surprised; before full englobement was
accomplished, a loud-speaker gave tongue.

“Flagship Chicago to Grand Fleet Headquarters!” it blatted, sharply.
“The Black Fleet has been detected. RA twelve hours, declination plus
twenty degrees, distance about thirty light-years….”

Kinnison started to say something; then, by main force, shut himself
up. He wanted intensely to take over, to tell the boys out there
exactly what to do, but he couldn’t. He was now a Big Shot–damn the
luck! He could be and must be responsible for broad policy and for
general strategy, but, once those vitally important decisions had been
made, the actual work would have to be done by others. He didn’t like
it–but there it was. Those flashing thoughts took only an instant of

“… which is such extreme range that no estimate of strength or
composition can be made at present. We will keep you informed.”

“Acknowledge,” he ordered Randolph; who, wearing now the five silver
bars of major, was his Chief Communications Officer. “No instructions.”

He turned to his plate. Clayton hadn’t had to be told to pull in his
light stuff; it was all pelting hell-for-leather for Sol and Tellus.
Three general plans of battle had been mapped out by Staff. Each
had its advantages–and its disadvantages. Operation Acorn–long
distance–would be fought at, say, twelve light-years. It would keep
everything, particularly the big stuff, away from the Hill, and would
make automatics useless … unless some got past, or unless the
automatics were coming in on a sneak course, or unless several other
things–in any one of which cases what a God-awful shellacking the
Hill would take!

He grinned wryly at Samms, who had been following his thought, and
quoted: “A vast hemisphere of lambent violet flame, through which
neither material substance nor destructive ray can pass.”

“Well, that dedicatory statement, while perhaps a bit florid, was
strictly true at the time–before the days of allotropic iron and of
polycyclic drills. Now I’ll quote one: ‘Nothing is permanent except

“Uh-huh,” and Kinnison returned to his thinking. Operation Adack.
Middle distance. Uh-uh. He didn’t like it any better now than he had
before, even though some of the Big Brains of Staff thought it the
ideal solution. A compromise. All of the disadvantages of both of the
others, and none of the advantages of either. It still stunk, and
unless the Black fleet had an utterly fantastic composition Operation
Adack was out.

And Virgil Samms, quietly smoking a cigarette, smiled inwardly. Rod
the Rock could scarcely be expected to be in favor of any sort of

That left Operation Affick. Close up. It had three tremendous
advantages. First, the Hill’s own offensive weapons–as long as they
lasted. Second, the new Rodebush-Bergenholm fields. Third, no sneak
attack could be made without detection and interception. It had
one tremendous disadvantage; some stuff, and probably a lot of it,
would get through. Automatics, robots, guided missiles equipped with
super-speed drives, with polycyclic drills, and with atomic war-heads
strong enough to shake the whole world.

But with those new fields, shaking the world wouldn’t be enough; in
order to get deep enough to reach Virgil Samms they would damn near
have to destroy the world. Could anybody build a bomb that powerful?
He didn’t think so. Earth technology was supreme throughout all known
space; of Earth technologists the North Americans were, and always had
been, tops. Grant that the Black Fleet was, basically, North American.
Grant further that they had a man as good as Adlington–or that they
could spy-ray Adlington’s brain and laboratories and shops–a tall
order. Adlington himself was several months away from a world-wrecker,
unless he could put one a hundred miles down before detonation, which
simply was not feasible. He turned to Samms.

“It’ll be Affick, Virge, unless they’ve got a composition that is
radically different from anything I ever saw put into space.”

“So? I can’t say that I am very much surprised.”

The calm statement and the equally calm reply were beautifully
characteristic of the two men. Kinnison had not asked, nor had Samms
offered, advice. Kinnison, after weighing the facts, made his decision.
Samms, calmly certain that the decision was the best that could be made
upon the data available, accepted it without question or criticism.

“We’ve still got a minute or two,” Kinnison remarked. “Don’t quite know
what to make of their line of approach. Coma Berenices. I don’t know
of anything at all out that way, do you? They could have detoured,

“No, I don’t.” Samms frowned in thought. “Probably a detour.”

“Check.” Kinnison turned to Randolph. “Tell them to report whatever
they know; we can’t wait any …”

As he was speaking the report came in.

The Black Fleet was of more or less normal make-up; considerably larger
than the North American contingent, but decidedly inferior to the
Patrol’s present Grand Fleet. Either three or four capital ships …

“And we’ve got six!” Kinnison said, exultantly. “Our own two, Asia’s
Himalaya, Africa’s Johannesburg, South America’s Bolivar, and
Europe’s Europa.”

… Battle cruisers and heavy cruisers, about in the usual proportions;
but an unusually high ratio of scouts and light cruisers. There
were either two or three large ships which could not be classified
definitely at that distance; long-range observers were going out to
study them.

“Tell Clayton,” Kinnison instructed Randolph, “that it is to be
Operation Affick, and for him to fly at it.”

“Report continued,” the speaker came to life again. “There are three
capital ships, apparently of approximately the Chicago class, but
tear-drop-shaped instead of spherical …”

“Ouch!” Kinnison flashed a thought at Samms. “I don’t like that. They
can both fight and run.”

“… The battle cruisers are also tear-drops. The small vessels are
torpedo-shaped. There are three of the large ships, which we are
still not able to classify definitely. They are spherical in shape,
and very large, but do not seem to be either armed or screened, and
are apparently carriers–possibly of automatics. We are now making

Instead of looking at the plates before them, the two Lensmen went
en rapport with Clayton, so that they could see everything he saw.
The stupendous Cone of Battle had long since been formed; the word to
fire was given in a measured two-second call. Every firing officer in
every Patrol ship touched his stud in the same split second. And from
the gargantuan mouth of the Cone there spewed a miles-thick column of
energy so raw, so stark, so incomprehensibly violent that it must have
been seen to be even dimly appreciated. It simply cannot be described.

Its prototype, Triplanetary’s Cylinder of Annihilation, had been
a highly effective weapon indeed. The offensive beams of the
fish-shaped Nevian cruisers of the void were even more powerful.
The Cleveland-Rodebush projectors, developed aboard the original
Boise on the long Nevian way, were stronger still. The composite
beam projected by this fleet of the Galactic Patrol, however, was
the sublimation and quintessence of each of these, redesigned and
redesigned by scientists and engineers of ever-increasing knowledge,
rebuilt and rebuilt by technologists of ever-increasing skill.

Capital ships and a few of the heaviest cruisers could mount screen
generators able to carry that frightful load; but every smaller ship
caught in that semi-solid rod of indescribably incandescent fury simply
flared into nothingness.

But in the instant before the firing order was given–as though
precisely timed, which in all probability was the case–the
ever-watchful observers picked up two items of fact which made the new
Admiral of the First Galactic Region cut his almost irresistible weapon
and break up his Cone of Battle after only a few seconds of action.
One: those three enigmatic cargo scows had fallen apart before the
beam reached them, and hundreds–yes, thousands–of small objects had
hurtled radially outward, out well beyond the field of action of the
Patrol’s beam, at a speed many times that of light. Two: Kinnison’s
forebodings had been prophetic. A swarm of Blacks, all small–must have
been hidden right on Earth somewhere!–were already darting at the Hill
from the south.

“Cease firing!” Clayton rapped into his microphone. The dreadful beam
expired. “Break cone formation! Independent action–light cruisers and
scouts, get those bombs! Heavy cruisers and battle cruisers, engage
similar units of the Blacks, two to one if possible. Chicago and
Boise, attack Black Number One. Bolivar and Himalaya, Number Two.
Europa and Johannesburg, Number Three!”

Space was full of darting, flashing, madly warring ships. The three
Black super-dreadnaughts leaped forward as one. Their massed batteries
of beams, precisely synchronized and aimed, lashed out as one at the
nearest Patrol super heavy, the Boise. Under the vicious power of
that beautifully-timed thrust that warship’s first, second, and third
screens, her very wall-shield, flared through the spectrum and into the
black. Her Chief Pilot, however, was fast–very fast–and he had a
fraction of a second in which to work. Thus, practically in the instant
of her wall-shield’s failure, she went free; and while she was holed
badly and put out of action, she was not blown out of space. In fact,
it was learned later that she lost only forty men.

The Blacks were not as fortunate. The Chicago, now without a
partner, joined beams with the Bolivar and the Himalaya against
Number Two; then, a short half-second later, with her other two
sister-ships against Number Three. And in that very short space of time
two Black super-dreadnaughts ceased utterly to be.

But also, in that scant second of time, Black Number One had all but
disappeared! Her canny commander, with no stomach at all for odds
of five to one against, had ordered flight at max; she was already
one-sixtieth of a light-year–about one hundred thousand million
miles–away from the Earth and was devoting her every energy to the
accumulation of still more distance.

Bolivar! Himalaya!” Clayton barked savagely. “Get him!” He wanted
intensely to join the chase, but he couldn’t. He had to stay here. And
he didn’t have time even to swear. Instead, without a break, the words
tripping over each other against his teeth: “Chicago! Johannesburg!
Europa! Act at will against heaviest craft left. Blast ’em down!”

He gritted his teeth. The scouts and light cruisers were doing their
damndest, but they were out-numbered three to one–Christ, what a
lot of stuff was getting through! The Blacks wouldn’t last long,
between the Hill and the heavies … but maybe long enough, at
that–the Patrol globe was leaking like a sieve! He voiced a couple of
bursts of deep-space profanity and, although he was almost afraid to
look, sneaked a quick peek to see how much was left of the Hill. He
looked–and stopped swearing in the middle of a four-letter Anglo-Saxon

What he saw simply did not make sense. Those Black bombs should have
peeled the armor off of that mountain like the skin off of a nectarine
and scattered it from the Pacific to the Mississippi. By now there
should be a hole a mile deep where the Hill had been. But there wasn’t.
The Hill was still there! It might have shrunk a little–Clayton
couldn’t see very well because of the worse-than-incandescent radiance
of the practically continuous, sense-battering, world-shaking atomic
detonations–but the Hill was still there!

And as he stared, chilled and shaken, at that indescribably terrific
spectacle, a Black cruiser, holed and helpless, fell toward that
armored mountain with an acceleration starkly impossible to credit.
And when it struck it did not penetrate, and splash, and crater, as it
should have done. Instead, it simply spread out, in a thin layer,
over an acre or so of the fortress’ steep and apparently still armored

“You saw that, Alex? Good. Otherwise you could scarcely believe it,”
came Kinnison’s silent voice. “Tell all our ships to stay away. There’s
a force of over a hundred thousand G’s acting in a direction normal to
every point of our surface. The boys are giving it all the decrement
they can–somewhere between distance cube and fourth power–but even so
it’s pretty fierce stuff. How about the Bolivar and the Himalaya?
Not having much luck catching Mr. Black, are they?”

“Why, I don’t know. I’ll check … No, sir, they aren’t. They report
that they are losing ground and will soon lose trace.”

“I was afraid so, from that shape. Rodebush was about the only one who
saw it coming … well, we’ll have to redesign and rebuild …”

Port Admiral Kinnison, shortly after directing the foregoing thought,
leaned back in his chair and smiled. The battle was practically over.
The Hill had come through. The Rodebush-Bergenholm fields had held
her together through the most God-awful session of saturation atomic
bombing that any world had ever seen or that the mind of man had ever
conceived. And the counter-forces had kept the interior rock from
flowing like water. So far, so good.

Her original armor was gone. Converted into … what? For hundreds of
feet inward from the surface she was hotter than the reacting slugs
of the Hanfords. Delousing her would be a project, not an operation;
millions of cubic yards of material would have to be hauled off into
space with tractors and allowed to simmer for a few hundred years; but
what of that?

Bergenholm had said that the fields would tend to prevent the
radioactives from spreading, as they otherwise would–and Virgil Samms
was still safe

“Virge, my boy, come along.” He took the First Lensman by his good
arm and lifted him out of his chair. “Old Doctor Kinnison’s peerless
prescription for you and me is a big, thick, juicy, porterhouse steak.”


That murderous attack upon Virgil Samms, and its countering by those
new super-lawmen, the Lensmen, and by an entire task force of the
North American Armed Forces, was news of Civilization-wide importance.
As such, it filled every channel of Universal Telenews for an hour.
Then, in stunning and crescendo succession, came the staccato reports
of the creation of the Galactic Patrol, the mobilization–allegedly
for maneuvers–of Galactic Patrol’s Grand Fleet, and the ultimately
desperate and all-too-nearly successful attack upon The Hill.

“Just a second, folks; we’ll have it very shortly. You’ll see something
that nobody ever saw before and that nobody will ever see again. We’re
getting in as close as the Law will let us.” The eyes of Telenews’ ace
reporter and the telephoto lens of his cameraman stared down from a
scooter at the furiously smoking, sputteringly incandescent surface of
Triplanetary’s ancient citadel; while upon dozens of worlds thousands
of millions of people packed themselves tighter and tighter around tens
of millions of visiplates and loud-speakers in order to see and to hear
the tremendous news.

“There it is, folks, look at it–the only really impregnable fortress
ever built by man! A good many of our experts had it written off as
obsolete, long ago, but it seems these Lensmen had something up their
sleeves besides their arms, heh-heh! And speaking of Lensmen, they
haven’t been throwing their weight around, so most of us haven’t
noticed them very much, but this reporter wants to go on record right
now as saying there must be a lot more to the Lens than any of us has
thought, because otherwise nobody would have gone to all that trouble
and expense, to say nothing of the tremendous loss of life, just to
kill the Chief Lensman, which seems to have been what they were after.

“We told you a few minutes ago, you know, that every Continent of
Civilization sent official messages denying most emphatically any
connection with this outrage. It’s still a mystery, folks; in fact,
it is getting more and more mysterious all the time. Not one single
man of the Black Fleet was taken alive!
Not even in the ships that
were only holed–they blew themselves up! And there were no uniforms
or books or anything of the kind to be found in any of the wrecks–no
identification whatever!

“And now for the scoop of all time! Universal Telenews has obtained
permission to interview the two top Lensmen, both of whom you all
know–Virgil Samms and ‘Rod the Rock’ Kinnison–personally for this
beam. We are now going down, by remote control, of course, right into
the Galactic patrol office, right in The Hill itself. Here we are. Now
if you will step just a little closer to the mike, please, Mr. Samms,
or should I say…?”

“You should say ‘First Lensman Samms’,” Kinnison said bruskly.

“Oh, yes, First Lensman Samms. Thank you, Mr. Kinnison. Now, First
Lensman Samms, our clients all want to know all about the Lens. We all
know what it does, but what, really, is it? Who invented it? How
does it work?”

Kinnison started to say something, but Samms silenced him with a

“I will answer those questions by asking you one.” Samms smiled
disarmingly. “Do you remember what happened because the pirates learned
to duplicate the golden meteor of the Triplanetary Service?”

“Oh, I see.” The Telenews ace, although brash and not at all
thin-skinned, was quick on the uptake. “Hush-hush? T. S.?”

“Top Secret. Very much so,” Samms confirmed, “and we are going to keep
some things about the Lens secret as long as we possibly can.”

“Fair enough. Sorry folks, but you will agree that they’re right on
that. Well, then, Mr. Samms, who do you think it was that tried to kill
you, and where do you think the Black Fleet came from?”

“I have no idea,” Samms said, slowly and thoughtfully. “No. No idea

“What? Are you sure of that? Aren’t you holding back maybe just a
little bit of a suspicion, for diplomatic reasons?”

“I am holding nothing back; and through my Lens I can make you certain
of the fact. Lensed thoughts come from the mind itself, direct, not
through such voluntary muscles as the tongue. The mind does not
lie–even such lies as you call ‘diplomacy’.”

The Lensman demonstrated and the reporter went on:

“He is sure, folks, which fact knocked me speechless for a second
or two–which is quite a feat in itself. Now, Mr. Samms, one last
question. What is all this Lens stuff really about? What are all
you Lensmen–the Galactic Council and so on–really up to? What do
you expect to get out of it? And why would anybody want to make
such an all-out effort to get rid of you? And give it to me on the
Lens, please, if you can do it and talk at the same time–that was a
wonderful sensation, folks, of getting the dope straight and knowing
that it was straight.”

“I can and will answer both by voice and by Lens. Our basic purpose
is …” and he quoted verbatim the resounding sentences which Mentor
had impressed so ineradicably upon his mind. “You know how little
happiness, how little real well-being, there is upon any world today.
We propose to increase both. What we expect to get out of it is
happiness and well-being for ourselves, the satisfaction felt by any
good workman doing the job for which he is best fitted and in which
he takes pride. As to why anyone should want to kill me, the logical
explanation would seem to be that some group or organization or race,
opposed to that for which we Lensmen stand, decided to do away with us
and started with me.”

“Thank you, Mr. Samms. I am sure that we all enjoyed this interview
very much. Now, folks, you all know ‘Rocky Rod’, ‘Rod the Rock’,
Kinnison … just a little closer, please … thank you. I don’t
suppose you have any suspicions, either, any more than….”

“I certainly have!” Kinnison barked, so savagely that five hundred
million people jumped as one. “How do you want it; voice, or Lens,
or both?” Then on the Lens: “Think it over, son, because I suspect

“Bub-both, please, Mr. Kinnison.” Even Universal’s star reporter was
shaken by the quiet but deadly fury of the big Lensman’s thought, but
he rallied so quickly that his hesitation was barely noticeable. “Your
Lensed thought to me was that you suspect everybody, Mr. Kinnison?”

“Just that. Everybody. I suspect every continental government of every
world we know, including that of North America of Tellus. I suspect
political parties and organized minorities. I suspect pressure groups.
I suspect capital and I suspect labor. I suspect an organization of
criminals. I suspect nations and races and worlds that no one of us
has as yet heard of–not even you, the top-drawer newshawk of the

“But you have nothing concrete to go on, I take it?”

“If I did have, do you think I’d be standing here talking to you?”

First Lensman Samms sat in his private quarters and thought.

Lensman Dronvire of Rigel Four stood behind him and helped him think.

Port Admiral Kinnison, with all his force and drive, began a
comprehensive program of investigation, consolidation, expansion,
redesigning, and rebuilding.

Virgilia Samms went to a party practically every night. She danced, she
flirted, she talked. How she talked! Meaningless small talk for the
most part–but interspersed with artless questions and comments which,
while they perhaps did not put her partner of the moment completely at
ease, nevertheless did not quite excite suspicion.

Conway Costigan, Lens under sleeve, undisguised but inconspicuous, rode
the ether-lanes; observing minutely and reporting fully.

Jack Kinnison piloted and navigated and computed for his friend and

Mason Northrop; who, completely surrounded by breadboard hookups of new
and ever-more-fantastic complexity, listened and looked; listened and
tuned; listened and rebuilt; listened and–finally–took bearings and
bearings and bearings with his ultra-sensitive loops.

DalNalten and Knobos, with dozens of able helpers, combed the records
of three worlds in a search which produced as a by-product a monumental
“who’s who” of crime.

Skilled technicians fed millions of cards, stack by stack, into
the most versatile and most accomplished machines known to the
statisticians of the age.

And Dr. Nels Bergenholm, abandoning temporarily his regular line of
work, devoted his peculiar talents to a highly abstruse research in the
closely allied field of organic chemistry.

The walls of Virgil Samms’ quarters became covered with charts,
diagrams, and figures. Tabulations and condensations piled up on his
desk and overflowed into baskets upon the floor. Until:

“Lensman Olmstead, of Alphacent, sir,” his secretary announced.

“Good! Send him in, please.”

The stranger entered. The two men, after staring intently at each
other for half a minute, smiled and shook hands vigorously. Except for
the fact that the newcomer’s hair was brown, they were practically

“I’m certainly glad to see you, George. Bergenholm passed you, of

“Yes. He says that he can match your hair to mine, even the individual
white ones. And he has made me a wig-maker’s dream of a wig.”

“Married?” Samms’ mind leaped ahead to possible complications.

“Widower, same as you. And….”

“Just a minute–going over this once will be enough.” He Lensed call
after call. Lensmen in various parts of space became en rapport with
him and thus with each other.

“Lensmen–especially you, Rod–George Olmstead is here, and his brother
Ray is available. I am going to work.”

“I still don’t like it!” Kinnison protested. “It’s too dangerous. I
told the Universe I was going to keep you covered, and I meant it!”

“That’s what makes it perfectly safe. That is, if Bergenholm is sure
that the duplication is close enough …”

“I am sure.” Bergenholm’s deeply resonant pseudo-voice left no doubt
at all in any one of the linked minds. “The substitution will not be

“… and that nobody knows, George, or even suspects, that you got your

“I am sure of that.” Olmstead laughed quietly. “Also, nobody except us
and your secretary knows that I am here. For a good many years I have
made a specialty of that sort of thing. Photos, fingerprints, and so on
have all been taken care of.”

“Good. I simply can not work efficiently here,” Samms expressed
what all knew to be the simple truth. “Dronvire is a much better
analyst-synthesist than I am; as soon as any significant correlation
is possible he will know it. We have learned that the Towne-Morgan
crowd, Mackenzie Power, Ossmen Industries, and Interstellar
Spaceways are all tied in together, and that thionite is involved,
but we have not been able to get any further. There is a slight
correlation–barely significant–between deaths from thionite and
the arrival in the Solarian System of certain Spaceways liners. The
fact that certain officials of the Earth-Screen Service have been and
are spending considerably more than they earn sets up a slight but
definite probability that they are allowing space-ships or boats from
space-ships to land illegally. These smugglers carry contraband, which
may or may not be thionite. In short, we lack fundamental data in every
department, and it is high time for me to begin doing my share in
getting it.”

“I don’t check you, Virge.” None of the Kinnisons ever did give
up without a struggle. “Olmstead is a mighty smooth worker,
and you are our prime coordinator. Why not let him keep up the
counter-espionage–do the job you were figuring on doing yourself–and
you stay here and boss it?”

“I have thought of that, a great deal, and have….”

“Because Olmstead can not do it,” a hitherto silent mind cut in,
decisively. “I, Rularion of North Polar Jupiter, say so. There are
psychological factors involved. The ability to separate and to evaluate
the constituent elements of a complex situation; the ability to make
correct decisions without hesitation; as well as many others not
as susceptible to concise statement, but which collectively could
be called power of mind. How say you, Bergenholm of Tellus? For I
have perceived in you a mind approximating in some respects the
philosophical and psychological depth of my own.” This outrageously
egotistical declaration was, to the Jovian, a simple statement of an
equally simple truth, and Bergenholm accepted it as such.

“I agree. Olmstead probably could not succeed.”

“Well, then, can Samms?” Kinnison demanded.

“Who knows?” came Bergenholm’s mental shrug, and simultaneously:

“Nobody knows whether I can or not, but I am going to try,” and Samms
ended–almost–the argument by asking Bergenholm and a couple of other
Lensmen to come into his office and by taking off his Lens.

“And that’s another thing I don’t like.” Kinnison offered one last
objection. “Without your Lens, anything can happen to you.”

“Oh, I won’t have to be without it very long. And besides,
Virgilia isn’t the only one in the Samms family who can work
better–sometimes–without a Lens.”

The Lensmen came in and, in a surprisingly short time, went out. A few
minutes later, two Lensmen strolled out of Samms’ inner office into
the outer one.

“Good-bye, George,” the red-headed man said aloud, “and good luck.”

“Same to you, Chief,” and the brown-haired one strode out.

Norma the secretary was a smart girl, and observant. In her position,
she had to be. Her eyes followed the man out, then scanned the Lensman
from toe to crown.

“I’ve never seen anything like it, Mr. Samms,” she remarked then.
“Except for the difference in coloring, and a sort of … well,
stoopiness … he could be your identical twin. You two must have had a
common ancestor–or several–not too far back, didn’t you?”

“We certainly did. Quadruple second cousins, you might call it. We have
known of each other for years, but this is the first time we have met.”

“Quadruple second cousins? What does that mean? How come?”

“Well, say that once upon a time there were two men named Albert and

“What? Not two Irishmen named Pat and Mike? You’re slipping, boss.” The
girl smiled roguishly. During rush hours she was always the fast, cool,
efficient secretary, but in moments of ease such persiflage as this was
the usual thing in the First Lensman’s private office. “Not at all up
to your usual form.”

“Merely because I am speaking now as a genealogist, not as a raconteur.
But to continue, we will say that Chester and Albert had four children
apiece, two boys and two girls, two pairs of identical twins, each. And
when they grew up–half way up, that is….”

“Don’t tell me that we are going to suppose that all those identical
twins married each other?”

“Exactly. Why not?”

“Well, it would be stretching the laws of probability all out of shape.
But go ahead–I can see what’s coming, I think.”

“Each of those couples had one, and only one, child. We will call those
children Jim Samms and Sally Olmstead; John Olmstead and Irene Samms.”

The girl’s levity disappeared. “James Alexander Samms and Sarah
Olmstead Samms. Your parents. I didn’t see what was coming, after all.
This George Olmstead; then, is your….”

“Whatever it is, yes. I can’t name it, either–maybe you had better
call Genealogy some day and find out. But it’s no wonder we look alike.
And there are three of us, not two–George has an identical twin

The red-haired Lensman stepped back into the inner office, shut the
door, and Lensed a thought at Virgil Samms.

“It worked, Virgil! I talked to her for five solid minutes, practically
leaning on her desk, and she didn’t tumble! And if this wig of
Bergenholm’s fooled her so completely, the job he did on you would
fool anybody!”

“Fine! I’ve done a little testing myself, on the keenest men I know,
without a trace of recognition so far.”

His last lingering doubt resolved, Samms boarded the ponderous,
radiation-proof, neutron-proof shuttle-scow which was the only possible
means of entering or leaving the Hill. A fast cruiser whisked him
to Nampa, where Olmstead’s “accidentally” damaged transcontinental
transport was being repaired, and from which city Olmstead had been
gone so briefly that no one had missed him. He occupied Olmstead’s
space; he surrendered the remainder of Olmstead’s ticket. He reached
New York. He took a ‘copter to Senator Morgan’s office. He was escorted
into the private office of Herkimer Herkimer Third.

“Olmstead. Of Alphacent.”

“Yes?” Herkimer’s hand moved, ever so little, upon his desk’s top.

“Here.” The Lensman dropped an envelope upon the desk in such fashion
that it came to rest within an inch of the hand.

“Prints. Here.” Samms made prints. “Wash your hands, over there.”
Herkimer pressed a button. “Check all these prints, against each other
and the files. Check the two halves of the torn sheet, fiber to fiber.”
He turned to the Lensless Lensman, now standing quietly before his
desk. “Routine; a formality, in your case, but necessary.”

“Of course.”

Then for long seconds the two hard men stared into the hard depths of
each other’s eyes.

“You may do, Olmstead. We have had very good reports of you. But you
have never been in thionite?”

“No. I have never even seen any.”

“What do you want to get into it for?”

“Your scouts sounded me out; what did they tell you? The usual
thing–promotion from the ranks into the brass–to get to where I can
do myself and the organization some good.”

“Yourself first, the organization second?”

“What else? Why should I be different from the rest of you?”

This time the locked eyes held longer; one pair smoldering, the other
gold-flecked, tawny ice.

“Why, indeed?” Herkimer smiled thinly. “We do not advertise it,

“Outside, I wouldn’t, either; but here I’m laying my cards flat on the

“I see. You will do, Olmstead, if you live. There’s a test, you know.”

“They told me there would be.”

“Well, aren’t you curious to know what it is?”

“Not particularly. You passed it, didn’t you?”

“What do you mean by that crack?” Herkimer leaped to his feet; his
eyes, smoldering before, now ablaze.

“Exactly what I said, no more and no less. You may read into it
anything you please.” Samms’ voice was as cold as were his eyes. “You
picked me out because of what I am. Did you think that moving upstairs
would make a boot-licker out of me?”

“Not at all.” Herkimer sat down and took from a drawer two small,
transparent, vaguely capsule-like tubes, each containing a few
particles of purple dust. “You know what this is?”

“I can guess.”

“Each of these is a good, heavy jolt; about all that a strong man with
a strong heart can stand. Sit down. Here is one dose. Pull the cover,
stick the capsule up one nostril, squeeze the ejector, and sniff. If
you can leave this other dose sitting here on the desk you will live,
and thus pass the test. If you can’t, you die.”

Samms sat, and pulled, and squeezed, and sniffed.

His forearms hit the desk with a thud. His hands clenched themselves
into fists, the tight-stretched tendons standing boldly out. His face
turned white. His eyes jammed themselves shut; his jaw-muscles sprang
into bands and lumps as they clamped his teeth hard together. Every
voluntary muscle in his body went into a rigor as extreme as that of
death itself. His heart pounded; his breathing became stertorous.

This was the dreadful “muscle-lock” so uniquely characteristic of
thionite; the frenzied immobility of the ultimately passionate
satisfaction of every desire.

The Galactic Patrol became for him an actuality; a force for good
pervading all the worlds of all the galaxies of all the universes of
all existing space-time continual. He knew what the Lens was, and why.
He understood time and space. He knew the absolute beginning and the
ultimate end.

He also saw things and did things over which it is best to draw a
kindly veil, for every desire–mental or physical, open or sternly
suppressed, noble or base–that Virgil Samms had ever had was being
completely satisfied. EVERY DESIRE.

As Samms sat there, straining motionlessly upon the verge of death
through sheer ecstasy, a door opened and Senator Morgan entered the
room. Herkimer started, almost imperceptibly, as he turned–had there
been, or not, an instantaneously-suppressed flash of guilt in those now
completely clear and frank brown eyes?

“Hi, Chief; come in and sit down. Glad to see you–this is not exactly
my idea of fun.”

“No? When did you stop being a sadist?” The senator sat down beside
his minion’s desk, the fingertips of his left hand began soundlessly
to drum. “You wouldn’t have, by any chance, been considering the idea
of…?” He paused significantly.

“What an idea.” Herkimer’s act–if it was an act–was flawless. “He’s
too good a man to waste.”

“I know it, but you didn’t act as though you did. I’ve never seen you
come out such a poor second in an interview … and it wasn’t because
you didn’t know to start with just what kind of a tiger he was–that’s
why he was selected for this job. And it would have been so easy to
give him just a wee bit more.”

“That’s preposterous, Chief, and you know it.”

“Do I? However, it couldn’t have been jealousy, because he isn’t being
considered for your job. He won’t be over you, and there’s plenty of
room for everybody. What was the matter? Your bloodthirstiness wouldn’t
have taken you that far, under these circumstances. Come clean,

“Okay–I hate the whole damned family!” Herkimer burst out, viciously.

“I see. That adds up.” Morgan’s face cleared, his fingers became
motionless. “You can’t make the Samms wench and aren’t in position to
skin her alive, so you get allergic to all her relatives. That adds
up, but let me tell you something.” His quiet, level voice carried
more of menace than most men’s loudest threats. “Keep your love life
out of business and keep that sadistic streak under control. Don’t let
anything like this happen again.”

“I won’t, Chief. I got off the beam–but he made me so damn mad!”

“Certainly. That’s exactly what he was trying to do. Elementary. If he
could make you look small it would make him look big, and he just about
did. But watch now, he’s coming to.”

Samms’ muscles relaxed. He opened his eyes groggily; then, as a wave
of humiliated realization swept over his consciousness, he closed them
again and shuddered. He had always thought himself pretty much of a
man; how could he possibly have descended to such nauseous depths
of depravity, of turpitude, of sheer moral degradation? And yet every
cell of his being was shrieking its demand for more; his mind and
his substance alike were permeated by an over-mastering craving to
experience again the ultimate thrills which they had so tremendously,
so outrageously enjoyed.

There was another good jolt lying right there on the desk in front of
him, even though thionite-sniffers always saw to it that no more of the
drug could be obtained without considerable physical exertion; which
exertion would bring them to their senses. If he took that jolt it
would kill him. What of it? What was death? What good was life, except
to enjoy such thrills as he had just had and was about to have again?
And besides, thionite couldn’t kill him. He was a super-man; he had
just proved it!

He straightened up and reached for the capsule; and that effort, small
as it was, was enough to bring First Lensman Virgil Samms back under
control. The craving, however, did not decrease. Rather, it increased.

Months were to pass before he could think of thionite, or even of
the color purple, without a spasmodic catching of the breath and a
tightening of every muscle. Years were to pass before he could forget,
even partially, the theretofore unsuspected dwellers in the dark
recesses of his own mind. Nevertheless, from the store of whatever it
was that made him what he was, Virgil Samms drew strength. Thumb and
forefinger touched the capsule, but instead of picking it up, he pushed
it across the desk toward Herkimer.

“Put it away, bub. One whiff of that stuff will last me for life.” He
stared unfathomably at the secretary, then turned to Morgan and nodded.
“After all, he did not say that he ever passed this or any other
test. He just didn’t contradict me when I said it.”

With a visible effort Herkimer remained silent, but Morgan did not.

“You talk too much, Olmstead. Can you stand up yet?”

Gripping the desk with both hands, Samms heaved himself to his feet.
The room was spinning and gyrating; every individual thing in it was
moving in a different and impossible orbit; his already splintered
skull threatened more and more violently to emulate a fragmentation
bomb; black and white spots and vari-colored flashes filled his cone of
vision. He wrenched one hand free, then the other–and collapsed back
into the chair.

“Not yet–quite,” he admitted, through stiff lips.

Although he was careful not to show it, Morgan was amazed–not that
the man had collapsed, but that he had been able so soon to lift
himself even an inch. “Tiger” was not the word; this Olmstead must be
seven-eighths dinosaur.

“It takes a few minutes; longer for some, not so long for others,”
Morgan said, blandly. “But what makes you think Herkimer here never
took one of the same?”

“Huh?” Again two pairs of eyes locked and held; and this time the duel
was longer and more pregnant. “What do you think? How do you suppose
I lived to get as old as I am now? By being dumb?”

Morgan unwrapped a Venerian cigar, settled it comfortably between his
teeth, lit it, and drew three slow puffs before replying.

“Ah, a student. An analytical mind,” he said, evenly,
and–apparently–irrelevantly. “Let’s skip Herkimer for the moment. Try
your hand on me.”

“Why not? From what we hear out in the field, you have always been in
the upper brackets, so you probably never had to prove that you could
take it or let it alone. My guess would be, though, that you could.”

“The good old oil, eh?” Morgan allowed his face and voice to register
a modicum, precisely metered, of contempt. “How to get along in the
world; Lesson One: Butter up the Boss.”

“Nice try, Senator, but I’ll have to score you a clean miss.” Samms,
now back almost to normal, grinned companionably. “We both know that if
I were still in the kindergarten I wouldn’t be here now.”

“I’ll let that one pass–this time.” Under that look and tone Morgan’s
underlings were wont to cringe, but this Olmstead was not the cringing
type. “Don’t do it again. It might not be safe.”

“Oh, it would be safe enough–for today, at least. There are two
factors which you are very carefully ignoring. First, I haven’t
accepted the job yet.”

“Are you innocent enough to think you’ll get out of this building
alive if I don’t accept you?”

“If you want to call it innocence, yes. Oh, I know you’ve got gunnies
all over the place, but they don’t mean a thing.”

“No?” Morgan’s voice was silkily venomous.

“No.” Olmstead was completely unimpressed. “Put yourself in my place.
You know I’ve been around a long time; and not just around my mother. I
was weaned quite a number of years ago.”

“I see. You don’t scare worth a damn. A point. And you are testing me,
just as I am testing you. Another point. I’m beginning to like you,
George. I think I know what your second point is, but let’s have it,
just for the record.”

“I’m sure you do. Any man, to be my boss, has got to be at least as
good a man as I am. Otherwise I take his job away from him.”

“Fair enough. By God, I do like you, Olmstead!” Morgan, his big face
wreathed in smiles, got up, strode over, and shook hands vigorously;
and Samms, scan as he would, could not even hazard a guess as to how
much–if any–of this enthusiasm was real. “Do you want the job? And
when can you go to work?”

“Yes, sir. Two hours ago, sir.”

“That’s fine!” Morgan boomed. Although he did not comment upon it, he
noticed and understood the change in the form of address. “Without
knowing what the job is or how much it pays?”

“Neither is important, sir, at the moment.” Samms, who had got up
easily enough to shake hands, now shook his head experimentally.
Nothing rattled. Good–he was in pretty good shape already. “As to the
job, I can either do it or find out why it can’t be done. As to pay,
I’ve heard you called a lot of things, but ‘piker’ was never one of

“Very well. I predict that you will go far.” Morgan again shook the
Lensman’s hand; and again Samms could not evaluate the Senator’s
sincerity. “Tuesday afternoon. New York Spaceport. Space-ship Virgin
. Report to Captain Willoughby in the dock office at fourteen
hundred hours. Stop at the cashier’s office on your way out. Good-bye.”


Piracy was rife. There was no suspicion, however, nor would there be
for many years, that there was anything of very large purpose about the
business. Murgatroyd was simply a Captain Kidd of space; and even if he
were actually connected with Galactic Spaceways, that fact would not be
surprising. Such relationships had always existed; the most ferocious
and dreaded pirates of the ancient world worked in full partnership
with the First Families of that world.

Virgil Samms was thinking of pirates and of piracy when he left Senator
Morgan’s office. He was still thinking of them while he was reporting
to Roderick Kinnison. Hence:

“But that’s enough about this stuff and me, Rod. Bring me up to date on
Operation Boskone.”

“Branching out no end. Your guess was right that Spaceways’ losses to
pirates are probably phony. But it wasn’t the known attacks–that
is, those cases in which the ship was found, later, with some or most
of the personnel alive–that gave us the real information. They were
all pretty much alike. But when we studied the total disappearances we
really hit the jack-pot.”

“That doesn’t sound just right, but I’m listening.”

“You’d better, since it goes farther than even you suspected. It was no
trouble at all to get the passenger lists and the names of the crews of
the independent ships that were lost without a trace. Their relatives
and friends–we concentrated mostly on wives–could be located, except
for the usual few who moved around so much that they got lost. Spacemen
average young, you know, and their wives are still younger. Well, these
young women got jobs, most of them remarried, and so on. In short,

“And in the case of Spaceways, not normal?”

“Decidedly not. In the first place, you’d be amazed at how little
publication was ever done of passenger lists, and apparently crew
lists were not published at all. No use going into detail as to how
we got the stuff, but we got it. However, nine tenths of the wives had
disappeared, and none had remarried. The only ones we could find were
those who did not care, even when their husbands were alive, whether
they ever saw them again or not. But the big break was–you remember
the disappearance of that girls’-school cruise ship?”

“Of course. It made a lot of noise.”

“An interesting point in connection with that cruise is that two days
before the ship blasted off the school was robbed. The vault was
opened with thermite and the whole Administration Building burned to
the ground. All the school’s records were destroyed. Thus, the list of
missing had to be made up from statements made by friends, relatives,
and what not.”

“I remember something of the kind. My impression was, though, that
the space-ship company furnished…. Oh!” The tone of Samms’ thought
alerted sharply. “That was Spaceways, under cover?”

“Definitely. Our best guess is that there were quite a few shiploads of
women disappeared about that time, instead of one. Austine’s College
had more students that year than ever before or since. It was the
extras, not the regulars, who went on that cruise; the ones who figured
it would be more convenient to disappear in space than to become
ordinary missing persons.”

“But Rod! That would mean … but where?”

“It means just that. And finding out ‘where’ will run into a project.
There are over two thousand million suns in this galaxy, and the best
estimate is that there are more than that many planets habitable by
beings more or less human in type. You know how much of the galaxy has
been explored and how fast the work of exploring the rest of it is
going. Your guess is just as good as mine as to where those spacemen
and engineers and their wives and girl-friends are now. I am sure,
though, of four things; none of which we can ever begin to prove. One;
they didn’t die in space. Two; they landed on a comfortable and very
well equipped Tellurian planet. Three; they built a fleet there. Four;
that fleet attacked the Hill.”

“Murgatroyd, do you suppose?” Although surprised by Kinnison’s
tremendous report, Samms was not dismayed.

“No idea. No data–yet.”

“And they’ll keep on building,” Samms said. “They had a fleet much
larger than the one they expected to meet. Now they’ll build one
larger than all our combined forces. And since the politicians will
always know what we are doing … or it might be … I wonder…?”

“You can stop wondering.” Kinnison grinned savagely.

“What do you mean?”

“Just what you were going to think about. You know the edge of the
galaxy closest to Tellus, where that big rift cuts in?”


“Across that rift, where it won’t be surveyed for a thousand years,
there’s a planet that could be Earth’s twin sister. No atomic energy,
no space-drive, but heavily industrialized and anxious to welcome
us. Project Bennett. Very, very hush-hush. Nobody except Lensmen
know anything about it. Two friends of Dronvire’s–smart, smooth
operators–are in charge. It’s going to be the Navy Yard of the
Galactic Patrol.”

“But Rod …” Samms began to protest, his mind leaping ahead to the
numberless problems, the tremendous difficulties, inherent in the
program which his friend had outlined so briefly.

“Forget it, Virge!” Kinnison cut in. “It won’t be easy, of course, but
we can do anything they can do, and do it better. You can go calmly
ahead with your own chores, knowing that when–and notice that I say
‘when’, not ‘if’–we need it we’ll have a fleet up our sleeves that
will make the official one look like a task force. But I see you’re
at the rendezvous, and there’s Jill. Tell her ‘hi’ for me. And as the
Vegians say–‘Tail high, brother!'”

Samms was in the hotel’s ornate lobby; a couple of uniformed “boys” and
Jill Samms were approaching. The girl reached him first.

“You had no trouble in recognizing me, then, my dear?”

“None at all, Uncle George.” She kissed him perfunctorily, the bell
hops faded away. “So nice to see you–I’ve heard so much about you.
The Marine Room, you said?”

“Yes. I reserved a table.”

And in that famous restaurant, in the unequalled privacy of the city’s
noisiest and most crowded night spot, they drank sparingly; ate
not-so-sparingly; and talked not sparingly at all.

“It’s perfectly safe here, you think?” Jill asked first.

“Perfectly. A super-sensitive microphone couldn’t hear anything, and
it’s so dark that a lip-reader, even if he could read us, would need a
pair of twelve-inch night-glasses.”

“Goody! They did a marvelous job, Dad. If it weren’t for your … well,
your personality, I wouldn’t recognize you even now.”

“You think I’m safe, then?”


“Then we’ll get down to business. You, Knobos, and DalNalten all have
keen and powerful minds. You can’t all be wrong. Spaceways, then, is
tied in with both the Towne-Morgan gang and with thionite. The logical
extension of that–Dal certainly thought of it, even though he didn’t
mention it–would be …” Samms paused.

“Check. That the notorious Murgatroyd, instead of being just another
pirate chief, is really working for Spaceways and belongs to the
Towne-Morgan-Isaacson gang. But dad–what an idea! Can things be that
rotten, really?”

“They may be worse than that. Now the next thing. Who, in your opinion,
is the real boss?”

“Well, it certainly is not Herkimer Herkimer Third.” Jill ticked him
off on a pink forefinger. She had been asked for an opinion; she
set out to give it without apology or hesitation. “He could–just
about–direct the affairs of a hot-dog stand. Nor is it Clander. He
isn’t even a little fish; he’s scarcely a minnow. Equally certainly
it is neither the Venerian nor the Martian. They may run planetary
affairs, but nothing bigger. I haven’t met Murgatroyd, of course, but
I have had several evaluations, and he does not rate up with Towne.
And Big Jim–and this surprised me as much as it will you–is almost
certainly not the prime mover.” She looked at him questioningly.

“That would have surprised me tremendously yesterday; but after
today–I’ll tell you about that presently–it doesn’t.”

“I’m glad of that. I expected an argument, and I have been inclined
to question the validity of my own results, since they do not agree
with common knowledge–or, rather, what is supposed to be knowledge.
That leaves Isaacson and Senator Morgan.” Jill frowned in perplexity;
seemed, for the first time, unsure. “Isaacson is of course a big man.
Able. Well-informed. Extremely capable. A top-notch executive. Not only
is, would have to be, to run Spaceways. On the other hand, I have
always thought that Morgan was nothing but a windbag….” Jill stopped
talking; left the thought hanging in air.

“So did I–until today,” Samms agreed grimly. “I thought that he was
simply an unusually corrupt, greedy, rabble-rousing politician. Our
estimates of him may have to be changed very radically.”

Samms’ mind raced. From two entirely different angles of approach, Jill
and he had arrived at the same conclusion. But, if Morgan were really
the Big Shot, would he have deigned to interview personally such small
fry as Olmstead? Or was Olmstead’s job of more importance than he,
Samms, had supposed?

“I’ve got a dozen more things to check with you,” he went on, almost
without a pause, “but since this leadership matter is the only one in
which my experience would affect your judgment, I had better tell you
about what happened today….”

Tuesday came, and hour fourteen hundred; and Samms strode into an
office. There was a big, clean desk; a wiry, intense, gray-haired man.

“Captain Willoughby?”


“George Olmstead reporting.”

“Fourth Officer.” The captain punched a button; the heavy, sound-proof
door closed itself and locked.

Fourth Officer? New rank, eh. What does the ticket cover?”

“New, and special. Here’s the articles; read it and sign it.” He did
not add “or else”, it was not necessary. It was clearly evident that
Captain Willoughby, never garrulous, intended to be particularly
reticent with his new subordinate.

Samms read. “… Fourth Officer … shall … no duties or
responsibilities in the operation or maintenance of said space-ship …
cargo …” Then came a clause which fairly leaped from the paper and
smote his eyes: “when in command of a detail outside the hull of said
space-ship he shall enforce, by the infliction of death or such other
penalty as he deems fit….”

The Lensman was rocked to the heels, but did not show it. Instead, he
took the captain’s pen–his own, as far as Willoughby was concerned,
could have been filled with vanishing ink–and wrote George Olmstead’s
name in George Olmstead’s bold, flowing script.

Willoughby then took him aboard the good ship Virgin Queen and led
him to his cabin.

“Here you are, Mr. Olmstead. Beyond getting acquainted with the
super-cargo and the rest of your men, you will have no duties for a few
days. You have full run of the ship, with one exception. Stay out of
the control room until I call you. Is that clear?”

“Yes, sir.” Willoughby turned away and Samms, after tossing his
space-bag into the rack, took inventory.

The room was of course very small; but, considering the importance of
mass, it was almost extravagantly supplied. There were shelves, or
rather, tight racks, of books; there were sun-lamps and card-shelves
and exercisers and games; there was a receiver capable of bringing in
programs from almost anywhere in space. The room had only one lack; it
did not have an ultra-wave visiplate. Nor was this lack surprising.
“They” would scarcely let George Olmstead know where “they” were taking

Samms was surprised, however, when he met the men who were to be
directly under his command; for instead of one, or at most two, they
numbered exactly forty. And they were all, he thought at first glance,
the dregs and sweepings of the lowest dives in space. Before long,
however, he learned that they were not all space-rats and denizens
of Skid Rows. Six of them–the strongest physically and the hardest
mentally of the lot–were fugitives from lethal chambers; murderers
and worse. He looked at the biggest, toughest one of the six–a
rock-drill-eyed, red-haired giant–and asked:

“What did they tell you, Tworn, that your job was going to be?”

“They didn’t say. Just that it was dangerous, but if I done exactly
what my boss would tell me to do, and nothing else, I might not even
get hurt. An’ I was due to take the deep breath the next week, see?
That’s just how it was, boss.”

“I see,” and one by one Virgil Samms, master psychologist, studied and
analyzed his motley crew until he was called into the control room.

The navigating tank was covered; no charts were to be seen. The one
“live” visiplate showed a planet and a fiercely blue-white sun.

“My orders are to tell you, at this point, all I know about what you’ve
got to do and about that planet down there. Trenco, they call it.” To
Virgil Samms, the first adherent of Civilization ever to hear it, that
name meant nothing whatever. “You are to take about five of your men,
go down there, and gather all the green leaves you can. Not green in
color; sort of purplish. What they call broadleaf is the best; leaves
about two feet long and a foot wide. But don’t be too choosy. If there
isn’t any broadleaf handy, grab anything you can get hold of.”

“What is the opposition?” Samms asked, quietly. “And what have they got
that makes them so tough?”

“Nothing. No inhabitants, even. Just the planet itself. Next to Arisia,
it’s the God damndest planet in space. I’ve never been any closer to it
than this, and I never will, so I don’t know anything about it except
what I hear; but there’s something about it that kills men or drives
them crazy. We spend seven or eight boats every trip, and thirty-five
or forty men, and the biggest load that anybody ever took away from
here was just under two hundred pounds of leaf. A good many times we
don’t get any.”

“They go crazy, eh?” In spite of his control, Samms paled. But it
couldn’t be like Arisia. “What are the symptoms? What do they say?”

“Various. Main thing seems to be that they lose their sight. Don’t go
blind, exactly, but can’t see where anything is; or, if they do see
it, it isn’t there. And it rains over forty feet deep every night, and
yet it all dries up by morning. The worst electrical storms in the
universe, and wind-velocities–I can show you charts on that–of over
eight hundred miles an hour.”

“Whew! How about time? With your permission, I would like to do some
surveying before I try to land.”

“A smart idea. A couple of the other boys had the same, but it didn’t
help–they didn’t come back. I’ll give you two Tellurian days–no,
three–before I give you up and start sending out the other boats. Pick
out your five men and see what you can do.”

As the boat dropped away, Willoughby’s voice came briskly from a
speaker. “I know that you five men have got ideas. Forget ’em. Fourth
Officer Olmstead has the authority and the orders to put a half-ounce
slug through the guts of any or all of you that don’t jump, and jump
fast, to do what he tells you. And if that boat makes any funny moves I
blast it out of the ether. Good harvesting!”

For forty-eight Tellurian hours, taking time out only to sleep, Samms
scanned and surveyed the planet Trenco; and the more he studied it, the
more outrageously abnormal it became.

Trenco was, and is, a peculiar planet indeed. Its atmosphere is not air
as we know air; its hydrosphere does not resemble water. Half of that
atmosphere and most of that hydrosphere are one chemical, a substance
of very low heat of vaporization and having a boiling point of about
seventy-five degrees Fahrenheit. Trenco’s days are intensely hot; its
nights are bitterly cold.

At night, therefore, it rains: and by comparison a Tellurian downpour
of one inch per hour is scarcely a drizzle. Upon Trenco it really
rains–forty seven feet and five inches of precipitation, every night
of every Trenconian year. And this tremendous condensation of course
causes wind. Willoughby’s graphs were accurate. Except at Trenco’s
very poles there is not a spot in which or a time at which an Earthly
gale would not constitute a dead calm; and along the equator, at every
sunrise and every sunset, the wind blows from the day side into the
night side at a velocity which no Tellurian hurricane or cyclone,
however violent, has even distantly approached.

Also, therefore, there is lightning. Not in the mild and occasional
flashes which we of gentle Terra know, but in a continuous, blinding
glare which outshines a normal sun; in battering, shattering,
multi-billion-volt discharges which not only make darkness unknown
there, but also distort beyond recognition and beyond function the warp
and the woof of space itself. Sight is almost completely useless in
that fantastically altered medium. So is the ultra-beam.

Landing on the daylight side, except possibly at exact noon, would be
impossible because of the wind, nor could the ship stay landed for
more than a couple of minutes. Landing on the night side would be
practically as bad, because of the terrific charge the boat would pick
up–unless the boat carried something that could be rebuilt into a
leaker. Did it? It did.

Time after time, from pole to pole and from midnight around the clock,
Samms stabbed Visibeam and spy-ray down toward Trenco’s falsely-visible
surface, with consistently and meaninglessly impossible results. The
planet tipped, lurched, spun, and danced. It broke up into chunks, each
of which began insanely to follow mathematically impossible paths.

Finally, in desperation, he rammed a beam down and held it down. Again
he saw the planet break up before his eyes, but this time he held on.
He knew that he was well out of the stratosphere, a good two hundred
miles up. Nevertheless, he saw a tremendous mass of jagged rock
falling straight down, with terrific velocity, upon his tiny lifeboat!

Unfortunately the crew, to whom he had not been paying overmuch
attention of late, saw it, too; and one of them, with a bestial yell,
leaped toward Samms and the controls. Samms, reaching for pistol and
blackjack, whirled around just in time to see the big red-head lay the
would-be attacker out cold with a vicious hand’s-edge chop at the base
of the skull.

“Thanks, Tworn. Why?”

“Because I want to get out of this alive, and he’d’ve had us all in
hell in fifteen minutes. You know a hell of a lot more than we do, so
I’m playin’ it your way. See?”

“I see. Can you use a sap?”

“An artist,” the big man admitted, modestly. “Just tell me how long
you want a guy to be out and I won’t miss it a minute, either way. But
you’d better blow that crumb’s brains out, right now. He ain’t no damn

“Not until after I see whether he can work or not. You’re a Procian,
aren’t you?”

“Yeah. Midlands–North Central.”

“What did you do?”

“Nothing much, at first. Just killed a guy that needed killing; but
the goddam louse had a lot of money, so they give me twenty five
years. I didn’t like it very well, and acted rough, so they give me
solitary–boot, bandage, and so on. So I tried a break–killed six or
eight, maybe a dozen, guards–but didn’t quite make it. So they slated
me for the big whiff. That’s all, boss.”

“I’m promoting you, now, to squad leader. Here’s the sap.” He handed
Tworn his blackjack. “Watch ’em–I’ll be too busy to. This landing is
going to be tough.”

“Gotcha, boss.” Tworn was calibrating his weapon by slugging himself
experimentally on the leg. “Go ahead. As far as these crumbs are
concerned, you’ve got this air-tank all to yourself.”

Samms had finally decided what he was going to do. He located the
terminator on the morning side, poised his little ship somewhat nearer
to dawn than to midnight, and “cut the rope”. He took one quick reading
on the sun, cut off his plates, and let her drop, watching only his
pressure gages and gyros.

One hundred millimeters of mercury. Three hundred. Five hundred. He
slowed her down. He was going to hit a thin liquid, but if he hit
it too hard he would smash the boat, and he had no idea what the
atmospheric pressure at Trenco’s surface would be. Six hundred. Even
this late at night, it might be greater than Earth’s … and it might
be a lot less. Seven hundred.

Slower and slower he crept downward, his tension mounting infinitely
faster than did the needle of the gage. This was an instrument landing
with a vengeance! Eight hundred. How was the crew taking it? How many
of them had Tworn had to disable? He glanced quickly around. None! Now
that they could not see the hallucinatory images upon the plates, they
were not suffering at all–he himself was the only one aboard who was
feeling the strain!

Nine hundred … nine hundred forty. The boat “hit the drink” with a
crashing, splashing impact. Its pace was slow enough, however, and the
liquid was deep enough, so that no damage was done. Samms applied a
little driving power and swung his craft’s sharp nose into the line
toward the sun. The little ship plowed slowly forward, as nearly just
awash as Samms could keep her; grounded as gently as a river steam-boat
upon a mud-flat. The starkly incredible downpour slackened; the Lensman
knew that the second critical moment was at hand.

“Strap down, men, until we see what this wind is going to do to us.”

The atmosphere, moving at a velocity well above that of sound, was in
effect not a gas, but a solid. Even a spaceboat’s hard skin of alloy
plate, with all its bracing, could not take what was coming next.
Inert, she would be split open, smashed, flattened out, and twisted
into pretzels. Samms’ finger stabbed down; the Berg went into action;
the lifeboat went free just as that raging blast of quasi-solid vapor
wrenched her into the air.

The second descent was much faster and much easier than the first. Nor,
this time, did Samms remain surfaced or drive toward shore. Knowing now
that this ocean was not deep enough to harm his vessel, he let her sink
to the bottom. More, he turned her on her side and drove her at a flat
angle into the bottom; so deep that the rim of her starboard lock was
flush with the ocean’s floor. Again they waited; and this time the wind
did not blow the lifeboat away.

Upon purely theoretical grounds Samms had reasoned that the weird
distortion of vision must be a function of distance, and his
observations so far had been in accord with that hypothesis. Now,
slowly and cautiously, he sent out a visibeam. Ten feet … twenty …
forty … all clear. At fifty the seeing was definitely bad; at sixty
it became impossible. He shortened back to forty and began to study the
vegetation, growing with such fantastic speed that the leaves, pressed
flat to the ground by the gale and anchored there by heavy rootlets,
were already inches long. There was also what seemed to be animal life,
of sorts, but Samms was not, at the moment, interested in Trenconian

“Are them the plants we’re going to get, boss?” Tworn asked, staring
into the plate over Samms’ shoulder. “Shall we go out now an’ start
pickin’ ’em?”

“Not yet. Even if we could open the port the blast would wreck us.
Also, it would shear your head off, flush with the coaming, as fast
as you stuck it out. This wind should ease off after a while; well go
out a little before noon. In the meantime we’ll get ready. Have the
boys break out a couple of spare Number Twelve struts, some clamps and
chain, four snatch blocks, and a hundred feet of heavy space-line….

“Good,” he went on, when the order had been obeyed. “Rig the line from
the winch through snatch blocks here, and here, and here, so I can haul
you back against the wind. While you are doing that I’ll rig a remote
control on the winch.”

Shortly before Trenco’s fierce, blue-white sun reached meridian, the
six men donned space-suits and Samms cautiously opened the air-lock
ports. They worked. The wind was now scarcely more than an Earthly
hurricane; the wildly whipping broadleaf plants, struggling upward,
were almost half-way to the vertical. The leaves were apparently almost
fully grown.

Four men clamped their suits to the line. The line was paid out. Each
man selected two leaves; the largest, fattest, purplest ones he could
reach. Samms hauled them back and received the loot; Tworn stowed the
leaves away. Again–again–again.

With noon there came a few minutes of “calm”. A strong man could
stand against the now highly variable wind; could move around without
being blown beyond the horizon; and during those few minutes all six
men gathered leaves. That time, however, was very short. The wind
steadied into the reverse direction with ever-increasing fury; winch
and space-line again came into play. And in a scant half hour, when the
line began to hum an almost musical note under its load, Samms decided
to call it quits.

“That’ll be all for today, boys,” he announced. “About twice more and
this line will part. You’ve done too good a job to lose you. Secure

“Shall I blow the air, sir?” Tworn asked.

“I don’t think so.” Samms thought for a moment. “No. I’m afraid to
take the chance. This stuff, whatever it is, is probably as poisonous
as cyanide. We’ll keep our suits on and exhaust into space.”

Time passed. “Night” came; the rain and the flood. The bottom softened.
Samms blasted the lifeboat out of the mud and away from the planet. He
opened the bleeder valves, then both air-lock ports; the contaminated
air was replaced by the ultra-hard vacuum of the inter-planetary void.
He signaled the Virgin Queen; the lifeboat was taken aboard.

“Quick trip, Olmstead,” Willoughby congratulated him. “I’m surprised
that you got back at all, to say nothing of with so much stuff and not
losing a man. Give me the weight, mister, fast!”

“Three hundred and forty eight pounds, sir,” the super-cargo reported.

“My God! And all pure broadleaf! Nobody ever did that before! How
did you do it, Olmstead?”

“I don’t know whether that would be any of your business or not.”
Samms’ mien was not insulting; merely thoughtful. “Not that I give a
damn, but my way might not help anybody else much, and I think I had
better report to the main office first, and let them do the telling.
Fair enough?”

“Fair enough,” the skipper conceded, ungrudgingly. “What a load! And no

“One boatload of air, is all; but air is expensive out here.” Samms
made a point, deliberately.

“Air!” Willoughby snorted. “I’ll swap you a hundred flasks of air, any
time, for any one of those leaves!” Which was what Samms wanted to know.

Captain Willoughby was smart. He knew that the way to succeed was to
use and then to trample upon his inferiors; to toady to such superiors
as were too strong to be pulled down and thus supplanted. He knew this
Olmstead had what it took to be a big shot. Therefore:

“They told me to keep you in the dark until we got to Trenco,” he more
than half apologized to his Fourth Officer shortly after the Virgin
blasted away from the Trenconian system. “But they didn’t say
anything about afterwards–maybe they figured you wouldn’t be aboard
any more, as usual–but anyway, you can stay right here in the control
room if you want to.”

“Thanks, Skipper, but mightn’t it be just as well,” he jerked his head
inconspicuously toward the other officers, “to play the string out,
this trip? I don’t care where we’re going, and we don’t want anybody
to get any funny ideas.”

“That’d be a lot better, of course–as long as you know that your cards
are all aces, as far as I’m concerned.”

“Thanks, Willoughby. I’ll remember that.”

Samms had not been entirely frank with the private captain. From
the time required to make the trip, he knew to within a few parsecs
Trenco’s distance from Sol. He did not know the direction, since the
distance was so great that he had not been able to recognize any star
or constellation. He did know, however, the course upon which the
vessel then was, and he would know courses and distances from then on.
He was well content.

A couple of uneventful days passed. Samms was again called into the
control room, to see that the ship was approaching a three-sun solar

“This where we’re going to land?” he asked, indifferently.

“We ain’t going to land,” Willoughby told him. “You are going to take
the broadleaf down in your boat, close enough so that you can parachute
it down to where it has to go. Way ’nuff, pilot, go inert and match
intrinsics. Now, Olmstead, watch. You’ve seen systems like this before?”

“No, but I know about them. Those two suns over there are a hell of
a lot bigger and further away than they look, and this one here,
much smaller, is in the Trojan position. Have those big suns got any

“Five or six apiece, they say; all hotter and dryer than the brazen
hinges of hell. This sun here has seven, but Number Two–‘Cavenda’,
they call it–is the only Tellurian planet in the system. The first
thing we look for is a big, diamond-shaped continent … there’s only
one of that shape … there it is, over there. Notice that one end is
bigger than the other–that end is north. Strike a line to split the
continent in two and measure from the north end one-third of the length
of the line. That’s the point we’re diving at now … see that crater?”

“Yes.” The Virgin Queen, although still hundreds of miles up, was
slowing rapidly. “It must be a big one.”

“It’s a good fifty miles across. Go down until you’re dead sure that
the box will land somewhere inside the rim of that crater. Then dump
it. The parachute and the sender are automatic. Understand?”

“Yes, sir; I understand,” and Samms took off.

He was vastly more interested in the stars, however, than in delivering
the broadleaf. The constellation directly beyond Sol from wherever he
was might be recognizable. Its shape would be smaller and more or less
distorted; its smaller stars, brilliant to Earthly eyes only because
of their nearness, would be dimmer, perhaps invisible; the picture
would be further confused by intervening, nearby, brilliant strangers;
but such giants as Canopus and Rigel and Betelgeuse and Deneb would
certainly be highly visible if he could only recognize them. From
Trenco his search had failed; but he was still trying.

There was something vaguely familiar! Sweating with the mental
effort, he blocked out the too-near, too-bright stars and studied
intensively those that were left. A blue-white and a red were most
prominent. Rigel and Betelgeuse? Could that constellation be Orion? The
Belt was very faint, but it was there. Then Sirius ought to be about
there, and Pollux about there; and, at this distance, about equally
bright. They were. Aldebaran would be orange, and about one magnitude
brighter than Pollux; and Capella would be yellow, and half a magnitude
brighter still. There they were! Not too close to where they should be,
but close enough–it was Orion! And this thionite way-station, then,
was somewhere near right ascension seventeen hours and declination plus
ten degrees!

He returned to the Virgin Queen. She blasted off. Samms asked very
few questions and Willoughby volunteered very little information;
nevertheless the First Lensman learned more than anyone of his fellow
pirates would have believed possible. Aloof, taciturn, disinterested to
a degree, he seemed to spend practically all of his time in his cabin
when he was not actually at work; but he kept his eyes and his ears
wide open. And Virgil Samms, as has been intimated, had a brain.

The Virgin Queen made a quick flit from Cavenda to Vegia, arriving
exactly on time; a proud, clean space-ship as high above suspicion as
Calpurnia herself. Samms unloaded her cargo; replaced it with one for
Earth. She was serviced. She made a fast, eventless run to Tellus. She
docked at New York Spaceport. Virgil Samms walked unconcernedly into
an ordinary-looking rest-room; George Olmstead, fully informed, walked
unconcernedly out.

As soon as he could, Samms Lensed Northrop and Jack Kinnison.

“We lined up a thousand and one signals, sir,” Northrop reported for
the pair, “but only one of them carried a message, and it didn’t make

“Why not?” Samms asked, sharply. “With a Lens, any kind of a message,
however garbled, coded, or interrupted, makes sense.”

“Oh, we understood what it said,” Jack came in, “but it didn’t say
enough. Just ‘READY–READY–READY’; over and over.”

“What!” Samms exclaimed, and the boys could feel his mind work. “Did
that signal, by any chance, originate anywhere near seventeen hours and
plus ten degrees?”

“Very near. Why? How did you know?”

“Then it does make sense!” Samms exclaimed, and called a general
conference of Lensmen.

“Keep working along these same lines,” Samms directed, finally. “Keep
Ray Olmstead in the Hill in my place. I am going to Pluto, and–I
hope–to Palain Seven.”

Roderick Kinnison of course protested; but, equally of course, his
protests were over-ruled.


Pluto is, on the average, about forty times as far away from the sun
as is Mother Earth. Each square yard of Earth’s surface receives about
sixteen hundred times as much heat as does each of Pluto’s. The sun
as seen from Pluto is a dim, wan speck. Even at perihelion, an event
which occurs only once in two hundred forty eight Tellurian years, and
at noon and on the equator, Pluto is so bitterly cold that climatic
conditions upon its surface simply cannot be described by or to
warm-blooded, oxygen-breathing man.

As good an indication as any can be given, perhaps, by mentioning the
fact that it had taken the Patrol’s best engineers over six months
to perfect the armor which Virgil Samms then wore. For no ordinary
space-suit would do. Space itself is not cold; the only loss of heat is
by radiation into or through an almost perfect vacuum. In contact with
Pluto’s rocky, metallic soil, however, there would be conduction; and
the magnitude of the inevitable heat-loss made the Tellurian scientists

“Watch your feet, Virge!” had been Roderick Kinnison’s insistent last
thought. “Remember those psychologists–if they stayed in contact with
that ground for five minutes they froze their feet to the ankles. Not
that the boys aren’t good, but slipsticks sometimes slip in more ways
than one. If your feet ever start to get cold, drop whatever you’re
doing and drive back here at max!”

Virgil Samms landed. His feet stayed warm. Finally, assured that the
heaters of his suit could carry the load indefinitely, he made his way
on foot into the settlement near which he had come to ground. And there
he saw his first Palainian.

Or, strictly speaking, he saw part of his first Palainian; for no
three-dimensional creature has ever seen or ever will see in entirety
any member of any of the frigid-blooded, poison-breathing races.
Since life as we know it–organic, three-dimensional life–is based
upon liquid water and gaseous oxygen, such life did not and could not
develop upon planets whose temperatures are only a few degrees above
absolute zero. Many, perhaps most, of these ultra-frigid planets have
an atmosphere of sorts; some have no atmosphere at all. Nevertheless,
with or without atmosphere and completely without oxygen and water,
life–highly intelligent life–did develop upon millions and millions
of such worlds. That life is not, however, strictly three-dimensional.
Of necessity, even in the lowest forms, it possesses an extension into
the hyper-dimension; and it is this metabolic extension alone which
makes it possible for life to exist under such extreme conditions.

The extension makes it impossible for any human being to see anything
of a Palainian except the fluid, amorphous, ever-changing thing which
is his three-dimensional aspect of the moment; makes any attempt at
description or portraiture completely futile.

Virgil Samms stared at the Palainian; tried to see what it looked like.
He could not tell whether it had eyes or antennae; legs, arms, or
tentacles, teeth or beaks, talons or claws or feet; skin, scales, or
feathers. It did not even remotely resemble anything that the Lensman
had ever seen, sensed, or imagined. He gave up; sent out an exploring

“I am Virgil Samms, a Tellurian,” he sent out slowly, carefully, after
he made contact with the outer fringes of the creature’s mind. “Is it
possible for you, sir or madam, to give me a moment of your time?”

“Eminently possible, Lensman Samms, since my time is of completely
negligible value.” The monster’s mind flashed into accord with Samms’
with a speed and precision that made him gasp. That is, a part of it
became en rapport with a part of his: years were to pass before even
the First Lensman would know much more about the Palainian than he
learned in that first contact; no human beings except the Children
of the Lens ever were to understand even dimly the labyrinthine
intricacies, the paradoxical complexities, of the Palainian mind.

“‘Madam’ might be approximately correct,” the native’s thought went
smoothly on. “My name, in your symbology, is Twelfth Pilinipsi; by
education, training, and occupation I am a Chief Dexitroboper. I
perceive that you are indeed a native of that hellish Planet Three,
upon which it was assumed for so long that no life could possibly
exist. But communication with your race has been almost impossible
heretofore … Ah, the Lens. A remarkable device, truly. I would slay
you and take it, except for the obvious fact that only you can possess

“What!” Dismay and consternation flooded Samms’ mind. “You already know
the Lens?”

“No. Yours is the first that any of us has perceived. The mechanics,
the mathematics, and the basic philosophy of the thing, however, are
quite clear.”

“What!” Samms exclaimed again. “You can, then, produce Lenses

“By no means, any more than you Tellurians can. There are magnitudes,
variables, determinants, and forces involved which no Palainian will
ever be able to develop, to generate, or to control.”

“I see.” The Lensman pulled himself together. For a First Lensman, he
was making a wretched showing indeed….

“Far from it, sir,” the monstrosity assured him. “Considering the
strangeness of the environment into which you have voluntarily flung
yourself so senselessly, your mind is well integrated and strong.
Otherwise it would have shattered. If our positions were reversed,
the mere thought of the raging heat of your Earth would–come no
closer, please!” The thing vanished; reappeared many yards away. Her
thoughts were a shudder of loathing, of terror, of sheer detestation.
“But to get on. I have been attempting to analyze and to understand
your purpose, without success. That failure is not too surprising, of
course, since my mind is weak and my total power is small. Explain
your mission, please, as simply as you can.”

Weak? Small? In view of the power the monstrosity had just shown,
Samms probed for irony, for sarcasm or pretense. There was no trace of
anything of the kind.

He tried, then, for fifteen solid minutes, to explain the Galactic
Patrol, but at the end the Palainian’s only reaction was one of blank

“I fail completely to perceive the use of, or the need for, such an
organization,” she stated flatly. “This altruism–what good is it? It
is unthinkable that any other race would take any risks or exert any
effort for us, any more than we would for them. Ignore and be ignored,
as you must already know, is the Prime Tenet.”

“But there is a little commerce between our worlds; your people did not
ignore our psychologists; and you are not ignoring me,” Samms pointed

“Oh, none of us is perfect,” Pilinipsi replied, with a mental shrug
and what seemed to be an airy wave of a multi-tentacled member. “That
ideal, like any other, can only be approached asymptotically, never
reached; and I, being somewhat foolish and silly, as well as weak and
vacillant, am much less perfect than most.”

Flabbergasted, Samms tried a new tack. “I might be able to make my
position clearer if I knew you better. I know your name, and that you
are a woman of Palain Seven”–it is a measure of Virgil Samms’ real
size that he actually thought “woman”, and not merely “female”–“but
all I can understand of your occupation is the name you have given it.
What does a Chief Dexitroboper do?”

“She–or he–or, perhaps, it … is a supervisor of the work of
dexitroboping.” The thought, while perfectly clear, was completely
meaningless to Samms, and the Palainian knew it. She tried again.
“Dexitroboping has to do with … nourishment? No–with nutrients.”

“Ah. Farming–agriculture,” Samms thought; but this time it was the
Palainian who could not grasp the concept. “Hunting? Fishing?” No
better. “Show me, then, please.”

She tried; but demonstration, too, was useless; for to Samms the
Palainian’s movements were pointless indeed. The peculiarly flowing
subtly changing thing darted back and forth, rose and fell, appeared
and disappeared; undergoing the while cyclic changes in shape and form
and size, in aspect and texture. It was now spiny, now tentacular, now
scaly, now covered with peculiarly repellent feather-like fronds,
each oozing a crimson slime. But it apparently did not do anything
whatever. The net result of all its activity was, apparently, zero.

“There, it is done.” Pilinipsi’s thought again came clear. “You
observed and understood? You did not. That is strange–baffling. Since
the Lens did improve communication and understanding tremendously, I
hoped that it might extend to the physical as well. But there must be
some basic, fundamental difference, the nature of which is at present
obscure. I wonder … if I had a Lens, too–but no….”

“But yes!” Samms broke in, eagerly. “Why don’t you go to Arisia and be
tested for one? You have a magnificent, a really tremendous mind.
It is of Lensman grade in every respect except one–you simply don’t
want to use it!”

“Me? Go to Arisia?” The thought would have been, in a Tellurian, a
laugh of scorn. “How utterly silly–how abysmally stupid! There would
be personal discomfort, quite possibly personal danger, and two Lenses
would be little or no better than one in resolving differences between
our two continua, which are probably in fact incommensurable.”

“Well, then,” Samms thought, almost viciously, “can you introduce me to
someone who is stupider, sillier, and more foolish than you are?”

“Not here on Pluto, no.” The Palainian took no offense. “That was why
it was I who interviewed the earlier Tellurian visitors and why I am
now conversing with you. The others avoided you.”

“I see.” Samms’ thought was grim. “How about the home planet, then?”

“Ah. Undoubtedly. In fact, there is a group, a club, of such persons.
None of them is, of course, as insane–as aberrant–as you are, but
they are all much more so than I am.”

“Who of this club would be most interested in becoming a Lensman?”

“Tallick was the least stable member of the New-Thought Club when I
left Seven; Kragzex a close second. There may of course have been
changes since then. But I cannot believe that even Tallick–even
Tallick at his outrageous worst–would be crazy enough to join your

“Nevertheless, I must see him myself. Can you and will you give me a
chart of a routing from here to Palain Seven?”

“I can and I will. Nothing you have thought will be of any use to me;
that will be the easiest and quickest way of getting rid of you.” The
Palainian spread a completely detailed chart in Samms’ mind, snapped
the telepathic line, and went unconcernedly about her incomprehensible

Samms, mind reeling, made his way back to his boat and took off.
And as the light-years and the parsecs screamed past, he sank
deeper and deeper into a welter of unproductive speculation. What
were–really–those Palainians? How could they–really–exist as they
seemed to exist? And why had some of that dexitroboper’s–whatever
that meant!–thoughts come in so beautifully sharp and clear and
plain while others…?

He knew that his Lens would receive and would convert into his own
symbology any thought or message, however coded or garbled or however
sent or transmitted. The Lens was not at fault; his symbology was.
There were concepts–things–actualities–occurrences–so foreign to
Tellurian experience that no referents existed. Hence the human mind
lacked the channels, the mechanisms, to grasp them.

He and Roderick Kinnison had glibly discussed the possibility of
encountering forms of intelligent life so alien that humanity would
have no point whatever of contact with them. After what Samms had
just gone through, that was more of a possibility than either he or
his friend had believed; and he hoped grimly, as he considered how
seriously this partial contact with the Palainian had upset him, that
the possibility would never become a fact.

He found the Palainian system easily enough, and Palain Seven. That
planet, of course, was almost as dark upon its sunward side as upon
the other, and its inhabitants had no use for light. Pilinipsi’s
instructions, however, had been minute and exact; hence Samms had
very little trouble in locating the principal city–or, rather, the
principal village, since there were no real cities. He found the
planet’s one spaceport. What a thing to call a port! He checked
back; recalled exactly this part of his interview with Pluto’s Chief

“The place upon which space-ships land,” had been her thought, when she
showed him exactly where it was in relationship to the town. Just that,
and nothing else. It had been his mind, not hers, that had supplied the
docks and cradles, the service cars, the officers, and all the other
things taken for granted in space-fields everywhere as Samms knew them.
Either the Palainian had not perceived the trappings with which Samms
had invested her visualization, or she had not cared enough about his
misapprehension to go to the trouble of correcting it; he did not know

The whole area was as bare as his hand. Except for the pitted,
scarred, slagged-down spots which showed so clearly what driving blasts
would do to such inconceivably cold rock and metal, Palainport was
in no way distinguishable from any other unimproved portion of the
planet’s utterly bleak surface.

There were no signals; he had been told of no landing conventions.
Apparently it was everyone for himself. Wherefore Samms’ tremendous
landing lights blazed out, and with their aid he came safely to ground.
He put on his armour and strode to the air-lock; then changed his
mind and went to the cargo-port instead. He had intended to walk, but
in view of the rugged and deserted field and the completely unknown
terrain between the field and the town, he decided to ride the “creep”

This vehicle, while slow, could go–literally–anywhere. It had a
cigar-shaped body of magnalloy; it had big, soft, tough tires; it
had cleated tracks; it had air- and water-propellers; it had folding
wings; it had driving, braking, and steering jets. It could traverse
the deserts of Mars, the oceans and swamps of Venus, the crevassed
glaciers of Earth, the jagged, frigid surface of an iron asteroid, and
the cratered, fluffy topography of the moon; if not with equal speed,
at least with equal safety.

Samms released the thing and drove it into the cargo lock, noting
mentally that he would have to exhaust the air of that lock into space
before he again broke the inner seal. The ramp slid back into the ship;
the cargo port closed. Here he was!

Should he use his headlights, or not? He did not know the Palainians’
reaction to or attitude toward light. It had not occurred to him
while at Pluto to ask, and it might be important. The landing lights
of his vessel might already have done his cause irreparable harm. He
could drive by starlight if he had to … but he needed light and he
had not seen a single living or moving thing. There was no evidence
that there was a Palainian within miles. While he had known, with his
brain, that Palain would be dark, he had expected to find buildings and
traffic–ground-cars, planes, and at least a few space-ships–and not
this vast nothingness.

If nothing else, there must be a road from Palain’s principal city to
its only spaceport; but Samms had not seen it from his vessel and he
could not see it now. At least, he could not recognize it. Wherefore he
clutched in the tractor drive and took off in a straight line toward
town. The going was more than rough–it was really rugged–but the
creep was built to stand up under punishment and its pilot’s chair
was sprung and cushioned to exactly the same degree. Hence, while the
course itself was infinitely worse than the smoothly paved approaches
to Rigelston, Samms found this trip much less bruising than the other
had been.

Approaching the village, he dimmed his roadlights and slowed down. At
its edge he cut them entirely and inched his way forward by starlight

What a town! Virgil Samms had seen the inhabited places of almost
every planet of Civilization. He had seen cities laid out in circles,
sectors, ellipses, triangles, squares, parallelopipeds–practically
every plan known to geometry. He had seen structures of all shapes
and sizes–narrow skyscrapers, vast-spreading one-stories, polyhedra,
domes, spheres, semi-cylinders, and erect and inverted full and
truncated cones and pyramids. Whatever the plan or the shapes of
the component units, however, those inhabited places had, without
exception, been understandable. But this!

Samms, his eyes now completely dark-accustomed, could see fairly
well, but the more he saw the less he grasped. There was no plan, no
coherence or unity whatever. It was as though a cosmic hand had flung a
few hundreds of buildings, of incredibly and senselessly varied shapes
and sizes and architectures, upon an otherwise empty plain, and as
though each structure had been allowed ever since to remain in whatever
location and attitude it had chanced to fall. Here and there were
jumbled piles of three or more utterly incongruous structures. There
were a few whose arrangement was almost orderly. Here and there were
large, irregularly-shaped areas of bare, untouched ground. There were
no streets–at least, nothing that the man could recognize as such.

Samms headed the creep for one of those open areas, then
stopped–declutched the tracks, set the brakes, and killed the engines.

“Go slow, fellow,” he advised himself then. “Until you find out what
a dexitroboper actually does while working at his trade, don’t take
chances of interfering or of doing damage!”

No Lensman knew–then–that frigid-blooded poison-breathers were not
strictly three-dimensional; but Samms did know that he had actually
seen things which he could not understand. He and Kinnison had
discussed such occurrences calmly enough; but the actuality was enough
to shake even the mind of Civilization’s First Lensman.

He did not need to be any closer, anyway. He had learned the
Palainians’ patterns well enough to Lens them from a vastly greater
distance than his present one; this personal visit to Palainopolis had
been a gesture of friendliness, not a necessity.

“Tallick? Kragzex?” He sent out the questing, querying thought.
“Lensman Virgil Samms of Sol Three calling Tallick and Kragzex of
Palain Seven.”

“Kragzex acknowledging, Virgil Samms,” a thought snapped back, as
diamond-clear, as precise, as Pilinipsi’s had been.

“Is Tallick here, or anywhere on the planet?”

“He is here, but he is emmfozing at the moment. He will join us

Damnation! There it was again! First “dexitroboping”, and now this!

“One moment, please,” Samms requested. “I fail to grasp the meaning of
your thought.”

“So I perceive. The fault is of course mine, in not being able to
attune my mind fully to yours. Do not take this, please, as any
aspersion upon the character or strength of your own mind.”

“Of course not. I am the first Tellurian you have met?”


“I have exchanged thoughts with one other Palainian, and the same
difficulty existed. I can neither understand nor explain it; but it is
as though there are differences between us so fundamental that in some
matters mutual comprehension is in fact impossible.”

“A masterly summation and undoubtedly a true one. This emmfozing,
then–if I read correctly, your race has only two sexes?”

“You read correctly.”

“I cannot understand. There is no close analogy. However, emmfozing has
to do with reproduction.”

“I see,” and Samms saw, not only a frankness brand-new to his
experience, but also a new view of both the powers and the limitations
of his Lens.

It was, by its very nature, of precisionist grade. It received thoughts
and translated them precisely into English. There was some leeway, but
not much. If any thought was such that there was no extremely close
counterpart or referent in English, the Lens would not translate it at
all, but would simply give it a hitherto meaningless symbol–a symbol
which would from that time on be associated, by all Lenses everywhere,
with that one concept and no other. Samms realized then that he might,
some day, learn what a dexitroboper actually did and what the act of
emmfozing actually was; but that he very probably would not.

Tallick joined them then, and Samms again described glowingly, as he
had done so many times before, the Galactic Patrol of his imaginings
and plannings. Kragzex refused to have anything to do with such
a thing, almost as abruptly as Pilinipsi had done, but Tallick
lingered–and wavered.

“It is widely known that I am not entirely sane,” he admitted, “which
may explain the fact that I would very much like to have a Lens. But I
gather, from what you have said, that I would probably not be given a
Lens to use purely for my own selfish purposes?”

“That is my understanding,” Samms agreed.

“I was afraid so.” Tallick’s mien was … “woebegone” is the only word
for it. “I have work to do. Projects, you know, of difficulty, of
extreme complexity and scope, sometimes even approaching danger. A Lens
would be of tremendous use.”

“How?” Samms asked. “If your work is of enough importance to enough
people, Mentor would certainly give you a Lens.”

“This would benefit me; only me. We of Palain, as you probably already
know, are selfish, mean-spirited, small-souled, cowardly, furtive, and
sly. Of what you call ‘bravery’ we have no trace. We attain our ends by
stealth, by indirection, by trickery and deceit.” Ruthlessly the Lens
was giving Virgil Samms the uncompromisingly exact English equivalent
of the Palainian’s every thought. “We operate, when we must operate at
all openly, with the absolutely irreducible minimum of personal risk.
These attitudes and attributes will, I have no doubt, preclude all
possibility of Lensmanship for me and for every member of my race.”

“Not necessarily.”

Not necessarily! Although Virgil Samms did not know it, this was
one of the really critical moments in the coming into being of the
Galactic Patrol. By a conscious, a tremendous effort, the First Lensman
was lifting himself above the narrow, intolerant prejudices of human
experience and was consciously attempting to see the whole through
Mentor’s Arisian mind instead of through his Tellurian own. That
Virgil Samms was the first human being to be born with the ability to
accomplish that feat even partially was one of the reasons why he was
the first wearer of the Lens.

“Not necessarily,” First Lensman Virgil Samms said and meant. He was
inexpressibly shocked–revolted in every human fiber–by what this
unhuman monster had so frankly and callously thought. There were,
however, many things which no human being ever could understand, and
there was not the shadow of a doubt that this Tallick had a really
tremendous mind. “You have said that your mind is feeble. If so, there
is no simple expression of the weakness of mine. I can perceive only
one, the strictly human, facet of the truth. In a broader view it is
distinctly possible that your motivation is at least as ‘noble’ as
mine. And to complete my argument, you work with other Palainians, do
you not, to reach a common goal?”

“At times, yes.”

“Then you can conceive of the desirability of working with
non-Palainian entities toward an end which would benefit both races?”

“Postulating such an end, yes; but I am unable to visualize any such.
Have you any specific project in mind?”

“Not at the moment.” Samms ducked. He had already fired every shot in
his locker. “I am quite certain, however, that if you go to Arisia you
will be informed of several such projects.”

There was a period of silence. Then:

“I believe that I will go to Arisia, at that!” Tallick exclaimed,
brightly. “I will make a deal with your friend Mentor. I will give him
a share–say fifty percent, or forty–of the time and effort I save on
my own projects!”

“Just so you go, Tallick.” Samms concealed right manfully his real
opinion of the Palainian’s scheme. “When can you go? Right now?”

“By no means. I must first finish this project. A year, perhaps–or
more; or possibly less. Who knows?”

Tallick cut communications and Samms frowned. He did not know the
exact length of Seven’s year, but he knew that it was long–very


A small, black scout-ship, commanded jointly by Master Pilot John K.
Kinnison and Master Electronicist Mason M. Northrop, was blasting along
a course very close indeed to RA17: D+10. In equipment and personnel,
however, she was not an ordinary scout. Her control room was so full
of electronics racks and computing machines that there was scarcely
footway in any direction; her graduated circles and vernier scales
were of a size and a fineness usually seen only in the great vessels
of the Galactic Survey. And her crew, instead of the usual twenty-odd
men, numbered only seven–one cook, three engineers, and three watch
officers. For some time the young Third Officer, then at the board,
had been studying something on his plate; comparing it minutely with
the chart clipped into the rack in front of him. Now he turned, with a
highly exaggerated deference, to the two Lensmen.

“Sirs, which of your Magnificences is officially the commander of this
here bucket of odds and ends at the present instant?”

“Him.” Jack used his cigarette as a pointer. “The guy with the
misplaced plucked eyebrow on his upper lip. I don’t come on duty until
sixteen hundred hours–one precious Tellurian minute yet in which to
dream of the beauties of Earth so distant in space and in both past and
future time.”

“Huh? Beauties? Plural? Next time I see a party whose pictures are
cluttering up this whole ship I’ll tell her about your polygamous
ideas. I’ll ignore that crack about my mustache, though, since you
can’t raise one of your own. I’m ignoring you, too–like this, see?”
Ostentatiously turning his back upon the lounging Kinnison, Northrop
stepped carefully over three or four breadboard hookups and stared into
the plate over the watch officer’s shoulder. He then studied the chart.
Was ist los, Stu? I don’t see a thing.”

“More Jack’s line than yours, Mase. This system we’re headed for is a
triple, and the chart says it’s a double. Natural enough, of course.
This whole region is unexplored, so the charts are astronomicals,
not surveys. But that makes us Prime Discoverers, and our Commanding
Officer–and the book says ‘Officer’, not ‘Officers’–has got to….”

“That’s me, now,” Jack announced, striding grandly toward the plate.
“Amscray, oobsbay. I will name the baby. I will report. I will go
down in history….”

“Bounce back, small fry. You weren’t at the time of discovery.”
Northrop placed a huge hand flat against Jack’s face and pushed gently.
“You’ll go down, sure enough–not in history, but from a knock on the
knob–if you try to steal any thunder away from me. And besides,
you’d name it ‘Dimples‘–what a revolting thought!”

“And what would you name it? ‘Virgilia‘, I suppose?”

“Far from it, my boy.” He had intended doing just that, but now he did
not quite dare. “After our project, of course. The planet we’re heading
for will be Zabriska; the suns will be A-, B-, and C-Zabriskae, in
order of size; and the watch officer then on duty, Lieutenant L. Stuart
Rawlings, will engross these and all other pertinent data in the log.
Can you classify ’em from here, Jack?”

“I can make some guesses–close enough, probably, for Discovery work.”
Then, after a few minutes: “Two giants, a blue-white and a bluish
yellow; and a yellow dwarf.”

“Dwarf in the Trojan?”

“That would be my guess, since that is the only place it could stay
very long, but you can’t tell much from one look. I can tell you one
thing, though–unless your Zabriska is in a system straight beyond this
one, it’s got to be a planet of the big fellow himself; and brother,
that sun is hot!”

“It’s got to be here, Jack. I haven’t made that big an error in
reading a beam since I was a sophomore.”

“I’ll buy that … well, we’re close enough, I guess.” Jack killed the
driving blasts, but not the Bergenholm; the inertialess vessel stopped
instantaneously in open space. “Now we’ve got to find out which one of
those twelve or fifteen planets was on our line when that last message
was sent…. There, we’re stable enough, I hope. Open your cameras,
Mase. Pull the first plate in fifteen minutes. That ought to give me
enough track so I can start the job, since we’re at a wide angle to
their ecliptic.”

The work went on for an hour or so. Then:

“Something coming from the direction of Tellus,” the watch officer
reported. “Big and fast. Shall I hail her?”

“Might as well,” but the stranger hailed first.

“Space-ship Chicago, NA2AA, calling. Are you in trouble? Identify
yourself, please.”

“Space-ship NA774J acknowledging. No trouble….”

“Northrop! Jack!” came Virgil Samms’ highly concerned thought. The
superdreadnaught flashed alongside, a bare few hundred miles away, and
stopped. “Why did you stop here?”

“This is where our signal came from, sir.”

“Oh.” A hundred thoughts raced through Samms’ mind, too fast and too
fragmentary to be intelligible. “I see you’re computing. Would it throw
you off too much to go inert and match intrinsics, so that I can join

“No sir; I’ve got everything I need for a while.”

Samms came aboard; three Lensmen studied the chart.

“Cavenda is there,” Samms pointed out. “Trenco is there, off to one
side. I felt sure that your signal originated on Cavenda; but Zabriska,
here, while on almost the same line, is less than half as far from
Tellus.” He did not ask whether the two young Lensmen were sure of
their findings. He knew. “This arouses my curiosity no end–does it
merely complicate the thionite problem, or does it set up an entirely
new problem? Go ahead, boys, with whatever you were going to do next.”

Jack had already determined that the planet they wanted was the second
out; A-Zabriskae Two. He drove the scout as close to the planet as he
could without losing complete coverage; stationed it on the line toward

“Now we wait a bit,” he answered. “According to recent periodicity, not
less than four hours and not more than ten. With the next signal we’ll
nail that transmitter down to within a few feet. Got your spotting
screens full out, Mase?”

Recent periodicity?” Samms snapped. “It has improved, then, lately?”

“Very much, sir.”

“That helps immensely. With George Olmstead harvesting broadleaf, it
would. It is still one problem. While we wait, shall we study the
planet a little?”

They explored; finding that A-Zabriskae Two was a disappointing planet
indeed. It was small, waterless, airless, utterly featureless, utterly
barren. There were no elevations, no depressions, no visible markings
whatever–not even a meteor crater. Every square yard of its surface
was apparently exactly like every other.

“No rotation,” Jack reported, looking up from the bolometer. “That
sand-pile is not inhabited and never will be. I’m beginning to wonder.”

“So am I, now,” Northrop admitted. “I still say that those signals came
from this line and distance, but it looks as though they must have
been sent from a ship. If so, now that we’re here–particularly the
Chicago–there will be no more signals.”

“Not necessarily.” Again Samms’ mind transcended his Tellurian
experience and knowledge. He did not suspect the truth, but he was not
jumping at conclusions. “There may be highly intelligent life, even
upon such a planet as this.”

They waited, and in a few hours a communications beam snapped into life.

“READY–READY–READY….” it said briskly, for not quite one minute,
but that was time enough.

Northrop yelped a string of numbers; Jack blasted the little vessel
forward and downward; the three watch officers, keen-eyed at their
plates, stabbed their visibeams, ultra-beams, and spy-rays along the
indicated line.

“And bore straight through the planet if you have to–they may be on
the other side!” Jack cautioned, sharply.

“They aren’t–it’s here, on this side!” Rawlings saw it first. “Nothing
much to it, though … it looks like a relay station.”

“A relay! I’ll be a….” Jack started to express an unexpurgated
opinion, but shut himself up. Young cubs did not swear in front of the
First Lensman. “Let’s land, sir, and look the place over, anyway.”

“By all means.”

They landed, and cautiously disembarked. The horizon, while actually
quite a little closer than that of Earth, seemed much more distant
because there was nothing whatever–no tree, no shrub, no rock or
pebble, not even the slightest ripple–to break the geometrical
perfection of that surface of smooth, hard, blindingly reflective,
fiendishly hot white sand. Samms was highly dubious at first–a
ground-temperature of four hundred seventy-five degrees was not to be
taken lightly; he did not at all like the looks of that ultra-fervent
blue-white sun; and in his wildest imaginings he had never pictured
such a desert. Their space-suits, however, were very well insulated,
particularly as to the feet, and highly polished; and in lieu of
atmosphere there was an almost perfect vacuum. They could stand it for
a while.

The box which housed the relay station was made of non-ferrous metal
and was roughly cubical in shape, perhaps five feet on a side. It was
so buried that its upper edge was flush with the surface; its top,
which was practically indistinguishable from the surrounding sand, was
not bolted or welded, but was simply laid on, loose.

Previous spy-ray inspection having proved that the thing was not
booby-trapped, Jack lifted the cover by one edge and all three Lensmen
studied the mechanisms at close range; learning nothing new. There was
an extremely sensitive non-directional receiver, a highly directional
sender, a beautifully precise uranium-clock director, and an “eternal”
powerpack. There was nothing else.

“What next, sir?” Northrop asked. “There’ll be an incoming signal,
probably, in a couple of days. Shall we stick around and see whether it
comes in from Cavenda or not?”

“You and Jack had better wait, yes.” Samms thought for minutes. “I do
not believe, now, that the signal will come from Cavenda, or that it
will ever come twice from the same direction, but we will have to make
sure. But I can’t see any reason for it!”

“I think I can, sir.” This was Northrop’s specialty. “No space-ship
could possibly hit Tellus from here except by accident with a
single-ended beam, and they can’t use a double-ender because it would
have to be on all the time and would be as easy to trace as the
Mississippi River. But this planet did all its settling ages ago–which
is undoubtedly why they picked it out–and that director in there is a
Marchanti–the second Marchanti I have ever seen.”

“Whatever that is,” Jack put in, and even Samms thought a question.

“The most precise thing ever built,” the specialist explained.
“Accuracy limited only by that of determination of relative motions.
Give me an accurate enough equation to feed into it, like that tape
is doing, and two sighting shots, and I’ll guarantee to pour an
eighteen-inch beam into any two foot cup on Earth. My guess is that
it’s aimed at some particular bucket-antenna on one of the Solar
planets. I could spoil its aim easily enough, but I don’t suppose that
is what you’re after.”

“Decidedly not. We want to trace them, without exciting any more
suspicion than is absolutely necessary. How often, would you say, do
they have to come here to service this station–change tapes, and
whatever else might be necessary?”

“Change tapes, is all. Not very often, by the size of those reels. If
they know the relative motions exactly enough, they could compute as
far ahead as they care to. I’ve been timing that reel–it’s got pretty
close to three months left on it.”

“And more than that much has been used. It’s no wonder we didn’t see
anything.” Samms straightened up and stared out across the frightful
waste. “Look there–I thought I saw something move–it is moving!”

“There’s something moving closer than that, and it’s really funny.”
Jack laughed deeply. “Its like the paddle-wheels, shaft and all, of an
old-fashioned river steam-boat, rolling along as unconcernedly as you
please. He won’t miss me by over four feet, but he isn’t swerving a
hair. I think I’ll block him off, just to see what he does.”

“Be careful, Jack!” Samms cautioned, sharply. “Don’t touch it–it may
be charged, or worse.”

Jack took the metal cover, which he was still holding, and by working
it back and forth edgewise in the sand, made of it a vertical barrier
squarely across the thing’s path. The traveler paid no attention, did
not alter its steady pace of a couple of miles per hour. It measured
about twelve inches long over all; its paddle-wheel-like extremities
were perhaps two inches wide and three inches in diameter.

“Do you think it’s actually alive, sir? In a place like this?”

“I’m sure of it. Watch carefully.”

It struck the barrier and stopped. That is, its forward motion stopped,
but its rolling did not. Its rate of revolution did not change; it
either did not know or did not care that its drivers were slipping
on the smooth, hard sand; that it could not climb the vertical metal
plate; that it was not getting anywhere.

“What a brain!” Northrop chortled, squatting down closer. “Why doesn’t
it back up or turn around? It may be alive, but it certainly isn’t very

The creature, now in the shadow of the ‘Troncist’s helmet, slowed down
abruptly–went limp–collapsed.

“Get out of his light!” Jack snapped, and pushed his friend
violently away; and as the vicious sunlight struck it, the native
revived and began to revolve as vigorously as before. “I’ve got
a hunch. Sounds screwy–never heard of such a thing–but it acts
like an energy-converter. Eats energy, raw and straight. No storage
capacity–on this world he wouldn’t need it–a few more seconds in
the shade would probably have killed him, but there’s no shade here.
Therefore, he can’t be dangerous.”

He reached out and touched the middle of the revolving shaft. Nothing
happened. He turned it at right angles to the plate. The thing rolled
away in a straight line, perfectly contented with the new direction. He
recaptured it and stuck a test-prod lightly into the sand, just ahead
of its shaft and just inside one paddle wheel. Around and around that
slim wire the creature went: unable, it seemed, to escape from even
such a simple trap; perfectly willing, it seemed, to spend all the rest
of its life traversing that tiny circle.

“‘What a brain!’ is right, Mase,” Jack exclaimed. “What a brain!”

“This is wonderful, boys, really wonderful; something completely new to
our science.” Samms’ thought was deep with feeling. “I am going to see
if I can reach its mind or consciousness. Would you like to come along?”

Would we!”

Samms tuned low and probed; lower and lower; deeper and deeper; and
Jack and Mase stayed with him. The thing was certainly alive; it
throbbed and vibrated with vitality: equally certainly, it was not
very intelligent. But it had a definite consciousness of its own
existence; and therefore, however tiny and primitive, a mind. Although
its rudimentary ego could neither receive nor transmit thought, it knew
that it was a fontema, that it must roll and roll and roll, endlessly,
that by virtue of determined rolling its species would continue and
would increase.

“Well, that’s one for the book!” Jack exclaimed, but Samms was

“I would like to find one or two more of them, to find out … I think
I’ll take the time. Can you see any more of them, either of you?”

“No, but we can find some–Stu!” Northrop called.


“Look around, will you? Find us a couple more of these fontema things
and flick them over here with a tractor.”

“Coming up!” and in a few seconds they were there.

“Are you photographing this, Lance?” Samms called the Chief
Communications Officer of the Chicago.

“We certainly are, sir–all of it. What are they, anyway? Animal,
vegetable, or mineral?”

“I don’t know. Probably no one of the three, strictly speaking. I’d
like to take a couple back to Tellus, but I’m afraid that they’d die,
even under an atomic lamp. We’ll report to the Society.”

Jack liberated his captive and aimed it to pass within a few feet of
one of the newcomers, but the two fontemas did not ignore each other.
Both swerved, so that they came together wheel to wheel. The shafts
bent toward each other, each into a right angle. The angles touched and
fused. The point of fusion swelled rapidly into a double fist-sized
lump. The half-shafts doubled in length. The lump split into four;
became four perfect paddle-wheels. Four full-grown fontemas rolled
away from the spot upon which two had met; their courses forming two
mutually perpendicular straight lines.

“Beautiful!” Samms exclaimed. “And notice, boys, the method of avoiding
inbreeding. Upon a perfectly smooth planet such as this, no two of
those four can ever meet, and the chance is almost vanishingly small
that any of their first-generation offspring will ever meet. But I’m
afraid I’ve been wasting time. Take me back out to the Chicago,
please, and I’ll be on my way.”

“You don’t seem at all optimistic, sir,” Jack ventured, as the NA774J
approached the Chicago.

“Unfortunately, I am not. The signal will almost certainly come in
from an unpredictable direction, from a ship so far away that even a
super-fast cruiser could not get close enough to her to detect–just a
minute. Rod!” He Lensed the elder Kinnison so sharply that both young
Lensmen jumped.

“What is it, Virge?”

Samms explained rapidly, concluding: “So I would like to have you throw
a globe of scouts around this whole Zabriskan system. One detet[A] out
and one detet apart, so as to be able to slap a tracer onto any ship
laying a beam to this planet, from any direction whatever. It would not
take too many scouts, would it?”

[Footnote A: Detet–the distance at which one space-ship can detect
another. EES.]

“No; but it wouldn’t be worth while.”

“Why not?”

“Because it wouldn’t prove a thing except what we already know–that
Spaceways is involved in the thionite racket. The ship would be clean.
Merely another relay.”

“Oh. You’re probably right.” If Virgil Samms was in the least put out
at this cavalier dismissal of his idea, he made no sign. He thought
intensely for a couple of minutes. “You are right. I will have to
work from the Cavenda end. How are you coming with Operation Bennett?”

“Nice!” Kinnison enthused. “When you get a couple of days, come over
and see it grow. This is a fine world, Virge–it’ll be ready!”

“I’ll do that.” Samms broke the connection and called Dronvire.

“The only change here is for the worse,” the Rigellian reported,
tersely. “The slight positive correlation between deaths from thionite
and the arrival of Spaceways vessels has disappeared.”

There was no need to elaborate on that bare statement. Both Lensmen
knew what it meant. The enemy, either in anticipation of statistical
analysis or for economic reasons, was rationing his small supply of the

And DalNalten was very much unlike his usual equable self. He was glum
and unhappy; so much so that it took much urging to make him report at

“We have, as you know, put our best operatives to work on the
inter-planetary lines,” he said finally, half sullenly. “We have
secured quite a little data. The accumulating facts, however, point
more and more definitely toward an utterly preposterous conclusion. Can
you think of any valid reason why the exports and imports of thionite
between Tellus and Mars, Mars and Venus, and Venus and Tellus, should
all be exactly equal to each other?”


“Precisely. That is why Knobos and I are not yet ready to present even
a preliminary report.”

Then Jill. “I can’t prove it, any more than I could before, but I’m
pretty sure that Morgan is the Boss. I have drawn every picture I can
think of with Isaacson in the driver’s seat, but none of them fit?” She
paused, questioningly.

“I am already reconciled to adopting that view; at least as a working
hypothesis. Go ahead.”

“The fact seems to be that Morgan has always had all the left-wingers
of the Nationalists under his thumb. Now he and his man Friday,
Representative Flierce, are wooing all the radicals and so-called
liberals on our side of both Senate and House–a new technique for
him–and they’re offering plenty of the right kind of bait. He has the
commentators guessing, but there’s no doubt whatever in my mind that he
is aiming at next Election Day and our Galactic Council.”

“And you and Dronvire are sitting idly by, doing nothing, of course?”

“Of course!” Jill giggled, but sobered quickly. “He’s a smooth,
smooth worker, Dad. We are organizing, of course, and putting out
propaganda of our own, but there’s so pitifully little that we can
actually do–look and listen to this for a minute, and you’ll see
what I mean.”

In her distant room Jill manipulated a reel and flipped a switch. A
plate came to life, showing Morgan’s big, sweating, passionately
earnest face.

“… and who are these Lensmen, anyway?” Morgan’s voice bellowed,
passionate conviction in every syllable. “They are the hired minions
of the classes, stabbers in the back, crooks and scoundrels, TOOLS OF
RUTHLESS WEALTH! They are hirelings of the inter-planetary bankers,
those unspeakable excrescences on the body politic who are still
grinding down into the dirt, under an iron heel, the face of the common
man! In the guise of democracy they are trying to set up the worst, the
most outrageous tyranny that this universe has ever….” Jill snapped
the switch viciously.

“And a lot of people swallow that … that bilge!” she almost
snarled. “If they had the brains of a … of even that Zabriskan
fontema Mase told me about, they wouldn’t, but they do!”

“I know they do. We have known all along that he is a masterly actor;
we now know that he is more than that.”

“Yes, and we’re finding out that no appeal to reason, no psychological
counter-measures, will work. Dronvire and I agree that you’ll have to
arrange matters so that you can do solid months of stumping yourself.

“It may come to that, but there’s a lot of other things to do first.”

Samms broke the connection and thought. He did not consciously try to
exclude the two youths, but his mind was working so fast and in such
a disjointed fashion that they could catch only a few fragments. The
incomprehensible vastness of space–tracing–detection–Cavenda’s one
tiny, fast moving moon–back, and solidly, to DETECTION.

“Mase,” Samms thought then, carefully. “As a specialist in such
things, why is it that the detectors of the smallest scout–lifeboat,
even–have practically the same range as those of the largest liners
and battleships?”

“Noise level and hash, sir, from the atomics.”

“But can’t they be screened out?”

“Not entirely, sir, without blocking reception completely.”

“I see. Suppose, then, that all atomics aboard were to be shut
down; that for the necessary heat and light we use electricity,
from storage or primary batteries or from a generator driven by
an internal-combustion motor or a heat-engine. Could the range of
detection then be increased?”

“Tremendously, sir. My guess is that the limiting factor would then be
the cosmics.”

“I hope you’re right. While you are waiting for the next signal to
come in, you might work out a preliminary design for such a detector.
If, as I anticipate, this Zabriska proves to be a dead end, Operation
Zabriska ends here–becomes a part of Zwilnik–and you two will follow
me at max to Tellus. You, Jack, are very badly needed on Operation
Boskone. You and I, Mase, will make appropriate alterations aboard a
J-class vessel of the Patrol.”


Approaching Cavenda in his dead-black, converted scout-ship,
Virgil Samms cut his drive, killed his atomics, and turned on
his super-powered detectors. For five full detets in every
direction–throughout a spherical volume over ten detets in
diameter–space was void of ships. Some activity was apparent upon the
planet dead ahead, but the First Lensman did not worry about that. The
drug-runners would of course have atomics in their plants, even if
there were no space-ships actually on the planet–which there probably
were. What he did worry about was detection. There would be plenty of
detectors, probably automatic; not only ordinary sub-ethereals, but
electros and radars as well.

He flashed up to within one and a quarter detets, stopped, and
checked again. Space was still empty. Then, after making a series of
observations, he went inert and established an intrinsic velocity
which, he hoped, would be close enough. He again shut off his atomics
and started the sixteen-cylinder Diesel engine which would do its best
to replace them.

That best was none too good, but it would do. Besides driving the
Bergenholm it could furnish enough kilodynes of thrust to produce a
velocity many times greater than any attainable by inert matter. It
used a lot of oxygen per minute, but it would not run for very many
minutes. With her atomics out of action his ship would not register
upon the plates of the long-range detectors universally used. Since she
was nevertheless traveling faster than light, neither electromagnetic
detector-webs nor radar could “see” her. Good enough.

Samms was not the System’s best computer, nor did he have the System’s
finest instruments. His positional error could be corrected easily
enough; but as he drove nearer and nearer to Cavenda, keeping, toward
the last, in line with its one small moon, he wondered more and more as
to how much of an allowance he should make for error in his intrinsic,
which he had set up practically by guess. And there was another
variable, the cut-off. He slowed down to just over one light; but even
at that comparatively slow speed an error of one millisecond at cut-off
meant a displacement of two hundred miles! He switched the spotter into
the Berg’s cut-off circuit, set it for three hundred miles, and waited
tensely at his controls.

The relays clicked, the driving force expired, the vessel went inert.
Samms’ eyes, flashing from instrument to instrument, told him that
matters could have been worse. His intrinsic was neither straight
up, as he had hoped, nor straight down, as he had feared, but almost
exactly half-way between the two–straight out. He discovered that fact
just in time; in another second or two he would have been out beyond
the moon’s protecting bulk and thus detectable from Cavenda. He went
free, flashed back to the opposite boundary of his area of safety, went
inert, and put the full power of the bellowing Diesel to the task of
bucking down his erroneous intrinsic, losing altitude continuously.
Again and again he repeated the maneuver; and thus, grimly and
stubbornly, he fought his ship to ground.

He was very glad to see that the surface of the satellite was rougher,
rockier, ruggeder, and more cratered even than that of Earth’s Luna.
Upon such a terrain as this, it would be next to impossible to spot
even a moving vessel–if it moved carefully.

By a series of short and careful inertialess hops–correcting his
intrinsic velocity after each one by an inert collision with the
ground–he maneuvered his vessel into such a position that Cavenda’s
enormous globe hung directly overhead. Breathing a profoundly deep
breath of relief he killed the big engine, cut in his fully-charged
accumulators, and turned on detector and spy-ray. He would see what he
could see.

His detectors showed that there was only one point of activity on the
whole planet. He located it precisely; then, after cutting his spy-ray
to minimum power, he approached it gingerly, yard by yard. Stopped!
As he had more than half expected, there was a spy-ray block. A big
one, almost two miles in diameter. It would be almost directly beneath
him–or rather, almost straight overhead–in about three hours.

Samms had brought along a telescope, considerably more powerful than
the telescopic visiplate of his scout. Since the surface gravity
of this moon was low–scarcely one-fifth that of Earth–he had no
difficulty in lugging the parts out of the ship or in setting the thing

But even the telescope did not do much good. The moon was close
to Cavenda, as astronomical distances go–but really worth-while
astronomical optical instruments simply are not portable. Thus the
Lensman saw something that, by sufficient stretch of the imagination,
could have been a factory; and, eyes straining at the tantalizing
limit of visibility, he even made himself believe that he saw a
toothpick-shaped object and a darkly circular blob, either of which
could have been the space-ship of the outlaws. He was sure, however, of
two facts. There were no real cities upon Cavenda. There were no modern
spaceports, or even air-fields.

He dismounted the ‘scope, stored it, set his detectors, and waited. He
had to sleep at times, of course; but any ordinary detector rig can
be set to sound off at any change in its status–and Samms’ was no
ordinary rig. Wherefore, when the drug-mongers’ vessel took off, Samms
left Cavenda as unobtrusively as he had approached it, and swung into
that vessel’s line.

Samms’ strategy had been worked out long since. On his Diesel, at a
distance of just over one detet, he would follow the outlaw as fast as
he could; long enough to establish his line. He would then switch to
atomic drive and close up to between one and two detets; then again go
onto Diesel for a check. He would keep this up for as long as might
prove necessary.

As far as any of the Lensmen knew, Spaceways always used regular liners
or freighters in this business, and this scout was much faster than
any such vessel. And even if–highly improbable thought!–the enemy
ship was faster than his own, it would still be within range of those
detectors when it got to wherever it was that it was going. But how
wrong Samms was!

At his first check, instead of being not over two detets away the
quarry was three and a half; at the second the distance was four and a
quarter; at the third, almost exactly five. Scowling, Samms watched the
erstwhile brilliant point of light fade into darkness. That circular
blob that he had almost seen, then, had been the space-ship, but it
had not been a sphere, as he had supposed. Instead, it had been a
tear-drop; sticking, sharp tail down, in the ground. Ultra-fast. This
was the result. But ideas had blown up under him before, they probably
would again. He resumed atomic drive and made arrangements with the
Port Admiral to rendezvous with him and the Chicago at the earliest
possible time.

“What is there along that line?” he demanded of the superdreadnaught’s
Chief Pilot, even before junction had been made.

“Nothing, sir, that we know of,” that worthy reported, after studying
his charts.

He boarded the gigantic ship of war, and with Kinnison pored over those
same charts.

“Your best bet is Eridan, I think,” Kinnison concluded finally. “Not
too near your line, but they could very easily figure that a one-day
dogleg would be a good investment. And Spaceways owns it, you know,
from core to planetary limits–the richest uranium mines in existence.
Made to order. Nobody would suspect a uranium ship. How about throwing
a globe around Eridan?”

Samms thought for minutes. “No … not yet, at least. We don’t know
enough yet.”

“I know it–that’s why it looks to me like a good time and place
to learn something,” Kinnison argued. “We know–almost know, at
least–that a super-fast ship, carrying thionite, has just landed
there. This is the hottest lead we’ve had. I say englobe the planet,
declare martial law, and not let anything in or out until we find it.
Somebody there must know something, a lot more than we do. I say hunt
him out and make him talk.”

“You’re just popping off, Rod. You know as well as I do that nabbing a
few of the small fry isn’t enough. We can’t move openly until we can
strike high.”

“I suppose not,” Kinnison grumbled. “But we know so damned little,

“Little enough,” Samms agreed. “Of the three main divisions, only
the political aspect is at all clear. In the drug division, we know
where thionite comes from and where it is processed, and Eridan
may be–probably is–another link. On the other end, we know a lot
of peddlers and a few middlemen–nobody higher. We have no actual
knowledge whatever as to who the higher-ups are or how they work; and
it’s the bosses we want. Concerning the pirates, we know even less.
‘Murgatroyd’ may be no more a man’s name than ‘zwilnik’ is….”

“Before you get too far away from the subject, what are you going to do
about Eridan?”

“Nothing, for the moment, would be best, I believe. However, Knobos
and DalNalten should switch their attention from Spaceways’ passenger
liners to the uranium ships from Eridan to all three of the inner
planets. Check?”

“Check. Particularly since it explains so beautifully the
merry-go-round they have been on so long–chasing the same packages of
dope backwards and forwards so many times that the corners of the boxes
got worn round. We’ve got to get the top men, and they’re smart. Which
reminds me–Morgan as Big Boss does not square up with the Morgan that
you and Fairchild smacked down so easily when he tried to investigate
the Hill. A loud-mouthed, chiseling politician might have a lock-box
full of documentary evidence about party bosses and power deals and
chorus girls and Martian tekkyl coats, but the man we’re after very
definitely would not.”

“You’re telling me?” This point was such a sore one that Samms relapsed
into idiom. “The boys should have cracked that box a week ago, but they
struck a knot. I’ll see if they know anything yet. Tune in, Rod. Ray!”
He Lensed a thought at his cousin.

“Yes, Virge?”

“Have you got a spy-ray into that lock-box yet?”

“Glad you called. Yes, last night. Empty. Empty as a sub-deb’s
skull–except for an atomic-powered gimmick that it took Bergenholm’s
whole laboratory almost a week to neutralize.”

“I see. Thanks. Off.” Samms turned to Kinnison. “Well?”

“Nice. A mighty smart operator.” Kinnison gave credit ungrudgingly.
“Now I’ll buy your picture–what a man! But now–and I’ve got my ears
pinned back–what was it you started to say about pirates?”

“Just that we have very little to go on, except for the kind of stuff
they seem to like best, and the fact that even armed escorts have not
been able to protect certain types of shipments of late. The escorts,
too, have disappeared. But with these facts as bases, it seems to me
that we could arrange something, perhaps like this….”

A fast, sleek freighter and a heavy battle-cruiser bored steadily
through the inter-stellar void. The merchantman carried a fabulously
valuable cargo: not bullion or jewels or plate of price, but things
literally above price–machine tools of highest precision, delicate
optical and electrical instruments, fine watches and chronometers. She
also carried First Lensman Virgil Samms.

And aboard the war-ship there was Roderick Kinnison; for the first time
in history a mere battle-cruiser bore a Port Admiral’s flag.

As far as the detectors of those two ships could reach, space was
empty of man-made craft; but the two Lensmen knew that they were not
alone. One and one-half detets away, loafing along at the freighter’s
speed and paralleling her course, in a hemispherical formation open to
the front, there flew six tremendous tear-drops; super-dreadnaughts
of whose existence no Tellurian or Colonial government had even an
inkling. They were the fastest and deadliest craft yet built by
man–the first fruits of Operation Bennett. And they, too, carried
Lensmen–Costigan, Jack Kinnison, Northrop, Dronvire of Rigel Four,
Rodebush, and Cleveland. Nor was there need of detectors: the eight
Lensmen were in as close communication as though they had been standing
in the same room.

“On your toes, men,” came Samms’ quiet thought. “We are about to
pass within a few light-minutes of an uninhabited solar system. No
Tellurian-type planets at all. This may be it. Tune to Kinnison on one
side and to your captains on the other. Take over, Rod.”

At one instant the ether, for one full detet in every direction, was
empty. In the next, three intensely brilliant spots of detection
flashed into being, in line with the dead planet so invitingly close at

This development came as a surprise, since only two raiders had been
expected: a battleship to take care of the escort, a cruiser to take
the merchantman. The fact that the pirates had become cautious or
suspicious and had sent three super-dreadnaughts on the mission,
however, did not operate to change the Patrol’s strategy; for Samms
had concluded, and Dronvire and Bergenholm and Rularion of Jupiter had
agreed, that the real commander of the expedition would be aboard the
vessel that attacked the freighter.

In the next instant, then–each Lensman saw what Roderick Kinnison
saw, in the very instant of his seeing it–six more points of hard,
white light sprang into being upon the plates of guileful freighter and
decoying cruiser.

“Jack and Mase, take the leader!” Kinnison snapped out the thought.
“Dronvire and Costigan, right wing–he’s the one that’s going after the
freighter. Fred and Lyman, left wing. Hipe!”

The pirate ships flashed up, filling ether and sub-ether alike with
a solid mush of interference through which no call for help could be
driven; two super-dreadnaughts against the cruiser, one against the
freighter. The former, of course, had been expected to offer more
than a token resistance. Battle cruisers of the Patrol were powerful
vessels, both on offense and defense, and it was a known and recognized
fact that the men of the Patrol were men. The pirate commander who
attacked the freighter, however, was a surprised pirate indeed. His
first beam, directed well forward, well ahead of the precious cargo,
should have wrought the same havoc against screens and wall-shields and
structure as a white-hot poker would against a pat of luke-warm butter.
Practically the whole nose-section, including the control room, should
have whiffed outward into space in gobbets and streamers of molten and
gaseous metal. But nothing of the sort happened–this merchantman was
no push-over!

No ordinary screens protected that particular freighter and the person
of First Lensman Samms–Roderick Kinnison had very thoroughly seen to
that. In sheer mass her screen generators out-weighed her entire cargo,
heavy as that cargo was, by more than two to one. Thus the pirate’s
beams stormed and struck and clawed and clung–uselessly. They did not
penetrate. And as the surprised attacker shoved his power up and up,
to his absolute ceiling of effort, the only result was to increase
the already tremendous pyrotechnic display of energies cascading in
all directions from the fiercely radiant defenses of the Tellurian

And in a few seconds the commanding officers of the other two attacking
battleships were also surprised. The battle-cruiser’s screens did not
go down, even under the combined top effort of two super-dreadnaughts!
And she did not have a beam hot enough to light a match–she must be
all screen! But before the startled outlaws could do anything about
the realization that they, instead of being the trappers, were in
cold fact the trapped, all three of them were surprised again–the
last surprise that any of them was ever to receive. Six mighty
tear-drops–vastly bigger, faster, more powerful than their own–were
rushing upon them, blanketing all channels of communication as
efficiently and as enthusiastically as they themselves had been doing
an instant before.

Being out simply and ruthlessly to kill, and not to capture, four of
the newcomers from Bennett polished off the cruiser’s two attackers
in very short order. They simply flashed in, went inert at the four
corners of an imaginary tetrahedron, and threw everything they had–and
they had plenty. Possibly–just barely possibly–there may have been,
somewhere, a space-battle shorter than that one; but there certainly
was never one more violent.

Then the four set out after their two sister-ships and the one
remaining pirate, who was frantically devoting his every effort to the
avoidance of engagement. But with six ships, each one of which was of
vastly greater individual power than his own, at the six corners of an
octahedron of which he was the geometrical center, his ability to cut
tractor beams and to “squirt out” from between two opposed pressors did
him no good whatever. He was englobed; or, rather, to apply the correct
terminology to an operation involving so few units, he was “boxed”.

To blow the one remaining raider out of the ether would have been
easy enough, but that was exactly what the Patrolmen did not want
to do. They wanted information. Wherefore each of the Patrol ships
directed a dozen or so beams upon the scintillating protective screens
of the enemy; enough so that every square yard of defensive web was
under direct attack. As rapidly as it could be done without losing
equilibrium or synchronization, the power of each beam was stepped
up until the wildly violet incandescence of the pirate screen showed
that it was hovering on the very edge of failure. Then, in the
instant, needle-beamers went furiously to work. The screen was already
loaded to its limit; no transfer of defensive energy was possible.
Thus, tremendously overloaded locally, locally it flared through the
ultra-violet into the black and went down; and the fiercely penetrant
daggers of pure force stabbed and stabbed and stabbed.

The engine room went first, even though the needlers had to gnaw a
hundred-foot hole straight through the pirate craft in order to find
the vital installations. Then, enough damage done so that spy-rays
could get in, the rest of the work was done with precision and
dispatch. In a matter of seconds the pirate hulk lay helpless, and the
Patrolmen peeled her like an orange–or, rather, more like an amateur
cook very wastefully peeling a potato. Resistless knives of energy
sheared off tail-section and nose-section, top and bottom, port and
starboard sides; then slabbed off the corners of what was left, until
the control room was almost bared to space.

Then, as soon as the intrinsic velocities could possibly be matched,
board and storm! With Dronvire of Rigel Four in the lead, closely
followed by Costigan, Northrop, Kinnison the Younger, and a platoon of
armed and armored Space Marines!

Samms and the two scientists did not belong in such a melee as that
which was to come, and knew it. Kinnison the Elder did not belong,
either, but did not know it. In fact, he cursed fluently and bitterly
at having to stay out–nevertheless, out he stayed.

Dronvire, on the other hand, did not like to fight. The very thought
of actual, bodily, hand-to-hand combat revolted every fiber of his
being. In view of what the spy-ray men were reporting, however, and of
what all the Lensmen knew of pirate psychology, Dronvire had to get
into that control room first, and he had to get there fast. And if
he had to fight, he could; and, physically, he was wonderfully well
equipped for just such activity. To his immense physical strength, the
natural concomitant of a force of gravity more than twice Earth’s,
the armor which so encumbered the Tellurian battlers was a scarcely
noticeable impediment. His sense of perception, which could not be
barred by any material substance, kept him fully informed of every
development in his neighborhood. His literally incredible speed enabled
him not merely to parry a blow aimed at him, but to bash out the brains
of the would-be attacker before that blow could be more than started.
And whereas a human being can swing only one space-axe or fire only two
ray-guns at a time, the Rigellian plunged through space toward what
was left of the pirate vessel, swinging not one or two space-axes, but
four; each held in a lithe and supple, but immensely strong, tentacular

Why axes? Why not Lewistons, or rifles, or pistols? Because the space
armor of that day could withstand almost indefinitely the output of two
or three hand-held projectors; because the resistance of its defensive
fields varied directly as the cube of the velocity of any material
projectile encountering them. Thus, and strangely enough, the advance
of science had forced the re-adoption of that long-extinct weapon.

Most of the pirates had died, of course, during the dismemberment of
their ship. Many more had been picked off by the needle-beam gunners.
In the control room, however, there was a platoon of elite guards,
clustered so closely about the commander and his officers that needles
could not be used; a group that would have to be wiped out by hand.

If the attack had come by way of the only doorway, so that the pirates
could have concentrated their weapons upon one or two Patrolmen, the
commander might have had time enough to do what he was under compulsion
to do. But while the Patrolmen were still in space a plane of force
sheared off the entire side of the room, a tractor beam jerked the
detached wall away, and the attackers floated in en masse.

Weightless combat is not at all like any form of gymnastics known to
us ground-grippers. It is much more difficult to master, and in times
of stress the muscles revert involuntarily and embarrassingly to
their wonted gravity-field techniques. Thus the endeavors of most of
the battlers upon both sides, while earnest enough and deadly enough
of intent, were almost comically unproductive of result. In a matter
of seconds frantically-struggling figures were floating from wall to
ceiling to wall to floor; striking wildly, darting backward from the
violence of their own fierce swings.

The Tellurian Lensmen, however, had had more practice and remembered
their lessons better. Jack Kinnison, soaring into the room, grabbed
the first solid thing he could reach; a post. Pulling himself down to
the floor, he braced both feet, sighted past the nearest foeman, swung
his axe, and gave a tremendous shove. Such was his timing that in the
instant of maximum effort the beak of his atrociously effective weapon
encountered the pirate’s helmet–and that was that. He wrenched his axe
free and shoved the corpse away in such a direction that the reaction
would send him against a wall at the floor line, in position to repeat
the maneuver.

Since Mason Northrop was heavier and stronger than his friend, his
technique was markedly different. He dove for the chart-table, which
of course was welded to the floor. He hooked one steel-shod foot
around one of the table’s legs and braced the other against its top.
Weightless but inert, it made no difference whether his position was
vertical or horizontal or anywhere between; from this point of vantage,
with his length of body and arm and axe, he could cover a lot of room.
He reached out, hooked bill of axe into belt or line-snap or angle of
armor, and pulled; and as the helplessly raging pirate floated past
him, he swung and struck. And that, too, was that.

Dronvire of Rigel Four did not rush to the attack. He had never
been and was not now either excited or angry. Indeed, it was only
empirically that he knew what anger and excitement were. He had
never been in any kind of a fight. Therefore he paused for a couple
of seconds to analyze the situation and to determine his own most
efficient method of operation. He would not have to be in physical
contact with the pirate captain to go to work on his mind, but he would
have to be closer than this and he would have to be free from physical
attack while he concentrated. He perceived what Kinnison and Costigan
and Northrop were doing, and knew why each was working in a different
fashion. He applied that knowledge to his own mass, to his own
musculature, to the length and strength of his arms–each one of which
was twice as long and ten times as strong as the trunk of an elephant.
He computed forces and leverages, actions and reactions, points of
application, stresses and strains.

He threw away two of his axes. The two empty arms reached out, each
curling around the neck of a pirate. Two axes flashed, grazing each
pinioning arm so nearly that it seemed incredible that the sharp
edges did not shear away the Rigellian’s own armor. Two heads floated
away from two bodies and Dronvire reached for two more. And two–and
two–and two. Calm and dispassionate, but not wasting a motion or a
millisecond, Dronvire accomplished more, in less time, than all the
Tellurians in the room.

“Costigan, Northrop, Kinnison–attend!” he launched a thought. “I
have no time to kill more of them. The commander is dying of a
self-inflicted wound and I have important work to do. See to it,
please, that these remaining creatures do not attack me while I am
doing it.”

Dronvire tuned his mind to that of the pirate and probed. Although
dying, the pirate captain offered fierce resistance, but the Rigellian
was not alone. Attuned to his mind, working smoothly with it, giving
it strengths and qualities which no Rigellian ever had had or ever
would have, were the two strongest minds of Earth: that of Rod the
Rock Kinnison, with the driving force, the indomitable will, the
transcendent urge of all human heredity; and that of Virgil Samms, with
all that had made him First Lensman.

“TELL!” that terrific triple mind demanded, with a force which simply
could not be denied. “WHERE ARE YOU FROM? Resistance is useless; yours
or that of those whom you serve. Your bases and powers are smaller and
weaker than ours, since Spaceways is only a corporation and we are the

Under that irresistible urge there appeared, foggily and without any
hint of knowledge of name or of spatial co-ordinates, an embattled
planet, very similar in a smaller way to the Patrol’s own Bennett, and–

Even more foggily, but still not so blurred but that their features
were unmistakeably recognizable, the images of two men. That of
Murgatroyd, the pirate chief, completely strange to both Kinnison and
Samms; and–

Back of Murgatroyd and above him, that of–



“First, about Murgatroyd.” In his office in The Hill Roderick Kinnison
spoke aloud to the First Lensman. “What do you think should be done
about him?”

“Murgatroyd. Hm … m … m.” Samms inhaled a mouthful of smoke
and exhaled it slowly; watched it dissipate in the air. “Ah, yes,
Murgatroyd.” He repeated the performance. “My thought, at the moment,
is to let him alone.”

“Check,” Kinnison said. If Samms was surprised at his friend’s
concurrence he did not show it. “Why? Let’s see if we check on that.”

“Because he does not seem to be of fundamental importance. Even if we
could find him … and by the way, what do you think the chance is of
our spies finding him?”

“Just about the same chance that theirs have of finding out about the
Samms-Olmstead switch or our planet Bennett. Vanishingly small. Zero.”

“Right. And even if we could find him–even find their secret base,
which is certainly as well hidden as ours is–it would do us no present
good, because we could take no positive action. We have, I think,
learned the prime fact; that Towne is actually Murgatroyd’s superior.”

“That’s the way I see it. We can almost draw an organization chart now.”

“I wouldn’t say ‘almost’.” Samms smiled half-ruefully. “There are
gaping holes, and Isaacson is as yet a highly unknown quantity.
I’ve tried to draw one a dozen times, but we haven’t got enough
information. An incorrect chart, you know, would be worse than none
at all. As soon as I can draw a correct one, I’ll show it to you. But
in the meantime, the position of our friend James F. Towne is now
clear. He is actually a Big Shot in both piracy and politics. That fact
surprised me, even though it did clarify the picture tremendously.”

“Me, too. One good thing, we won’t have to hunt for him. You’ve been
working on him right along, though, haven’t you?”

“Yes, but this new relationship throws light on a good many details
which have been obscure. It also tends to strengthen our working
hypothesis as to Isaacson–which we can’t prove yet, of course–that
he is the actual working head of the drug syndicate. Vice-President in
charge of Drugs, so to speak.”

“Huh? That’s a new one on me. I don’t see it.”

“There is very little doubt that at the top there is Morgan. He is,
and has been for some time, the real boss of North America. Under him,
probably taking orders direct, is President Witherspoon.”

“Undoubtedly. The Nationalist party is strictly a la machine, and
Witherspoon is one of the world’s slimiest skinkers. Morgan is Chief
Engineer of the Machine. Take it from there.”

“We know that Boss Jim is also in the top echelon–quite possibly the
Commander-in-Chief–of the enemy’s Armed Forces. By analogy, and since
Isaacson is apparently on the same level as Towne, immediately below

“Wouldn’t there be three? Witherspoon?”

“I doubt it. My present idea is that Witherspoon is at least one level
lower. Comparatively small fry.”

“Could be–I’ll buy it. A nice picture, Virge; and beautifully
symmetrical. His Mightiness Morgan. Secretary of War Towne and
Secretary of Drugs Isaacson; and each of them putting a heavy shoulder
behind the political bandwagon. Very nice. That makes Operation
Mateese tougher than ever–a triple-distilled toughie. Glad I told you
it wasn’t my dish–saves me the trouble of backing out now.”

“Yes, I have noticed how prone you are to duck tough jobs.” Samms
smiled quietly. “However, unless I am even more mistaken than usual,
you will be in it up to your not-so-small ears, my friend, before it is

“Huh? How?” Kinnison demanded.

“That will, I hope, become clear very shortly.” Samms stubbed out the
butt of his cigarette and lit another. “The basic problem can be stated
very simply. How are we going to persuade the sovereign countries of
Earth–particularly the North American Continent–to grant the Galactic
Patrol the tremendous power and authority it will have to have?”

“Nice phrasing, Virge, and studied. Not off the cuff. But aren’t you
over-drawing a bit? Little if any conflict. The Patrol would be pretty
largely inter-systemic in scope … with of course the necessary
inter-planetary and inter-continental … and … um … m….”


“But it’s logical enough, Virge, even at that, and has plenty
of precedents, clear back to ancient history. ‘Way back, before
space-travel, when they first started to use atomic energy, and the
only drugs they had to worry about were cocaine, morphine, heroin, and
other purely Tellurian products. I was reading about it just the other

Kinnison swung around, fingered a book out of a matched set, and
riffled its leaves. “Russia was the world’s problem child then–put up
what they called an iron curtain–wouldn’t play with the neighbors’
children, but picked up her marbles and went home. But yet–here it is.
Original source unknown–some indications point to a report of somebody
named Hoover, sometime in the nineteen forties or fifties, Gregorian
calendar. Listen:

“‘This protocol’–he’s talking about the agreement on world-wide
Narcotics Control–‘was signed by fifty-two nations, including the
U.S.S.R.’–that was Russia–‘and its satellite states. It was the only
international agreement to which the Communist countries’–you know
more about what Communism was, I suppose, than I do.”

“Just that it was another form of dictatorship that didn’t work out.”

“‘… to which the Communist countries ever gave more than lip service.
This adherence is all the more surprising, in view of the political
situation then obtaining, in that all signatory nations obligated
themselves to surrender national sovereignty in five highly significant
respects, as follows:

“‘First, to permit Narcotics agents of all other signatory nations
free, secret, and unregistered entry into, unrestricted travel
throughout, and exit from, all their lands and waters, wherever situate:

“‘Second, upon request, to allow known criminals and known contraband
to enter and to leave their territories without interference:

“‘Third, to cooperate fully, and as a secondary and not as a prime
mover, in any Narcotics Patrol program set up by any other signatory

“‘Fourth, upon request, to maintain complete secrecy concerning any
Narcotics operation: and

“‘Fifth, to keep the Central Narcotics Authority fully and continuously
informed upon all matters hereinbefore specified.’

“And apparently, Virge, it worked. If they could do that, ‘way back
then, we certainly should be able to make the Patrol work now.”

“You talk as though the situations were comparable. They aren’t.
Instead of giving up an insignificant fraction of their national
sovereignty, all nations will have to give up practically all of it.
They will have to change their thinking from a National to a Galactic
viewpoint; will have to become units in a Galactic Civilization, just
as counties used to be units of states, and states are units of the
continents. The Galactic Patrol will not be able to stop at being the
supreme and only authority in inter-systemic affairs. It is bound
to become intra-systemic, intra-planetary, and intra-continental.
Eventually, it must and it shall be the sole authority, except for
such purely local organizations as city police.”

What a program!” Kinnison thought silently for minutes. “But I’m
still betting that you can bring it off.”

“We’ll keep on driving until we do. What gives us our chance is that
the all-Lensman Solarian Council is already in existence and is
functioning smoothly; and that the government of North America has no
jurisdiction beyond the boundaries of its continent. Thus, and even
though Morgan has extra-legal powers both as Boss of North America
and as the head of an organization which is in fact inter-systemic in
scope, he can do nothing whatever about the fact that the Solarian
Council has been enlarged into the Galactic Council. As a matter of
fact, he was and is very much in favor of that particular move–just as
much so as we are.”

“You’re going too fast for me. How do you figure that?”

“Unlike our idea of the Patrol as a coordinator of free and independent
races, Morgan sees it as the perfect instrument of a Galactic
dictatorship, thus: North America is the most powerful continent of
Earth. The other continents will follow her lead–or else. Tellus can
very easily dominate the other Solarian planets, and the Solar System
can maintain dominance over all other systems as they are discovered
and colonized. Therefore, whoever controls the North American Continent
controls all space.”

“I see. Could be, at that. Throw the Lensmen out, put his own stooges
in. Wonder how he’ll go about it? A tour de force? No. The next
election, would be my guess. If so, that will be the most important
election in history.”

“If they decide to wait for the election, yes. I’m not as sure as you
seem to be that they will not act sooner.”

“They can’t,” Kinnison declared. “Name me one thing they think they can
do, and I’ll shoot it fuller of holes than a target.”

“They can, and I am very much afraid that they will,” Samms replied,
soberly. “At any time he cares to do so, Morgan–through the North
American Government, of course–can abrogate the treaty and name his
own Council.”

“Without my boys–the backbone and the guts of North America, as well
as of the Patrol? Don’t be stupid, Virge. They’re loyal.”

“Admitted–but at the same time they are being paid in North American
currency. Of course, we will soon have our own Galactic credit system
worked out, but….”

“What the hell difference would that make?” Kinnison wanted savagely
to know. “You think they’d last until the next pay-day if they start
playing that kind of ball? What in hell do you think I’d be doing?
And Clayton and Schweikert and the rest of the gang? Sitting on our fat
rumps and crying into our beers?”

“You would do nothing. I could not permit any illegal….”

“Permit!” Kinnison blazed, leaping to his feet. “Permit–hell! Are
you loose-screwed enough to actually think I would ask or need your
permission? Listen, Samms!” The Port Admiral’s voice took on a quality
like nothing his friend had ever before heard. “The first thing I
would do would be to take off your Lens, wrap you up–especially your
mouth–in seventeen yards of three-inch adhesive tape, and heave you
into the brig. The second would be to call out everything we’ve got,
including every half-built ship on Bennett able to fly, and declare
martial law. The third would be a series of summary executions,
starting with Morgan and working down. And if he’s got any fraction of
the brain I credit him with, Morgan knows damned well exactly what
would happen.”

“Oh.” Samms, while very much taken aback, was thrilled to the center of
his being. “I had not considered anything so drastic, but you probably

“Not ‘probably’,” Kinnison corrected him grimly. “‘Certainly’.”

“… and Morgan does know … except about Bennett, of course … and
he would not, for obvious reasons, bring in his secret armed forces.
You’re right, Rod, it will be the election.”

“Definitely; and it’s plain enough what their basic strategy will
be.” Kinnison, completely mollified, sat down and lit another cigar.
“His Nationalist party is now in power, but it was our Cosmocrats
of the previous administration who so basely slipped one over on
the dear pee-pul–who betrayed the entire North American Continent
into the claws of rapacious wealth, no less–by ratifying that
unlawful, unhallowed, unconstitutional, and so on, treaty. Scoundrels!
Bribe-takers! Betrayers of a sacred trust! How Rabble-Rouser Morgan
will thump the tub on that theme–he’ll make the welkin ring as it
never rang before.”

Kinnison mimicked savagely the demagogue’s round and purple tones as he
went on: “‘Since they had no mandate from the pee-pul to trade their
birthright for a mess of pottage that nefarious and underhanded treaty
is, a prima vista and ipso facto and a priori, completely and
necessarily and positively null and void. People of Earth, arouse!
Arise! Rise in your might and throw off this stultifying and degrading,
this paralyzing yoke of the Monied Powers–throw out this dictatorial,
autocratic, wealth-directed, illegal, monstrous Council of so-called
Lensmen! Rise in your might at the polls! Elect a Council of your own
choosing–not of Lensmen, but of ordinary folks like you and me. Throw
off this hellish yoke, I say!’–and here he begins to positively
froth at the mouth–‘so that government of the people, by the people,
and for the people shall not perish from the Earth!’

“He has used that exact peroration, ancient as it is, so many times
that practically everybody thinks he originated it; and it’s always
good for so many decibels of applause that he’ll keep on using it

“Your analysis is vivid, cogent, and factual, Rod–but the situation is
not at all funny.”

“Did I act as though I thought it was? If so, I’m a damned poor actor.
I’d like to kick the bloodsucking leech all the way from here to the
Great Nebula in Andromeda, and if I ever get the chance I’m going to!”

“An interesting, but somewhat irrelevant idea.” Samms smiled at his
friend’s passionate outburst. “But go on. I agree with you in principle
so far, and your viewpoint is–to say the least–refreshing.”

“Well, Morgan will have so hypnotized most of the dear pee-pul that
they will think it their own idea when he re-nominates this spineless
nincompoop Witherspoon for another term as President of North America,
with a solid machine-made slate of hatchet-men behind him. They win the
election. Then the government of the North American Continent–not the
Morgan-Towne-Isaacson machine, but all nice and legal and by mandate
and in strict accordance with the party platform–abrogates the treaty
and names its own Council. And right then, my friend, the boys and I
will do our stuff.”

“Except that, in such a case, you wouldn’t. Think it over, Rod.”

“Why not?” Kinnison demanded, in a voice which, however, did not carry
much conviction.

“Because we would be in the wrong; and we are even less able to go
against united public opinion than is the Morgan crowd.”

“We’d do something–I’ve got it!” Kinnison banged the desk with his
fist. “That would be a strictly unilateral action. North America would
be standing alone.”

“Of course.”

“So we’ll pull all the Cosmocrats and all of our friends out of North
America–move them to Bennett or somewhere–and make Morgan and Company
a present of it. We won’t declare martial law or kill anybody, unless
they decide to call in their reserves. We’ll merely isolate the whole
damned continent–throw a screen around it and over it that a microbe
won’t be able to get through–one that would make that iron curtain I
read about look like a bride’s veil–and we’ll keep them isolated
until they beg to join up on our terms. Strictly legal, and the perfect
solution. How about me giving the boys a briefing on it, right now?”

“Not yet.” Samms’ mien, however, lightened markedly. “I never thought
of that way out…. It could be done, and it would probably work, but
I would not recommend it except as an ultimately last resort. It has at
least two tremendous drawbacks.”

“I know it, but….”

“It would wreck North America as no nation has ever been wrecked; quite
possibly beyond recovery. Furthermore, how many people, including
yourself and your children, would like to renounce their North American
citizenship and remove themselves, permanently and irrevocably, from
North American soil?”

“Um … m … m. Put that away, it doesn’t sound so good, does it? But
what the hell else can we do?”

“Just what we have been planning on doing. We must win the election.”

“Huh?” Kinnison’s mouth almost fell open. “You say it easy. How? With
whom? By what stretch of the imagination do you figure that you can
find anybody with a loose enough mouth to out-lie and out-promise
Morgan? And can you duplicate his machine?”

“We can not only duplicate his machine; we can better it. The truth,
presented to the people in language they can understand and appreciate,
by a man whom they like, admire, and respect, will be more attractive
than Morgan’s promises. The same truth will dispose of Morgan’s lies.”

“Well, go on. You’ve answered my questions, after a fashion, except the
stinger. Does the Council think it’s got a man with enough dynage to
lift the load?”

“Unanimously. They also agreed unanimously that we have only one.
Haven’t you any idea who he is?”

“Not a glimmering of one.” Kinnison frowned in thought, then his
face cleared into a broad grin and he yelled: “What a damn fool I
am–you, of course!”

“Wrong. I was not even seriously considered. It was the concensus that
I could not possibly win. My work has been such as to keep me out of
the public eye. If the man in the street thinks of me at all, he thinks
that I hold myself apart and above him–the ivory tower concept.”

“Could be, at that; but you’ve got my curiosity aroused. How can a man
of that caliber have been kicking around so long without me knowing
anything about him?”

“You do. That’s what I’ve been working around to all afternoon. You.”

“Huh?” Kinnison gasped as though he had received a blow in the solar
plexus. “Me? ME? Hell’s–Brazen–Hinges!”

“Exactly. You.” Silencing Kinnison’s inarticulate protests, Samms went
on: “First, you’ll have no difficulty in talking to an audience as
you’ve just talked to me.”

“Of course not–but did I use any language that would burn out the
transmitters? I don’t remember whether I did or not.”

“I don’t, either. You probably did, but that would be nothing new.
Telenews has never yet cut you off the ether because of it. The point
is this: while you do not realize it, you are a better tub-thumper and
welkin-ringer than Morgan is, when something–such as just now–really
gets you going. And as for a machine, what finer one is possible than
the Patrol? Everybody in it or connected with it will support you to
the hilt–you know that.”

“Why, I … I suppose so … probably they would, yes.”

“Do you know why?”

“Can’t say that I do, unless it’s because I treat them fair, so they do
the same to me.”

“Exactly. I don’t say that everybody likes you, but I don’t know of
anybody who doesn’t respect you. And, most important, everybody–all
over space–knows ‘Rod the Rock’ Kinnison, and why he is called that.”

“But that very ‘man on horseback’ thing may backfire on you, Virge.”

“Perhaps–slightly–but we’re not afraid of that. And finally, you said
you’d like to kick Morgan from here to Andromeda. How would you like to
kick him from Panama City to the North Pole?”

“I said it, and I wasn’t just warming up my jets, either. I’d like it.”
The big Lensman’s nostrils flared, his lips thinned. “By God, Virge, I

“Thanks, Rod.” With no display whatever of the emotion he felt, Samms
skipped deliberately to the matter next in hand. “Now, about Eridan.
Let’s see if they know anything yet.”

The report of Knobos and DalNalten was terse and exact. They had
found–and that finding, so baldly put, could have filled and should
fill a book–that Spaceways’ uranium vessels were, beyond any
reasonable doubt, hauling thionite from Eridan to the planets of
Sol. Spy-rays being useless, they had considered the advisability of
investigating Eridan in person, but had decided against such action.
Eridan was closely held by Uranium, Incorporated. Its population was
one hundred percent Tellurian human. Neither DalNalten nor Knobos could
disguise himself well enough to work there. Either would be caught
promptly, and as promptly shot.

“Thanks, fellows,” Samms said, when it became evident that the brief
report was done. Then, to Kinnison, “That puts it up to Conway
Costigan. And Jack? Or Mase? Or both?”

“Both,” Kinnison decided, “and anybody else they can use.”

“I’ll get them at it.” Samms sent out thoughts. “And now, I wonder what
that daughter of mine is doing? I’m a little worried about her, Rod.
She’s too cocky for her own good–or strength. Some of these days she’s
going to bite off more than she can chew, if she hasn’t already. The
more we learn about Morgan, the less I like the idea of her working on
Herkimer Herkimer Third. I’ve told her so, a dozen times, and why, but
of course it didn’t do any good.”

“It wouldn’t. The only way to develop teeth is to bite with ’em. You
had to. So did I. Our kids have got to, too. We lived through it. So
will they. As for Herky the Third….” He thought for moments, then
went on: “Check. But she’s done a job so far that nobody else could do.
In spite of that fact, if it wasn’t for our Lenses I’d say to pull her,
if you have to heave the insubordinate young jade into the brig. But
with the Lenses, and the way you watch her … to say nothing of Mase
Northrop, and he’s a lot of man … I can’t see her getting in either
very bad or very deep. Can you?”

“No, I can’t.” Samms admitted, but the thoughtful frown did not leave
his face. He Lensed her: finding, as he had supposed, that she was at
a party; dancing, as he had feared, with Senator Morgan’s Number One

“Hi, Dad!” she greeted him gaily, with no slightest change in the
expression of the face turned so engagingly to her partner’s. “I have
the honor of reporting that all instruments are still dead-centering
the green.”

“And have you, by any chance, been paying any attention to what I have
been telling you?”

“Oh, lots,” she assured him. “I’ve collected reams of data. He could
be almost as much of a menace as he thinks he is, in some cases, but I
haven’t begun to slip yet. As I have told you all along, this is just a
game, and we’re both playing it strictly according to the rules.”

“That’s good. Keep it that way, my dear.” Samms signed off and his
daughter returned her full attention–never noticeably absent–to the
handsome secretary.

The evening wore on. Miss Samms danced every dance; occasionally with
one or another of the notables present, but usually with Herkimer
Herkimer Third.

“A drink?” he asked. “A small, cold one?”

“Not so small, and very cold,” she agreed, enthusiastically.

Glass in hand, Herkimer indicated a nearby doorway. “I just heard that
our host has acquired a very old and very fine bronze–a Neptune. We
should run an eye over it, don’t you think?”

“By all means,” she agreed again.

But as they passed through the shadowed portal the man’s head perked
to the right. “There’s something you really ought to see, Jill!” he
exclaimed. “Look!”

She looked. A young woman of her own height and build and with her own
flamboyant hair, identical as to hair-do and as to every fine detail of
dress and of ornamentation, glass in hand, was strolling back into the

Jill started to protest, but could not. In the brief moment of inaction
the beam of a snub-nosed P-gun had played along her spine from hips to
neck. She did not fall–he had given her a very mild jolt–but, rage as
she would, she could neither struggle nor scream. And, after the fact,
she knew.

But he couldn’t–couldn’t possibly! Nevian paralysis-guns were as
outlawed as was Vee Two gas itself! Nevertheless, he had.

And on the instant a woman, dressed in crisp and spotless white and
carrying a hooded cloak, appeared–and Herkimer now wore a beard and
heavy, horn rimmed spectacles. Thus, very shortly, Virgilia Samms
found herself, completely helpless and completely unrecognizable,
walking awkwardly out of the house between a businesslike doctor and a
solicitous nurse.

“Will you need me any more, Doctor Murray?” The woman carefully and
expertly loaded the patient into the rear seat of a car.

“Thank you, no, Miss Childs.” With a sick, cold certainty Jill knew
that this conversation was for the benefit of the doorman and the
hackers, and that it would stand up under any examination. “Mrs.
Harman’s condition is … er … well, nothing at all serious.”

The car moved out into the street and Jill, really frightened for the
first time in her triumphant life, fought down an almost overwhelming
wave of panic. The hood had slipped down over her eyes, blinding her.
She could not move a single voluntary muscle. Nevertheless, she knew
that the car traveled a few blocks–six, she thought–west on Bolton
Street before turning left.

Why didn’t somebody Lens her? Her father wouldn’t, she knew, until
tomorrow. Neither of the Kinnisons would, nor Spud–they never did
except on direct invitation. But Mase would, before he went to bed–or
would he? It was past his bed-time now, and she had been pretty
caustic, only last night, because she was doing a particularly delicate
bit of reading. But he would … he must!

“Mase! Mase! MASE!”

And, eventually, Mase did.

Deep under The Hill, Roderick Kinnison swore fulminantly at the sheer
physical impossibility of getting out of that furiously radiating
mountain in a hurry. At New York Spaceport, however, Mason Northrop and
Jack Kinnison not only could hurry, but did.

“Where are you, Jill?” Northrop demanded presently. “What kind of a car
are you in?”

“Quite near Stanhope Circle.” In communication with her friends at
last, Jill regained a measure of her usual poise. “Within eight or ten
blocks, I’m sure. I’m in a black Wilford sedan, last year’s model. I
didn’t get a chance to see its license plates.”

“That helps a lot!” Jack grunted, savagely. “A ten-block radius covers
a hell of a lot of territory, and half the cars in town are black
Wilford sedans.”

“Shut up, Jack! Go ahead, Jill–tell us all you can, and keep on
sending us anything that will help at all.”

“I kept the right and left turns and distances straight for quite a
while–about twenty blocks–that’s how I know it was Stanhope Circle. I
don’t know how many times he went around the circle, though, or which
way he went when he left it. After leaving the Circle, the traffic was
very light, and here there doesn’t seem to be any traffic at all. That
brings us up to date. You’ll know as well as I do what happens next.”

With Jill, the Lensmen knew that Herkimer drove his car up to the
curb and stopped–parked without backing up. He got out and hauled
the girl’s limp body out of the car, displacing the hood enough to
free one eye. Good! Only one other car was visible; a bright yellow
convertible parked across the street, about half a block ahead. There
was a sign–“NO PARKING ON THIS SIDE 7 TO 10.” The building toward
which he was carrying her was more than three stories high, and had a
number–one, four–if he would only swing her a little bit more, so
that she could see the rest of it–one four-seven-nine!

“Rushton Boulevard, you think, Mase?”

“Could be. Fourteen seventy nine would be on the downtown-traffic side.

Into the building, where two masked men locked and barred the door
behind them. “And keep it locked!” Herkimer ordered. “You know what to
do until I come back down.”

Into an elevator, and up. Through massive double doors into a room,
whose most conspicuous item of furniture was a heavy steel chair,
bolted to the floor. Two masked men got up and placed themselves behind
that chair.

Jill’s strength was coming back fast; but not fast enough. The cloak
was removed. Her ankles were tied firmly, one to each front leg of
the chair. Herkimer threw four turns of rope around her torso and the
chair’s back, took up every inch of slack, and tied a workmanlike knot.
Then, still without a word, he stood back and lighted a cigarette. The
last trace of paralysis disappeared, but the girl’s mad struggles,
futile as they were, were not allowed to continue.

“Put a double hammerlock on her,” Herkimer directed, “but be damned
sure not to break anything at this stage of the game. That comes later.”

Jill, more furiously angry than frightened until now, locked her teeth
to keep from screaming as the pressure went on. She could not bend
forward to relieve the pain; she could not move; she could only grit
her teeth and glare. She was beginning to realize, however, what was
actually in store; that Herkimer Herkimer Third was in fact a monster
whose like she had never known.

He stepped quietly forward, gathered up a handful of fabric, and
heaved. The strapless and backless garment, in no way designed to
withstand such stresses, parted; squarely across at the upper strand
of rope. He puffed his cigarette to a vivid coal–took it in his
fingers–there was an audible hiss and a tiny stink of burning flesh as
the glowing ember was extinguished in the clear, clean skin below the
girl’s left armpit. Jill flinched then, and shrieked desperately, but
her tormentor was viciously unmoved.

“That was just to settle any doubt as to whether or not I mean
business. I’m all done fooling around with you. I want to know two
things. First, everything you know about the Lens; where it comes from,
what it really is, and what it does besides what your press-agents
advertise. Second, what really happened at the Ambassadors’ Ball. Start
talking. The faster you talk, the less you’ll get hurt.”

“You can’t get away with this, Herkimer.” Jill tried desperately to
pull her shattered nerves together. “I’ll be missed–traced….” She
paused, gasping. If she told him that the Lensmen were in full and
continuous communication with her–and if he believed it–he would kill
her right then. She switched instantly to another track. “That double
isn’t good enough to fool anybody who really knows me.”

“She doesn’t have to be.” The man grinned venomously. “Nobody who knows
you will get close enough to her to tell the difference. This wasn’t
done on the spur of the moment, Jill; it was planned–minutely. You
haven’t got the chance of the proverbial celluloid dog in hell.”

“Jill!” Jack Kinnison’s thought stabbed in. “It isn’t
Rushton–fourteen seventy-nine is a two-story. What other streets could
it be?”

“I don’t know….” She was not in very good shape to think.

“Damnation! Got to get hold of somebody who knows the streets. Spud,
grab a hacker at the Circle and I’ll Lens Parker….” Jack’s thought
snapped off as he tuned to a local Lensman.

Jill’s heart sank. She was starkly certain now that the Lensmen could
not find her in time.

“Tighten up a little, Eddie. You, too, Bob.”

“Stop it! Oh, God, STOP IT!” The unbearable agony relaxed a little. She
watched in horrified fascination a second glowing coal approach her
bare right side. “Even if I do talk you’ll kill me anyway. You couldn’t
let me go now.”

“Kill you, my pet? Not if you behave yourself. We’ve got a lot of
planets the Patrol never heard of, and you could keep a man interested
for quite a while, if you really tried. And if you beg hard enough
maybe I’ll let you try. However, I’d get just as much fun out of
killing you as out of the other, so it’s up to you. Not sudden death,
of course. Little things, at first, like we’ve been doing. A few more
touches of warmth here and there–so….

“Scream as much as you please. I enjoy it, and this room is
sound-proof. Once more, boys, about half an inch higher this
time … up … steady … down. We’ll have half an hour or so
of this stuff”–Herkimer knew that to the quivering, sensitive,
highly imaginative girl his words would be practically as punishing
as the atrocious actualities themselves–“then I’ll do things to
your finger-nails and toe-nails, beginning with burning slivers of
double-base flare powder and working up. Then your eyes–or no,
I’ll save them until last, so you can watch a couple of Venerian
slasher-worms work on you, one on each leg, and a Martian digger on
your bare belly.”

Gripping her hair firmly in his left hand, he forced her head back and
down; down almost to her hard-held hands. His right hand, concealing
something which he had not mentioned and which was probably starkly
unmentionable, approached her taut-stretched throat.

“Talk or not, just as you please.” The voice was utterly callous, as
chill as the death she now knew he was so willing to deal. “But listen.
If you elect to talk, tell the truth. You won’t lie twice. I’ll count
to ten. One.”

Jill uttered a gurgling, strangling noise and he lifted her head a

“Can you talk now?”



Helpless, immobile, scared now to a depth of terror she had never
imagined it possible to feel, Jill fought her wrenched and shaken mind
back from insanity’s very edge; managed with a pale tongue to lick
bloodless lips. Pops Kinnison always said a man could die only once,
but he didn’t know … in battle, yes, perhaps … but she had already
died a dozen times–but she’d keep on dying forever before she’d say a
word. But–

“Tell him, Jill!” Northrop’s thought beat at her mind. He, her lover,
was unashamedly frantic; as much with sheer rage as with sympathy for
her physical and mental anguish. “For the nineteenth time I say tell
! We’ve just located you–Hancock Avenue–we’ll be there in two

“Yes, Jill, quit being a damned stubborn jackass and tell him!” Jack
Kinnison’s thought bit deep; but this time, strangely enough, the
girl felt no repugnance at his touch. There was nothing whatever of
the lover; nor of the brother, except of the fraternity of arms. She
belonged. She would come out of this brawl right side up or none of
them would. “Tell the goddam rat the truth!” Jack’s thought drove on.
“It won’t make any difference–he won’t live long enough to pass it on!”

“But I can’t–I won’t!” Jill stormed. “Why, Pops Kinnison would….”

“Not this time I wouldn’t, Jill!” Samms’ thought tried to come in, too,
but the Port Admiral’s vehemence was overwhelming. “No harm–he’s doing
this strictly on his own–if Morgan had had any idea he’d’ve killed him
first. Start talking or I’ll spank you to a rosy blister!”

They were to laugh, later, at the incongruity of that threat, but it
did produce results.

“Nine.” Herkimer grinned wolfishly, in sadistic anticipation.

“Stop it–I’ll tell!” she screamed. “Stop it–take that thing away–I
can’t stand it–I’ll tell!” She burst into racking, tearing sobs.

“Steady.” Herkimer put something in his pocket, then slapped her so
viciously that fingers-long marks sprang into red relief upon the
chalk-white background of her cheek. “Don’t crack up; I haven’t started
to work on you yet. What about that Lens?”

She gulped twice before she could speak. “It comes from–ulp!–Arisia.
I haven’t got one myself, so I don’t know very much–ulp!–about it at
first hand, but from what the boys tell me it must be….”

Outside the building three black forms arrowed downward. Northrop and
young Kinnison stopped at the sixth level; Costigan went on down to
take care of the guards.

“Bullets, not beams,” the Irishman reminded his younger fellows. “We’ll
have to clean up the mess without leaving a trace, so don’t do any more
damage to the property than you absolutely have to.”

Neither made any reply; they were both too busy. The two thugs standing
behind the steel chair, being armed openly, went first; then Jack put a
bullet through Herkimer’s head. But Northrop was not content with that.
He slid the pin to “full automatic” and ten more heavy slugs tore into
the falling body before it struck the floor.

Three quick slashes and the girl was free.



Locked in each other’s arms, straining together, no bystander would
have believed that this was their first kiss. It was plainly–yes,
quite spectacularly–evident, however, that it would not be their last.

Jack, blushing furiously, picked up the cloak and flung it at the
oblivious couple.

“P-s-s-t! P-s-s-t! Jill! Wrap ’em up!” he whispered, urgently. “All
the top brass in space is coming at full emergency blast–there’ll
be scrambled eggs all over the place any second now–Mase! Damn
your thick, hard skull, snap out of it! He’s always frothing at the
mouth about her running around half naked and if he sees her like
this–especially with you–he’ll simply have a litter of lizards!
You’ll get a million black spots and seven hundred years in the clink!
That’s better–‘bye now–I’ll see you up at New York Spaceport.”

Jack Kinnison dashed to the nearest window, threw it open, and dived
headlong out of the building.


The employment office of any concern with personnel running into the
hundreds of thousands is a busy place indeed, even when its plants are
all on Tellus and its working conditions are as nearly ideal as such
things can be made. When that firm’s business is Colonial, however,
and its working conditions are only a couple of degrees removed from
slavery, procurement of personnel is a first-magnitude problem; the
Personnel Department, like Alice in Wonderland, must run as fast
as it can go in order to stay where it is. Thus the “Help Wanted”
advertisements of Uranium, Incorporated covered the planet Earth with
blandishment and guile; and thus for twelve hours of every day and for
seven days of every week the employment offices of Uranium, Inc. were
filled with men–mostly the scum of Earth.

There were, of course, exceptions; one of which strode through the
motley group of waiting men and thrust a card through the “Information”
wicket. He was a chunky-looking individual, appearing shorter than
his actual five feet nine because of a hundred and ninety pounds of
weight–even though every pound was placed exactly where it would do
the most good. He looked–well, slouchy–and his mien was sullen.

“Birkenfeld–by appointment,” he growled through the wicket, in a voice
which could have been pleasantly deep.

The coolly efficient blonde manipulated plugs. “Mr. George W. Jones,
sir, by appointment…. Thank you, sir,” and Mr. Jones was escorted
into Mr. Birkenfeld’s private office.

“Have a chair, please, Mr. … er … Jones.”

“So you know?”

“Yes. It is seldom that a man of your education, training, and
demonstrated ability applies to us for employment of his own
initiative, and a very thorough investigation is indicated.”

“What am I here for, then?” the visitor demanded, truculently. “You
could have turned me down by mail. Everybody else has, since I got out.”

“You are here because we who operate on the frontiers cannot afford
to pass judgment upon a man because of his past, unless that past
precludes the probability of a useful future. Yours does not; and
in some cases, such as yours, we are very deeply interested in the
future.” The official’s eyes drilled deep.

Conway Costigan had never been in the limelight. On the contrary, he
had made inconspicuousness a passion and an art. Even in such scenes of
violence as that which had occurred at the Ambassadors’ Ball he managed
to remain unnoticed. His Lens had never been visible. No one except
Lensmen–and Clio and Jill–knew that he had one; and Lensmen–and
Clio and Jill–did not talk. Although he was calmly certain that this
Birkenfeld was not an ordinary interviewer, he was equally certain that
the investigators of Uranium, Inc. had found out exactly and only what
the Patrol had wanted them to find.

“So?” Jones’ bearing altered subtly, and not because of the penetrant
eyes. “That’s all I want–a chance. I’ll start at the bottom, as far
down as you say.”

“We advertise, and truthfully, that opportunity on Eridan is
unlimited.” Birkenfeld chose his words with care. “In your case,
opportunity will be either absolutely unlimited or zero, depending
entirely upon yourself.”

“I see.” Dumbness had not been included in the fictitious Mr. Jones’
background. “You don’t need to draw a blue-print.”

“You’ll do, I think.” The interviewer nodded in approval.
“Nevertheless, I must make our position entirely clear. If the slip
was–shall we say accidental?–you will go far with us. If you try to
play false, you will not last long and you will not be missed.”

“Fair enough.”

“Your willingness to start at the bottom is commendable, and it is a
fact that those who come up through the ranks make the best executives;
in our line at least. Just how far down are you willing to start?”

“How low do you go?”

“A mucker, I think would be low enough; and, from your build, and
obvious physical strength, the logical job.”


“One who skoufers ore in the mine. Nor can we make any exception in
your case as to the routines of induction and transportation.”

“Of course not.”

“Take this slip to Mr. Calkins, in Room 6217. He will run you through
the mill.”

And that night, in an obscure boarding-house, Mr. George Washington
Jones, after a meticulous Service Special survey in every direction,
reached a large and somewhat grimy hand into a screened receptacle in
his battered suitcase and touched a Lens.

“Clio?” The lovely mother of their wonderful children appeared in his
mind. “Made it, sweetheart, no suspicion at all. No more Lensing for a
while–not too long, I hope–so … so-long, Clio.”

“Take it easy, Spud darling, and be careful.” Her tone was light, but
she could not conceal a stark background of fear. “Oh, I wish I could
go, too!”

“I wish you could, Tootie.” The linked minds flashed back to what the
two had done together in the red opacity of Nevian murk; on Nevia’s
mighty, watery globe–but that kind of thinking would not do. “But the
boys will keep in touch with me and keep you posted. And besides, you
know how hard it is to get a baby-sitter!”

It is strange that the fundamental operations of working metalliferous
veins have changed so little throughout the ages. Or is it? Ores came
into being with the crusts of the planets; they change appreciably only
with the passage of geologic time. Ancient mines, of course, could
not go down very deep or follow a seam very far; there was too much
water and too little air. The steam engine helped, in degree if not in
kind, by removing water and supplying air. Tools improved–from the
simple metal bar through pick and shovel and candle, through drill and
hammer and low explosive and acetylene, through Sullivan slugger and
high explosive and electrics, through skoufer and rotary and burley
and sourceless glow, to the complex gadgetry of today–but what,
fundamentally, is the difference? Men still crawl, snake-like, to where
the metal is. Men still, by dint of sheer brawn, jackass the precious
stuff out to where our vaunted automatics can get hold of it. And men
still die, in horribly unknown fashions and in callously recorded
numbers, in the mines which supply the stuff upon which our vaunted
culture rests.

But to resume the thread of narrative, George Washington Jones went
to Eridan as a common laborer; a mucker. He floated down beside the
skip–a “skip” is a mine elevator–some four thousand eight hundred
feet. He rode an ore-car a horizontal distance of approximately eight
miles to the brilliantly-illuminated cavern which was the Station of
the Twelfth and lowest level. He was assigned to the bunk in which he
would sleep for the next fifteen nights: “Fifteen down and three up,”
ran the standard underground contract.

He walked four hundred yards, yelled “Nothing Down!” and inched his
way up a rise–in many places scarcely wider than his shoulders–to
the stope some three hundred feet above. He reported to the miner who
was to be his immediate boss and bent his back to the skoufer–which,
while not resembling a shovel at all closely, still meant hard physical
labor. He already knew ore–the glossy, sub-metallic, pitchy black
luster of uraninite or pitchblende; the yellows of autunite and
carnotite; the variant and confusing greens of tobernite. No values
went from Jones’ skoufer into the heavily-timbered, steel-braced
waste-pockets of the stope; very little base rock went down the rise.

He became accustomed to the work; got used to breathing the peculiarly
lifeless, dry, oily compressed air. And when, after a few days, his
stentorian “Nothing Down!” called forth a “Nothing but a little
fine stuff!” and a handful of grit and pebbles, he knew that he had
been accepted into the undefined, unwritten, and unofficial, yet
nevertheless intensely actual, fellowship of hard-rock men. He belonged.

He knew that he must abandon his policy of invisibility; and, after
several days of thought, he decided how he would do it. Hence, upon the
first day of his “up” period, he joined his fellows in their descent
upon one of the rawest, noisiest dives of Danapolis. The men were met,
of course, by a bevy of giggling, shrieking, garishly painted and
strongly perfumed girls–and at this point young Jones’ behavior became
exceedingly unorthodox.

“Buy me a drink, mister? And a dance, huh?”

“On your way, sister.” He brushed the importunate wench aside. “I get
enough exercise underground, an’ you ain’t got a thing I want.”

Apparently unaware that the girl was exchanging meaningful glances with
a couple of husky characters labelled “BOUNCER” in billposter type,
the atypical mucker strode up to the long and ornate bar.

“Gimme a bottle of pineapple pop,” he ordered bruskly, “an’ a package
of Tellurian cigarettes–Sunshines.”

“P-p-pine…?” The surprised bartender did not finish the word.

The bouncers were fast, but Costigan was faster. A hard knee took one
in the solar plexus; a hard elbow took the other so savagely under
the chin as to all but break his neck. A bartender started to swing a
bung-starter, and found himself flying through the air toward a table.
Men, table, and drinks crashed to the floor.

“I pick my own company an’ I drink what I damn please,” Jones
announced, grittily. “Them lunkers ain’t hurt none, to speak of …”
His hard eyes swept the room malevolently, “but I ain’t in no gentle
mood an’ the next jaspers that tackle me will wind up in the repair
shop, or maybe in the morgue. See?”

This of course was much too much; a dozen embattled roughnecks leaped
to mop up on the misguided wight who had so impugned the manhood of all
Eridan. Then, while six or seven bartenders blew frantic blasts upon
police whistles, there was a flurry of action too fast to be resolved
into consecutive events by the eye. Conway Costigan, one of the fastest
men with hands and feet the Patrol has ever known, was trying to keep
himself alive; and he succeeded.

“What the hell goes on here?” a chorus of raucously authoritative
voices yelled, and sixteen policemen–John Law did not travel singly in
that district, but in platoons–swinging clubs and saps, finally hauled
George Washington Jones out from the bottom of the pile. He had sundry
abrasions and not a few contusions, but no bones were broken and his
skin was practically whole.

And since his version of the affair was not only inadequate, but
also differed in important particulars from those of several
non-participating witnesses, he spent the rest of his holiday in jail;
a development with which he was quite content.

The work–and time–went on. He became in rapid succession a head
mucker, a miner’s pimp (which short and rugged Anglo-Saxon word means
simply “helper” in underground parlance) a miner, a top-miner, and
then–a long step up the ladder!–a shift-boss.

And then disaster struck; suddenly, paralyzingly, as mine disasters do.
Loud-speakers blared briefly–“Explosion! Cave-in! Flood! Fire! Gas!
Radiation! Damp!”–and expired. Short-circuits; there was no way of
telling which, if any, of those dire warnings were true.

The power failed, and the lights. The hiss of air from valves, a noise
which by its constant and unvarying and universal presence soon becomes
unheard, became noticeable because of its diminution in volume and
tone. And then, seconds later, a jarring, shuddering rumble was felt
and heard, accompanied by the snapping of shattered timbers and the
sharper, utterly unforgettable shriek of rending and riven steel. And
the men, as men do under such conditions, went wild; yelling, swearing,
leaping toward where, in the rayless dark, each thought the rise to be.

It took a couple of seconds for the shift-boss to break out and
hook up his emergency battery-lamp; and three or four more seconds,
and by dint of fists, feet, and a two-foot length of air-hose, to
restore any degree of order. Four men were dead; but that wasn’t too

“Up there! Under the hanging wall!” he ordered, sharply. “That won’t
fall–unless the whole mountain slips. Now, how many of you jaspers
have got your emergency kits on you? Twelve–out of twenty-six–what
brains! Put on your masks. You without ’em can stay up here–you’ll be
safe for a while–I hope.”

Then, presently: “There, that’s all for now. I guess.” He flashed
his light downward. The massive steel members no longer writhed; the
crushed and tortured timbers were still.

“That rise may be open, it goes through solid rock, not waste. I’ll
see. Wright, you’re all in one piece, aren’t you?”

“I guess so–yes.”

“Take charge up here. I’ll go down to the drift. If the rise is open
I’ll give you a flash. Send the ones with masks down, one at a time.
Take a jolly-bar and bash the brains out of anybody who gets panicky

Jones was not as brave as he sounded: mine disasters carry a terror
which is uniquely and peculiarly poignant. Nevertheless he went down
the rise, found it open, and signalled. Then, after issuing brief
orders, he led the way along the dark and silent drift toward the
Station; wondering profanely why the people on duty there had not done
something with the wealth of emergency equipment always ready there.
The party found some cave-ins, but nothing they could not dig through.

The Station was also silent and dark. Jones, flashing his head-lamp
upon the emergency panel, smashed the glass, wrenched the door open,
and pushed buttons. Lights flashed on. Warning signals flared, bellowed
and rang. The rotary air-pump began again its normal subdued,
whickering whirr. But the water-pump! Shuddering, clanking, groaning,
it was threatening to go out any second–but there wasn’t a thing in
the world Jones could do about it–yet.

The Station itself, so buttressed and pillared with alloy steel as
to be little more compressible than an equal volume of solid rock,
was unharmed; but in it nothing lived. Four men and a woman–the
nurse–were stiffly motionless at their posts; apparently the leads to
the Station had been blasted in such fashion that no warning whatever
had been given. And smoke, billowing inward from the main tunnel,
was growing thicker by the minute. Jones punched another button; a
foot-thick barrier of asbestos, tungsten, and vitrified refractory slid
smoothly across the tunnel’s opening. He considered briefly, pityingly,
those who might be outside, but felt no urge to explore. If any lived,
there were buttons on the other side of the fire-door.

The eddying smoke disappeared, the flaring lights winked out, air-horns
and bells relapsed into silence. The shift-boss, now apparently the
Superintendent of the whole Twelfth Level, removed his mask, found the
Station walkie-talkie, and snapped a switch. He spoke, listened, spoke
again then called a list of names–none of which brought any response.

“Wright, and you five others,” picking out miners who could be depended
upon to keep their heads, “take these guns. Shoot if you have to, but
not unless you have to. Have the muckers clear the drift, just enough
to get through. You’ll find a shift-boss, with a crew of nineteen, up
in Stope Sixty. Their rise is blocked. They’ve got light and power
again now, and good air, and they’re working on it, but opening the
rise from the top is a damned slow job. Wright, you throw a chippie
into it from the bottom. You others, work back along the drift, clear
to the last glory hole. Be sure that all the rises are open–check all
the stopes and glory holes–tell everybody you find alive to report to
me here….”

“Aw, what good!” a man shrieked. “We’re all goners anyway–I want
water an’….”

“Shut up, fool!” There was a sound as of fist meeting flesh, the shriek
was stilled. “Plenty of water–tanks full of the stuff.” A grizzled
miner turned to the self-appointed boss and twitched his head–toward
the laboring pump. “Too damn much water too soon, huh?”

“I wouldn’t wonder–but get busy!”

As his now orderly and purposeful men disappeared, Jones picked up his
microphone and changed the setting of a dial.

“On top, somebody,” he said crisply. “On top….”

“Oh, there’s somebody alive down in Twelve, after all!” a girl’s voice
screamed in his ear. “Mr. Clancy! Mr. Edwards!”

“To hell with Clancy, and Edwards, too,” Jones barked. “Gimme the Chief
Engineer and the Head Surveyor, and gimme ’em fast.”

“Clancy speaking, Station Twelve.” If Works Manager Clancy had heard
that pointed remark, and he must have, he ignored it. “Stanley and
Emerson will be here in a moment. In the meantime, who’s calling? I
don’t recognize your voice, and it’s been so long….”

“Jones. Shift-boss, Stope Fifty Nine. I had a little trouble getting
here to the Station.”

“What? Where’s Pennoyer? And Riley? And…?”

“Dead. Everybody. Gas or damp. No warning.”

“Not enough to turn on anything–not even the purifiers?”


“Where were you?”

“Up in the stope.”

“Good God!” That news, to Clancy, was informative enough.

“But to hell with all that. What happened, and where?”

“A skip-load, and then a magazine, of high explosive, right at Station
Seven–it’s right at the main shaft, you know.” Jones did not know,
since he had never been in that part of the mine, but he could see
the picture. “Main shaft filled up to above Seven, and both emergency
shafts blocked. Number One at Six, Number Two at Seven–must have been
a fault–But here’s Chief Engineer Stanley.” The works manager, not too
unwillingly, relinquished the microphone.

A miner came running up and Jones covered his mouth-piece. “How about
the glory holes?”

“Plugged solid, all four of ’em–by the vibro, clear up to Eleven.”

“Thanks.” Then, as soon as Stanley’s voice came on:

“What I want to know is, why is this damned water-pump overloading?
What’s the circuit?”

“You must be … yes, you are pumping against too much head. Five
levels above you are dead, you know, so….”

“Dead? Can’t you raise anybody?”

“Not yet. So you’re pumping through dead boosters on Eleven and Ten and
so on up, and when your overload-relief valve opens….”

Relief valve!” Jones almost screamed, “Can I dog the damn thing

“No, it’s internal.”

“Christ, what a design–I could eat a handful of iron filings and
puke a better emergency pump than that!”

“When it opens,” Stanley went stolidly on, “the water will go through
the by-pass back into the sump. So you’d better rod out one of the
glory holes and….”

“Get conscious, fat-head!” Jones blazed. “What would we use for time?
Get off the air–gimme Emerson!”

“Emerson speaking.”

“Got your maps?”


“We got to run a sag up to Eleven–fast–or drown. Can you give me the
shortest possible distance?”

“Can do.” The Head Surveyor snapped orders. “We’ll have it for you in a
minute. Thank God there was somebody down there with a brain.”

“It doesn’t take super-human intelligence to push buttons.”

“You’d be surprised. Your point on glory holes was very well taken–you
won’t have much time after the pump quits. When the water reaches the

“Curtains. And it’s all done now–running free and easy–recirculating.
Hurry that dope!”

“Here it is now. Start at the highest point of Stope Fifty Nine.

“Stope Fifty-Nine.” Jones waved a furious hand as he shouted the
words; the tight-packed miners turned and ran. The shift-boss followed
them, carrying the walkie-talkie, aiming an exasperated kick of pure
frustration at the merrily-humming water pump as he passed it.

“Thirty two degrees from the vertical–anywhere between thirty and
thirty five.”

“Thirty to thirty five off vertical.”

“Direction–got a compass?”


“Set the blue on zero. Course two hundred seventy five degrees.”

“Blue on zero. Course two seven five.”

“Dex sixty nine point two zero feet. That’ll put you into Eleven’s
class yard–so big you can’t miss it.”

“Distance sixty nine point two–that all? Fine! Maybe we’ll make it,
after all. They’re sinking a shaft, of course. From where?”

“About four miles in on Six. It’ll take time.”

“If we can get up into Eleven we’ll have all the time on the
clock–it’ll take a week or more to flood Twelve’s stopes. But this sag
is sure as hell going to be touch and go. And say, from the throw of
the pump and the volume of the sump, will you give me the best estimate
you can of how much time we’ve got? I want at least an hour, but I’m
afraid I won’t have it.”

“Yes. I’ll call you back.”

The shift-boss elbowed his way through the throng of men and, dragging
the radio behind him, wriggled and floated up the rise.

“Wright!” he bellowed, the echoes resounding deafeningly all up and
down the narrow tube. “You up there ahead of me?”

“Yeah!” that worthy bellowed back.

“More men left than I thought–how many–half of ’em?”

“Just about.”

“Good. Sort out the ones you got up there by trades.” Then, when he
had emerged into the now brilliantly illuminated stope, “Where are the

“Over there.”

“Rustle timbers. Whatever you can find and wherever you find it, grab
it and bring it up here. Get some twelve-inch steel, too, six feet
long. Timbermen, grab that stuff off of the face and start your staging
right here. You muckers, rig a couple of skoufers to throw muck to bury
the base and checkerwork up to the hanging wall. Doze a sluice-way down
into that waste pocket there, so we won’t clog ourselves up. Work fast,
fellows, but make it solid–you know the load it’ll have to carry and
what will happen if it gives.”

They knew. They knew what they had to do and did it; furiously, but
with care and precision.

“How wide a sag you figurin’ on, Supe?” the boss timberman asked.
“Eight foot checkerwork to the hangin’, anyway, huh?”

“Yes. I’ll let you know in a minute.”

The surveyor came in. “Forty one minutes is my best guess.”

“From when?”

“From the time the pump failed.”

“That was four minutes ago–nearer five. And five more before we can
start cutting. Forty one less ten is thirty one. Thirty one into sixty
nine point two goes….”

“Two point two three feet per minute, my slip-stick says.”

“Thanks. Wright, what would you say is the biggest sag we can cut in
this kind of rock at two and a quarter feet a minute?”

“Um … m … m”. The miner scratched his whiskery chin. “That’s a
tough one, boss. You’ll hafta figure damn close to a hundred pounds of
air to the foot on plain cuttin’–that’s two hundred and a quarter.
But without a burley to pimp for ‘er, a rotary can’t take that kind of
air–she’ll foul herself to a standstill before she cuts a foot. An’
with a burley riggin’ she’s got to make damn near a double cut–seven
foot inside figger–so any way you look at it you ain’t goin’ to cut no
two foot to the minute.”

“I was hoping you wouldn’t check my figures, but you do. So we’ll cut
five feet. Saw your timbers accordingly. We’ll hold that burley by

Wright shook his head dubiously. “We don’t want to die down here any
more than you do, boss, so we’ll do our damndest–but how in hell do
you figure you can hold her to her work?”

“Rig a yoke. Cut a stretcher up for canvas and padding. It’ll pound,
but a man can stand almost anything, in short enough shifts, if he’s
got to or die.”

And for a time–two minutes, to be exact, during which the rotary
chewed up and spat out a plug of rock over five feet deep–things went
very well indeed. Two men, instead of the usual three, could run the
rotary; that is, they could tend the complicated pneumatic walking
jacks which not only oscillated the cutting demon in a geometrical
path, but also rammed it against the face with a steadily held and
enormous pressure, even while climbing almost vertically upward under a
burden of over twenty thousand pounds.

An armored hand waved a signal–voice was utterly useless–up! A
valve was flipped; a huge, flat, steel foot arose; a timber slid into
place, creaking and groaning as that big flat foot smashed down.
Up–again! Up–a third time! Eighteen seconds–less than one-third of a
minute–ten inches gained!

And, while it was not easy, two men could hold the burley–in
one-minute shifts. As has been intimated, this machine “pimped” for
the rotary. It waited on it, ministering to its every need with a
singleness of purpose impossible to any except robotic devotion. It
picked the rotary’s teeth, it freed its linkages, it deloused its
ports, it cleared its spillways of compacted debris, it even–and this
is a feat starkly unbelievable to anyone who does not know the hardness
of neocarballoy and the tensile strength of ultra-special steels–it
even changed, while in full operation, the rotary’s diamond-tipped

Both burley and rotary were extremely efficient, but neither was either
quiet or gentle. In their quietest moments they shrieked and groaned
and yelled, producing a volume of sound in which nothing softer than a
cannon-shot could have been heard. But when, in changing the rotary’s
cutting teeth, the burley’s “fingers” were driven into and through the
solid rock–a matter of merest routine to both machines–the resultant
blasts of sound cannot even be imagined, to say nothing of being

And always both machines spewed out torrents of rock, in sizes ranging
from impalpable dust up to chunks as big as a fist.

As the sag lengthened and the checkerwork grew higher, the work began
to slow down. They began to lose the time they had gained. There were
plenty of men, but in that narrow bore there simply was not room for
enough men to work. Even through that storm of dust and hurtling rock
the timbermen could get their blocking up there, but they could not
place it fast enough–there were too many other men in the way. One of
them had to get out. Since one man could not possibly run the rotary,
one man would have to hold the burley.

They tried it, one after another. No soap. It hammered them flat. The
rotary, fouled in every tooth and channel and vent under the terrific
thrust of two hundred thirty pounds of air, merely gnawed and slid.
The timbermen now had room–but nothing to do. And Jones, who had been
biting at his mustache and ignoring the frantic walkie-talkie for
minutes, stared grimly at watch and tape. Three minutes left, and over
eight feet to go.

“Gimme that armor!” he rasped, and climbed the blocks. “Open the air
wide open–give ‘er the whole two-fifty! Get down, Mac–I’ll take it
the rest of the way!”

He put his shoulders to the improvised yoke, braced his feet, and
heaved. The burley, screaming and yelling and clamoring, went joyously
to work–both ways–God, what punishment! The rotary, free and clear,
chewed rock more viciously than ever. An armored hand smote his leg.
Lift! He lifted that foot, set it down two inches higher. The other
one. Four inches. Six. One foot. Two. Three. Lord of the ancients! Was
this lifetime of agony only one minute? Or wasn’t he holding her–had
the damn thing stopped cutting? No, it was still cutting–the rocks
were banging against and bouncing off of his helmet as viciously and
as numerously as ever; he could sense, rather than feel, the furious
fashion in which the relays of timbermen were laboring to keep those
high-stepping jacks in motion.

No, it had been only one minute. Twice that long yet to go. God!
Nothing could be that brutal–a bull elephant couldn’t take it–but
by all the gods of space and all the devils in hell, he’d stay with
it until that sag broke through. And grimly, doggedly, toward the end
nine-tenths unconsciously, Lensman Conway Costigan stayed with it.

And in the stope so far below, a new and highly authoritative voice
blared from the speaker.

“Jones! God damn it, Jones, answer me! If Jones isn’t there, somebody
else answer me–anybody!”

“Yes, sir?” Wright was afraid to answer that peremptory call, but more
afraid not to.

“Jones? This is Clancy.”

“No, sir. Not Jones. Wright, sir–top miner.”

“Where’s Jones?”

“Up in the sag, sir. He’s holding the burley–alone.”

Alone! Hell’s purple fires! Tell him to–how many men has he got on
the rotary?”

“Two, sir. That’s all they’s room for.”

“Tell him to quit it–put somebody else on it–I won’t have him
killed, damn it!”

“He’s the only one strong enough to hold it, sir, but I’ll send up
word.” Word went up via sign language, and came back down. “Beggin’
your pardon, sir, but he says to tell you to go to hell, sir. He won’t
have no time for chit-chat, he says, until this goddam sag is through
or the juice goes off, sir.”

A blast of profanity erupted from the speaker, of such violence
that the thoroughly scared Wright threw the walkie-talkie down the
waste-chute, and in the same instant the rotary crashed through.

Dazed, groggy, barely conscious from his terrific effort, Jones stared
owlishly through the heavy, steel-braced lenses of his helmet while the
timbermen set a few more courses of wood and the rotary walked itself
and the clinging burley up and out of the hole. He climbed stiffly out,
and as he stared at the pillar of light flaring upward from the sag,
his gorge began to rise.

“Wha’s the idea of that damn surveyor lying to us like that?” he
babbled. “We had oodles an’ oodles of time–didn’t have to kill
ourselves–damn water ain’t got there yet–wha’s the big….” He
wobbled weakly, and took one short step, and the lights went out. The
surveyor’s estimate had been impossibly, accidentally close. They had
had a little extra time; but it was measured very easily in seconds.

And Jones, logical to the end in a queerly addled way, stood in
the almost palpable darkness, and wobbled, and thought. If a man
couldn’t see anything with his eyes wide open, he was either blind or
unconscious. He wasn’t blind, therefore he must be unconscious and not
know it. He sighed, wearily and gratefully, and collapsed.

Battery lights were soon reconnected, and everybody knew that they had
holed through. There was no more panic. And, even before the shift-boss
had recovered full consciousness, he was walking down the drift toward
Station Eleven.

There is no need to enlarge upon the rest of that grim and grisly
affair. Level after level was activated; and, since working upward
in mines is vastly faster than working downward, the two parties met
on the Eighth Level. Half of the men who would otherwise have died
were saved, and–much more important from the viewpoint of Uranium,
Inc.–the deeper and richer half of the biggest and richest uranium
mine in existence, instead of being out of production for a year or
more, would be back in full operation in a couple of weeks.

And George Washington Jones, still a trifle shaky from his ordeal, was
called into the front office. But before he arrived:

“I’m going to make him Assistant Works Manager,” Clancy announced.

“I think not.”

“But listen, Mr. Isaacson–please! How do you expect me to build up a
staff if you snatch every good man I find away from me?”

“You didn’t find him. Birkenfeld did. He was here only on a test. He is
going into Department Q.”

Clancy, who had opened his mouth to continue his protests, shut it
wordlessly. He knew that department Q was–



Costigan was not surprised to see the man he had known as Birkenfeld in
Uranium’s ornate conference room. He had not expected, however, to see
Isaacson. He knew, of course, that Spaceways owned Uranium, Inc., and
the planet Eridan, lock, stock, and barrel; but it never entered his
modest mind that his case would be of sufficient importance to warrant
the personal attention of the Big Noise himself. Hence the sight of
that suave and unrevealing face gave the putative Jones a more than
temporary qualm. Isaacson was top-bracket stuff, ‘way out of his class.
Virgil Samms ought to be taking this assignment, but since he wasn’t–

But instead of being an inquisition, the meeting was friendly and
informal from the start. They complimented him upon the soundness of
his judgment and the accuracy of his decisions. They thanked him, both
with words and with a considerable sum of expendable credits. They
encouraged him to talk about himself, but there was nothing whatever
of the star-chamber or of cross-examination. The last question was
representative of the whole conference.

“One other thing, Jones, has me slightly baffled,” Isaacson said, with
a really winning smile. “Since you do not drink, and since you were not
in search of feminine … er … companionship, just why did you go
down to Roaring Jack’s dive?”

“Two reasons,” Jones said, with a somewhat shamefaced grin. “The
minor one isn’t easy to explain, but … well, I hadn’t been having
an exactly easy time of it on Earth … you all know about that, I

They knew.

“Well, I was taking a very dim view of things in general, and a good
fight would get it out of my system. It always does.”

“I see. And the major reason?”

“I knew, of course, that I was on probation. I would have to get
promoted, and fast, or stay sunk forever. To get promoted fast, a man
can either be enough of a boot-licker to be pulled up from on high,
or he can be shoved up by the men he is working with. The best way to
get a crowd of hard-rock men to like you is to lick a few of ’em–off
hours, of course, and according to Hoyle–and the more of ’em you can
lick at once, the better. I’m pretty good at rough-and-tumble brawling,
so I gambled that the cops would step in before I got banged up too
much. I won.”

“I see,” Isaacson said again, in an entirely different tone. He
did see, now. “The first technique is so universally used that the
possibility of the second did not occur to me. Nice work–very
nice.” He turned to the other members of the Board. “This, I believe,
concludes the business of the meeting?”

For some reason or other Isaacson nodded slightly as he asked the
question; and one by one, as though in concurrence, the others nodded
in reply. The meeting broke up. Outside the door, however, the magnate
did not go about his own business nor send Jones about his. Instead:

“I would like to show you, if I may, the above-ground part of our

“My time is yours, sir. I am interested.”

It is unnecessary here to go into the details of a Civilization’s
greatest uranium operation; the storage bins, the grinders, the
Wilfley tables and slime tanks, the flotation sluices, the roasters
and reducers, the processes of solution and crystallization and
recrystallization, of final oxidation and reduction. Suffice it to say
that Isaacson showed Jones the whole immensity of Uranium Works Number
One. The trip ended on the top floor of the towering Administration
Building, in a heavily-screened room containing a desk, a couple of
chairs, and a tremendously massive safe.

“Smoke up.” Isaacson indicated a package of Jones’ favorite brand of
cigarettes and lighted a cigar. “You knew that you were under test. I
wonder, though, if you knew how much of it was testing?”

“All of it.” Jones grinned. “Except for the big blow, of course.”

“Of course.”

“There were too many possibilities, of too many different kinds, too
pat. I might warn you, though–I could have got away clear with that

“The possibility existed.” Surprisingly, Isaacson did not tell him that
the trap was more subtle than it had appeared to be. “It was, however,
worth the risk. Why didn’t you?”

“Because I figure on making more than that, a little later, and I might
live longer to spend it.”

“Sound thinking, my boy–really sound. Now–you noticed, of course, the
vote at the end of the meeting?”

Jones had noticed it; and, although he did not say so, he had been
wondering about it ever since. The older man strolled over to the safe
and opened it, revealing a single, startlingly small package.

“You passed, unanimously; you are now learning what you have to know.
Not that we trust you unreservedly. You will be watched for a long
time, and before you can make one false step, you will die.”

“That would seem to be good business, sir.”

“Glad you look at it that way–we thought you would. You saw the Works.
Quite an operation, don’t you think?”

“Immense, sir. The biggest thing I ever saw.”

“What would you say, then, to the idea of this office being our real
headquarters, of that little package there being our real business?” He
swung the safe door shut, spun the knob.

“It would have been highly surprising a couple of hours ago.” Costigan
could not afford to appear stupid, nor to possess too much knowledge.
He had to steer an extremely difficult middle course. “After the climax
of this build-up, though, it wouldn’t seem at all impossible. Or that
there were wheels–plenty of ’em!–within wheels.”

“Smart!” Isaacson applauded. “And what would you think might be in that
package? This room is ray-proof.”

“Against anything the Galactic Patrol can swing?”


“Well, then, it might be something beginning with the letter” he
flicked two fingers, almost invisibly fast, into a T and went on
without a break “M, as in morphine.”

“Your caution and restraint are commendable. If I had any remaining
doubt as to your ability, it is gone.” He paused, frowning. As belief
in ability increased, that in sincerity lessened. This doubt, this
questioning, existed every time a new executive was initiated into the
mysteries of Department Q. The Board’s judgment was good. They had
slipped only twice, and those two errors had been corrected easily
enough. The fellow had been warned once; that was enough. He took the
plunge. “You will work with the Assistant Works Manager here until
you understand the duties of the position. You will be transferred to
Tellus as Assistant Works Manager there. Your principal duties will,
however, be concerned with Department Q–which you will head up one
day if you make good. And, just incidentally, when you go to Tellus, a
package like that one in the safe will go with you.”

“Oh … I see. I’ll make good, sir.” Jones let Isaacson see his
jaw-muscles tighten in resolve. “It may take a little time for me to
learn my way around, sir, but I’ll learn it.”

“I’m sure you will. And now, to go into greater detail….”

Virgil Samms had to be sure of his facts. More than that, he had to be
able to prove them; not merely to the satisfaction of a law-enforcement
officer, but beyond any reasonable doubt of the hardest-headed member
of a cynical and skeptical jury. Wherefore Jack Kinnison and Mase
Northrop took up the thionite trail at the exact point where, each
trip, George Olmstead had had to abandon it; in the atmosphere of
Cavenda. And fortunately, not too much preparation was required.

Cavenda was, as has been intimated, a primitive world. Its native
people, humanoid in type, had developed a culture approximating in
some respects that of the North American Indian at about the time
of Columbus, in others that of the ancient Nomads of Araby. Thus
a couple of wandering natives, unrecognizable under their dirty
stormproof blankets and their scarcely thinner layers of grease and
grime, watched impassively, incuriously, while a box floated pendant
from its parachute from sky to ground. Mounted upon their uncouth
steeds, they followed that box when it was hauled to the white
man’s village. Unlike many of the other natives, these two did not
shuffle into that village, to lean silently against a rock or a wall
awaiting their turns to exchange a few hours of simple labor for a
container of a new and highly potent beverage. They did, however,
keep themselves constantly and minutely informed as to everything
these strange, devil-ridden white men did. One of these pseudo-natives
wandered off into the wilderness two or three days before the huge
thing-which-flies-without-wings left ground; the other immediately

Thus the departure of the space-ship from Cavenda was recorded, as was
its arrival at Eridan. It had been extremely difficult for the Patrol’s
engineers to devise ways and means of tracing that ship from departure
to arrival without exciting suspicion, but it had not proved impossible.

And Jack Kinnison, lounging idly and elegantly in the concourse
of Danopolis Spaceport, seethed imperceptibly. Having swallowed a
tiny Service Special capsule that morning, he knew that he had been
under continuous spy-ray inspection for over two hours. He had not
given himself away–practically everybody screened their inside coat
pockets and hip pockets, and the cat-whisker lead from Lens to leg
simply could not be seen–but for all the good they were doing him his
ultra-instruments might just as well have been back on Tellus.

“Mase!” he sent, with no change whatever in the vapid expression then
on his face. “I’m still covered. Are you?”

“Covered!” the answering thought was a snort. “They’re covering me like
water covers a submarine!”

“Keep tuned. I’ll call Spud. Spud!”

“Come in, Jack.” Conway Costigan, alone now in the sanctum of
Department Q, did not seem to be busy, but he was.

“That red herring they told us to drag across the trail was too damned
red. They must be touchier than fulminate to spy-work on their armed
forces–neither Mase nor I can do a lick of work. Anybody else covered?”

“No. All clear.”

“Good. Tell them the zwilnik blockers took us out.”

“I’ll do that. Distance only, or is somebody on your tail?”

“Somebody; and I mean some body. A slick chick with a classy
chassis; a blonde, with great, big come-hither eyes. Too good to be
true; especially the falsies. Wiring, my friend–and I haven’t been
able to get a close look, but I wouldn’t wonder if her nostrils had a
skillionth of a whillimeter too much expansion. I want a spy-ray op–is
it safe to use Fred?” Kinnison referred to the grizzled engineer now
puttering about in a certain space-ship; not the one in which he and
Northrop had come to Eridan.

“Definitely not. I can do it myself and still stay very much in
character…. No, I don’t know her. Not surprising, of course, since
the policy here is never to let the right hand know what the left is
doing. How about you, Mase? Have you got a little girl-friend, too?”

“Yea, verily, brother; but not little. More my size.” Northrop pointed
out a tall, trim brunette, strolling along with the effortless,
consciously unconscious poise of the professional model.

“Hm … m … m. I don’t know her, either,” Costigan reported, “but
both of them are wearing four-inch spy-ray blocks and are probably
wired up like Christmas trees. By inference, P-gun proof. I can’t
penetrate, of course, but maybe I can get a viewpoint…. You’re right,
Jack. Nostrils plugged. Anti-thionite, anti-Vee-Two, anti-everything.
In fact, anti-social. I’ll spread their pictures around and see if
anybody knows either of them.”

He did so, and over a hundred of the Patrol’s shrewdest
operatives–upon this occasion North America had invaded Eridan in
force–studied and thought. No one knew the tall brunette, but–

“I know the blonde.” This was Parker of Washington, a Service ace for
twenty five years. “‘Hell-cat Hazel’ DeForce, the hardest-boiled babe
unhung. Watch your step around her; she’s just as handy with a knife
and knock-out drops as she is with a gun.”

“Thanks, Parker. I’ve heard of her.” Costigan was thinking fast.
“Free-lance. No way of telling who she’s working for at the moment.”
This was a statement, not a question.

“Only that it would have to be somebody with a lot of money. Her price
is high. That all?”

“That’s all, fellows.” Then, to Jack and Northrop: “My thought is that
you two guys are completely out-classed–out-weighed, out-numbered,
out-manned, and out-gunned. Undressed, you’re sitting ducks; and if
you put out any screens it’ll crystallize their suspicions and they’ll
grab you right then–or maybe even knock you off. You’d better get out
of here at full blast; you can’t do any more good here, the way things

“Sure we can!” Kinnison protested. “You wanted a diversion, didn’t you?”

“Yes, but you already….”

“What we’ve done already isn’t a patch to what we can do next. We
can set up such a diversion that the boys can walk right on the
thionite-carrier’s heels without anybody paying any attention. By the
way, you don’t know yet who is going to carry it, do you?”

“No. No penetration at all.”

“You soon will, bucko. Watch our smoke!”

“What do you think you’re going to do?” Costigan demanded, sharply.

“This.” Jack explained. “And don’t try to say no. We’re on our own, you

“We … l … l … it sounds good, and if you can pull it off it will
help no end. Go ahead.”

The demurely luscious blonde stared disconsolately at the bulletin
board, upon which another thirty minutes was being added to the
time of arrival of a ship already three hours late. She picked up
a book, glanced at its cover, put it down. Her hand moved toward a
magazine, drew back, dropped idly into her lap. She sighed, stifled a
yawn prettily, leaned backward in her seat–in such a position, Jack
noticed, that he could not see into her nostrils–and closed her eyes.
And Jack Kinnison, coming visibly to a decision, sat down beside her.

“Pardon me, miss, but I feel just like you look. Can you tell me why
convention decrees that two people, stuck in this concourse by arrivals
that nobody knows when will arrive, have got to suffer alone when they
could have so much more fun suffering together?”

The girl’s eyes opened slowly; she was neither startled, nor afraid,
nor–it seemed–even interested. In fact, she gazed at him with so much
disinterest and for so long a time that he began to wonder–was she
going to play sweet and innocent to the end?

“Yes, conventions are stupid, sometimes,” she admitted finally, her
lovely lips curving into the beginnings of a smile. Her voice, low
and sweet, matched perfectly the rest of her charming self. “After
all, perfectly nice people do meet informally on shipboard; why not in

“Why not, indeed? And I’m perfectly nice people, I assure you. Willi
Borden is the name. My friends call me Bill. And you?”

“Beatrice Bailey; Bee for short. Tell me what you like, and we’ll talk
about it.”

“Why talk, when we could be eating? I’m with a guy. He’s out on the
field somewhere–a big bruiser with a pencil-stripe black mustache.
Maybe you saw him talking to me a while back?”

“I think so, now that you mention him. Too big–much too big.” The
girl spoke carelessly, but managed to make it very clear that Jack
Kinnison was just exactly the right size. “Why?”

“I told him I’d have supper with him. Shall we hunt him up and eat

“Why not? Is he alone?”

“He was, when I saw him last.” Although Jack knew exactly where
Northrop was, and who was with him, he had to play safe; he did not
know how much this “Bee Bailey” really knew. “He knows a lot more
people around here than I do, though, so maybe he isn’t now. Let me
carry some of that plunder?”

“You might carry those books–thanks. But the field is so big–how do
you expect to find him? Or do you know where he is?”

“Uh-uh!” he denied, vigorously. This was the critical moment. She
certainly wasn’t suspicious–yet–but she was showing signs of not
wanting to go out there, and if she refused to go…. “To be honest, I
don’t care whether I find him or not–the idea of ditching him appeals
to me more and more. So how about this? We’ll dash out to the third
dock–just so I won’t have to actually lie about looking for him–and
dash right back here. Or wouldn’t you rather have it a twosome?”

“I refuse to answer, by advice of counsel.” The girl laughed gaily, but
her answer was plain enough.

Their rate of progress was by no means a dash, and Kinnison did not
look–with his eyes–for Northrop. Nevertheless, just south of the
third dock, the two young couples met.

“My cousin, Grace James,” Northrop said, without a tremor or a quiver.
“Wild Willi Borden, Grace–usually called Baldy on account of his hair.”

The girls were introduced; each vouchsafing the other a completely
meaningless smile and a colorlessly conventional word of greeting. Were
they, in fact as in seeming, total strangers? Or were they in fact
working together as closely as were the two young Lensmen themselves?
If that was acting, it was a beautiful job; neither man could detect
the slightest flaw in the performance of either girl.

“Whither away, pilot?” Jack allowed no lapse of time. “You know all the
places around here. Lead us to a good one.”

“This way, my old and fragrant fruit.” Northrop led off with a
flourish, and again Jack tensed. The walk led straight past the
third-class, apparently deserted dock of which a certain ultra-fast
vessel was the only occupant. If nothing happened for fifteen more

Nothing did. The laughing, chattering four came abreast of the portal.
The door swung open and the Lensmen went into action.

They did not like to strong-arm women, but speed was their first
consideration, with safety a close second; and it is impossible
for a man to make speed while carrying a conscious, lithe, strong,
heavily-armed woman in such a position that she cannot use fists, feet,
teeth, gun or knife. An unconscious woman, on the other hand, can be
carried easily and safely enough. Therefore Jack spun his partner
around, forced both of her hands into one of his. The free hand flashed
upward toward the neck; a hard finger pressed unerringly against a
nerve; the girl went limp. The two victims were hustled aboard and the
space-ship, surrounded now by full-coverage screen, took off.

Kinnison paid no attention to ship or course; orders had been given
long since and would be carried out. Instead, he lowered his burden to
the floor, spread her out flat, and sought out and removed item after
item of wiring, apparatus, and offensive and defensive armament. He did
not undress her–quite–but he made completely certain that the only
weapons left to the young lady were those with which Nature had endowed
her. And, Northrop having taken care of his alleged cousin with equal
thoroughness, the small-arms were sent out and both doors of the room
were securely locked.

“Now, Hell-cat Hazel DeForce,” Kinnison said, conversationally, “You
can snap out of it any time–you’ve been back to normal for at least
two minutes. You’ve found out that your famous sex-appeal won’t work.
There’s nothing loose you can grab, and you’re too smart an operator
to tackle me bare-handed. Who’s the captain of your team–you or the

“Clothes-horse!” the statuesque brunette exclaimed, but her protests
were drowned out. The blonde could–and did–talk louder, faster, and

“Do you think you can get away with this?” she demanded. “Why,
you …” and the unexpurgated, trenchant, brilliantly detailed
characterization could have seared its way through four-ply asbestos.
“And just what do you think you’re going to do with me?”

“As to the first, I think so,” Kinnison replied, ignoring the
deep-space verbiage. “As to the second–as of now I don’t know. What
would you do if our situations were reversed?”

“I’d blast you to a cinder–or else take a knife and….”

“Hazel!” the brunette cautioned sharply. “Careful! You’ll touch them
off and they’ll….”

“Shut up, Jane! They won’t hurt us any more than they have already;
it’s psychologically impossible. Isn’t that true, copper?” Hazel
lighted a cigarette, inhaled deeply, and blew a cloud of smoke at
Kinnison’s face.

“Pretty much so, I guess,” the Lensman admitted, frankly enough, “but
we can put you away for the rest of your lives.”

“Space-happy? Or do you think I am?” she sneered. “What would you use
for a case? We’re as safe as if we were in God’s pocket. And besides,
our positions will be reversed pretty quick. You may not know it, but
the fastest ships in space are chasing us, right now.”

“For once you’re wrong. We’ve got plenty of legs ourselves and we’re
blasting for rendezvous with a task-force. But enough of this chatter.
I want to know what job you’re on and why you picked on us. Give.”

“Oh, does ‘oo?” Hazel cooed, venomously. “Come and sit on mama’s lap,
itty bitty soldier boy, and she’ll tell you everything you want to

Both Lensmen probed, then, with everything they had, but learned
nothing of value. The women did not know what the Patrolmen were trying
to do, but they were so intensely hostile that their mental blocks,
unconscious although they were, were as effective as full-driven
thought screens against the most insidious approaches the men could

“Anything in their hand-bags, Mase?” Jack asked, finally.

“I’ll look…. Nothing much–just this,” and the very tonelessness of
Northrop’s voice made Jack look up quickly.

“Just a letter from the boy-friend.” Hazel shrugged her shoulders.
“Nothing hot–not even warm–go ahead and read it.”

“Not interested in what it says, but it might be smart to develop
it, envelope and all, for invisible ink and whatnot.” He did so,
deeming it a worth-while expenditure of time. He already knew what the
hidden message was; but no one not of the Patrol should know that no
transmission of intelligence, however coded or garbled or disguised or
by whatever means sent, could be concealed from any wearer of Arisia’s

“Listen, Hazel,” Kinnison said, holding up the now slightly stained
paper. “‘Three six two’–that’s you, I suppose, and you’re the squad
leader–‘Men mentioned previously being investigated stop assign three
nine eight’–that must be you, Jane–‘and make acquaintance stop if
no further instructions received by eighteen hundred hours liquidate
immediately stop party one’.”

The blond operative lost for the first time her brazen control.
“Why … that code is unbreakable!” she gasped.

“Wrong again, Gentle Alice. Some of us are specialists.” He directed a
thought at Northrop. “This changes things slightly, Mase. I was going
to turn them loose, but now I don’t know. Better we take it up with the
boss, don’t you think?”


Samms was called, and considered the matter for approximately one
minute. “Your first idea was right, Jack. Let them go. The message
may be helpful and informative, but the women would not. They know
nothing. Congratulations, boys, on the complete success of Operation
Red Herring.”

“Ouch!” Jack grimaced mentally to his partner after the First Lensman
had cut off. “They know enough to be in on bumping you and me off, but
that ain’t important, says he!”

“And it ain’t, bub,” Northrop grinned back. “Moderately so, maybe, if
they had got us, but not at all so now they can’t. The Lensmen have
landed and the situation is well in hand. It is written. Selah.”

“Check. Let’s wrap it up.” Jack turned to the blonde. “Come on, Hazel.
Out. Number Four lifeboat. Do you want to come peaceably or shall I
work on your neck again?”

“You could think of other places that would be more fun.” She got up
and stared directly into his eyes, her lip curling. “That is, if you
were a man instead of a sublimated Boy Scout.”

Kinnison, without a word, wheeled and unlocked a door. Hazel swaggered
forward, but the taller girl hung back. “Are you sure there’s air–and
they’ll pick us up? Maybe they’re going to make us breathe space….”

“Huh? They haven’t got the guts,” Hazel sneered. “Come on, Jane. Number
Four, you said, darling?”

She led the way. Kinnison opened the portal. Jane hurried aboard, but
Hazel paused and held out her arms.

“Aren’t you even going to kiss mama goodbye, baby boy?” she taunted.

“Better not waste much more time. We blow this boat, sealed or open,
in fifteen seconds.” By what effort Kinnison held his voice level and
expressionless, he hoped the wench would never know.

She looked at him, started to say something, looked again. She had gone
just about as far as it was safe to go. She stepped into the boat and
reached for the lever. And as the valve was swinging smoothly shut the
men heard a tinkling laugh, reminiscent of icicles breaking against
steel bells.

“Hell’s–Brazen–Hinges!” Kinnison wiped his forehead as the lifeboat
shot away. Hazel was something brand new to him; a phenomenon with
which none of his education, training, or experience had equipped him
to cope. “I’ve heard about the guy who got hold of a tiger by the tail,
but….” His thought expired on a wondering, confused note.

“Yeah.” Northrop was in no better case. “We won–technically–I
guess–or did we? That was a God-awful drubbing we took, mister.”

“Well, we got away alive, anyway…. We’ll tell Parker his dope is
correct to the proverbial twenty decimals. And now that we’ve escaped,
let’s call Spud and see how things came out.”

And Costigan-Jones assured them that everything had come out very
well indeed. The shipment of thionite had been followed without any
difficulty at all, from the space-ship clear through to Jones’ own
office, and it reposed now in Department Q’s own safe, under Jones’
personal watch and ward. The pressure had lightened tremendously, just
as Kinnison and Northrop had thought it would, when they set up their
diversion. Costigan listened impassively to the whole story.

“Now should I have shot her, or not?” Jack demanded. “Not whether I
could have or not–I couldn’t–but should I have, Spud?”

“I don’t know.” Costigan thought for minutes. “I don’t think so.
No–not in cold blood. I couldn’t have, either, and wouldn’t if I
could. It wouldn’t be worth it. Somebody will shoot her some day, but
not one of us–unless, of course, it’s in a fight.”

“Thanks, Spud; that makes me feel better. Off.”

Costigan-Jones’ desk was already clear, since there was little or no
paper-work connected with his position in Department Q. Hence his
preparations for departure were few and simple. He merely opened the
safe, stuck the package into his pocket, closed and locked the safe,
and took a company ground-car to the spaceport.

Nor was there any more formality about his leaving the planet. Eridan
had, of course, a Customs frontier of sorts; but since Uranium Inc.
owned Eridan in fee simple, its Customs paid no attention whatever to
company ships or to low-number, gold-badge company men. Nor did Jones
need ticket, passport, or visa. Company men rode company ships to and
from company plants, wherever situated, without let or hindrance. Thus,
wearing the aura of power of his new position–and Gold Badge Number
Thirty Eight–George W. Jones was whisked out to the uranium ship and
was shown to his cabin.

Nor was it surprising that the trip from Eridan to Earth was completely
without incident. This was an ordinary freighter, hauling uranium on a
routine flight. Her cargo was valuable, of course–the sine qua non of
inter-stellar trade–but in no sense precious. Not pirate-bait, by any
means. And only two men knew that this flight was in any whit different
from the one which had preceded it or the one which would follow it.
If this ship was escorted or guarded the fact was not apparent: and
no Patrol vessel came nearer to it than four detets–Virgil Samms and
Roderick Kinnison saw to that.

The voyage, however, was not tedious. Jones was busy every minute. In
fact, there were scarcely minutes enough in which to assimilate the
material which Isaacson had given him–the layouts, flow-sheets, and
organization charts of Works Number Eighteen, on Tellus.

And upon arrival at the private spaceport which was an integral part
of Works Number Eighteen, Jones was not surprised (he knew more now
than he had known a few weeks before; and infinitely more than the
man on the street) to learn that the Customs men of this particular
North American Port of Entry were just as complaisant as were those of
Eridan. They did not bother even to count the boxes, to say nothing
of inspecting them. They stamped the ship’s papers without either
reading or checking them. They made a perfunctory search, it is true,
of crewmen and quarters, but a low number gold badge was still a magic
talisman. Unquestioned, sacrosanct, he and his baggage were escorted to
the ground-car first in line.

“Administration Building,” Jones-Costigan told the hacker, and that was


It has been said that the basic drive of the Eddorians was a lust
for power; a thought which should be elucidated and perhaps slightly
modified. Their warrings, their strifes, their inter-necine intrigues
and connivings were inevitable because of the tremendousness and
capability–and the limitations–of their minds. Not enough could
occur upon any one planet to keep such minds as theirs even partially
occupied; and, unlike the Arisians, they could not satiate themselves
in a static philosophical study of the infinite possibilities of the
Cosmic All. They had to be doing something; or, better yet, making
other and lesser beings do things to make the physical universe conform
to their idea of what a universe should be.

Their first care was to set up the various echelons of control. The
second echelon, immediately below the Masters, was of course the most
important, and after a survey of both galaxies they decided to give
this high honor to the Ploorans. Ploor, as is now well known, was
a planet of a sun so variable that all Plooran life had to undergo
radical cyclical changes in physical form in order to live through the
tremendous climatic changes involved in its every year. Physical form,
however, meant nothing to the Eddorians. Since no other planet even
remotely like theirs existed in this, our normal plenum, physiques like
theirs would be impossible; and the Plooran mentality left very little
to be desired.

In the third echelon there were many different races, among which the
frigid-blooded, poison-breathing Eich were perhaps the most efficient
and most callous; and in the fourth there were millions upon millions
of entities representing thousands upon thousands of widely-variant

Thus, at the pinpoint in history represented by the time of Virgil
Samms and Roderick Kinnison, the Eddorians were busy; and if such
a word can be used, happy. Gharlane of Eddore, second in authority
only to the All-Highest, His Ultimate Supremacy himself, paid little
attention to any one planet or to any one race. Even such a mind as
his, when directing the affairs of twenty million and then sixty
million and then a hundred million worlds, can do so only in broad, and
not in fine.

And thus the reports which were now flooding in to Gharlane in a
constantly increasing stream concerned classes and groups of worlds,
and solar systems, and galactic regions. A planet might perhaps be
mentioned as representative of a class, but no individual entity
lower than a Plooran was named or discussed. Gharlane analyzed those
tremendous reports; collated, digested, compared, and reconciled them;
determined trends and tendencies and most probable resultants. Gharlane
issued orders, the carrying out of which would make an entire galactic
region fit more and ever more exactly into the Great Plan.

But, as has been pointed out, there was one flaw inherent in the
Boskonian system. Underlings, then as now, were prone to gloss over
their own mistakes, to cover up their own incompetences. Thus, since
he had no reason to inquire specifically, Gharlane did not know that
anything whatever had gone amiss on Sol Three, the pestiferous planet
which had formerly caused him more trouble than all the rest of his
worlds combined.

After the fact, it is easy to say that he should have continued
his personal supervision of Earth, but can that view be defended?
Egotistical, self-confident, arrogant, Gharlane knew that he had
finally whipped Tellus into line. It was the same now as any other
planet of its class. And even had he thought it worth while to make
such a glaring exception, would not the fused Elders of Arisia have

Be those things as they may, Gharlane did not know that the new-born
Galactic Patrol had been successful in defending Triplanetary’s Hill
against the Black Fleet. Nor did the Plooran Assistant Director in
charge. Nor did any member of that dreadful group of Eich which was
even then calling itself the Council of Boskone. The highest-ranking
Boskonian who knew of the fiasco, calmly confident of his own ability,
had not considered this minor reverse of sufficient importance to
report to his immediate superior. He had already taken steps to
correct the condition. In fact, as matters now stood, the thing was
more fortunate than otherwise, in that it would lull the Patrol into
believing themselves in a position of superiority–a belief which
would, at election time, prove fatal.

This being, human to the limit of classification except for a faint but
unmistakable blue coloration, had been closeted with Senator Morgan for
a matter of two hours.

“In the matters covered, your reports have been complete and
conclusive,” the visitor said finally, “but you have not reported on
the Lens.”

“Purposely. We are investigating it, but any report based upon our
present knowledge would be partial and inconclusive.”

“I see. Commendable enough, usually. News of this phenomenon has,
however, gone farther and higher than you think and I have been ordered
to take cognizance of it; to decide whether or not to handle it myself.”

“I am thoroughly capable of….”

“I will decide that, not you.” Morgan subsided. “A partial report is
therefore in order. Go ahead.”

“According to the procedure submitted and approved, a Lensman was
taken alive. Since the Lens has telepathic properties, and hence is
presumably operative at great distances, the operation was carried out
in the shortest possible time. The Lens, immediately upon removal from
the Patrolman’s arm, ceased to radiate and the operative who held the
thing died. It was then applied by force to four other men–workers,
these, of no importance. All four died, thus obviating all possibility
of coincidence. An attempt was made to analyze a fragment of the active
material, without success. It seemed to be completely inert. Neither
was it affected by electrical discharges or by sub-atomic bombardment,
nor by any temperatures available. Meanwhile, the man was of course
being questioned, under truth-drug and beams. His mind denied any
knowledge of the nature of the Lens; a thing which I am rather inclined
to believe. His mind adhered to the belief that he obtained the Lens
upon the planet Arisia. I am offering for your consideration my opinion
that the high-ranking officers of the Patrol are using hypnotism to
conceal the real source of the Lens.”

“Your opinion is accepted for consideration.”

“The man died during examination. Two minutes after his death his Lens

“Disappeared? What do you mean? Flew away? Vanished? Was stolen?
Disintegrated? Or what?”

“No. More like evaporation or sublimation, except that there was no
gradual diminution in volume, and there was no detectable residue,
either solid, liquid, or gaseous. The platinum-alloy bracelet remained

“And then?”

“The Patrol attacked in force and our expedition was destroyed.”

“You are sure of these observational facts?”

“I have the detailed records. Would you like to see them?”

“Send them to my office. I hereby relieve you of all responsibility
in the matter of the Lens. In fact, even I may decide to refer it to
a higher echelon. Have you any other material, not necessarily facts,
which may have bearing?”

“None,” Morgan replied; and it was just as well for Virgilia Samms’
continued well-being that the Senator did not think it worth while to
mention the traceless disappearance of his Number One secretary and a
few members of a certain unsavory gang. To his way of thinking, the
Lens was not involved, except perhaps very incidentally. Herkimer, in
spite of advice and orders, had probably got rough with the girl, and
Samms’ mob had rubbed him out. Served him right.

“I have no criticism of any phase of your work. You are doing a
particularly nice job on thionite. You are of course observing all
specified precautions as to key personnel?”

“Certainly. Thorough testing and unremitting watchfulness. Our Mr.
Isaacson is about to promote a man who has proved very capable. Would
you like to observe the proceedings?”

“No. I have no time for minor matters. Your results have been
satisfactory. Keep them that way. Good-bye.” The visitor strode out.

Morgan reached for a switch, then drew his hand back. No. He would
like to sit in on the forthcoming interview, but he did not have the
time. He had tested Olmstead repeatedly and personally; he knew what
the man was. It was Isaacson’s department; let Isaacson handle it. He
himself must work full time at the job which only he could handle; the
Nationalists must and would win this forthcoming election.

And in the office of the president of Interstellar Spaceways, Isaacson
got up and shook hands with George Olmstead.

“I called you in for two reasons. First, in reply to your message that
you were ready for a bigger job. What makes you think that any such are

“Do I need to answer that?”

“Perhaps not … no.” The magnate smiled quietly. Morgan was right;
this man could not be accused of being dumb. “There is such a job,
you are ready for it, and you have your successor trained in the work
of harvesting. Second, why did you cut down, instead of increasing as
ordered, the weight of broadleaf per trip? This, Olmstead, is really

“I explained why. It would have been more serious the other way. Didn’t
you believe I knew what I was talking about?”

“Your reasoning may have been distorted in transmittal. I want it
straight from you.”

“Very well. It isn’t smart to be greedy. There’s a point at which
something that has been merely a nuisance becomes a thing that has to
be wiped out. Since I didn’t want to be in that ferry when the Patrol
blows it out of the ether, I cut down the take, and I advise you to
keep it down. What you’re getting now is a lot more than you ever got
before, and a hell of a lot more than none at all. Think it over.”

“I see. Upon what basis did you arrive at the figure you established?”

“Pure guesswork, nothing else. I guessed that about three hundred
percent of the previous average per month ought to satisfy anybody who
wasn’t too greedy to have good sense, and that more than that would
ring a loud, clear bell right where we don’t want any noise made. So I
cut it down to three, and advised Ferdy either to keep it at three or
quit while he was still all in one piece.”

“You exceeded your authority … and were insubordinate … but it
wouldn’t surprise me if you were right. You are certainly right in
principle, and the poundage can be determined by statistical and
psychological analysis. But in the meantime, there is tremendous
pressure for increased production.”

“I know it. Pressure be damned. My dear cousin Virgil is, as you
already know, a crackpot. He is visionary, idealistic, full of sweet
and beautiful concepts of what the universe would be like if there
weren’t so many people like you and me in it; but don’t ever make the
mistake of writing him off as anybody’s fool. And you know, probably
better than I do, what Rod Kinnison is like. If I were you I’d tell
whoever is doing the screaming to shut their damn mouths before they
get their teeth kicked down their throats.”

“I’m very much inclined to take your advice. And now as to this
proposed promotion. You are of course familiar in a general way with
our operation at Northport?”

“I could scarcely help knowing something about the biggest uranium
works on Earth. However, I am not well enough qualified in detail to
make a good technical executive.”

“Nor is it necessary. Our thought is to make you a key man in a new and
increasingly important branch of the business, known as Department Q.
It is concerned neither with production nor with uranium.”

“Q as in ‘quiet’, eh? I’m listening with both ears. What duties would
be connected with this … er … position? What would I really do?”

Two pairs of hard eyes locked and held, staring yieldlessly into each
other’s depths.

“You would not be unduly surprised to learn that substances other than
uranium occasionally reach Northport?”

“Not too surprised, no,” Olmstead replied dryly. “What would I do
with it?”

“We need not go into that here or now. I offer you the position.”

“I accept it.”

“Very well. I will take you to Northport, and we will continue our talk
en route.”

And in a spy-ray-proof, sound-proof compartment of a Spaceways-owned
stratoliner they did so.

“Just for my information, Mr. Isaacson, how many predecessors have I
had on this particular job, and what happened to them? The Patrol get

“Two. No; we have not been able to find any evidence that the Samms
crowd has any suspicion of us. Both were too small for the job; neither
could handle personnel. One got funny ideas, the other couldn’t stand
the strain. If you don’t get funny ideas, and don’t crack up, you will
make out in a big–and I mean really big–way.”

“If I do either I’ll be more than somewhat surprised.” Olmstead’s
features set themselves into a mirthless, uncompromising, somehow
bitter grin.

“So will I.” Isaacson agreed.

He knew what this man was, and just how case-hardened he was. He knew
that he had fought Morgan himself to a scoreless tie after twisting
Herkimer–and he was no soft touch–into a pretzel in nothing flat. At
the thought of the secretary, so recently and so mysteriously vanished,
the magnate’s mind left for a moment the matter in hand. What was
at the bottom of that affair–the Lens or the woman? Or both? If he
were in Morgan’s shoes … but he wasn’t. He had enough grief of his
own, without worrying about any of Morgan’s stinkeroos. He studied
Olmstead’s inscrutable, subtly sneering smile and knew that he had made
a wise decision.

“I gather that I am going to be one of the main links in the primary
chain of deliveries. What’s the technique, and how do I cover up?”

“Technique first. You go fishing. You are an expert at that, I believe?”

“You might say so. I won’t have to do any faking there.”

“Some week-end soon, and every week-end later on, we hope, you will
indulge in your favorite sport at some lake or other. You will take the
customary solid and liquid refreshments along in a lunch-box. When you
have finished eating you will toss the lunch-box overboard.”

“That all?”

“That’s all.”

“The lunch-box, then, will be slightly special?”

“More or less, although it will look ordinary enough. Now as to the
cover-up. How would ‘Director of Research’ sound?”

“I don’t know. Depends on what the researchers are doing. Before I
became an engineer I was a pure scientist of sorts; but that was quite
a while ago and I was never a specialist.”

“That is one reason why I think you will do. We have plenty of
specialists–too many, I often think. They dash off in all directions,
without rhyme or reason. What we want is a man with enough scientific
training to know in general what is going on, but what he will need
mostly is hard common sense, and enough ability–mental force, you
might call it–to hold the specialists down to earth and make them pull
together. If you can do it–and if I didn’t think you could I wouldn’t
be talking to you–the whole force will know that you are earning your
pay; just as we could not hide the fact that your two predecessors

“Put that way it sounds good. I wouldn’t wonder if I could handle it.”

The conversation went on, but the rest of it is of little importance
here. The plane landed. Isaacson introduced the new Director of
Research to Works Manager Rand, who in turn introduced him to a few of
his scientists and to the svelte and spectacular red-head who was to be
his private secretary.

It was clear from the first that the Research Department was not going
to be an easy one to manage. The top men were defiant, the middle ranks
were sullen, the smaller fry were apprehensive as well as sullen. The
secretary flaunted chips on both shapely shoulders. Men and women alike
expected the application of the old wheeze “a new broom sweeps clean”
for the third time in scarcely twice that many months, and they were
defying him to do his worst. Wherefore they were very much surprised
when the new boss did nothing whatever for two solid weeks except read
reports and get acquainted with his department.

“How d’ya like your new boss, May?” another secretary asked, during a

“Oh, not too bad … I guess.” May’s tone was full of reservations.
“He’s quiet–sort of reserved–no passes or anything like that–it’d be
funny if I finally got a boss that had something on the ball, wouldn’t
it? But you know what, Molly?” The red-head giggled suddenly. “I had
a camera-fiend first, you know, with a million credits’ worth of
stereo-cams and such stuff, and then a golf-nut. I wonder what this Dr.
Olmstead does with his spare cash?”

“You’ll find out, dearie, no doubt.” Molly’s tone gave the words a
meaning slightly different from the semantic one of their arrangement.

“I intend to, Molly–I fully intend to.” May’s meaning, too, was not
expressed exactly by the sequence of words used. “It must be tough, a
boss’s life. Having to sit at a desk or be in conference six or seven
hours a day–when he isn’t playing around somewhere–for a measly
thousand credits or so a month. How do they get that way?”

“You said it, May. You really said it. But we’ll get ours, huh?”

Time went on. George Olmstead studied reports, and more reports. He
read one, and re-read it, frowning. He compared it minutely with
another; then sent red-headed May to hunt up one which had been turned
in a couple of weeks before. He took them home that evening, and in the
morning he punched three buttons. Three stiffly polite young men obeyed
his summons.

“Good morning, Doctor Olmstead.”

“Morning, boys. I’m not up on the fundamental theory of any one of
these three reports, but if you combine this, and this, and this,”
indicating heavily-penciled sections of the three documents, “would
you, or would you not, be able to work out a process that would do away
with about three-quarters of the final purification and separation

They did not know. It had not been the business of any one of them, or
of all them collectively, to find out.

“I’m making it your business as of now. Drop whatever you’re doing, put
your heads together, and find out. Theory first, then a small-scale
laboratory experiment. Then come back here on the double.”

“Yes, sir,” and in a few days they were back.

“Does it work?”

“In theory it should, sir, and on a laboratory scale it does.” The
three young men were, if possible, even stiffer than before. It was not
the first time, nor would it be the last, that a Director of Research
would seize credit for work which he was not capable of doing.

“Good. Miss Reed, get me Rand … Rand? Olmstead. Three of my boys
have just hatched out something that may be worth quite a few million
credits a year to us…. Me? Hell, no! Talk to them. I can’t understand
any one of the three parts of it, to say nothing of inventing it. I
want you to give ’em a class AAA priority on the pilot plant, as of
right now. If they can develop it, and I’m betting they can, I’m going
to put their pictures in the Northport News and give ’em a couple of
thousand credits apiece and a couple of weeks vacation to spend it
in…. Yeah, I’ll send ’em in.” He turned to the flabbergasted three.
“Take your dope in to Rand–now. Show him what you’ve got; then tear
into that pilot plant.”

And, a little later, Molly and May again met in the powder room.

“So your new boss is a fisherman!” Molly snickered. “And they say he
paid over two hundred credits for a reel! You were right, May; a
boss’s life must be mighty hard to take. And he sits around more and
does less, they say, than any other exec in the plant.”

Who says so, the dirty, sneaking liars?” the red-head blazed,
completely unaware that she had reversed her former position. “And even
if it was so, which it isn’t, he can do more work sitting perfectly
still than any other boss in the whole Works can do tearing around at
forty parsecs a minute, so there!”

George Olmstead was earning his salary.

His position was fully consolidated when, a few days later, a tremor of
excitement ran through the Research Department. “Heads up, everybody!
Mr. Isaacson–himself–is coming–here! What for, I wonder? Y’don’t
s’pose he’s going to take the Old Man away from us already, do you?”

He came. He went through, for the first time, the entire department. He
observed minutely, and he understood what he saw.

Olmstead led the Big Boss into his private office and flipped the
switch which supposedly rendered that sanctum proof against any and all
forms of spying, eavesdropping, intrusion, and communication. It did
not, however, close the deeper, subtler channels which the Lensmen used.

“Good work, George. So damned good that I’m going to have to take
you out of Department Q entirely and make you Works Manager of our new
plant on Vegia. Have you got a man you can break in to take your place

“Including Department Q? No.” Although Olmstead did not show it, he
was disappointed at hearing the word “Vegia”. He had been aiming much
higher than that–at the secret planet of the Boskonian Armed Forces,
no less–but there might still be enough time to win a transfer there.

“Excluding. I’ve got another good man here now for that. Jones. Not
heavy enough, though, for Vegia.”

“In that case, yes. Dr. Whitworth, one of the boys who worked out the
new process. It’ll take a little time, though. Three weeks minimum.”

“Three weeks it is. Today’s Friday. You’ve got things in shape, haven’t
you, so that you can take the week-end off?”

“I was figuring on it. I’m not going where I thought I was, though, I

“Probably not. Lake Chesuncook, on Route 273. Rough country, and the
hotel is something less than fourth rate, but the fishing can’t be

“I’m glad of that. When I fish, I like to catch something.”

“It would smell if you didn’t. They stock lunch-boxes in the cafeteria,
you know. Have your girl get you one, full of sandwiches and stuff.
Start early this afternoon, as soon as you can after I leave. Be sure
and see Jones, with your lunch-box, before you leave. Good-bye.”

“Miss Reed, please send Whitworth in. Then skip down to the cafeteria
and get me a lunch-box. Sandwiches and a thermos of coffee. Provender
suitable for a wet and hungry fisherman.”

“Yes, sir!” There were no chips now; the red-head’s boss was the top
ace of the whole plant.

“Hi, Ned. Take the throne.” Olmstead waved his hand at the now vacant
chair behind the big desk. “Hold it down ’til I get back. Monday,

“Going fishing, huh?” Gone was all trace of stiffness, of reserve, of
unfriendliness. “You big, lucky stiff!”

“Well, my brilliant young squirt, maybe you’ll get old and fat enough
to go fishing yourself some day. Who knows? ‘Bye.”

Lunch-box in hand and encumbered with tackle, Olmstead walked blithely
along the corridor to the office of Assistant Works Manager Jones.
While he had not known just what to expect, he was not surprised to see
a lunch-box exactly like his own upon the side-table. He placed his box
beside it.

“Hi, Olmstead.” By no slightest flicker of expression did either
Lensman step out of character. “Shoving off early?”

“Yeah. Dropped by to let the Head Office know I won’t be in ’til

“O.K. So’m I, but more speed for me. Chemquassabamticook Lake.”

“Do you pronounce that or sneeze it? But have fun, my boy. I’m
combining business with pleasure, though–breaking in Whitworth on my
job. That Fairplay thing is going to break in about an hour, and it’ll
scare the pants off of him. But it’ll keep until Monday, anyway, and if
he handles it right he’s just about in.”

Jones grinned. “A bit brutal, perhaps, but a sure way to find out.

“So long.” Olmstead strolled out, nonchalantly picking up the wrong
lunch box on the way, and left the building.

He ordered his Dillingham, and tossed the lunch-box aboard as
carelessly as though it did not contain an unknown number of millions
of credits’ worth of clear-quill, uncut thionite.

“I hope you have a nice week-end, sir,” the yard-man said, as he helped
stow baggage and tackle.

“Thanks, Otto. I’ll bring you a couple of fish Monday, if I catch that
many,” and it should be said in passing that he brought them. Lensmen
keep their promises, under whatever circumstances or however lightly

It being mid-afternoon of Friday, the traffic was already heavy.
Northport was not a metropolis, of course; but on the other hand it did
not have metropolitan multi-tiered, one-way, non-intersecting streets.
But Olmstead was in no hurry. He inched his spectacular mount–it was
a violently iridescent chrome green in color, with highly polished
chromium gingerbread wherever there was any excuse for gingerbread to
be–across the city and into the north-bound side of the superhighway.
Even then, he did not hurry. He wanted to hit the inspection station at
the edge of the Preserve at dusk. Ninety miles an hour would do it. He
worked his way into the ninety-mile lane and became motionless relative
to the other vehicles on the strip.

It was a peculiar sensation; it seemed as though the cars themselves
were stationary, with the pavement flowing backward beneath them. There
was no passing, no weaving, no cutting in and out. Only occasionally
would the formation be broken as a car would shift almost imperceptibly
to one side or the other; speeding up or slowing down to match the
assigned speed of the neighboring way.

The afternoon was bright and clear, neither too hot nor too cold.
Olmstead enjoyed his drive thoroughly, and arrived at the turn-off
right on schedule. Leaving the wide, smooth way, he slowed down
abruptly; even a Dillingham Super-Sporter could not make speed on the
narrow, rough, and hilly road to Chesuncook Lake.

At dusk he reached the Post. Instead of stopping on the pavement
he pulled off the road, got out, stretched hugely, and took a few
drum-major’s steps to take the kinks out of his legs.

“A lot of road, eh?” the smartly-uniformed trooper remarked. “No guns?”

“No guns.” Olmstead opened up for inspection. “From Northport.
Funny, isn’t it, how hard it is to stop, even when you aren’t in any
particular hurry? Guess I’ll eat now–join me in a sandwich and some
hot coffee or a cold lemon sour or cherry soda?”

“I’ve got my own supper, thanks; I was just going to eat. But did you
say a cold lemon sour?”

“Uh-huh. Ice-cold. Zero degrees Centigrade.”

“I will join you, in that case. Thanks.”

Olmstead opened a frost-lined compartment; took out two half-liter
bottles; placed them and his open lunch-box invitingly on the low stone

“Hm … m … m. Quite a zipper you got there, mister.” The trooper
gazed admiringly at the luxurious, two-wheeled monster; listened
appreciatively to its almost inaudible hum. “I’ve heard about those new
supers, but that is the first one I ever saw. Nice. All the comforts of
home, eh?”

“Just about. Sure you won’t help me clean up on those sandwiches,
before they get stale?”

Seated on the wall, the two men ate and talked. If that trooper had
known what was in the box beside his leg he probably would have fallen
over backward; but how was he even to suspect? There was nothing crass
or rough or coarse about any of the work of any of Boskone’s high-level

Olmstead drove on to the lake and took up his reservation at the
ramshackle hotel. He slept, and bright and early the next morning he
was up and fishing–and this part of the performance he really enjoyed.
He knew his stuff and the fish were there; big, wary, and game. He
loved it.

At noon he ate, and quite openly and brazenly consigned the “empty”
box to the watery deep. Even if he had not had so many fish to carry,
he was not the type to lug a cheap lunch-box back to town. He fished
joyously all afternoon, without getting quite the limit, and as the sun
grazed the horizon he started his putt-putt and skimmed back to the

The thing hadn’t sent out any radiation yet, Northrop informed him
tensely, but it certainly would, and when it did they’d be ready. There
were Lensmen and Patrolmen all over the place, thicker than hair on a

And George Olmstead, sighing wearily and yet blissfully anticipatory of
one more day of enthralling sport, gathered up his equipment and his
fish and strolled toward the hotel.


Forty thousand miles from Earth’s center the Chicago loafed along
a circular arc, inert, at a mere ten thousand miles an hour; a speed
which, and not by accident, kept her practically stationary above a
certain point on the planet’s surface. Nor was it by chance that both
Virgil Samms and Roderick Kinnison were aboard. And a dozen or so other
craft, cruisers and such, whose officers were out to put space-time in
their logs, were flitting aimlessly about; but never very far away from
the flagship. And farther out–well out–a cordon of diesel-powered
detector ships swept space to the full limit of their prodigious reach.
The navigating officers of those vessels knew to a nicety the place
and course of every ship lawfully in the ether, and the appearance of
even one unscheduled trace would set in motion a long succession of
carefully-planned events.

And far below, grazing atmosphere, never very far from the direct line
between the Chicago and Earth’s core, floated a palatial pleasure
yacht. And this craft carried not one Lensman, or two, but eight; two
of whom kept their eyes fixed upon their observation plates. They were
watching a lunch-box resting upon the bottom of a lake.

“Hasn’t it radiated yet?” Roderick Kinnison demanded. “Or been
approached, or moved?”

“Not yet,” Lyman Cleveland replied, crisply. “Neither Northrop’s rig
nor mine has shown any sign of activity.”

He did not amplify the statement, nor was there need. Mason Northrop
was a Master Electronicist; Cleveland was perhaps the world’s greatest
living expert. Neither of them had detected radiation. Ergo, none

Equally certainly the box had not moved, or been moved, or approached.
“No change, Rod,” Doctor Frederick Rodebush Lensed the assured thought.
“Six of us have been watching the plates in five-minute shifts.”

A few minutes later, however: “Here is a thought which may be of
interest,” DalNalten the Venerian announced, spraying himself with
a couple pints of water. “It is natural enough, of course, for any
Venerian to be in or on any water he can reach–I would enjoy very
much being on or in that lake myself–but it may not be entirely by
coincidence that one particular Venerian, Ossmen, is visiting this
particular lake at this particular time.”

“What!” Nine Lensmen yelled the thought practically as one.

“Precisely. Ossmen.” It was a measure of the Venerian Lensman’s concern
that he used only two words instead of twenty or thirty. “In the red
boat with the yellow sail.”

“Do you see any detector rigs?” Samms asked.

“He wouldn’t need any,” DalNalten put in. “He will be able to see it.
Or, if a little colane had been rubbed on it which no Tellurian could
have noticed, any Venerian could smell it from one end of that lake to
the other.”

“True. I didn’t think of that. It may not have a transmitter after all.”

“Maybe not, but keep on listening, anyway,” the Port Admiral ordered.
“Bend a plate on Ossmen, and a couple more on the rest of the boats.
But Ossmen is clean, you say, Jack? Not even a spy-ray block?”

“He couldn’t have a block, Dad. It’d give too much away, here on our
home grounds. Like on Eridan, where their ops could wear anything
they could lift, but we had to go naked.” He flinched mentally as he
recalled his encounter with Hazel the Hell-cat, and Northrop flinched
with him.

“That’s right, Rod,” Olmstead in his boat below agreed, and Conway
Costigan, in his room in Northport, concurred. The top-drawer
operatives of the enemy depended for safety upon perfection of
technique, not upon crude and dangerous mechanical devices.

“Well, since you’re all so sure of it, I’ll buy it,” and the waiting
went on.

Under the slight urge of the light and vagrant breeze, the red boat
moved slowly across the water. A somnolent, lackadaisical youth, who
very evidently cared nothing about where the boat went, sat in its
stern, with his left arm draped loosely across the tiller. Nor was
Ossmen any more concerned. His only care, apparently, was to avoid
interference with the fishermen; his under-water jaunts were long, even
for a Venerian, and he entered and left the water as smoothly as only a
Venerian–or a seal–could.

“However, he could have, and probably has got, a capsule spy-ray
detector,” Jack offered, presently. “Or, since a Venerian can swallow
anything one inch smaller than a kitchen stove, he could have a whole
analyzing station stashed away in his stomach. Nobody’s put a beam on
him yet, have you?”

Nobody had.

“It might be smart not to. Watch him with ‘scopes … and when he gets
up close to the box, better pull your beams off of it. DalNalten, I
don’t suppose it would be quite bright for you to go swimming down
there too, would it?”

“Very definitely not, which is why I am up here and dry. None of them
would go near it.”

They waited, and finally Ossmen’s purposeless wanderings brought him
over the spot on the lake’s bottom which was the target of so many
Tellurian eyes. He gazed at the discarded lunch-box as incuriously as
he had looked at so many other sunken objects, and swam over it as
casually–and only the ultra-cameras caught what he actually did. He
swam serenely on.

“The box is still there,” the spy-ray men reported, “but the package is

“Good!” Kinnison exclaimed, “Can you ‘scopists see it on him?”

“Ten to one they can’t,” Jack said. “He swallowed it. I expected him to
swallow it box and all.”

“We can’t see it, sir. He must have swallowed it.”

“Make sure.”

“Yes, sir…. He’s back on the boat now and we’ve shot him from all
angles. He’s clean–nothing outside.”

“Perfect! That means he isn’t figuring on slipping it to somebody else
in a crowd. This will be an ordinary job of shadowing from here on in,
so I’ll put in the umbrella.”

The detector ships were recalled. The Chicago and the various other
ships of war returned to their various bases. The pleasure craft
floated away. But on the other hand there were bursts of activity
throughout the forest for a mile or so back from the shores of the
lake. Camps were struck. Hiking parties decided that they had hiked
enough and began to retrace their steps. Lithe young men, who had been
doing this and that, stopped doing it and headed for the nearest trails.

For Kinnison pere had erred slightly in saying that the rest of
the enterprise was to be an ordinary job of shadowing. No ordinary
job would do. With the game this nearly in the bag it must be made
absolutely certain that no suspicion was aroused, and yet Samms had to
have facts. Sharp, hard, clear facts; facts so self-evidently facts
that no intelligence above idiot grade could possibly mistake them for
anything but facts.

Wherefore Ossmen the Venerian was not alone thenceforth. From lake to
hotel, from hotel to car, along the road, into and in and out of train
and plane, clear to an ordinary-enough-looking building in an ordinary
business section of New York, he was never alone. Where the traveling
population was light, the Patrol operatives were few and did not crowd
the Venerian too nearly; where dense, as in a metropolitan station,
they ringed him three deep.

He reached his destination, which was of course spy-ray proofed, late
Sunday night. He went in, remained briefly, came out.

“Shall we spy-ray him, Virge? Follow him? Or what?”

“No spy-rays. Follow him. Cover him like a blanket. At the usual time
give him the usual spy-ray going-over, but not until then. This time,
make it thorough. Make certain that he hasn’t got it on him, in him,
or in or around his house.”

“There’ll be nothing doing here tonight, will there?”

“No, it would be too noticeable. So you, Fred, and Lyman, take the
first trick; the rest of us will get some sleep.”

When the building opened Monday morning the Lensmen were back, with
dozens of others, including Knobos of Mars. There were also present or
nearby literally hundreds of the shrewdest, most capable detectives of

“So this is their headquarters–one of them at least,” the Martian
thought, studying the trickle of people entering and leaving the
building. “It is as we thought, Dal, why we could never find it, why we
could never trace any wholesaler backward. None of us has ever seen any
of these persons before. Complete change of personnel per operation;
probably inter-planetary. Long periods of quiescence. Check?”

“Check: but we have them now.”

“Just like that, huh?” Jack Kinnison jibed; and from his viewpoint his
idea was the more valid, for the wholesalers were very clever operators

From the more professional viewpoint of Knobos and DalNalten, however,
who had fought a steadily losing battle so long, the task was not too
difficult. Their forces were beautifully organized and synchronized;
they were present in such overwhelming numbers that “tails” could be
changed every fifteen seconds; long before anybody, however suspicious,
could begin to suspect any one shadow. Nor was it necessary for the
tails to signal each other, however inconspicuously, or to indicate
any suspect at change-over time. Lensed thoughts directed every move,
without confusion or error.

And there were tiny cameras with tremendous, protuberant lenses, the
“long eyes” capable of taking wire-sharp close ups from five hundred
feet; and other devices and apparatus and equipment too numerous to
mention here.

Thus the wholesalers were traced and their transactions with the retail
peddlers were recorded. And from that point on, even Jack Kinnison had
to admit that the sailing was clear. These small fry were not smart,
and their customers were even less so. None had screens or detectors
or other apparatus; their every transaction could be and was recorded
from a distance of many miles by the ultra-instruments of the Patrol.
And not only the transactions. Clearly, unmistakeably, the purchaser
was followed from buying to sniffing; nor was the time intervening
ever long. Thionite, then as now, was bought at retail only to use,
and the whole ghastly thing went down on tape and film. The gasping,
hysterical appeal; the exchange of currency for drug; the headlong rush
to a place of solitude; the rigid muscle-lock and the horribly ecstatic
transports; the shaken, soul-searing recovery or the entranced death.
It all went on record. It was sickening to have to record such things.
More than one observer did sicken in fact, and had to be relieved. But
Virgil Samms had to have concrete, positive, irrefutable evidence. He
got it. Any possible jury, upon seeing that evidence, would know it to
be the truth; no possible jury, after seeing that evidence, could bring
in any verdict other than “guilty”.

Oddly enough, Jack Kinnison was the only casualty of that long and
hectic day. A man–later proved to be a middle-sized potentate of the
underworld–who was not even under suspicion at the time, for some
reason or other got the idea that Jack was after him. The Lensman
had, perhaps, allowed some part of his long eye to show; a fast and
efficient long-range telephoto lens is a devilishly awkward thing to
conceal. At any rate the racketeer sent out a call for help, just
in case his bodyguards would not be enough, and in the meantime his
personal attendants rallied enthusiastically around.

They had two objects in view; One, to pass a knife expeditiously
and quietly through young Kinnison’s throat from ear to ear; and:
Two, to tear the long eye apart and subject a few square inches of
super-sensitive emulsion to the bright light of day. And if the Big
Shot had known that the photographer was not alone, that the big,
hulking bruiser a few feet away was also a bull, they might have

Two of the four hoods reached Jack just fractionally ahead of the
other two; one to seize the camera, the other to swing the knife.
But Jack Kinnison was fast; fast of brain and nerve and muscle. He
saw them coming. In three flashing motions he bent the barrel of the
telephoto into a neat arc around the side of the first man’s head,
ducked frantically under the fiercely-driven knife, and drove the toe
of his boot into the spot upon which prize-fighters like to have their
rabbit-punches land. Both of those attackers lost interest promptly.
One of them lost interest permanently; for a telephoto lens in barrel
is heavy, very rigid, and very, very hard.

While Battling Jack was still off balance, the other two guards
arrived–but so did Mason Northrop. Mase was not quite as fast as Jack
was; but, as has been pointed out, he was bigger and much stronger.
When he hit a man, with either hand, that man dropped. It was the same
as being on the receiving end of the blow of a twenty-pound hammer
falling through a distance of ninety seven and one-half feet.

The Lensmen had of course also yelled for help, and it took only a
split second for a Patrol speedster to travel from any given point to
any other in the same county. It took no time at all for that speedster
to fill a couple of square blocks with patterns of force through which
neither bullets nor beams could be driven. Therefore the battle ended
as suddenly as it began; before more thugs, with their automatics and
portables, could reach the scene.

Kinnison fils cursed and damned fulminantly the edict which had
forbidden arms that day, and swore that he would never get out of bed
again without strapping on at least two blasters; but he had to admit
finally that he had nothing to squawk about. Kinnison pere explained
quite patiently–for him–that all he had got out of the little fracas
was a split lip, that young Northrop’s hair wasn’t even mussed, and
that if everybody had been packing guns some scatter-brained young damn
fool like him would have started blasting and blown everything higher
than up–would have spoiled Samms’ whole operation maybe beyond repair.
Now would he please quit bellyaching and get to hell out?

He got.

“That buttons thionite up, don’t you think?” Rod Kinnison asked. “And
the lawyers will have plenty of time to get the case licked into shape
and lined up for trial.”

“Yes and no.” Samms frowned in thought. “The evidence is complete,
from original producer to ultimate consumer; but our best guess is that
it will take years to get the really important offenders behind bars.”

“Why? I thought you were giving them altogether too much time when you
scheduled the blow-off for three weeks ahead of election.”

“Because the drug racket is only a small part of it. We’re going
to break the whole thing at once, you know, and Mateese covers
a lot more ground–murder, kidnapping, bribery, corruption,
misfeasance–practically everything you can think of.”

“I know. What of it?”

“Jurisdiction, among other things. With the President, over half of the
Congress, much of the judiciary, and practically all of the political
bosses and police chiefs of the Continent under indictment at once, the
legal problem becomes incredibly difficult. The Patrol’s Department of
Law has been working on it twenty four hours a day, and the only thing
they seem sure of is a long succession of bitterly-contested points of
law. There are no precedents whatever.”

“Precedents be damned! They’re guilty and everybody knows it. We’ll
change the laws so that….”

“We will not!” Samms interrupted, sharply. “We want and we will have
government by law, not by men. We have had too much of that already.
Speed is not of the essence; justice very definitely is.”

“‘Crusader’ Samms, now and forever! But I’ll buy it, Virge–now let’s
get back down to earth. Operation Zwilnik is all set. Mateese is going
good. Zabriska tied into Zwilnik. That leaves Operation Boskone, which
is, I suppose, still getting nowhere fast.”

The First Lensman did not reply. It was, and both men knew it. The
shrewdest, most capable and experienced operatives of the Patrol
had hit that wall with everything they had, and had simply bounced.
Low-level trials had found no point of contact, no angle of approach.
Middle level, ditto. George Olmstead, working at the highest possible
level, was morally certain that he had found a point of contact, but
had not been able to do anything with it.

“How about calling a Council conference on it?” Kinnison asked finally.
“Or Bergenholm at least? Maybe he can get one of his hunches on it.”

“I have discussed it with them all, just as I have with you. No one had
anything constructive to offer, except to go ahead with Bennett as you
are doing. The concensus is that the Boskonians know just as much about
our military affairs as we know about theirs–no more.”

“It would be too much to expect them to be dumb enough to figure us
as dumb enough to depend only on our visible Grand Fleet, after the
warning they gave us at The Hill,” Kinnison admitted.

“Yes. What worries me most is that they had a running start.”

“Not enough to count,” the Port Admiral declared. “We can out-produce
’em and out-fight ’em.”

“Don’t be over-optimistic. You can’t deny them the possession of
brains, ability, man-power and resources at least equal to ours.”

“I don’t have to.” Kinnison remained obstinately cheerful. “Morale,
my boy, is what counts. Man-power and tonnage and fire-power are
important, of course, but morale has won every war in history. And our
morale right now is higher than a cat’s back–higher than any time
since John Paul Jones–and getting higher by the day.”

“Yes?” The question was monosyllabic but potent.

“Yes. I mean just that–yes. From what we know of their system they
can’t have the morale we’ve got. Anything they can do we can do more
of and better. What you’ve got, Virge, is a bad case of ingrowing
nerves. You’ve never been to Bennett, in spite of the number of times
I’ve asked you to. I say take time right now and come along–it’ll be
good for what ails you. It will also be a very fine thing for Bennett
and for the Patrol–you’ll find yourself no stranger there.”

“You may have something there … I’ll do it.”

Port Admiral and First Lensman went to Bennett, not in the Chicago
or other superdreadnaught, but in a two-man speedster. This was
necessary because space-travel, as far as that planet was concerned,
was a strictly one-way affair except for Lensmen. Only Lensmen could
leave Bennett, under any circumstances or for any reason whatever.
There was no out-going mail, express, or freight. Even the war-vessels
of the Fleet, while on practice maneuvers outside the bottle-tight
envelopes surrounding the system, were so screened that no unauthorized
communication could possibly be made.

“In other words,” Kinnison finished explaining, “we slapped on
everything anybody could think of, including Bergenholm and Rularion;
and believe me, brother, that was a lot of stuff.”

“But wouldn’t the very fact of such rigid restrictions operate against
morale? It is a truism of psychology that imprisonment, like everything
else, is purely relative.”

“Yeah, that’s what I told Rularion, except I used simpler and rougher
language. You know how sarcastic and superior he is, even when he’s

How I know!”

“Well, when he’s right he’s too damned insufferable for words. You’d’ve
thought he was talking to the prize boob of a class of half-wits.
As long as nobody on the planet knew that there was any such thing
as space-travel, or suspected that they were not the only form of
intelligent life in the universe, it was all right. No such concept
as being planet-bound could exist. They had all the room there was.
But after they met us, and digested all the implications, they would
develop the colly-wobbles no end. This, of course, is an extreme
simplification of the way the old coot poured it into me; but he came
through with the solution, so I took it like a little man.”

“What was the solution?”

“It’s a shame you were too busy to come in on it. You’ll see when we

But Virgil Samms was quick on the uptake. Even before they landed,
he understood. When the speedster slowed down for atmosphere he saw
blazoned upon the clouds a welter of one many-times repeated signal;
as they came to ground he saw that the same set of symbols was
repeated, not only upon every available cloud, but also upon airships,
captive balloons, streamers, roofs and sides of buildings–even, in
multi-colored rocks and flower-beds, upon the ground itself.

“Twenty Haress,” Samms translated, and frowned in thought. “A date of
the Bennettan year. Would it by any chance happen to coincide with our
Tellurian November fourteenth of this present year?”

“Bright boy!” Kinnison applauded. “I thought you’d get it, but not so
fast. Yes–election day.”

“I see. They know what is going on, then?”

“Everything that counts. They know what we stand to win–and lose.
They’ve named it Liberation Day, and everything on the planet is
building up to it in a grand crescendo. I was a little afraid of it at
first, but if the screens are really tight it won’t make any difference
how many people know it, and if they aren’t the beans would all be
spilled anyway. And it really works–I get a bigger thrill every time I
come here.”

“I can see where it might work.”

Bennett was a fully Tellurian world in mass, in atmosphere and in
climate; her native peoples were human to the limit of classification,
both physically and mentally. And First Lensman Samms, as he toured it
with his friend, found a world aflame with a zeal and an ardor unknown
to blase Earth since the days of the Crusades. The Patrol’s cleverest
and shrewdest psychologists, by merely sticking to the truth, had done
a marvelous job.

Bennett knew that it was the Arsenal and the Navy Yard of Civilization,
and it was proud of it. Its factories were humming as they had never
hummed before; every industry, every business, every farm was operating
at one hundred percent of capacity. Bennett was dotted and spattered
with spaceports already built, and hundreds more were being rushed to
completion. The already staggering number of ships of war operating out
of those ports was being augmented every hour by more and ever more
ultra-modern, ultra-fast, ultra-powerful shapes.

It was an honor to help build those ships; it was a still greater one
to help man them. Competitive examinations were being held constantly,
nor were all or even most of the applicants native Bennettans.

Samms did not have to ask where these young people were coming
from. He knew. From all the planets of Civilization, attracted by
carefully-worded advertisements of good jobs at high pay on new and
highly secret projects on newly discovered planets. There were hundreds
of such ads. Most were probably the Patrol’s, and led here; many were
of Spaceways, Uranium Incorporated, and other mercantile firms. The
possibility that some of them might lead to what was now being called
Boskonia had been tested thoroughly, but with uniformly negative
results. Lensmen had applied by scores for those non-Patrol jobs and
had found them bona-fide. The conclusion was unavoidable–Boskone was
doing its recruiting on planets unknown to any wearer of Arisia’s Lens.
On the other hand, more than a trickle of Boskonians were applying for
Patrol jobs, but Samms was almost certain that none had been accepted.
The final screening was done by Lensmen, and in such matters Lensmen
did not make many or serious mistakes.

Bennett had been informed of the First Lensman’s arrival, and Kinnison
had been guilty of a gross understatement indeed in telling Samms that
he would not be regarded as a stranger. Wherever Samms went he was met
by wildly enthusiastic crowds. He had to make speeches, each of which
was climaxed by a tremendous roar of “TO LIBERATION DAY!”

“No Lensman material here, you say, Rod?” Samms asked, after the
first city-shaking demonstration was over. One of his prime concerns,
throughout his life, was this. “With all this enthusiasm? Sure?”

“We haven’t found any good enough to refer to you yet. However, in
a few years, when the younger generation gets a little older, there
certainly will be.”

“Check.” The tour of inspection and acquaintance was finished, the two
Lensmen started back to Earth.

“Well, my skeptical and pessimistic friend, was I lying, or not?”
Kinnison asked, as soon as the speedster’s ports were sealed. “Can they
match that or not?”

“You weren’t–and I don’t believe they can. I have never seen anything
like it. Autocracies have parades and cheers and demonstrations, of
course, but they have always been forced–artificial. Those were

“Not only that, but the enthusiasm will carry through. We’ll be piping
hot and ready to go. But about this stumping–you said I’d better start
as soon as we get back?”

“Within a few days, I’d say.”

“I wouldn’t wonder, so let’s use this time in working out a plan of
campaign. My idea is to start out like this….”


Conway Costigan, leaving behind him scores of clues, all highly
misleading, severed his connection with Uranium, Inc. as soon as he
dared after Operation Zwilnik had been brought to a successful close.
The technical operation, that is; the legal battles in which it figured
so largely were to run on for enough years to make the word “zwilnik”
a common noun and adjective in the language.

He came to Tellus as unobtrusively as was his wont, and took an
inconspicuous but very active part in Operation Mateese, now in full

“Now is the time for all good men and true to come to the aid of the
party, eh?” Clio Costigan giggled.

“You can play that straight across the keyboard of your electric, pet,
and not with just two fingers, either. Did you hear what the boss told
’em today?”

“Yes.” The girl’s levity disappeared. “They’re so dirty, Spud–I’m
really afraid.”

“So am I. But we’re not too lily-fingered ourselves if we have to be,
and we’re covering ’em like a blanket–Kinnison and Samms both.”


“And in that connection, I’ll have to be out half the night again
tonight. All right?”

“Of course. It’s so nice having you home at all, darling, instead of a
million light-years away, that I’m practically delirious with delight.”

It was sometimes hard to tell what impish Mrs. Costigan meant by what
she said. Costigan looked at her, decided she was taking him for a
ride, and smacked her a couple of times where it would do the most
good. He then kissed her thoroughly and left. He had very little time,
these days, either to himself or for his lovely and adored wife.

For Roderick Kinnison’s campaign, which had started out rough and
not too clean, became rougher and rougher, and no cleaner, as it
went along. Morgan and his crew were swinging from the heels, with
everything and anything they could dig up or invent, however little
of truth or even of plausibility it might contain, and Rod the Rock
had never held even in principle with the gentle precept of turning
the other cheek. He was rather an Old Testamentarian, and he was no
neophyte at dirty fighting. As a young operative, skilled in the
punishing, maiming techniques of hand-to-hand rough-and-tumble combat,
he had brawled successfully in most of the dives of most of the
solarian planets and of most of their moons. With this background,
and being a quick study, and under the masterly coaching of Virgil
Samms, Nels Bergenholm, and Rularion of North Polar Jupiter, it did
not take him long to learn the various gambits and ripostes of this
non-physical, but nevertheless no-holds-barred, political mayhem.

And the “boys and girls” of the Patrol worked like badgers, digging up
an item here and a fact there and a bit of information somewhere else,
all for the day of reckoning which was to come. They used ultra-wave
scanners, spy-rays, long eyes, stool-pigeons–everything they could
think of to use–and they could not always be blocked out or evaded.

“We’ve got it, boss–now let’s use it!”

“No. Save it! Nail it down, solid! Get the facts–names, dates, places,
and amounts. Prove it first–then save it!”

Prove it! Save it! The joint injunction was used so often that it
came to be a slogan and was accepted as such. Unlike most slogans,
however, it was carefully and diligently put to use. The operatives
proved it and saved it, over and over, over and over again; by dint of
what unsparing effort and selfless devotion only they themselves ever
fully knew.

Kinnison stumped the Continent. He visited every state, all of the
big cities, most of the towns, and many villages and hamlets; and
always, wherever he went, a part of the show was to demonstrate to his
audiences how the Lens worked.

“Look at me. You know that no two individuals are or ever can be alike.
Robert Johnson is not like Fred Smith; Joe Jones is entirely different
from John Brown. Look at me again. Concentrate upon whatever it is in
your mind that makes me Roderick Kinnison, the individual. That will
enable each of you to get into as close touch with me as though our
two minds were one. I am not talking now; you are reading my mind.
Since you are reading my very mind, you know exactly what I am really
thinking, for better or for worse. It is impossible for my mind to
lie to yours, since I can change neither the basic pattern of my
personality nor my basic way of thought; nor would I if I could. Being
in my mind, you know that already; you know what my basic quality is.
My friends call it strength and courage; Pirate Chief Morgan and his
cut-throat crew call it many other things. Be that as it may, you now
know whether or not you want me for your President. I can do nothing
whatever to sway your opinion, for what your minds have perceived you
know to be the truth. That is the way the Lens works. It bares the
depths of my mind to yours, and in return enables me to understand your

“But it is in no sense hypnotism, as Morgan is so foolishly trying to
make you believe. Morgan knows as well as the rest of us do that even
the most accomplished hypnotist, with all his apparatus, CAN NOT AFFECT
A STRONG AND DEFINITELY OPPOSED WILL. He is therefore saying that each
and every one of you now receiving this thought is such a spineless
weakling that–but you may draw your own conclusions.

“In closing, remember–nail this fact down so solidly that you will
never forget it–a sound and healthy mind CAN NOT LIE. The mouth can,
and does. So does the typewriter. But the mind–NEVER! I can hide
my thoughts from you, even while we are en rapport, like this …
but I CAN NOT LIE TO YOU. That is why, some day, all of your highest
executives will have to be Lensmen, and not politicians, diplomats,
crooks and boodlers. I thank you.”

As that long, bitter, incredibly vicious campaign neared its vitriolic
end tension mounted higher and ever higher: and in a room in the Samms
home three young Lensmen and a red-haired girl were not at ease. All
four were lean and drawn. Jack Kinnison was talking.

“… not the party, so much, but Dad. He started out with bare fists,
and now he’s wading into ’em with spiked brass knuckles.”

“You can play that across the board,” Costigan agreed.

“He’s really giving ’em hell,” Northrop said, admiringly.

“Did you boys listen in on his Casper speech last night?”

They hadn’t; they had been too busy.

“I could give it to you on your Lenses, but I couldn’t reproduce the
tone–the exquisite way he lifted large pieces of hide and rubbed
salt into the raw places. When he gets excited you know he can’t help
but use voice, too, so I got some of it on a record. He starts out
on voice, nice and easy, as usual; then goes onto his Lens without
talking; then starts yelling as well as thinking. Listen:”

“You ought to have a Lensman president. You may not believe that any
Lensman is, and as a matter of fact must be incorruptible. That is
my belief, as you can feel for yourselves, but I cannot prove it to
you. Only time can do that. It is a self-evident fact, however, which
you can feel for yourselves, that a Lensman president could not lie to
you except by word of mouth or in writing. You could demand from him
at any time a Lensed statement upon any subject. Upon some matters of
state he could and should refuse to answer; but not upon any question
involving moral turpitude. If he answered, you would know the truth. If
he refused to answer, you would know why and could initiate impeachment
proceedings then and there.

“In the past there have been presidents who used that high office for
low purposes; whose very memory reeks of malfeasance and corruption.
One was impeached, others should have been. Witherspoon never should
have been elected. Witherspoon should have been impeached the day after
he was inaugurated. Witherspoon should be impeached now. We know, and
at the Grand Rally at New York Spaceport three weeks from tonight
we are going to PROVE, that Witherspoon is simply a minor cog-wheel
in the Morgan-Towne-Isaacson machine, ‘playing footsie’ at command
with whatever group happens to be the highest bidder at the moment,
irrespective of North America’s or the System’s good. Witherspoon is a
gangster, a cheat, and a God damn liar, but he is of very little actual
importance; merely a boodling nincompoop. Morgan is the real boss and
the real menace, the Operating Engineer of the lowest-down, lousiest,
filthiest, rottenest, most corrupt machine of murderers, extortionists,
bribe-takers, panderers, perjurers, and other pimples on the body
politic that has ever disgraced any so-called civilized government.
Good night.”

“Wow!” Jack Kinnison yelped. “That’s high, even for him!”

“Just a minute, Jack,” Jill cautioned. “The other side, too. Listen to
this choice bit from Senator Morgan.”

“It is not exactly hypnotism, but something infinitely worse; something
that steals away your very minds; that makes anyone listening believe
that white is yellow, red, purple, or pea-green. Until our scientists
have checked this menace, until we have every wearer of that cursed
Lens behind steel bars, I advise you in all earnestness not to listen
to them at all. If you do listen your minds will surely be insidiously
decomposed and broken; you will surely end your days gibbering in a
padded cell.

“And murders? Murders! The feeble remnants of the gangs which our
government has all but wiped out may perhaps commit a murder or so per
year; the perpetrators of which are caught, tried, and punished. But
how many of your sons and daughters has Roderick Kinnison murdered,
either personally or through his uniformed slaves? Think! Read the
record! Then make him explain, if he can; but do not listen to his
lying, mind-destroying Lens.

“Democracy? Bah! What does ‘Rod the Rock’ Kinnison–the hardest, most
vicious tyrant, the most relentless and pitiless martinet ever known to
any Armed Force in the long history of our world–know of democracy?
Nothing! He understands only force. All who oppose him in anything,
however small, or who seek to reason with him, die without record or
trace; and if he is not arrested, tried, and executed, all such will
continue, tracelessly and without any pretense of trial, to die.

“But at bottom, even though he is not intelligent enough to realize
it, he is merely one more in the long parade of tools of ruthless
and predatory wealth, the MONIED POWERS. They, my friends, never
sleep; they have only one God, one tenet, one creed–the almighty
CREDIT. That is what they are after, and note how craftily, how
stealthily, they have done and are doing their grabbing. Where is
your representation upon that so-called Galactic Council? How did
this criminal, this vicious, this outrageously unconstitutional, this
irresponsible, uncontrollable, and dictatorial monstrosity come into
being? How and when did you give this bloated colossus the right to
establish its own currency–to have the immeasurable effrontery to
debar the solidest currency in the universe, the credit of North
America, from inter-planetary and inter-stellar commerce? Their aim is
clear; they intend to tax you into slavery and death. Do not forget for
one instant, my friends, that the power to tax is the power to destroy.
THE POWER TO TAX IS THE POWER TO DESTROY. Our forefathers fought and
bled and died to establish the principle that taxation without rep….”

“And so on, for one solid hour!” Jill snarled, as she snapped the
switch viciously. “How do you like them potatoes?”

“Hell’s–Blazing–Pinnacles!” This from Jack, silent for seconds, and:

“Rugged stuff … very, very rugged,” from Northrop. “No wonder you
look sort of pooped, Spud. Being Chief Bodyguard must have developed
recently into quite a chore.”

“You ain’t just snapping your choppers, bub,” was Costigan’s grimly
flippant reply. “I’ve yelled for help–in force.”

“So have I, and I’m going to yell again, right now,” Jack declared. “I
don’t know whether Dad is going to kill Morgan or not–and don’t give
a damn–but if Morgan isn’t going all out to kill Dad it’s because
they’ve forgotten how to make bombs.”

He Lensed a call to Bergenholm.

“Yes, Jack?… I will refer you to Rularion, who has had this matter
under consideration.”

“Yes, John Kinnison, I have considered the matter and have taken
action,” the Jovian’s calmly assured thought rolled into the minds of
all, even Lensless Jill’s. “The point, youth, was well taken. It was
your thought that some thousands–perhaps five–of spy-ray operators
and other operatives will be required to insure that the Grand Rally
will not be marred by episodes of violence.”

“It was,” Jack said, flatly. “It still is.”

“Not having considered all possible contingencies nor the extent of
the field of necessary action, you err. The number will approach
nineteen thousand very nearly. Admiral Clayton has been so advised and
his staff is now at work upon a plan of action in accordance with my
recommendation. Your suggestions, Conway Costigan, in the matter of
immediate protection of Roderick Kinnison’s person, are now in effect,
and you are hereby relieved of that responsibility. I assume that you
four wish to continue at work?”

The Jovian’s assumption was sound.

“I suggest, then, that you confer with Admiral Clayton and fit
yourselves into his program of security. I intend to make the same
suggestion to all Lensmen and other qualified persons not engaged in
work of more pressing importance.”

Rularion cut off and Jack scowled blackly. “The Grand Rally is going to
be held three weeks before election day. I still don’t like it. I’d
save it until the night before election–knock their teeth out with it
at the last possible minute.”

“You’re wrong, Jack; the Chief is right,” Costigan argued. “Two ways.
One, we can’t play that kind of ball. Two, this gives them just enough
rope to hang themselves.”

“Well … maybe.” Kinnison-like, Jack was far from being convinced.
“But that’s the way it’s going to be, so let’s call Clayton.”

“First,” Costigan broke in. “Jill, will you please explain why they
have to waste as big a man as Kinnison on such a piffling job as
president? I was out in the sticks, you know–it doesn’t make sense.”

“Because he’s the only man alive who can lick Morgan’s machine at the
polls,” Jill stated a simple fact. “The Patrol can get along without
him for one term, after that it won’t make any difference.”

“But Morgan works from the side-lines. Why couldn’t he?”

“The psychology is entirely different. Morgan is a boss. Pops
Kinnison isn’t. He’s a leader. See?”

“Oh … I guess so…. Yes. Go ahead.”

Outwardly, New York Spaceport did not change appreciably. At any
given moment of day or night there were so many hundreds of persons
strolling aimlessly or walking purposefully about that an extra hundred
or so made no perceptible difference. And the spaceport was only the
end-point. The Patrol’s activities began hundreds or thousands or
millions or billions of miles away from Earth’s metropolis.

A web was set up through which not even a grain-of-sand meteorite could
pass undetected. Every space-ship bound for Earth carried at least one
passenger who would not otherwise have been aboard; passengers who, if
not wearing Lenses, carried Service Special equipment amply sufficient
for the work in hand. Geigers and other vastly more complicated
mechanisms flew toward Earth from every direction in space; streamed
toward New York in Earth’s every channel of traffic. Every train and
plane, every bus and boat and car, every conveyance of every kind and
every pedestrian approaching New York City was searched; with a search
as thorough as it was unobtrusive. And every thing and every entity
approaching New York Spaceport was combed, literally by the cubic

No arrests were made. No package was confiscated, or even disturbed,
throughout the ranks of public check boxes, in private offices, or
in elaborate or casual hiding-places. As far as the enemy knew, the
Patrol had no suspicion whatever that anything out of the ordinary was
going on. That is, until the last possible minute. Then a tall, lean,
space-tanned veteran spoke softly aloud, as though to himself:

“Spy-ray blocks–interference–umbrella–on. Report.”

That voice, low and soft as it was, was picked up by every Service
Special receiver within a radius of a thousand miles, and by every
Lensman listening, wherever he might be. So were, in a matter of
seconds, the replies.

“Spy-ray blocks on, sir.”

“Interference on, sir.”

“Umbrella on, sir.”

No spy-ray could be driven into any part of the tremendous port. No
beam, communicator or detonating, could operate anywhere near it. The
enemy would now know that something had gone wrong, but he would not be
able to do anything about it.

“Reports received,” the tanned man said, still quietly. “Operation Zunk
will proceed as scheduled.”

And four hundred seventy one highly skilled men, carrying duplicate
keys and/or whatever other specialized apparatus and equipment would be
necessary, quietly took possession of four hundred seventy one objects,
of almost that many shapes and sizes. And, out in the gathering crowd,
a few disturbances occurred and a few ambulances dashed busily here and
there. Some women had fainted, no doubt, ran the report. They always

And Conway Costigan, who had been watching, without seeming even to
look at him, a porter loading a truck with opulent-looking hand-luggage
from a locker, followed man and truck out into the concourse. Closing
up, he asked:

“Where are you taking that baggage, Charley?”

“Up Ramp One, boss,” came the unflurried reply. “Flight Ninety will be
late taking off, on accounta this jamboree, and they want it right up
there handy.”

“Take it down to the….”

Over the years a good many men had tried to catch Conway Costigan off
guard or napping, to beat him to the punch or to the draw–with a
startlingly uniform lack of success. The Lensman’s fist traveled a bare
seven inches: the supposed porter gasped once and traveled–or rather,
staggered backward–approximately seven feet before he collapsed and
sprawled unconscious upon the pavement.

“Decontamination,” Costigan remarked, apparently to empty air, as
he picked the fellow up and draped him limply over the truckful
of suitcases. “Deke. Front and center. Area forty-six. Class
Eff-ex–hotter than the middle tailrace of hell.”

“You called Deke?” A man came running up. “Eff-ex six–nineteen. This

“Check. It’s yours, porter and all. Take it away.”

Costigan strolled on until he met Jack Kinnison, who had a
rapidly-developing mouse under his left eye.

“How did that happen, Jack?” he demanded sharply. “Something slip?”

“Not exactly.” Kinnison grinned ruefully. “I have the damndest luck!
A woman–an old lady at that–thought I was staging a hold-up and swung
on me with her hand-bag–southpaw and from the rear. And if you laugh,
you untuneful harp, I’ll hang one right on the end of your chin, so
help me!”

“Far be it from such,” Costigan assured him, and did not–quite–laugh.
“Wonder how we came out? They should have reported before
this–p-s-s-t! Here it comes!”

Decontamination was complete; Operation Zunk had been a
one-hundred-percent success; there had been no casualties.

“Except for one black eye,” Costigan could not help adding; but his
Lens and his Service Specials were off. Jack would have brained him if
any of them had been on.

Linking arms, the two young Lensmen strode away toward Ramp Four, which
was to be their station.

This was the largest crowd Earth had ever known. Everybody,
particularly the Nationalists, had wondered why this climactic
political rally had been set for three full weeks ahead of the
election, but their curiosity had not been satisfied. Furthermore, this
meeting had been advertised as no previous one had ever been; neither
pains nor cash had been spared in giving it the greatest build-up ever
known. Not only had every channel of communication been loaded for
weeks, but also Samms’ workers had been very busily engaged in starting
rumors; which grew, as rumors do, into things which their own fathers
and mothers could not recognize. And the baffled Nationalists, trying
to play the whole thing down, made matters worse. Interest spread from
North America to the other continents, to the other planets, and to the
other solar systems.

Thus, to say that everybody was interested in, and was listening to,
the Cosmocrats’ Grand Rally would not be too serious an exaggeration.

Roderick Kinnison stepped up to the battery of microphones; certain
screens were cut.

“Fellow entities of Civilization and others: while it may seem strange
to broadcast a political rally to other continents and to beam it to
other worlds, it was necessary in this case. The message to be given,
while it will go into the political affairs of the North American
Continent of Tellus, will deal primarily with a far larger thing; a
matter which will be of paramount importance to all intelligent beings
of every inhabited world. You know how to attune your minds to mine. Do
it now.”

He staggered mentally under the shock of encountering practically
simultaneously so many minds, but rallied strongly and went on, via

“My first message is not to you, my fellow Cosmocrats, nor to you,
my fellow dwellers on Earth, nor even to you, my fellow adherents to
Civilization; but to THE ENEMY. I do not mean my political opponents,
the Nationalists, who are almost all loyal fellow North Americans. I
mean the entities who are using the leaders of that Nationalist party
as pawns in a vastly larger game.

“I know, ENEMY, that you are listening. I know that you had goon
squads in this audience, to kill me and my superior officer. Know
now that they are impotent. I know that you had atomic bombs, with
which to obliterate this assemblage and this entire area. They have
been disassembled and stored. I know that you had large supplies of
radio-active dusts. They now lie in the Patrol vaults near Weehauken.
All the devices which you intended to employ are known, and all save
one have been either nullified or confiscated.

“That one exception is your war-fleet, a force sufficient in your
opinion to wipe out all the Armed Forces of the Galactic Patrol. You
intended to use it in case we Cosmocrats win this forthcoming election;
you may decide to use it now. Do so if you like; you can do nothing to
interrupt or to affect this meeting. This is all I have to say to you,
Enemy of Civilization.

“Now to you, my legitimate audience. I am not here to deliver the
address promised you, but merely to introduce the real speaker–First
Lensman Virgil Samms….”

A mental gasp, millions strong, made itself tellingly felt.

“… Yes–First Lensman Samms, of whom you all know. He has not been
attending political meetings because we, his advisers, would not
let him. Why? Here are the facts. Through Archibald Isaacson, of
Interstellar Spaceways, he was offered a bribe which would in a few
years have amounted to some fifty billion credits; more wealth than
any individual entity has ever possessed. Then there was an attempt at
murder, which we were able–just barely–to block. Knowing there was no
other place on Earth where he would be safe, we took him to The Hill.
You know what happened; you know what condition The Hill is in now.
This warfare was ascribed to pirates.

“The whole stupendous operation, however, was made in a vain attempt to
kill one man–Virgil Samms. The Enemy knew, and we learned, that Samms
is the greatest man who has ever lived. His name will last as long as
Civilization endures, for it is he, and only he, who can make it
possible for Civilization to endure.

“Why was I not killed? Why was I allowed to keep on making campaign
speeches? Because I do not count. I am of no more importance to the
cause of Civilization than is my opponent Witherspoon to that of the

“I am a wheel-horse, a plugger. You all know me–‘Rocky Rod’ Kinnison,
the hard-boiled egg. I’ve got guts enough to stand up and fight for
what I know is right. I’ve got the guts and the inclination to stand
up and slug it out, toe to toe, with man, beast, or devil. I would make
and WILL MAKE a good president; I’ve got the guts and inclination to
keep on slugging after you elect me; before God I promise to smash down
every machine-made crook who tries to hold any part of our government
down in the reeking muck in which it now is.

“I am a plugger and a slugger, with no spark of the terrific flame of
inspirational genius which makes Virgil Samms what he so uniquely is.
My kind may be important, but I individually am not. There are so
many of us! If they had killed me another slugger would have taken my
place and the effect upon the job would have been nil.

“Virgil Samms, however, can not be replaced and the Enemy knows
it. He is unique in all history. No one else can do his job. If he
is killed before the principles for which he is working are firmly
established Civilization will collapse back into barbarism. It will not
recover until another such mind comes into existence, the probability
of which occurrence I will let you compute for yourselves.

“For those reasons Virgil Samms is not here in person. Nor is he in
The Hill, since the Enemy may now possess weapons powerful enough to
destroy not only that hitherto impregnable fortress, but also the whole
Earth. And they would destroy Earth, without a qualm, if in so doing
they could kill the First Lensman.

“Therefore Samms is now out in deep space. Our fleet is waiting to
be attacked. If we win, the Galactic Patrol will go on. If we lose,
we hope you shall have learned enough so that we will not have died

“Die? Why should you die? You are safe on Earth!”

“Ah, one of the goons sent that thought. If our fleet is defeated no
Lensman, anywhere, will live a week. The Enemy will see to that.

“That is all from me. Stay tuned. Come in, First Lensman Virgil
Samms … take over, sir.”

It was psychologically impossible for Virgil Samms to use such language
as Kinnison had just employed. Nor was it either necessary or desirable
that he should; the ground had been prepared. Therefore–coldly,
impersonally, logically, tellingly–he told the whole terrific
story. He revealed the most important things dug up by the Patrols’
indefatigable investigators, reciting names, places, dates,
transactions, and amounts. Only in the last couple of minutes did he
warm up at all.

“Nor is this in any sense a smear campaign or a bringing of baseless
charges to becloud the issue or to vilify without cause and upon the
very eve of election a political opponent. These are facts. Formal
charges are now being preferred; every person mentioned, and many
others, will be put under arrest as soon as possible. If any one of
them were in any degree innocent our case against him could be made to
fall in less than the three weeks intervening before election day. That
is why this meeting is being held at this time.

“Not one of them is innocent. Being guilty, and knowing that we can and
will prove guilt, they will adopt a policy of delay and recrimination.
Since our courts are, for the most part, just, the accused will be able
to delay the trials and the actual presentation of evidence until after
election day. Forewarned, however, you will know exactly why the trials
will have been delayed, and in spite of the fog of misrepresentation
you will know where the truth lies. You will know how to cast your
votes. You will vote for Roderick Kinnison and for those who support

“There is no need for me to enlarge upon the character of Port Admiral
Kinnison. You know him as well as I do. Honest, incorruptible,
fearless, you know that he will make the best president we have ever
had. If you do not already know it, ask any one of the hundreds of
thousands of strong, able, clear-thinking young men and women who have
served under him in our Armed Forces.

“I thank you, everyone who has listened, for your interest.”


As long as they were commodores, Clayton of North America and
Schweikert of Europe had stayed fairly close to the home planet except
for infrequent vacation trips. With the formation of the Galactic
Patrol, however, and their becoming Admiral and Lieutenant-Admiral of
the First Galactic Region, and their acquisition of Lenses, the radius
of their sphere of action was tremendously increased. One or the other
of them was always to be found in Grand Fleet Headquarters at New
York Spaceport, but only very seldom were both of them there at once.
And if the absentee were not to be found on Earth, what of it? The
First Galactic Region included all of the solar systems and all of the
planets adherent to Civilization, and the absentee could, as a matter
of business and duty, be practically anywhere.

Usually, however, he was not upon any of the generally-known planets,
but upon Bennett–getting acquainted with the officers, supervising
the drilling of Grand Fleet in new maneuvers, teaching classes in
advanced strategy, and holding skull-practice generally. It was hard
work, and not too inspiring, but in the end it paid off big. They knew
their men; their men knew them. They could work together with a snap, a
smoothness, a precision otherwise impossible; for imported top brass,
unknown to and unacquainted with the body of command, can not have and
does not expect the deep regard and the earned respect so necessary to
high morale.

Clayton and Schweikert had both. They started early enough, worked
hard enough, and had enough stuff, to earn both. Thus it came about
that when, upon a scheduled day, the two admirals came to Bennett
together, they were greeted as enthusiastically as though they had
been Bennettans born and bred; and their welcome became a planet-wide
celebration when Clayton issued the orders which all Bennett had been
waiting so long and so impatiently to hear. Bennettans were at last to
leave Bennett!

Group after group, sub-fleet after sub-fleet, the component units of
the Galactic Patrol’s Grand Fleet took off. They assembled in space;
they maneuvered enough to shake themselves down into some semblance of
unity; they practiced the new maneuvers; they blasted off in formation
for Sol. And as the tremendous armada neared the Solar System it
met–or, rather, was joined by–the Patrol ships about which Morgan
and his minions already knew; each of which fitted itself into its
long-assigned place. Every planet of Civilization had sent its every
vessel capable of putting out a screen or of throwing a beam, but so
immense was the number of warships in Grand Fleet that this increment,
great as it intrinsically was, made no perceptible difference in its

On Rally Day Grand Fleet lay poised near Earth. As soon as he had
introduced Samms to the intensely interested listeners at the Rally,
Roderick Kinnison disappeared. Actually, he drove a bug to a distant
corner of the spaceport and left the Earth in a light cruiser, but to
all intents and purposes, so engrossed was everyone in what Samms was
saying, Kinnison simply vanished. Samms was already in the Boise; the
Port Admiral went out to his old flagship, the Chicago. Nor, in case
any observer of the Enemy should be trying to keep track of him, could
his course be traced. Cleveland and Northrop and Rularion and all they
needed of the vast resources of the Patrol saw to that.

Neither Samms nor Kinnison had any business being with Grand Fleet in
person, of course, and both knew it; but everyone knew why they were
there and were glad that the two top Lensmen had decided to live or
die with their Fleet. If Grand Fleet won, they would probably live; if
Grand Fleet lost they would certainly die–if not in the pyrotechnic
dissolution of their ships, then in a matter of days upon the ground.
With the Fleet their presence would contribute markedly to morale. It
was a chance very much worth taking.

Nor were Clayton and Schweikert together, or even near each other.
Samms, Kinnison, and the two admirals were as far away from each other
as they could get and still remain in Grand Fleet’s fighting cylinder.

Cylinder? Yes. The Patrol’s Board of Strategy, assuming that the enemy
would attack in conventional cone formation and knowing that one cone
could defeat another only after a long and costly engagement, had long
since spent months and months at war-games in their tactical tanks,
in search of a better formation. They had found it. Theoretically,
a cylinder of proper composition could defeat, with negligible loss
and in a very short time, the best cones they were able to devise.
The drawback was that the ships composing a theoretically efficient
cylinder would have to be highly specialized and vastly greater in
number than any one power had ever been able to put into the ether.
However, with all the resources of Bennett devoted to construction,
this difficulty would not be insuperable.

This, of course, brought up the question of what would happen if
cylinder met cylinder–if the Black strategists should also have
arrived at the same solution–and this question remained unanswered.
Or, rather, there were too many answers, no two of which agreed; like
those to the classical one of what would happen if an irresistible
force should strike an immovable object. There would be a lot of
intensely interesting by-products!

Even Rularion of Jove did not come up with a definite solution.
Nor did Bergenholm; who, although a comparatively obscure young
Lensman-scientist and not a member of the Galactic Council, was
frequently called into consultation because of his unique ability to
arrive at correct conclusions via some obscurely short-circuiting
process of thought.

“Well,” Port Admiral Kinnison had concluded, finally, “If they’ve got
one, too, we’ll just have to shorten ours up, widen it out, and pray.”

“Clayton to Port Admiral Kinnison,” came a communication through
channels. “Have you any additional orders or instructions?”

“Kinnison to Admiral Clayton. None,” the Port Admiral replied, as
formally, then went on via Lens: “No comment or criticism to make,
Alex. You fellows have done a job so far and you’ll keep on doing one.
How much detection have you got out?”

“Twelve detets–three globes of diesels. If we sit here and do nothing
the boys will get edgy and go stale, so if you and Virge agree we’ll
give ’em some practice. Lord knows they need it, and it’ll keep ’em on
their toes. But about the Blacks–they may be figuring on delaying any
action until we’ve had time to crack from boredom. What’s your idea on

“I’ve been worried about the same thing. Practice will help, but
whether enough or not I don’t know. What do you think, Virge? Will they
hold it up deliberately or strike fast?”

“Fast,” the First Lensman replied, promptly and definitely. “As soon
as they possibly can, for several reasons. They don’t know our real
strength, any more than we know theirs. They undoubtedly believe,
however, the same as we do, that they are more efficient than we are
and have the larger force. By their own need of practice they will know
ours. They do not attach nearly as much importance to morale as we do;
by the very nature of their regime they can’t. Also, our open challenge
will tend very definitely to force their hands, since face-saving is
even more important to them than it is to us. They will strike as soon
as they can and as hard as they can.”

Grand Fleet maneuvers were begun, but in a day or so the alarms came
blasting in. The enemy had been detected; coming in, as the previous
Black Fleet had come, from the direction of Coma Berenices. Calculating
machines clicked and whirred; orders were flashed, and a brief string
of numbers; ships by the hundreds and the thousands flashed into their
assigned positions.

Or, more precisely, almost into them. Most of the navigators and
pilots had not had enough practice yet to hit their assigned positions
exactly on the first try, since a radical change in axial direction
was involved, but they did pretty well; a few minutes of juggling and
jockeying were enough. Clayton and Schweikert used a little caustic
language–via Lens and to their fellow Lensmen only, of course–but
Samms and Kinnison were well enough pleased. The time of formation had
been very satisfactorily short and the cone was smooth, symmetrical,
and of beautifully uniform density.

The preliminary formation was a cone, not a cylinder. It was not a
conventional Cone of Battle in that it was not of standard composition,
was too big, and had altogether too many ships for its size. It was,
however, of the conventional shape, and it was believed that by the
time the enemy could perceive any significant differences it would be
too late for him to do anything about it. The cylinder would be forming
about that time, anyway, and it was almost believed–at least it was
strongly hoped–that the enemy would not have the time or the knowledge
or the equipment to do anything about that, either.

Kinnison grinned to himself as his mind, en rapport with Clayton’s,
watched the enemy’s Cone of Battle enlarge upon the Admiral’s conning
plate. It was big, and powerful; the Galactic Patrol’s publicly-known
forces would have stood exactly the chance of the proverbial snowball
in the nether regions. It was not, however, the Port Admiral thought,
big enough to form an efficient cylinder, or to handle the Patrol’s
real force in any fashion–and unless they shifted within the next
second or two it would be too late for the enemy to do anything at all.

As though by magic about ninety-five percent of the Patrol’s tremendous
cone changed into a tightly-packed double cylinder. This maneuver
was much simpler than the previous one, and had been practiced to
perfection. The mouth of the cone closed in and lengthened; the closed
end opened out and shortened. Tractors and pressors leaped from ship to
ship, binding the whole myriad of hitherto discrete units into a single
structure as solid, even comparatively as to size, as a cantilever
bridge. And instead of remaining quiescent, waiting to be attacked, the
cylinder flashed forward, inertialess, at maximum blast.

Throughout the years the violence, intensity, and sheer brute power of
offensive weapons had increased steadily. Defensive armament had kept
step. One fundamental fact, however, had not changed throughout the
ages and has not changed yet. Three or more units of given power have
always been able to conquer one unit of the same power, if engagement
could be forced and no assistance could be given; and two units could
practically always do so. Fundamentally, therefore, strategy always
has been and still is the development of new artifices and techniques
by virtue of which two or more of our units may attack one of theirs;
the while affording the minimum of opportunity for them to retaliate in

The Patrol’s Grand Fleet flashed forward, almost exactly along the axis
of the Black cone; right where the enemy wanted it–or so he thought.
Straight into the yawning mouth, erupting now a blast of flame beside
which the wildest imaginings of Inferno must pale into insignificance;
straight along that raging axis toward the apex, at the terrific speed
of the two directly opposed velocities of flight. But, to the complete
consternation of the Black High Command, nothing much happened. For,
as has been pointed out, that cylinder was not of even approximately
normal composition. In fact, there was not a normal war-vessel in it.
The outer skin and both ends of the cylinder were purely defensive.
Those vessels, packed so closely that their repellor fields actually
touched, were all screen; none of them had a beam hot enough to light a
match. Conversely, the inner layer, or “Liner”, was composed of vessels
that were practically all offense. They had to be protected at every
point–but how they could ladle it out!

The leading and trailing edges of the formation–the ends of the
gigantic pipe, so to speak–would of course bear the brunt of the
Black attack, and it was this factor that had given the Patrol’s
strategists the most serious concern. Wherefore the first ten and
the last six double rings of ships were special indeed. They were
all screen–nothing else. They were drones, operated by remote
control, carrying no living thing. If the Patrol losses could be held
to eight double rings of ships at the first pass and four at the
second–theoretical computations indicated losses of six and two–Samms
and his fellows would be well content.

All of the Patrol ships had, of course, the standard equipment
of so-called “violet”, “green”, and “red” fields, as well as
duodecaplylatomate and ordinary atomic bombs, dirigible torpedoes
and transporters, slicers, polycyclic drills, and so on; but in this
battle the principal reliance was to be placed upon the sheer, brutal,
overwhelming power of what had been called the “macro beam”–now
simply the “beam”. Furthermore, in the incredibly incandescent frenzy
of the chosen field of action–the cylinder was to attack the cone
at its very strongest part–no conceivable material projectile could
have lasted a single microsecond after leaving the screens of force
of its parent vessel. It could have flown fast enough; ultra-beam
trackers could have steered it rapidly enough and accurately enough;
but before it could have traveled a foot, even at ultra-light speed,
it would have ceased utterly to be. It would have been resolved into
its sub-atomic constituent particles and waves. Nothing material could
exist, except instantaneously, in the field of force filling the axis
of the Black’s Cone of Battle; a field beside which the exact center of
a multi-billion-volt flash of lightning would constitute a dead area.

That field, however, encountered no material object. The Patrol’s
“screeners”, packed so closely as to have a four hundred percent
overlap, had been designed to withstand precisely that inconceivable
environment. Practically all of them withstood it. And in a fraction of
a second the hollow forward end of the cylinder engulfed, pipe-wise,
the entire apex of the enemy’s war-cone, and the hitherto idle
“sluggers” of the cylinder’s liner went to work.

Each of those vessels had one heavy pressor beam, each having the same
push as every other, directed inward, toward the cylinder’s axis, and
backward at an angle of fifteen degrees from the perpendicular line
between ship and axis. Therefore, wherever any Black ship entered the
Patrol’s cylinder or however, it was driven to and held at the axis and
forced backward along that axis. None of them, however, got very far.
They were perforce in single file; one ship opposing at least one solid
ring of giant sluggers who did not have to concern themselves with
defense, but could pour every iota of their tremendous resources into
offensive beams. Thus the odds were not merely two or three to one; but
never less than eighty, and very frequently over two hundred to one.

Under the impact of those unimaginable torrents of force the screens of
the engulfed vessels flashed once, practically instantaneously through
the spectrum, and went down. Whether they had two or three or four
courses made no difference–in fact, even the ultra-speed analyzers of
the observers could not tell. Then, a couple of microseconds later,
the wall-shields–the strongest fabrics of force developed by man up
to that time–also failed. Then those ravenous fields of force struck
bare, unprotected metal, and every molecule, inorganic and organic, of
ships and contents alike, disappeared in a bursting flare of energy so
raw and so violent as to stagger even those who had brought it into
existence. It was certainly vastly more than a mere volatilization; it
was deduced later that the detonating unstable isotopes of the Black’s
own bombs, in the frightful temperatures already existing in the
Patrol’s quasi-solid beams, had initiated a chain reaction which had
resulted in the fissioning of a considerable proportion of the atomic
nuclei of usually completely stable elements!

The cylinder stopped; the Lensmen took stock. The depth of erosion
of the leading edge had averaged almost exactly six double rings of
drones. In places the sixth ring was still intact; in others, which had
encountered unusually concentrated beaming, the seventh was gone. Also,
a fraction of one percent of the manned war-vessels had disappeared.
Brief though the time of engagement had been, the enemy had been able
to concentrate enough beams to burn a few holes through the walls of
the attacking cylinder.

It had not been hoped that more than a few hundreds of Black vessels
could be blown out of the ether at this first pass. General Staff
had been sure, however, that the heaviest and most dangerous ships,
including those carrying the enemy’s High Command, would be among them.
The mid-section of the apex of the conventional Cone of Battle had
always been the safest place to be; therefore that was where the Black
admirals had been and therefore they no longer lived.

In a few seconds it became clear that if any Black High Command
existed, it was not in shape to function efficiently. Some of the
enemy ships were still blasting, with little or no concerted effort,
at the regulation cone which the cylinder had left behind; a few were
attempting to get into some kind of a formation, possibly to attack the
Patrol’s cylinder. Indecision was visible and rampant.

To turn that tremendous cylindrical engine of destruction around would
have been a task of hours, but it was not necessary. Instead, each
vessel cut its tractors and pressors, spun end for end, reconnected,
and retraced almost exactly its previous course; cutting out and
blasting into nothingness another “plug” of Black warships. Another
reversal, another dash; and this time, so disorganized were the foes
and so feeble the beaming, not a single Patrol vessel was lost. The
Black fleet, so proud and so conquering of mien a few minutes before,
had fallen completely apart.

“That’s enough, Rod, don’t you think?” Samms thought then. “Please
order Clayton to cease action, so that we can hold a parley with their
senior officers.”

“Parley, hell!” Kinnison’s answering thought was a snarl. “We’ve got
’em going–mop ’em up before they can pull themselves together! Parley
be damned!”

“Beyond a certain point military action becomes indefensible butchery,
of which our Galactic Patrol will never be guilty. That point has now
been reached. If you do not agree with me, I’ll be glad to call a
Council meeting to decide which of us is right.”

“That isn’t necessary. You’re right–that’s one reason I’m not First
Lensman.” The Port Admiral, fury and fire ebbing from his mind, issued
orders; the Patrol forces hung motionless in space. “As President of
the Galactic Council, Virge, take over.”

Spy-rays probed and searched; a communicator beam was sent. Virgil
Samms spoke aloud, in the lingua franca of deep space.

“Connect me, please, with the senior officer of your fleet.”

There appeared upon Samms’ plate a strong, not unhandsome face;
deep-stamped with the bitter hopelessness of a strong man facing
certain death.

“You’ve got us. Come on and finish us.”

“Some such indoctrination was to be expected, but I anticipate no
trouble in convincing you that you have been grossly misinformed in
everything you have been told concerning us; our aims, our ethics,
our morals, and our standards of conduct. There are, I assume, other
surviving officers of your rank, although of lesser seniority?”

“There are ten other vice-admirals, but I am in command. They will obey
my orders or die.”

“Nevertheless, they shall be heard. Please go inert, match our
intrinsic velocity, and come aboard, all eleven of you. We wish to
explore with all of you the possibilities of a lasting peace between
our worlds.”

“Peace? Bah! Why lie?” The Black commander’s expression did not change.
“I know what you are and what you do to conquered races. We prefer
a clean, quick death in your beams to the kind you deal out in your
torture rooms and experimental laboratories. Come ahead–I intend to
attack you as soon as I can make a formation.”

“I repeat, you have been grossly, terribly, shockingly misinformed.”
Samms’ voice was quiet and steady; his eyes held those of the other.
“We are civilized men, not barbarians or savages. Does not the fact
that we ceased hostilities so soon mean anything to you?”

For the first time the stranger’s face changed subtly, and Samms
pressed the slight advantage.

“I see it does. Now if you will converse with me mind to mind….” The
First Lensman felt for the man’s ego and began to tune to it, but this
was too much.

“I will not!” The Black put up a solid block. “I will have nothing to
do with your cursed Lens. I know what it is and will have none of it!”

“Oh, what’s the use, Virge!” Kinnison snapped. “Let’s get on with it!”

“A great deal of use, Rod,” Samms replied, quietly. “This is a
turning-point. I must be right–I can’t be that far wrong,” and he
again turned his attention to the enemy commander.

“Very well, sir, we will continue to use spoken language. I repeat,
please come aboard with your ten fellow vice-admirals. You will not be
asked to surrender. You will retain your side-arms–as long as you make
no attempt to use them. Whether or not we come to any agreement, you
will be allowed to return unharmed to your vessels before the battle is

“What? Side-arms? Returned? You swear it?”

“As President of the Galactic Council, in the presence of the highest
officers of the Galactic Patrol as witnesses, I swear it.”

“We will come aboard.”

“Very well. I will have ten other Lensmen and officers here with me.”

The Boise, of course, inerted first; followed by the Chicago and
nine of the tremendous tear-drops from Bennett. Port Admiral Kinnison
and nine other Lensmen joined Samms in the Boise’s con room; the
tight formation of eleven Patrol ships blasted in unison in the
space-courtesy of meeting the equally tight formation of Black warships
half-way in the matter of intrinsic velocity.

Soon the two little sub-fleets were motionless in respect to each
other. Eleven Black gigs were launched. Eleven Black vice-admirals came
aboard, to the accompaniment of the full military honors customarily
granted to visiting admirals of friendly powers. Each was armed with
what seemed to be an exact duplicate of the Patrol’s own current
blaster; Lewiston, Mark Seventeen. In the lead strode the tall, heavy,
gray-haired man with whom Samms had been dealing; still defiant, still
sullen, still concealing sternly his sheer desperation. His block was
still on, full strength.

The man next in line was much younger than the leader, much less
wrought up, much more intent. Samms felt for this man’s ego, tuned to
it, and got the shock of his life. This Black vice-admiral’s mind was
not at all what he had expected to encounter–it was, in every respect,
of Lensman grade!

“Oh … how? You are not speaking, and … I see … the Lens … THE
LENS!” The stranger’s mind was for seconds an utterly indescribable
turmoil in which relief, gladness, and high anticipation struggled for

In the next few seconds, even before the visitors had reached their
places at the conference table, Virgil Samms and Corander of Petrine
exchanged thoughts which would require many thousands of words to
express; only a few of which are necessary here.

“The LENS … I have dreamed of such a thing, without hope of
realization or possibility. How we have been misled! They are, then,
actually available upon your world, Samms of Tellus?”

“Not exactly, and not at all generally,” and Samms explained as he had
explained so many times before. “You will wear one sooner than you
think. But as to ending this warfare. You survivors are practically all
natives of your own world. Petrine?”

“Not ‘practically’, we are Petrinos all. The ‘teachers’ were all in the
Center. Many remain upon Petrine and its neighboring worlds, but none
remain alive here.”

“Ohlanser, then, who assumed command, is also a Petrino? So
hard-headed, I had assumed otherwise. He will be a stumbling-block. Is
he actually in supreme command?”

“Only by and with our consent, under such astounding circumstances
as these. He is a reactionary, of the old, die-hard, war-dog school.
He would ordinarily be in supreme command and would be supported by
the teachers if any were here; but I will challenge his authority and
theirs; standing upon my right to command my own fleet as I see fit. So
will, I think, several others. So go ahead with your meeting.”

“Be seated, Gentlemen.” All saluted punctiliously and sat down. “Now,
Vice-Admiral Ohlanser….”

“How do you, a stranger, know my name?”

“I know many things. We have a suggestion to offer which, if you
Petrinos will follow it, will end this warfare. First, please believe
that we have no designs upon your planet, nor any quarrel with any of
its people who are not hopelessly contaminated by the ideas and the
culture of the entities who are back of this whole movement; quite
possibly those whom you refer to as the ‘teachers’. You did not know
whom you were to fight, or why.” This was a statement, with no hint of
question about it.

“I see now that we did not know all the truth,” Ohlanser admitted,
stiffly. “We were informed, and given proof sufficient to make
us believe, that you were monsters from outer space–rapacious,
insatiable, senselessly and callously destructive to all other forms of
intelligent life.”

“We suspected something of the kind. Do you others agree? Vice-Admiral

“Yes. We were shown detailed and documented proofs; stereos of battles,
in which no quarter was given. We saw system after system conquered,
world after world laid waste. We were made to believe that our only
hope of continued existence was to meet you and destroy you in space;
for if you were allowed to reach Petrine every man, woman, and child on
the planet would either be killed outright or tortured to death. I see
now that those proofs were entirely false; completely vicious.”

“They were. Those who spread that lying propaganda and all who support
their organization must be and shall be weeded out. Petrine must be
and shall be given her rightful place in the galactic fellowship of
free, independent, and cooperative worlds. So must any and all planets
whose peoples wish to adhere to Civilization instead of to tyranny and
despotism. To further these ends, we Lensmen suggest that you re-form
your fleet and proceed to Arisia….”

“Arisia!” Ohlanser did not like the idea.

“Arisia,” Samms insisted. “Upon leaving Arisia, knowing vastly more
than you do now, you will return to your home planet, where you will
take whatever steps you will then know to be necessary.”

“We were told that your Lenses are hypnotic devices,” Ohlanser sneered,
“designed to steal away and destroy the minds of any who listen to you.
I believe that, fully. I will not go to Arisia, nor will any part of
Petrine’s Grand Fleet. I will not attack my home planet. I will not do
battle against my own people. This is final.”

“I am not saying or implying that you should. But you continue to close
your mind to reason. How about you, Vice-Admiral Corander? And you

In the momentary silence Samms put himself en rapport with the other
officers, and was overjoyed at what he learned.

“I do not agree with Vice-Admiral Ohlanser,” Corander said, flatly. “He
commands, not Grand Fleet, but his sub-fleet merely, as do we all. I
will lead my sub-fleet to Arisia.”

“Traitor!” Ohlanser shouted. He leaped to his feet and drew his
blaster, but a tractor beam snatched it from his grasp before he could

“You were allowed to wear side-arms, not to use them,” Samms said,
quietly. “How many of you others agree with Corander; how many with

All nine voted with the younger man.

“Very well. Ohlanser, you may either accept Corander’s leadership
or leave this meeting now and take your sub-fleet directly back to
Petrine. Decide now which you prefer to do.”

“You mean you aren’t going to kill me, even now? Or even degrade me, or
put me under arrest?”

“I mean exactly that. What is your decision?”

“In that case … I was–must have been–wrong. I will follow Corander.”

“A wise choice. Corander, you already know what to expect; except that
four or five other Petrinos now in this room will help you, not only in
deciding what must be done upon Petrine, but also in the doing of it.
This meeting will adjourn.”

“But … no reprisals?” Corander, in spite of his newly acquired
knowledge, was dubious, almost dumbfounded. “No invasion or occupation?
No indemnities to your Patrol, or reparations? No punishment of us, our
men, or our families?”


“That does not square up even with ordinary military usage.”

“I know it. It does conform, however, to the policy of the Galactic
Patrol which is to spread throughout our island universe.”

“You are not even sending your fleet, or heavy units of it, with us, to
see to it that we follow your instructions?”

“It is not necessary. If you need any form of help you will inform us
of your requirements via Lens, as I am conversing with you now, and
whatever you want will be supplied. However, I do not expect any such
call. You and your fellows are capable of handling the situation.
You will soon know the truth, and know that you know it; and when
your house-cleaning is done we will consider your application for
representation upon the Galactic Council. Good-bye.”

Thus the Lensmen–particularly First Lensman Virgil Samms–brought
another sector of the galaxy under the aegis of Civilization.


After the Rally there were a few days during which neither Samms nor
Kinnison was on Earth. That the Cosmocrats’ presidential candidate and
the First Lensman were both with the Fleet was not a secret; in fact,
it was advertised. Everyone was told why they were out there, and
almost everyone approved.

Nor was their absence felt. Developments, fast and terrific, were
slammed home. Cosmocratic spellbinders in every state of North America
waved the flag, pointed with pride, and viewed with alarm, in the
very best tradition of North American politics. But above all, there
appeared upon every news-stand and in every book-shop of the Continent,
at opening time of the day following Rally Day, a book of over eighteen
hundred pages of fine print; a book the publication of which had given
Samms himself no little concern.

“But I’m afraid of it!” he had protested. “We know it’s true; but
there’s material on almost every page for the biggest libel and slander
suits in history!”

“I know it,” the bald and paunchy Lensman-attorney had replied. “Fully.
I hope they do take action against us, but I’m absolutely certain
they won’t.”

“You hope they do?”

“Yes. If they take the initiative they can’t prevent us from presenting
our evidence in full; and there is no court in existence, however
corrupt, before which we could not win. What they want and must have is
delay; avoidance of any issue until after the election.”

“I see.” Samms was convinced.

The location of the Patrol’s Grand Fleet had been concealed from all
inhabitants of the Solarian system, friends and foes alike; but the
climactic battle–liberating as it did energies sufficient to distort
the very warp and woof of the fabric of space itself–could not be
hidden or denied, or even belittled. It was not, however, advertised or
blazoned abroad. Then as now the newshawks wanted to know, instantly
and via long-range communicators, vastly more than those responsible
for security cared to tell; then as now the latter said as little as it
was humanly possible to say.

Everyone knew that the Patrol had won a magnificent victory; but nobody
knew who or what the enemy had been. Since the rank and file knew it,
everyone knew that only a fraction of the Black fleet had actually been
destroyed; but nobody knew where the remaining vessels went or what
they did. Everyone knew that about ninety five percent of the Patrol’s
astonishingly huge Grand Fleet had come from, and was on its way back
to, the planet Bennett, and knew–since Bennettans would in a few weeks
be scampering gaily all over space–in general what Bennett was; but
nobody knew why it was.

Thus, when the North American Contingent landed at New York Spaceport,
everyone whom the newsmen could reach was literally mobbed. However,
in accordance with the aphorism ascribed to the wise old owl, those
who knew the least said the most. But the Telenews ace who had once
interviewed both Kinnison and Samms wasted no time upon small fry. He
insisted on seeing the two top Lensmen, and kept on insisting until he
did see them.

“Nothing to say,” Kinnison said curtly, leaving no doubt whatever that
he meant it. “All talking–if any–will be done by First Lensman Samms.”

“Now, all you millions of Telenews listeners, I am interviewing First
Lensman Samms himself. A little closer to the mike, please, First
Lensman. Now, sir, what everybody wants to know is–who are the Blacks?”

“I don’t know.”

“You don’t know? On the Lens, sir?”

“On the Lens. I still don’t know.”

“I see. But you have suspicions or ideas? You can guess?”

“I can guess; but that’s all it would be–a guess.”

“And my guess, folks, is that his guess would be a very highly informed
guess. Will you tell the public, First Lensman Samms, what your guess

“I will.” If this reply astonished the newshawk, it staggered
Kinnison and the others who knew Samms best. It was, however, a
coldly calculated political move. “While it will probably be several
weeks before we can furnish detailed and unassailable proof, it is my
considered opinion that the Black fleet was built and controlled by the
Morgan-Towne-Isaacson machine. That they, all unknown to any of us,
enticed, corrupted, and seduced a world, or several worlds, to their
program of domination and enslavement. That they intended by armed
force to take over the Continent of North America and through it the
whole earth and all the other planets adherent to Civilization. That
they intended to hunt down and kill every Lensman, and to subvert the
Galactic Council to their own ends. This is what you wanted?”

“That’s fine, sir–just what we wanted. But just one more thing,
sir.” The newsman had obtained infinitely more than he had expected to
get; yet, good newsmanlike, he wanted more. “Just a word, if you will,
Mr. Samms, as to these trials and the White Book?”

“I can add very little, I’m afraid, to what I have already said and
what is in the book; and that little can be classed as ‘I told you so’.
We are trying, and will continue to try, to force those criminals to
trial; to break up, to prohibit, an unending series of hair-splitting
delays. We want, and are determined to get, legal action; to make each
of those we have accused defend himself in court and under oath. Morgan
and his crew, however, are working desperately to avoid any action at
all, because they know that we can and will prove every allegation we
have made.”

The Telenews ace signed off, Samms and Kinnison went to their
respective offices, and Cosmocratic orators throughout the nation held
a field-day. They glowed and scintillated with triumph. They yelled
themselves hoarse, leather-lunged tub-thumpers though they were, in
pointing out the unsullied purity, the spotless perfection of their
own party and its every candidate for office; in shuddering revulsion
at the never-to-be-sufficiently-condemned, proved and demonstrated
villainy and blackguardy of the opposition.

And the Nationalists, although they had been dealt a terrific and
entirely unexpected blow, worked near-miracles of politics with what
they had. Morgan and his minions ranted and raved. They were being
jobbed. They were being crucified by the Monied Powers. All those
allegations and charges were sheerest fabrications–false, utterly
vicious, containing nothing whatever of truth. They, not the Patrol,
were trying to force a show-down; to vindicate themselves and to
confute those unspeakably unscrupulous Lensmen before Election Day.
And they were succeeding! Why, otherwise, had not a single one of the
thousands of accused even been arrested? Ask that lying First Lensman,
Virgil Samms! Ask that rock-hearted, iron-headed, conscienceless
murderer, Roderick Kinnison! But do not, at peril of your sanity,
submit your minds to their Lenses!

And why, the reader asks, were not at least some of those named persons
arrested before Election Day? And your historian must answer frankly
that he does not know. He is not a lawyer. It would be of interest–to
some few of us–to follow in detail at least one of those days of legal
battling in one of the high courts of the land; to quote verbatim at
least a few of the many thousands of pages of transcript: but to most
of us the technicalities involved would be boring in the extreme.

But couldn’t the voters tell easily enough which side was on the
offensive and which on the defensive? Which pressed for action and
which insisted on postponement and delay? They could have, easily
enough, if they had cared enough about the basic issues involved to
make the necessary mental effort, but almost everyone was too busy
doing something else. And it was so much easier to take somebody else’s
word for it. And finally, thinking is an exercise to which all too
few brains are accustomed.

But Morgan neither ranted nor raved nor blustered when he sat in
conference with his faintly-blue superior, who had come storming in as
soon as he had learned of the crushing defeat of the Black fleet. The
Kalonian was very highly concerned; so much so that the undertone of
his peculiar complexion was turning slowly to a delicate shade of green.

“How did that happen? How could it happen? Why was I not informed
of the Patrol’s real power–how could you be guilty of such stupidity?
Now I’ll have to report to Scrwan of the Eich. He’s pure, undiluted
poison–and if word of this catastrophe ever gets up to Ploor…!!!”

“Come down out of the stratosphere, Fernald,” Morgan countered,
bitingly. “Don’t try to make me the goat–I won’t sit still for it.
It happened because they could build a bigger fleet than we could. You
were in on that–all of it. You knew what we were doing, and approved
it–all of it. You were as badly fooled as I was. You were not informed
because I could find out nothing–I could learn no more of their
Bennett than they could of our Petrine. As to reporting, you will of
course do as you please; but I would advise you not to cry too much
before you’re really hurt. This battle isn’t over yet, my friend.”

The Kalonian had been a badly shaken entity; it was a measure of his
state of mind that he did not liquidate the temerarious Tellurian then
and there. But since Morgan was as undisturbed as ever, and as sure of
himself, he began to regain his wonted aplomb. His color became again
its normal pale blue.

“I will forgive your insubordination this time, since there were no
witnesses, but use no more such language to me,” he said, stiffly.
“I fail to perceive any basis for your optimism. The only chance now
remaining is for you to win the election, and how can you do that? You
are–must be–losing ground steadily and rapidly.”

“Not as much as you might think.” Morgan pulled down a large,
carefully-drawn chart. “This line represents the hide-bound
Nationalists, whom nothing we can do will alienate from the party; this
one the equally hide-bound Cosmocrats. The balance of power lies, as
always, with the independents–these here. And many of them are not
as independent as is supposed. We can buy or bring pressure to bear
on half of them–that cuts them down to this size here. So, no matter
what the Patrol does, it can affect only this relatively small block
here, and it is this block we are fighting for. We are losing a little
ground, and steadily, yes; since we can’t conceal from anybody with
half a brain the fact that we’re doing our best to keep the cases from
ever coming to trial. But here’s the actual observed line of sentiment,
as determined from psychological indices up to yesterday; here is the
extrapolation of that line to Election Day. It forecasts us to get just
under forty nine percent of the total vote.”

“And is there anything cheerful about that?” Fernald asked frostily.

“I’ll say there is!” Morgan’s big face assumed a sneering smile, an
expression never seen by any voter. “This chart deals only with living,
legally registered, bona-fide voters. Now if we can come that close
to winning an absolutely honest election, how do you figure we can
possibly lose the kind this one is going to be? We’re in power, you
know. We’ve got this machine and we know how to use it.”

“Oh, yes, I remember–vaguely. You told me about North American
politics once, a few years ago. Dead men, ringers, repeaters,
ballot-box stuffing, and so on, you said?”

“‘And so on’ is right, Chief!” Morgan assured him, heartily.
“Everything goes, this time. It’ll be one of the biggest landslides in
North American history.”

“I will, then, defer any action until after the election.”

“That will be the smart thing to do, Chief; then you won’t have to take
any, or make any report at all,” and upon this highly satisfactory note
the conference closed.

And Morgan was actually as confident as he had appeared. His
charts were actual and factual. He knew the power of money and the
effectiveness of pressure; he knew the capabilities of the various
units of his machine. He did not, however, know two things: Jill Samms’
insidious, deeply-hidden Voters’ Protective League and the bright
flame of loyalty pervading the Galactic Patrol. Thus, between times
of bellowing and screaming his carefully-prepared, rabble-rousing
speeches, he watched calmly and contentedly the devious workings of his
smooth and efficient organization.

Until the day before election, that is. Then hordes of young men and
young women went suddenly and briefly to work; at least four in every
precinct of the entire nation. They visited, it seemed, every residence
and every dwelling unit, everywhere. They asked questions, and took
notes, and vanished; and the machine’s operatives, after the alarm
was given, could not find man or girl or notebook. And the Galactic
Patrol, which had never before paid any attention to elections, had
given leave and ample time to its every North American citizen. Vessels
of the North American Contingent were grounded and practically emptied
of personnel; bases and stations were depopulated; and even from every
distant world every Patrolman registered in any North American precinct
came to spend the day at home.

Morgan began then to worry, but there was nothing he could do about the
situation–or was there? If the civilian boys and girls were checking
the registration books–and they were–it was as legally-appointed
checkers. If the uniformed boys and girls were all coming home to
vote–and they were–that, too, was their inalienable right. But boys
and girls were notoriously prone to accident and to debauchery …
but again Morgan was surprised; and, this time, taken heavily aback.
The web which had protected Grand Rally so efficiently, but greatly
enlarged now, was functioning again; and Morgan and his minions spent a
sleepless and thoroughly uncomfortable night.

Election Day dawned clear, bright, and cool; auguring a record
turn-out. Voting was early and extraordinarily heavy; the polls were
crowded. There was, however, very little disorder. Surprisingly little,
in view of the fact that the Cosmocratic watchers, instead of being
the venal wights of custom, were cold-eyed, unreachable men and women
who seemed to know by sight every voter in the precinct. At least they
spotted on sight and challenged without hesitation every ringer, every
dead one, every repeater, and every imposter who claimed the right
to vote. And those challenges, being borne out in every case by the
carefully-checked registration lists, were in every case upheld.

Not all of the policemen on duty, especially in the big cities, were
above suspicion, of course. But whenever any one of those officers
began to show a willingness to play ball with the machine a calm,
quiet-eyed Patrolman would remark, casually:

“Better see that this election stays straight, bud, and strictly
according to the lists and signatures–or you’re apt to find yourself
listed in the big book along with the rest of the rats.”

It was not that the machine liked the way things were going, or that it
did not have goon squads on the job. It was that there were, everywhere
and always, more Patrolmen than there were goons. And those Patrolmen,
however young in years some of them might have appeared to be, were
space-bronzed veterans, space-hardened fighting men, armed with the
last word in blasters–Lewiston, Mark Seventeen.

To the boy’s friends and neighbors, of course, his Lewiston was
practically invisible. It was merely an article of clothing, the same
as his pants. It carried no more of significance, of threat or of
menace, than did the pistol and the club of the friendly Irish cop on
the beat. But the goon did not see the Patrolman as a friend. He saw
the keen, clear, sharply discerning eyes; the long, strong fingers;
the smoothly flowing muscles, so eloquent of speed and of power. He
saw the Lewiston for what it was; the deadliest, most destructive
hand-weapon known to man. Above all he saw the difference in numbers:
six or seven or eight Patrolmen to four or five or six of his own kind.
If more hoods arrived, so did more spacemen; if some departed, so did a
corresponding number of the wearers of the space-black and silver.

“Ain’t you getting tired of sticking around here, George?” One mobster
asked confidentially of one Patrolman. “I am. What say we and some of
you fellows round up some girls and go have us a party?”

“Uh-uh,” George denied. His voice was gay and careless, but his eyes
were icy cold. “My uncle’s cousin’s stepson is running for second
assistant dog-catcher, and I can’t leave until I find out whether he
wins or not.”

Thus nothing happened; thus the invisible but nevertheless terrific
tension did not erupt into open battle; and thus, for the first time in
North America’s long history, a presidential election was ninety nine
and ninety nine one-hundredths percent pure!

Evening came. The polls closed. The Cosmocrats’ headquarters for the
day, the Grand Ballroom of the Hotel van der Voort, became the goal
of every Patrolman who thought he stood any chance at all of getting
in. Kinnison had been there all day, of course. So had Joy, his wife,
who for lack of space has been sadly neglected in these annals.
Betty, their daughter, had come in early, accompanied by a husky and
personable young lieutenant, who has no other place in this story. Jack
Kinnison arrived, with Dimples Maynard–dazzlingly blonde, wearing a
screamingly red wisp of silk. She, too, has been shamefully slighted
here, although she was never slighted anywhere else.

“The first time I ever saw her,” Jack was wont to say, “I went right
into a flat spin, running around in circles and biting myself in the
small of the back, and couldn’t pull out of it for four hours!”

That Miss Maynard should be a very special item is not at all
surprising, in view of the fact that she was to become the wife of one
of THE Kinnisons and the mother of another.

The First Lensman, who had been in and out, came in to stay. So did
Jill and her inseparable, Mason Northrop. And so did others, singly or
by twos or threes. Lensmen and their wives. Conway and Clio Costigan,
Dr. and Mrs. Rodebush, and Cleveland, Admiral and Mrs. Clayton, ditto
Schweikert, and Dr. Nels Bergenholm. And others. Nor were they all
North Americans, or even human. Rularion was there; and so was blocky,
stocky Dronvire of Rigel Four. No outsider could tell, ever, what any
Lensman was thinking, to say nothing of such a monstrous Lensman as
Dronvire–but that hotel was being covered as no political headquarters
had ever been covered before.

The returns came in, see-sawing maddeningly back and forth. Faster and
faster. The Maritime Provinces split fifty-fifty. Maine, New Hampshire,
and Vermont, Cosmocrat. New York, upstate, Cosmocrat. New York City,
on the basis of incomplete but highly significant returns, was piling
up a huge Nationalist majority. Pennsylvania–labor–Nationalist.
Ohio–farmers–Cosmocrat. Twelve southern states went six and six.
Chicago, as usual, solidly for the machine; likewise Quebec and Ottawa
and Montreal and Toronto and Detroit and Kansas City and St. Louis and
New Orleans and Denver.

Then northern and western and far southern states came in and evened
the score. Saskatchewan, Alberta, Britcol, and Alaska, all went
Cosmocrat. So did Washington, Idaho, Montana, Oregon, Nevada, Utah,
Arizona, Newmex, and most of the states of Mexico.

At three o’clock in the morning the Cosmocrats had a slight but
definite lead and were, finally, holding it. At four o’clock the lead
was larger, but California was still an unknown quantity–California
could wreck everything. How would California go? Especially, how
would California’s two metropolitan districts–the two most independent
and free-thinking and least predictable big cities of the nation–how
would they go?

At five o’clock California seemed safe. Except for Los Angeles and
San Francisco, the Cosmocrats had swept the state, and in those two
great cities they held a commanding lead. It was still mathematically
possible, however, for the Nationalists to win.

“It’s in the bag! Let’s start the celebration!” someone shouted, and
others took up the cry.

“Stop it! No!” Kinnison’s parade-ground voice cut through the noise.
“No celebration is in order or will be held until the result becomes
certain or Witherspoon concedes!”

The two events came practically together: Witherspoon conceded a couple
of minutes before it became mathematically impossible for him to win.
Then came the celebration, which went on and on interminably. At the
first opportunity, however, Kinnison took Samms by the arm, led him
without a word into a small office, and shut the door. Samms, also
saying nothing, sat down in the swivel chair, put both feet up on the
desk, lit a cigarette, and inhaled deeply.

“Well, Virge–satisfied?” Kinnison broke the silence at last. His Lens
was off. “We’re on our way.”

“Yes, Rod. Fully. At last.” No more than his friend did he dare to
use his Lens; to plumb the depths he knew so well were there. “Now it
will roll–under its own power–no one man now is or ever will be
indispensable to the Galactic Patrol–nothing can stop it now!”


The murder of Senator Morgan, in his own private office, was never
solved. If it had occurred before the election, suspicion would
certainly have fallen upon Roderick Kinnison, but as it was it did not.
By no stretch of the imagination could anyone conceive of “Rod the
Rock” kicking a man after he had knocked him down. Not that Morgan did
not have powerful and vindictive enemies in the underworld: he had so
many that it proved impossible to fasten the crime to any one of them.

Officially, Kinnison was on a five-year leave of absence from the
Galactic Patrol, the office of Port Admiral had been detached entirely
from the fleet and assigned to the Office of the President of North
America. Actually, however, in every respect that counted, Roderick
Kinnison was still Port Admiral, and would remain so until he died or
until the Council retired him by force.

Officially, Kinnison was taking a short, well-earned vacation from the
job in which he had been so outstandingly successful. Actually, he was
doing a quick flit to Petrine, to get personally acquainted with the
new Lensmen and to see what kind of a job they were doing. Besides,
Virgil Samms was already there.

He arrived. He got acquainted. He saw. He approved.

“How about coming back to Tellus with me, Virge?” he asked, when the
visiting was done. “I’ve got to make a speech, and it’d be nice to have
you hold my head.”

“I’d be glad to,” and the Chicago took off.

Half of North America was dark when they neared Tellus; all of it,
apparently, was obscured by clouds. Only the navigating officers of the
vessel knew where they were, nor did either of the two Lensmen care.
They were having too much fun arguing about the talents and abilities
of their respective grandsons.

The Chicago landed. A bug was waiting. The two Lensmen, without an
order being given, were whisked away. Samms had not asked where the
speech was to be given, and Kinnison simply did not realize that he
had not told him all about it. Thus Samms had no idea that he was just
leaving Spokane Spaceport, Washington.

After a few miles of fast, open-country driving the bug reached the
city. It slowed down, swung into brightly-lighted Maple Street, and
passed a sign reading “Cannon Hill” something-or-other–neither of
which names meant anything to either Lensman.

Kinnison looked at his friend’s red-thatched head and glanced at his

“Looking at you reminds me–I need a haircut,” he remarked. “Should
have got one aboard, but didn’t think of it Joy told me if I come home
without it she’ll braid it in pigtails and tie it up with pink ribbons,
and you’re shaggier than I am. You’ve got to get one or else buy
yourself a violin. What say we do it now?”

“Have we got time enough?”

“Plenty.” Then, to the driver: “Stop at the first barber shop you see,

“Yes, sir. There’s a good one a few blocks further along.”

The bug sped down Maple Street, turned sharply into plainly-marked
Twelfth Avenue. Neither Lensman saw the sign.

“Here you are, sir.”


There were two barbers and two chairs, both empty. The Lensmen,
noticing that the place was neatly kept and meticulously clean, sat
down and resumed their discussion of two extremely unusual infants. The
barbers went busily to work.

“Just as well, though–better, really–that the kids didn’t marry each
other, at that,” Kinnison concluded finally. “The way it is, we’ve each
got a grandson–it’d be tough to have to share one with you.”

Samms made no reply to this sally, for something was happening. The
fact that this fair-skinned, yellow-haired blue-eyed barber was
left-handed had not rung any bells–there were lots of left-handed
barbers. He had neither seen nor heard the cat–a less-than-half-grown,
gray, tiger-striped kitten–which, after standing up on its hind legs
to sniff ecstatically at his nylon-clad ankles, had uttered a couple
of almost inaudible “meows” and had begun to purr happily. Crouching,
tensing its strong little legs, it leaped almost vertically upward. Its
tail struck the barber’s elbow.

Hastily brushing the kitten aside, and beginning profuse apologies both
for his awkwardness and for the presence of the cat–he had never
done such a thing before and he would drown him forthwith–the barber
applied a styptic pencil and recollection hit Samms a pile-driver blow.

“Well, I’m a…!” He voiced three highly un-Samms-like, highly specific
expletives which, as Mentor had foretold so long before, were both
self-derogatory and profane. Then, as full realization dawned, he bit a
word squarely in two.

“Excuse me, please, Mr. Carbonero, for this outrageous display. It was
not the scratch, nor was any of it your fault Nothing you could have
done would have….”

“You know my name?” the astonished barber interrupted.

“Yes. You were … ah … recommended to me by a … a friend….”
Whatever Samms could say would make things worse. The truth, wild as it
was, would have to be told, at least in part. “You do not look like an
Italian, but perhaps you have enough of that racial heritage to believe
in prophecy?”

“Of course, sir. There have always been prophets–true prophets.”

“Good. This event was foretold in detail; in such complete detail that
I was deeply, terribly shocked. Even to the kitten. You call it Thomas.”

“Yes, sir. Thomas Aquinas.”

“It is actually a female. In here, Thomasina!” The kitten had been
climbing enthusiastically up his leg; now, as he held a pocket
invitingly open, she sprang into it, settled down, and began to purr
blissfully. While the barbers and Kinnison stared pop-eyed Samms went

“She is determined to adopt me, and it would be a shame not to requite
such affection. Would you part with her–for, say, ten credits?”

Ten credits! I’ll be glad to give her to you for nothing!”

“Ten it is, then. One more thing. Rod, you always carry a pocket rule.
Measure this scratch, will you? You’ll find it’s mighty close to three
millimeters long.”

“Not ‘close’, Virge–it’s exactly three millimeters, as near as this
vernier can scale it.”

“And just above and parallel to the cheek-bone.”

“Check. Just above and as parallel as though it had been ruled there by
a draftsman.”

“Well, that’s that. Let’s get finished with the haircuts, before you’re
late for your speech,” and the barbers, with thoughts which will be
left to the imagination, resumed their interrupted tasks.

“Spill it, Virge!” Kinnison Lensed the pent-up thought. If Carbonero,
who did not know Samms at all, had been amazed at what had been
happening, Kinnison, who had known him so long and so well, had been
literally and completely dumbfounded. “What in hell’s behind this?
What’s the story? GIVE!”

Samms told him, and a mental silence fell; a silence too deep for
intelligible thought. Each was beginning to realize that he never
would and never could know what Mentor of Arisia really was.

The Secret Planet

No human had ever landed on the hidden planet of Arisia. A mysterious
space barrier turned back both men and ships.

Then the word came to Earth; “Go to Arisia!” Samms of the Galactic
Patrol went–and came back with the Lens, the strange device that gave
its wearer powers no man had ever possessed before.

Samms knew the price of that power would be high. But even he had no
idea of the ultimate cost, and the weird destiny waiting for the

First Lensman

A PYRAMID BOOK 60¢ Cover: Jack Gaughan Printed in U.S.A.




The Skylark Series


The Lensman Series


This entry was posted in Classics and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.